|
On April 17 2012 14:47 sinani206 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2012 09:32 EchelonTee wrote:
prplhz, I have never ever known you to play a lurky town style. You have literally posted nothing and as a semi-vet this is a glaring big red flag. I propose a prplhz lynch because he has done nothing which is utterly strange for him. And then he sheeps on MrZentor with 0 reasoning. Regardless of MrZ's alignment, prplhz absence is scummy.
##Vote prplhz Nice bandwagon. ##Vote: EchelonTee
This makes NO sense... but lets look at this bandwagon on prplhz...
If anything- Coagulation should be seen as the most suspicious after this exchange.. he jumps right on and targets prplhz, and was a big "lynch Ace" advocate....
And then we still have MrZentor, who I think is bussing prphlz with his meager response/reason for softly going along with a prplhz vote....
That being said, I'm willing to vote for either Zentor or prphlz, whichever will get a lynch...
Have people been talking to prphlz in PMs (outside of the one that was posted)?
|
On April 17 2012 09:04 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2012 08:58 Maverick32x wrote:
Just to back track-
@Sandroba-
You mentioned you had told the vig to l10f.. do we have proof on that?
I won't say that confirms you're town, but its pretty close, especially so early in the game....
Back on track-
I don't approve of this Mr. Zentor lynch. A lot of lurkers seem to be coming out of the woodwork to bandwagon on this one... Reading through his filters... not nearly that suspicious...
One huge problem I'm coming up against is reading filters, and wondering if this person is inactive (mavellosity for example) or if they are engaging in PMs with other players to make them seem more 'town'? Given I was talking to VE's wife, I would dare say I talk to people in PM land. I have a null read on her. If you had a specific question or questions, I'd love to give answering a bash.
I guess my specific question would be- who are you talking to in PM's and what is your read on them~
|
My vote is going with Coagulation... unnecessary hard lynching on Ace, and major bandwagoning as described above^
|
On April 17 2012 23:14 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2012 22:57 Maverick32x wrote:On April 17 2012 09:04 marvellosity wrote:On April 17 2012 08:58 Maverick32x wrote:
Just to back track-
@Sandroba-
You mentioned you had told the vig to l10f.. do we have proof on that?
I won't say that confirms you're town, but its pretty close, especially so early in the game....
Back on track-
I don't approve of this Mr. Zentor lynch. A lot of lurkers seem to be coming out of the woodwork to bandwagon on this one... Reading through his filters... not nearly that suspicious...
One huge problem I'm coming up against is reading filters, and wondering if this person is inactive (mavellosity for example) or if they are engaging in PMs with other players to make them seem more 'town'? Given I was talking to VE's wife, I would dare say I talk to people in PM land. I have a null read on her. If you had a specific question or questions, I'd love to give answering a bash. I guess my specific question would be- who are you talking to in PM's and what is your read on them~ There we go. People I spoke to most were Acro (as others can attest), sandroba, and recently wbg. Also had PM contact with others, perhaps notably zentor and GMarshal early. Reads for me are... difficult. At the moment I'm liking VE's interrogative stance on the GMarshal/sandroba duo. Early on, it was GMarshal that led me to trust sandroba and claim to sandroba. GMarshal's reasoning was that sandroba's plan that was apparently shot down by DrH was a town thing, plus the sheer amount of effort sandroba was putting in. What makes me uncomfortable is GMarshal's practically complete absence from the thread since then, eye problems not withstanding. Regarding zentor, in our (somewhat limited) contact I didn't really get a scummy vibe off him. Somewhat annoyingly, Acro told me to be suspicious of Zentor if Acro died, but supplied me with no reasoning for it.
That kinda makes me nervous..
|
Ok... I may of just had an epiphany and I'd like others to comment if they've shared this experience...
I've PM'ed back and forth with Sandroba VERY little... but it went like this:
Original Message From sandroba: Okay did you start off with any items? I got a green check on you. Show nested quote +Original Message From Maverick32x:
Ok, so I am a Station Researcher... which is pretty much a vanilla town...Also I currently don't have any items
Original Message From sandroba:
Did the host pm'ed you some weird flavour stuff as night 1 event? If he did i need to know who was mentioned in the pm. thx
And that is literally IT. I am not part of the secret PM club... and he offered really nothing back... it really seems like the only thing he is interested in are items and blue roles.... I'd be REALLY curious how his interactions have been with other players....
Also- still waiting on some kind of confirmation that Sandroba had made the decision to kill l1o since my 'town' read pretty much is revolving around that...
|
Honestly, I don't think that case against Kurumi is that solid...
I see a lot of connections that you are making..but I don't think a scum would defend their fellow scum-mates that frequently... would be WAY too suspicious....
As for my vote... I'm still reading and such.... which is barely useful based off the thread and how everyone just PMs;;
|
So I got a chance to flip through Strongandbig's filters... a couple trends that I noticed-
Constantly apologetic.
Really focused on Zentor... almost obsessively.. However, as others noted- he didn't actually stick a vote on him...
I'm thinking that a lynch on Strongandbig is the way to go, and he is the one I will be voting for. Not to mention a really late switch to Jackal on the last voting...
On a more general note- there was a point where a ton of hate landed on Zentor at almost the same time- Ace pointed this out... Depending on how Strongandbig flips, could indicate Zentor's alignment potentially.
|
whhooaa!! Nice shot!! So unexpected....
Also I empathize with you Rayzor..
|
Also based of Bug's okay-ness with lynching Strongandbig, I'm willing to change my vote... ET or Sinani I guess are the main people under scrutiny so I'll be checking them out.
|
Chaoser- I'm tempted to lean more towards ET than either of those two...
My reasoning is that Sinani and S&B were both voted/encouraged by WBG... Any strong counters to an ET vote?
|
yep- this was my first PM.. and 100% my last... I felt like I wasn't even playing ;;
Good to know I was got some good reads though!!
Thanks for the game Dr. H~
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
