C9++ Mini Mafia - Page 4

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 23 2012 01:37 GMT

#1003

On March 23 2012 07:59 Dirkzor wrote:

I know. But my statement is still valid. Even is Nemesis is town how can you justify lynching anyone else then him giving how day 1 + 2 went down?

How do you read TIPD?

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 23 2012 03:04 GMT

#1007

On March 23 2012 08:44 Nemesis wrote:
Obviously you look town now. I was thinking that either you or probulous was scum day 2, but not both of you.

As to who I would lynch right now I'm not sure, but I would take a look at Tobon for not being on the day 1 lynch. I find it more likely that the remaining mafia bussed their teammate on day 2 than on day 1 as I think everyone else in day 2 who weren't on probulous are town.

Okie dokes. A case (like the one you had on VE) would be nice when possible, or fleshing out your reasoning of the day 2 situation would be good to.

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 23 2012 03:13 GMT

#1008

Right now forcing transparency is probably the best thing we can do as it severely limits the mislynch options that scum have available. So time to bust out those town reads!

I'd particularly like these people to take this opportunity to speak up:
TIPD, Dirkzor, Nemesis

Topics you can talk about:
- What do you think of the voting patterns of people? Anything suspicious stick out?
- What do you think of each other?
- What would mafia try to do now? (I know this has WIFOM but if you had to guess then what would it be)

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 23 2012 14:06 GMT

#1051

Hurray for town!

Oh man Probulous I feel for you - inactivity + early deadline must have been painful.
From ScumQT:

I think I can get Sloosh onside, he can play really well but has a major tendency to tunnel. He just needs a little support.

Hehe you nailed it. I think with your case on me I just turned on the tunnel and dug right in, which is really good for town if the receiving end is mafia as all sorts of stuff you want hidden are forced to get revealed, especially when VE got on board. Which is interesting as to why you picked me as a target - I know when I played as mafia in NMMIV I led two mislynches and it was hard to have people still listen to me. Who would have you gone for if I flipped D2?

I think you should have exploited my tendency to tunnel. If you somehow instigated the xsksc vs me thing I might have gone full blown OMGUS + tunnel and dominated the discussion while you guys would be free to lurk, as you saw cringingly in SNMMVII. Basically making me mislynch myself.

VE is dangerous because he is prodding people and getting correct town reads on him, plus he will most certainly be a medic protect option tonight given his early death in the last game he played and his vocal nature.

This one gave me a chuckle :p. (to those who don't know, refer to NMMIII where shooting the obviously-protected-cause-he-is-so-town medic d1 could have totally changed game)

Thank you to the hosts and players for an overall enjoyable game. Got to experience the other side of a mislynch and thrill of flipping scum. Oh and reading really does help as I learnt - with my back against the wall I pulled out any and everything to survive from thread and filter which helps town so much by bringing up inconsistencies / limiting possible mafia agendas (assuming you don't have that many derps like mine).

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 23 2012 21:50 GMT

#1092

?? Did I say something misleading?

I didn't consciously decide to lurk D1 if that is the question.

Uhh, actually maybe I did - when VE pushed johnnywub I just sat back and watched to see who would do what. That is where I got my Nemesis town read from, because he did what I would have done. Plus since I wanted to see some discussion happen I didn't want to do an absolute roadblock on that.

My case on xsksc was a genuine misread - I missed that one post and he looked really suspicious after I saw ( or rather I didn't see) it. I backed off when I realized I missed everything else.

Then being on the other side of a mislynch generally gave me much content and an avenue to talk and share reads etc. So I suppose in comparison my D1 seems more inactive / lurking than D2. I really don't know how to properly drive discussion D1 with nothing to go off on, so any tips there would be good.

Hmm. So as I see there is two styles of doing it.
One is more active in your face like VE this game or Probulous (town / SK)
the other is little prods like Sandroba this game or Adam4179 in the games I've played.

Any advice which one I should tend to or how I should improve that aspect?

slOosh

3291 Posts

March 24 2012 16:19 GMT

#1148

On March 25 2012 01:14 wherebugsgo wrote:
had you guys fakeclaimed off the jackal death and become "confirmed" (I can 100% guarantee that they would never think a scum claim+counterclaim of cop would ever in a million years happen) then killing jcarl might have been okay.

What should the counterclaim cop do after the scum cop flips? Play town with wrong reads?
Since it is possible in a c9++ setting for multiple cops, how can you say that it makes sense that a (town) cop would insta-counterclaim?

Prev 1 2 3 4 All

Please or register to reply.

C9++ Mini Mafia - Page 4

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming