EPTNewbie Mini Mafia XXXVII - Page 13
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
| ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
You know I have asked several times now for a top scum read and why. Sylencia you have never delivered; and when you come out of hibernation its only to comment on what is matters to you... ##Vote:Sylencia In the scum game I played; we got the RB to block me.. to get town cred... i can see this happening here. (will be out doing house chores most of the day, be back in 6 hours) | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 10:59 cDgCorazon wrote: There are three scum, just in case you didn't know...WB cannot be your only scumread. On phone And why are you so certain? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 11:31 cDgCorazon wrote: Because a set-up with 8 town and 5 non-town would be really imbalanced, and a set-up with 10 town and 3 non-town would also be ridiculously imbalanced. On phone: This is silly poo corazon. There have been several 13 player newbie games, each with 3 scum and never SK. You just said 10 town, 3 non-town is unbalanced... y? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 13:15 Sevryn wrote: I made a post about the other two lurkers my times I'm able to be on are a little different than most people but that doesnt mean I'm hardcore lurking mandalor is the lurkiest but syl is the scummiest IMO so if you want to smoke somebody out why woudlnt you go for the least active this seems to me almost like an OMGUS from the previous night and my posts about you. WB that is the deffinition of sheeping voting with someone without giving your own reasons I know you said you thought I was the scummiest but your whole case is cherry picking my filter I have made good constructive posts and you have just ignored them. you want me to go through your whole filter and post all the zero content posts? right now my current scum team read is 1.syl 2.Cora 3.wb in that order Sevryn, i said before I think you're the voice that tries to stand up in the crowd and is then ignored. However, posts like the above; make me think you're just a lurker and make me realise how much you have blended in. When I read the above I think, you are either defending yourself; or trying to contribute without contributing. Regardless it is not helping town scum hunt. Step up and pressure your reads. If your #1 read is sylencia.. lead the way and show us why you think he is scummy. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
I said before, a case shows more about the maker, than the recipient. Is the above your case for warbaby? Is that the best you can muster? Why is this a contribution of merit compared to posts from Mandalor or Sevryn? Why should we believe you were even RB'd twice? You pointed out you said you were not blue, so i cant see why scum would RB you in the first place... and then why the heck would a JK target you over TestSubject. - All you have returned to us is WIFOM. This smells *really* fishy to me. I want some answers to the above. Let me remind you On February 17 2013 10:47 Mocsta wrote: ##Vote:Sylencia | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
As for. Sevryn I do not care for his last post. But the point u raise can be applied to many. And By itself is not scummy. Need to tie to other behaviour | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 14:25 cDgCorazon wrote: Would you like to discuss the set-up more then? Not particularly, I don't think it is of value for todays scum hunt. I just think you're making conclusions on setup that is both misleading; and on par with association flips. Sylencia produced some discussion, but it was all WIFOM - and thus pointless. Is there actually a conclusion? On February 17 2013 15:41 Sylencia wrote: The introduction of the SK in this game will be balanced by having either a higher number of blues and/or stronger mafia roles. (Rhetorical) How is what you(Corazon) produced about setup; helping the scum hunt? (Question to all) Is Sylencia making comments like above aiding the scum hunt? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 14:27 Sevryn wrote: how about your reads? who do you think the scum team is? you think its all lurkers? Whoah whoah, take a step back sunshine. You're not in a position to be questioning others. It works like this Mr.Lurker. We question you and your motives. OR You build a case on someone, that we pick to shreds to find out if you are bullshitting. The "case" you wrote on Sylencia is pretty hard to read; and reads as a summary post to me. I want to see some analysis on why the things you are raising have to be from scum; and not from town. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 14:29 cDgCorazon wrote: If you are wondering what my reads are, you're not paying attention to the game at all... You bringing out that case today; or focusing on the lurkers? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 15:48 cDgCorazon wrote: WB and I are getting really impatient as well. Is this a blatant scum slip or something? You accuse me all game of associating with you (when its clear I haven't been).. and now.. you're suddenly chummy with a guy you have been 'chasing' all game? WTF... | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 15:41 Sylencia wrote: Because unlike Sevryn who firstly gets asked thoughts on specific players - in which he then responds, I don't piggyback on the opportunity to claim X lurker is scum. Does this mean Sevryn is scum? Possibly. Mandalor hasn't been around since the start of Day 2. Nothing is really known about him other than the fact he's pretty much full AFK at this point in time. As for my case on Warbaby, if you think it's a weak case then so be it - I see there's enough for me to vote for him from what I've read. Regarding my double roleblock - why would I double roleblock over roleblocking a person and then myself if I was scum? 1) It confirms there's actually a roleblocker in the game, 2) it 'confirms' me as town a hell of a lot more than double roleblock ever would. Given the fact you've all been suspicious of me for a while, would I really bring even more attention to myself as scum? No, but these points don't really have much weight behind them since you don't know my role. #1 - I find it ironic you state Sevyrn does not speak till spoken to... because.. I thought many of your posts were originating from others ideas/statements. i.e. I cant recall you introducing something unique into the fray; other than the RB claims.... #2 - I have seen you make WAY better cases than what did for warbaby. To me, the only point you raised was that warbaby scum slipped. Sorry, I am not going to vote someone for a fuckn scum slip.. it has to be backed up with analysis of motives. Where is this? You have provided a bunch of analysis when it comes to setup speculation... all of which amount to NO CONCLUSION. What I see is a bunch of posts taking no firm stance; and in the rare situation you do take a stance, its with no detailed explanation of thought process. #3 - I dont know what to make of the RB. And mulling over it is WIFOM... if you are town it *MUST* be proven by how you scum hunt; not by a RB claim that may or may not have occurred. Stop suggesting you are town because of the RB claim(s); and then continue to not produce the goods when it comes to scum hunting. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
On February 17 2013 19:29 Sevryn wrote: so sharing your reads and answering questions is something people who are on 24/7 dont have to do? Touche, Do you always answer questions with questions? Cos thats scummy as Mr. Lurker. How about this.. we are near MYLO; and its pretty clear the candidates for this lynch is You, Sylencia and Mandalor. So how about stop being a smart arse, and start to contribute; nothing you wrote on Sylencia suggests why he is mafia; it is simply a collection of his posts. Again, scummy behaviour. If you could reply to that post, I am sure its not hard to reply to the content of what I wrote instead..... | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Wtf.... No lynch is meant to be cast in final hours if no candidate is clear.. What you are suggesting is scummy as fuck. How many times have we had to ask for a second scum read - with some justification.... My vote on u remains | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Just goes to show. More contributions from him that go no where. For someone that is as keen to speculate on setup as him. He shoulda known its a last resort.. I think he is starting to cave from the pressure | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
whats ya time deadline for sno and zare to post before finding it stinky? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
how long are u willing to wait before starting to think their lack of activity is suspicious? | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
However i am going to need detailed feedback from them in say the next 12 to 16 hours...otherwise to me. Its suspicious the lack of contributoons given the severity of a mislynch. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Just yeah its really odd sno and zare havent commented. I agree though sno>>zare based in contributions. As mentioned before. I think another 12hours is very reasonable to expect something meaningful. If no response i can only surmise scum is happy with how everything is proceeding. That doesnt make the lurkers clear though. Im certain scum exists within the three lurkers. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9388 Posts
Talk god dammit (other than corazon and maybe warbaby). ========= [fluff] - Cos I am going nuts here with the lack of activity 1. Syvern 2. Sylencia 3. Mandalor 4. Sylencia 5. zarepath 6. Sylencia RNG = 2... awesome, dont have to change me vote. 5 | ||
| ||
