Normal Mini Mafia II - Page 13

On July 14 2012 23:58 MrZentor wrote:
There were tons of cases against Sinensis, and I was directing you toward those to find why he's scummy. Why should I have to make my own case?

On July 15 2012 11:40 Zephirdd wrote:
1. Marvellosity
You worked the hardest. You should've listened to me on the VE/MrZentor shit tho T_T Especially to you, the last few posts from VE should be evidence that he was town. This was your biggest mistake IMO.

To be honest, even without the vig shot, I'd never think of you as scum all game long. Confirming yourself was insanely good though. Well done. Not much else to say really. Maybe don't doubt your MrZentor lynch like that?

2. NoSmurfHere(wbg?)
Vanilla claim was great LOL. It actually worked into catching bluelightz. I don't know why we didn't push him more, and instead opted for his target day 1.
Overall, I don't remember doubting your innocence and felt you were a good day 1 shot target(along with me and marv).

3. slOosh
When you say you'll do something, do it goddamnit. Like voting Zentor when we ask.
You also gotta agree your case on me was terrible. The reason is simple: I didn't give space for a good case come at me. You became paranoid when I started tunneling you, and I think you should revise that.
Your earlier posts also looked a bit shady; On MSMM, you were very different. That's why we all had so much suspicion on you.

6. Dangeresque77
Somehow, I feel that instaclaim on JK was the correct thing to do. I hate the lack of breadcrumbs, but instaclaiming right after I claim the rb was good because this is a mini and there was another confirmed town.

However, you lacked on your vanilla department. Your scumhunting was sub-par, and most of the time you were only sheeping marv and me. Doubt everything, and play for yourself. Don't leave the game on the hands of the others, especially when you are semi-confirmed.

8. Sinensis
When you are town, don't overthink your posts. That gives us mechanical posts that resemble a lot of a cautious scum.

You were vanilla, you didn't had to be shy. You did a good job pissing me off day 1 though; and I admit it gave me some ideas for some cool plays. Still, you sheeped too much and put too little pressure into the scum team. These are some things worth mentioning

10. VE
I'm sorry
This is how it worked for me. I thought you were town. Then I realized you were always in the middle of the voters. Then I remembered that (useless) text I read about voters.
Then I made some suspicion on you, thought you were scum, but your reactions made me realize you actually were town.

To be honest, purely defending yourself is bad. When you are under pressure, you gotta show you are town not only by defending yourself, but by showing you can find scum. You didn't show much of scumhunting day 1 either.

You improved from MSMM though, and that's awesome. Much better to play with you here.

11. MsZontar
Next time your brother doesn't help you with the game, call him scum please.
Post more, be more active. Forum mafia is very different from live mafia as in it requires a lot more activity and you can't just go "I'm not sure ##vote".

Hopefully you get these things right in the future :D

12. drwiggl3s
The lynch on you was bad. I was away at the time and couldn't fight against it. Well, I'm not sure how I'd react though.
Day 1 lynches are always a pain though so there isn't much I can talk about here ;x

The Aberrants
MrZentor
I KNEW YOU WERE FUCKING SCUM SADGASFDHSDFHKJAHDJKFGASKJDGHDF well played sir. At various points, I was thinking "wait, I think I'm wrong" and I thought you were town by the endgame.

I'm glad my case on you was objectively correct though, helps me hunt moar :D

prplhz
BALLS. Claiming cop day 1? Fuck you. Why didn't I question that. I had you, but you came back with some emotional bullshit and a cop claim? I mean, that's a prime example of an excellent use of TL mafia meta, when we had so many mislynches by bullshit lately. Congratulations.

Bluelightz
I had a lot of doubts on you, but I thought all the time "He is always a big question mark so I can't read him". I can't believe it took me so long to realize you were scum. Well played sir.

Overall, scum team successfully raped town.
I feel ashamed to let the day 1 stuff pass by that way.

Anyways, GGWP scum. Deserve a mention on mafia awards.

On July 16 2012 00:54 VisceraEyes wrote:
sigh.
I'll be doing it again, but I'll be lynched for it.

Thx GM.

On July 16 2012 12:39 HiroPro wrote:


I thought you pulled it off nicely. It was probably inevitable that you would get lynched once for acting differently, but like it really was a huge difference in your style and defintely better for town.

---

The thing that really struck me as odd during this game was the way in which town shifted off lynching mafia so quickly. No one in mafia really was considered very townie yet all of them were able to cover for each other.