You are spamming up the thread with one liners, please stop it. I am not looking forward to rereading these pages. The reason for you to claim is at the moment it seems like you all have something to hide, and we really have no way of telling if it's for the right reason. Marv comes across as more direct and open with his views while risk is being a jerk. I got nothing on sentinel though, he placed a vote and went awol, and at the moment he is leading the lynch.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 19 2012 08:25 GMT

#1018

OK so mafia team is bad. I guess they where setting up for a blame on the top spots, but unless they found a way to clear sentinel he was going to die when we eventually found out he was lieing.

Agreed with talis analysis.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 19 2012 08:55 GMT

#1020

It actually makes me feel better about you, I wouldn't expect a mafia team with an experienced player on it to make a play like that and allow Sentinel to afk while town eventually figures him out. Marv was never really suspected because he actually took part in the discussion and seemed to want to figure things out, risk.nuke did as well eventually.

I'm not clearing sandroba though, he suggested we solved the situation with role checks and no lynch, went on to suggest a marv scenario and in the end traitor scenario.

Toad is interesting, he has been focusing a lot on how people aren't listening, I'm starting to fear he might be talking unclear because he has the wrong motivation. Gone to a null read for me.

Both can wait though, I'm fairly certain I know where I'll vote tomorrow.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 19 2012 10:17 GMT

#1024

mass claim at night=bad. We got enough information for at least a lynch tomorrow imo. I don't understand why you won't shoot palmar but an angry vigi should? For the record, angry vigi can't shoot at first night.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 19 2012 11:46 GMT

#1028

Well townies are more likely to spill their roles than mafia/SK, so it might not be a bad idea. Risk is most likely town and can shoot non coorporaters.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 19 2012 14:52 GMT

#1034

On May 19 2012 23:37 Mattchew wrote:
I think any townie with a gun should shoot barundar

Yeah that'd be great

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 21 2012 08:00 GMT

#1147

I see my name getting thrown around a lot without any reasons, and quite frankly it makes me less likely to contribute. I didn't take a hit last night (and why would they hit me), but hey maybe the last mafia will be nice and tell us who the sk is when we get him.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 21 2012 17:58 GMT

#1174

I guess I was just frustrated that I put a ton of effort into reading and re-reading yesterday before coming to the conclusion Palmar is town (which I still think for those who cares). My comment about who I was going to vote "tomorrow" was obviously PaqMan, before the action mess that apparantly happened. My top suspect for last scum is either sandroba or Hiro Protagonist, specially Hiro because he barely even considered the case against sentinel, but now I'm the one throwing names around without any backup.

My best guess for SK is Toad at this point with his self focus as well as mason claim as far as I remember after sandroba claimed vanilla and marv claimed mason, but I have no idea if that fits with the politician vanilla claim.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 22 2012 12:44 GMT

#1242

I did not get shot and suggesting I did is quite frankly stupid

. Bluelightz dieing I can only assume is either a blue snipe or an attempt to frame me. Zephirdd, I skimmed his case and couldn't find anything worth responding to yesterday, would you mind pointing it out?

If people want to hunt for SK today between those unclaimed names I'll be roleclaiming, otherwise I won't. I assume zepph is marv's mason buddy?

I discarded zelblade due to his vanilla claim, but I guess Hiro's scenario is possible. Will have to re-read before deciding between the 2 + sand.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 22 2012 12:47 GMT

#1245

On May 22 2012 21:46 risk.nuke wrote:
Barundar, if you refuse to roleclaim today I shoot you tonight. Start with claiming if you are vanilla or not.

Not vanilla.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 22 2012 12:49 GMT

#1247

he sugested the cpr mass murder thing

What?

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 22 2012 13:02 GMT

#1250

On May 22 2012 21:58 sandroba wrote:
@barundar your first post saying that I was likely town and i should pick cpr.

Fair enough, knew that was a... not sure of the english word, statement which people would get offended by that early in the game. Because I called you town, not because of the use.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 08:37 GMT

#1317

On May 23 2012 03:15 hiro protagonist wrote:
Im the Doctor. I protected Qatol both nights.

Liar!

Still a few pages to go, but Hiro is lieing.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 08:46 GMT

#1318

I protected qatol both night 1 and night 2. I like that Hiro say he did as well if he was roleblocked as Misder claim?

I thought I was the most obvious doctor ever, why did you think I was a roleblocker?

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 10:11 GMT

#1321

Why would you support a lynch on me

. I didn't want to reveal before it was absolutely necessary, because Im most likely to get night killed now. Hiro is lying, and based on the politician claims he must be the last scum. Lynching him means he can tell us who the sk is from the night hits.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 10:15 GMT

#1323

Sigh at this point where Im dead anyways come night it doesn't make the big difference, but you are set in your way and not looking things through. Hiro made an easy claim, willingly and way too early. Someone in top is the politician, and it's more efficient to get hiro to tell us who than to just let me die, lynch him tomorrow and then possible getting the sk reveal.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 10:21 GMT

#1325

On May 23 2012 19:19 zelblade wrote:
I actually think that hiro's behaviour has been more scummy as compared to Barundar's. However, I also find it extremely unlikely that the SK/scum would be willing to claim medic at position 16 due to the fact that its rather likely that someone above them in the draft could have taken it, and doing so would obviously force them into a 1-1 trade at best, and when theres one scum/sk left that isnt exactly the best trade.

Which means if we go by the assumption that hiro isnt making a (really bad) gambit barundar is the SK.

This is so much bull. Sigh.

Barundar

Denmark1582 Posts

May 23 2012 15:33 GMT

#1351

Didn't expect me to have picked doctor eh hiro? As I said it's smarter to kill Hiro first, since he is obviously lying to anyone who doesnt go by hear say but who actually reads the thread, but at least you are dead the moment I flip