Meh, posting a PM convo with Sandroba so people have something to read in an otherwise boring thread. A bit of info has been edited out.
I offered to have him filter DT hits through me to support my town claim to him. I would obviously do this, since failure would look scummy, intel would get out to all, DT would be safe, and only one at risk would be a vanilla townie{me}. Seemed good to me, simple yet effective way to contribute.
He rejected my idea. I asked him in thread to post some info. He refused again, but erased any hint of a doubt that he was scum via the jackal kill.
Original Message From michaelthe:
Ok, apparently you just want to only have a few people inside of you loop, but are confirmed town.
Original Message From sandroba:
Man, it's not wise for me to derail the thread discussion into stuff that does not find scum, that's why I was not responding to your inquiries in thread. It's not that I'm purposely leaving you out of the loop, I'm just protecting the info I have for the sake of town. It would be a really bad idea to claim to me if I just spilled it off at the first sign of pressure right?
I appreciate you trying to help out and I know it's hard to trust people, so I understand where you were coming from.
Original Message From michaelthe:
Show nested quote +It's not that I'm purposely leaving you out of the loop, I'm just protecting the info I have for the sake of town.
You literally say you aren't keeping me out of the loop, then describe keeping me out of the loop, in the same sentence.
I play to win, but I have zero incentive to be active in thread. Why spend a few hours making a case when you simply come in during the last 12 hours and say "I've found a inconsistency, vote Jackal" and everyone does it.
Original Message From sandroba:
What would you suggest me to do? I can't share my info with you based on hoping you are town. Sorry if you think the game is not interesting, but I'm doing my best to win, and whatever lack of activity in the thread is not my fault really.
About leaving it all to me, well it's not that easy unfortunately. All I have is information, and while that netted us one scum, the others still have to be found out. It would be great if you could keep on posting and trying to find scum based on the thread and keep it active. In the end behavior analysis is really the most effective weapon.
You should reread the thread with this new perspective (jackal + l10f scum, me + gm + * town) and try to figure out who is likely to be scum. I'm doing the same here, but I have like 20 people pming me constantly, so I really could use some help.
I just actually read that last line: try to figure out who is likely to be scum.... I really could use some help.
If our new overlord masters want help, give the entire thread all of the intel you have. Sure, maybe edit out one or two things that could be very harmful as soon as a scum knows it, but overall, I'm not going to waste 2 hours scum hunting just to have the above happen: On April 19 2012 11:40 chaoser wrote:
negative, kurumi is probably not mafia
2cents.