|
On September 20 2012 02:00 RemedySC wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2012 01:12 kushm4sta wrote:
Remedy postpone your suspicion of me until d2 please. Who of the possible lynches, including lurkers, do you want to lynch?
Also guys if we are going to have an choice to lynch a lurker, which one shall it be?
Cubu's filter is just enough to prevent modkill. Kush, you seem way too intent on lynching a lurker. Why does it have to be a lurker? Show nested quote +On September 20 2012 00:47 kushm4sta wrote:
@remedy Why would you vote for me at this point?
I'm not a serious lynch candidate today. At this point your vote just unfocuses the town.
You say my vote unfocuses the town. Why would my vote on you unfocus the town? Your defense seems to be that my vote would just bring confusion.
Right now we are trying to figure out who to lynch. That is what town needs to be talking about now, not random suspicions.
Why do I want to lynch a lurker? Because sharrant doesn't seem scummy enough to be a better vote than a lurker.
I would rather lynch a lurker d1 than have to waste a later vote on a lurker. I do not want there to be the presence of a town lurker for mafia to safely vote for again and again. Are we just going to let cubu lurk all game, posting 1 shitty thing a day, and pray that he's not scum?
|
The lynch votes are amassing for sharrant.
Lynching someone active d1 almost always results in lynching a townie!
Can i present an alternative bandwagon for the people who think he's probably town:
CUBU... He is winning the race for biggest lurker. At least if he is town we can lynch and not feel so bad if he flips green.
On September 19 2012 20:25 Cubu wrote:
Oh and sorry for lurking, but i am really busy with assignments. I gotta write four 2k word essays by next week.
So basically he is saying that he will continue to lurk throughout the whole game. Until next week is a long time.
We have 3 options.
1 We lynch him now as a policy lynch.
2 We let him live and continue to argue lurker policy until we lynch him.
3 We ignore him and just rely on the 75% chance he is town.
Our read of sharrant will get better. Our read of drazak will remain null.
I'm unvoting debears but I still suspect him. Just that bandwagon isn't happening anymore and I would rather lynch a lurker anyway.
##unvote debears
##vote cubu
|
@stutters
Scummy by not talking about what is going on in the game at all.
This recent post... wtf you spend the entire time talking about what you say you shouldn't talk about.
Dropping it for now as there are bigger fish to fry today. Still suspicious.
Then why are you continuing to ride my ass instead of frying those fishes?
You really want me to talk more about the nk? Like seriously you are bringing up the nk shit again? Now?
Can you please fucking vote please??
|
On September 20 2012 04:01 RemedySC wrote:
Also why would the town feel less badly about Cubu turning up green than sharrant? Everyone else seems to have a good indication that he is mafia. Are you trying to protect him?
Why would a green cubu lynch feel better than green sharrant lynch?
Because lurkers are bad for town.
Sharrant is very active and does a lot of scumhunting. That helps town.
Seems pretty self explanatory to me.
I said from the beginning that unless we have a really good scum read that we could agree on I think we should lynch a lurker.
For me sharrant is not a good scumread. His recent posts definitely have made him more scummy in my eyes. Certain stuff he just won't let go for some reason... like to let it go would admit to his guilt. Also all that talk about mods and not understanding the game. It's not clear to me what he didn't understand and what he was planning on doing in the first place.
However it just doesn't make sense to me that a first time forum mafia player rolling scum would put himself out like that
|
if someone makes 2 posts but doesn't vote do they get modkilled?
|
OK so as I see it here are our options atm: Sharrant, cubu, killing.
Killing is not that much of a lurker. He's not lurker enough to even be considered a lurker IMO.
Killing is scummy looking to me, but he looked that way last game too.
|
wait sharrant is claiming mason?? where did that happen?
|
Ahh I get it he wanted him to roleclaim mason.
|
@killing I understand it as sharrant is not roleclaiming. He was trying to get debears to roleclaim mason. I think that's it.
|
So isn't this a roleclaim that we can't prove one way or another?
|
Mason pairs do not seem that valuable except to confirm each other town. So yeah if people don't change their mind about lynching you I would say definitely call out your partner.
|
AHHH WTF huge developments and I wish these happened earlier when i was at my computer.
to the people saying keep the vote cuba are you fucking kidding me or what? either they are both mafia or they are both town. You think they are both mafia and sharrant is stupid enough to give up both mafia... sharrant vote and cubu vote just seems totally ridiculous to me.
##unvote
we need an alternate bandwagon and we need it fast. I like debears if people really don't want to lynch a lurker. I like another lurker as the best choice though I'm not sure which one I would pick now. drazak maybe? I want to here what other people think.
we need an epic swift band wagon of justice or we are going to get a no lynch
|
ok looks like drazzak is the bandwagon then
##vote drazzak
|
there is 2 hours 15 minute left
|
My thoughts on killing vs drazak.
drazak
I didn't even think drazak is scummy. I just voted for him now because of the last minute omg we need to vote for someone confusion.
1 he is not that scummy. a lot of scumhunting and nothing that strikes me as a huge scumslip
2 he's not even a lurker. I thought he was more of a lurker but I just went through his filter and I would not consider him a lurker.
killingtime
i was in the process of reading his filter just now, but i just realized the deadline already passed.
so fail.
|
yeah i don't consider drazak to really be a lurker. and yeah the only reason i voted for him was total 100% bandwagon ill admit it lol
|
On September 20 2012 09:16 Atreides- wrote:
The instant bandwagon against him is pretty interesting, and it's obvious now that the mafia had a strong hand in it.
No? What caused that instant bandwagon was sharrant telling everybody that he and cubu were masons. suddenly our 2 bandwagons went to shit and town had to insta pick another because time was almost up.
|
On September 20 2012 09:22 thrawn2112 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2012 09:09 kushm4sta wrote:
My thoughts on killing vs drazak.
drazak
I didn't even think drazak is scummy. I just voted for him now because of the last minute omg we need to vote for someone confusion.
1 he is not that scummy. a lot of scumhunting and nothing that strikes me as a huge scumslip
2 he's not even a lurker. I thought he was more of a lurker but I just went through his filter and I would not consider him a lurker.
killingtime
i was in the process of reading his filter just now, but i just realized the deadline already passed.
so fail. Kush, you have been a big "we must lynch the biggest lurker" advocate. Based on that last line you were writing that post before you saw the drazak flip right? So not only did you not follow your own policy in your final vote (there are lurkier people than drazak), you also voted for someone that you didn't think is scummy. On top of all of that your drazak vote was even worse than drazak's sharrant vote. Time to go read through your filter.
sighhh...
yes that post was before i saw the flip. i was in the process of looking through killing's filter to try to figure out if i would rather vote for him.
Cubu was the biggest lurker and i think it's obvious after sharrant's roleclaim that we shouldn't lynch him anymore. who is the next biggest lurker? no one comes to mind really and i didn't have time to find out esp not on my cell phone.
drazak seemed like the only option at the time.
|
I did stay around to discuss it and i was in the middle of writing that fuckign post when i realized it was past 8 oclock.
this all happened at the last minute you have to realize. i did not have time to weigh my options. all i knew was that i didn't want to vote for cubu anymore.
|
im done for tonight goodbye. and a special fuck you to thrawn for accusing me for voting for drazak.
@ thrawn you are the one who pushed a lynch on the active, obviously town, mason. you are the one who right after said it might still be a good idea to lynch cubu. you are the one who shoudl feel bad. goodnight.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
