|
On March 03 2012 10:27 Palmar wrote:
you Adam4167
also, if I'm scum you lynch me, vet or not it's bad logic to let vets get away with shit.
On March 04 2012 03:14 Palmar wrote:Deconduo, you decided to use an easy fucking bullshit explanation to vote a townie, even after I told you that it was bullshit, and I later explained that I thought he was town. I take that as an insult. You're literally calling me bad at mafia by straight up refusing to listen to me.I will make sure you die this game.
Palmar do you still think a scum team of sandroba, Adam and decon makes sense? Your input would be appreciated. As with Jackal you're good when you're town so I value your thoughts.
|
@Everyone 
What would be a reasonably balanced number of scum if there was a Serial Killer. I know this is setup speculation and so cannot be relied upon but I have no idea how these setups are usually balanced. I have been basing on reads on the assumption of three mafia, is this reasonable?
|
EBWOP: *my reads
What a fail 
|
Once the lynch is done can we please get a final vote count that includes the ordering of the votes? eg Toast is labelled as the first voter for sandroba which is not correct. I can do this if it is not part of the hosts' responsibility. Thanks
|
On March 06 2012 11:38 Adam4167 wrote:
I'm posting from my phone so I can't quote stuff.
Prob, I already stated why I'm on the sandroba lynch in that post. It's too late in the day for me to push the cases I want to push, so I'm bandwagon voting on sandroba to try and get a better grasp on what happened last night. I like other lynches better but convincing at least 4 people to move off of sandroba is something that would take more time then we had when I voted.
It's a shit vote and I know it, but my vote going anywhere else is just as shit, considering the current vote tally.
Well this is completely illogical. Your last sentence implies that sandroba is getting lynched regardless of your vote. The rest of your post suggests you want a conclusion to the night hit. Well combining those would suggest that you will get that conclusion regardless of how you vote.
In this situation it would make sense to stick with your reads. If people switch to your reads then great, if not you get clarification on the hit. Either way it looks like you don't believe he is scum, so why vote for him? You're taking the easy way out and I don't like it. Town Adam doesn't do things the easy way.
|
Waiting for a typical TL last minute vote switch that leads to a medic outing themselves and a no-lynch. This game has been pretty boring. Half the time I end up talking to myself.
Paper I am still waiting on your response to my question about decon.
|
ROFL that timing again. Always gets me.
f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5f5
|
*dancing in the street*
ooooh yeah!!!!
|
Final Scummy Votes
Sandroba - 8
3) bluelightz
Deconduo - 1
1) Paperscraps
Bluelightz
On March 06 2012 00:12 Bluelightz wrote:
Alright, I'm voting sandroba, I believe his scum because he is useless and has not provided good content, his hit claim is interesting though.
##Vote: sandroba
He needs to be splattered across the pavement, preferably across many pavements.
Paperscraps
On March 06 2012 09:22 Paperscraps wrote:
Hmmmm, my gut tells me that Sandroba is vet, but logic dictates that Sandroba is mafia/SK. This bandwagon on Sandroba went up pretty darn fast. But, alas Sandroba hasn't taken his vote off of AKCT and not putting up a fight at all. This lynch on Sandroba doesn't feel right. I feel if I change my vote though, people will think that scummy. Only one person died last night. Something doesn't fit here. Going to change my vote anyways. Back to my "tunnel" on Deconduo, who has been coasting.
##Unvote
##Vote: Deconduo
Inb4 people say I am scum trying to make myself look townie "if" Sandroba flips vet.
A single person getting shot simply implies there is no SK. It's almost like he knows there is another kill point and that is what is causing the confusion. In other words sandroba did get shot and his claim was real. I believe this to be true as referenced by my earlier posts. Sandroba's claim was not one of celebration that a vet or fake claim would be. He didn't want to claim the shot but he had to. He flipped red which means that if sandroba was shot he was saved by a mafia medic.
The rest of this post is a clear attempt to distance himself from sandroba. His decision to vote for decon isn't that he thinks decon is scum but rather that sandroba "feels" like a vet. I've asked him to clarify his reason for voting for decon because all I read is "bad reads" which clearly Paper also has. I would not be upset if I saw him missing a head.
|
Urrgh this thread is dead. I'm going to laugh if I die overnight cause this thread will turn into a ghost town. Come on guys post your thoughts, move this thread along. There is plenty to analyse but no-one is here. I'm heading home now and might log on later.
|
*High five*
You could have boiled that down but it is a decent case. I laughed when I jumped back on here and you had posted this massive case and Adam has posted "what do you want to talk about?" There is a reason you look town and he doesn't. I am interested in Paper's response, especially an explanation for his voting.
|
On March 06 2012 20:58 Paperscraps wrote:
1. Decon's read on Misder was wrong. Probulous he called you scum as well. Was he wrong in that?
2. Decon says making lists are pointless, claiming they are filler. I disagree
3. Decon's reaction to me calling him scum was bad. He over reacted. I find this scummy.
4. Decon's reaction to Misder flipping scum was bad. He wasn't remorseful about it.
5. Decon also rages at Sandroba for being useless this game, saying a vig should shoot Sandroba. There is merit here for both town and mafia play.
6. Decon has been coasting the past two days. Posting filler, no scum hunting, not very town.
7. Decon votes up Sandroba, calling him "almost certainly SK". There is merit here for both town and mafia play once again.
I don't think you thought your case through very well. You have seven points all of which could come from a town or mafia agenda. What is with the bolded bit?
As for this
On March 06 2012 21:04 Paperscraps wrote:
Also on side note: Since Sandroba flipped mafia. What does everyone think of the hit claim?
1. The hit claim was fake.
2. The hit was real and mafia/town medic saved Sandroba?
I've explained my reasoning why I think the shot was real. Why would a mafia sandroba claim veteran with such a weak claim? If he wanted to get credit for it he would have celebrated the shot, make it clear to everyone he was targeted. Instead he responds to something else and then casually mentions the fact. It makes sense that he was shot given his reaction to it. This means scum have a medic and we have a SK. Vig would have claimed by now.
|
On March 06 2012 15:55 Adam4167 wrote:
I don't push cases at night time, unless its so close to the deadline that mafia cant shoot me for it.
On March 06 2012 21:21 Adam4167 wrote:
There's really no way to know which it is until morning. Even then, there's situations where it could be ambiguous.
Why you such a downer this game Adam? I don't think I have ever seen someone get shot for posting at night. All you are doing is refusing to contribute behind a weak excuse. The sandoba shot is the one thing we have right now that can help provide some useful information. Of course the conclusions have to be tentative but we can still work it out based on his posting. I think my logic is clear and fairly robust. Besides if there was one thing you could comment on that would surely not get you shot it would be the dead guy. You're avoiding posting, why?
|
On March 06 2012 19:01 Bluelightz wrote:
Nice flip ^^! Was at school for most of the day so couldnt post much. We should take a look at the people who wanted to derail the lynch.
In my ideal world there are two possible things happening to you- You actually provide this analysis and it is useful
- You make a handsome throw rug
I'm clearing the floor to make room cause I think hell will freeze before I get useful information from you.
I love how you completely ignore this post
On March 06 2012 12:34 Probulous wrote:Final Scummy VotesSandroba - 83) bluelightz BluelightzShow nested quote +On March 06 2012 00:12 Bluelightz wrote:
Alright, I'm voting sandroba, I believe his scum because he is useless and has not provided good content, his hit claim is interesting though.
##Vote: sandroba He needs to be splattered across the pavement, preferably across many pavements.
You still haven't explained responded to my original case/s (1, 2) You are lurking and need to die.
|
EBWOP: explained
I think I need a coffee. BRB
|
On March 07 2012 07:32 Paperscraps wrote: The bolded part is a question to you? Was Decon wrong in calling you scum?
Now that right there is a stupid question  I have made it clear all game long that I am just your regular townie, which given my game history is a refreshing change. Decon being wrong does not make him scum.
|
ROFL Snarfs on the ball
Palmar needs a hug but it is a long way to go for me. Can I send a hug through the internet or is that just weaksauce?
|
I voted 2.
I like even numbers and being the only even prime, 2 has to get my vote.
|
That's a big post, what's it say?
|
I see you have a full grasp of the quoting function. Whilst this is a useful skill to have it would be more beneficial if you made a point. If this continues you will be guilty of spamming which is highly ironic given your first post.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
