Normal Mini Mafia II - Page 7

On July 13 2012 09:31 slOosh wrote:

prphlz plays cop like that because he is most likely scums.
D77 looks like he is dodging my medic question. This guy can't be newb town.

If you won't be swayed off my lynch, can we at least talk about my cases? I'm curious to see what people think of them, apart from the people they are directed to. Starting with D77 since it seems the most straightforward of my cases / "newb" players tend to be easier to read.

On July 13 2012 23:34 slOosh wrote:

You once again acknowledge my points but choose to focus on the "easier" one, and on that you still haven't explained how the whole possibility of a medic helps us kill scum.

I'll lay it out for everyone:
From scum perspective, they have 1kp. Perhaps they have 2kp from strongarm.
If D77 is town jailor, they will know that a marv prot is certain. Therefore, unless they had 2kp from strongarm, they wouldn't make the shot on marv - it just doesn't make sense. It is totally sensible to shoot D77 - I mean, no one suspects him, everyone has basically accepted that he is jailor.

If they did have 2kp, maybe they shot marv, and since we had an additional medic prot, he didn't die. However, this still doesn't explain why knowing that it is this situation rather than scum using delay helps us. What is to gain from outing the medic? Will it not result in more surefire shots from the scum team? How does it help town at all to know the possible presence of a strongarm which has already been used up?

D77 isn't asking people thoughts on possibilities, he is straight up asking medic to claim.

This isn't asking about the possibility of a medic - he is inviting medics to claim.