On March 02 2012 01:15 sandroba wrote:
It doesn't matter if LaL is stupid or not we will talk about it when/if it becomes a problem. I don't mind any of the people that start talking about it because I realize we have to start at something and it's as good as any starting subject but that's it. I agree that the list is pointless but, I wouldn't touch on probulous right now as he is posting a lot and trying to get things moving.

Less posting, more proving you're town by finding the one confirmed townie in the game. (pro-tip: it's not me)

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 01 2012 16:18 GMT

#186

well, there's one guy in the thread who's almost certainly town. If you can't find him you're scum.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 01 2012 16:21 GMT

#187

On March 02 2012 01:18 deconduo wrote:

Show nested quote +

Do you want me to show you how often scum make pointless lists in games? Its the most obvious filler you can make, because it a massive important looking post that adds absolutely nothing to the game.

Show nested quote +

No, I have no idea why YOU think its bad.

Yeah, please show me examples of scum making fluffy lists.

And I think it's bad because none of the things you mentioned say anything about the alignment of the players in question. It doesn't mean they're town, it just means that your analysis is invalid. For example, you're being massively dumb and saying LAL is stupid when it isn't (I'm not going to argue this, I'm right). However that tells me very little about your alignment.

While the posts you quoted from both probulous and misder do reflect something about them, what you pointed out certainly isn't it.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 01 2012 16:24 GMT

#189

lol, you so scum.

Please post more so I can prove it to the rest of the thread.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 01 2012 16:30 GMT

#191

Sharing town reads isn't bad, it's just something some scum invented at some point in order to not have to call either their teammates or townies town. One incriminates them when either flips, and the other is bad because it limits their options.

I think it's very likely rgTS is town from his posting so far in the thread. It's not unreasonable that you didn't find him because you're not looking for it in the same way I am, we are different people after all. The problem is the reasoning you gave for not looking for or sharing your town reads.

##Vote Sandroba

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 09:41 GMT

#246

I still think we should be lynching sandroba.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 09:41 GMT

#247

i don't think deconduo is scum, or well, his response to me calling him terrible seemed kinda towny

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 09:52 GMT

#248

Paperscraps looks towny, so does rgTS. I'm not really sure about teacup, but there's nothing super scummy in his posting so far.

I refuse to analyse jackal58, cause I never get it right. misder seems towny i think. Adam not so much, he could be scummer. I'm not quite sure about probulous, something is off about his play I think, but I can't exactly tell if it's because he's scum. Bluelightz is impossible to read, but assuming the obvious he's town.

I actually think snarfs looks pretty towny from his sk asking post, it just seemed genuine enough not to be fabricated to make us think he's clueless town, in addition I don't think scum often does that.

No clue about the rest really. Toast and Pandain and anyone else I might be forgetting, but if I forget you it's because your content has been worthless so far. So take it as an insult please.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 09:53 GMT

#249

I think it's very likely we have an SK, due to the number of players in the game.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 11:07 GMT

#251

That's an incorrect conclusion to draw from my wording, an alternative scenario is that you're simply town and playing in a different way than I expected. That would certainly make something off about your play, without making you either sk or scum.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 02 2012 23:42 GMT

#290

Cause I want to lynch sandroba you dumbass. Don't be thick.

The case on sandroba isn't weak at all. It's based on the simple fact that his reads are off, he's disagreeing with me for the incorrect reasons and not putting any time into the game at all. I'll list it up:

1. Sandroba refused to try and point out a random townie in the thread because "he doesn't want to give away townreads". Now I know this is a common misconception, but sandroba is not dumb enough to fall for it like all the newbies. Giving away town reads is fine because if you force mafia to do it, they have to either call their scum mates town, or double back later in the game.

2. Sandroba's reasons for voting people in this game seem to not be the ones I'd expect him to use. he has basically attacked two people who in my opinion had at the time done very little that reveals much about their alignment in the thread.

3. Sandroba has put almost no effort into figuring out my alignment this game. While as town it would be a very obvious thing to do for him to put in a lot of effort into seeing if I'm scum, both because my scum play tends to be quite obvious and also because he knows that as a team we could probably smash the game.

I conclude, he must be scum.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 03 2012 01:01 GMT

#297

this isn't a pure meta case. Of course it's influenced by the fact that I give sandroba less leeway then the normal newbie, but anyone posting the way he is would be wrong and scummy, it's just less likely he's dumb than the normal townie.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 03 2012 01:08 GMT

#301

Can we get some people to switch to sandroba please, misder is very unlikely to flip scum.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 03 2012 01:27 GMT

#310

you Adam4167

also, if I'm scum you lynch me, vet or not it's bad logic to let vets get away with shit.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 03 2012 01:42 GMT

#313

I can only lynch one person today, and I think sandroba has a much higher chance of flipping scum than you. Hell, he isn't even trying to deflect the lynch off of him.

Palmar

Iceland22633 Posts

March 03 2012 18:14 GMT

#332

misder as far from useless, anyone voting him is not reading the thread, stupid, or scum.

Deconduo, you decided to use an easy fucking bullshit explanation to vote a townie, even after I told you that it was bullshit, and I later explained that I thought he was town. I take that as an insult. You're literally calling me bad at mafia by straight up refusing to listen to me.

I will make sure you die this game.