EPTNewbie Mini Mafia IV - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
 it sucks when you get treated like scum because you act like scum but don't get the powers.Also you said yourself the case against phagga is weak which is why I haven't attacked him till now, hopefully it'll get stronger when/if I flip green. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 02 2012 09:55 Chocolate wrote: Why can't we vote nttea? If he prevents himself from getting modkilled we should lynch him, gum contributes more than him. NF I will post a better reasoning at home but basically I thought the fact that you dropped ghost because he defended himself but not me was scummy. Especially considering his short post. You talked about this but I still think it's scummy. Cou-lynching me will give more information-gh Ehhhh what a cough, i totally agree with you chocolate we should lynch ntte, his behaviour is way scummier. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 02 2012 10:00 NightFury wrote: If you flip green, then it's the event where you could not have known his alignment. That is not basis alone to absolve him. damm your good. No not really, I find people who have suspects lined up that have no connection to one another very suspicius. It sound like You intend to mislynch me today and mislynch alderan tomorrow. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 02 2012 10:05 DoYouHas wrote: ##Unvote: k2hd ##Vote: nttea DYH that vote isnt going to happen -_- | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 02 2012 10:05 DoYouHas wrote: ##Unvote: k2hd ##Vote: nttea and I find it sorta scummy that your willing to waste your vote like that. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 02 2012 10:09 DoYouHas wrote: ##Unvote: nttea ##Vote: k2hd yeees goooood trigger a no lynch why wont you fair sir. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
Oh and mafia well played I suppose. Lastly, DYH your a better man than I, all the best and I am sorry for badgering you , good luck winning this game. | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
| ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 08 2012 12:46 gonzaw wrote: So the first time we are even mentioned in a suspicious light, is at the beginning of N3? So...who were you talking about there with the "better analysis"? >_> Wait... OBS QT; WHY Y NOT FOS US NOT EVEN A SINGLE TIME!!!???? Really? No players from the game FoSed us a single time; and no one from the Obs QT FoSes us either. Wtf? lol I was making a bet with Ceph the other day (at the beginning of D3) about when players would FoS us for the first time He betted on halfway through D3, I betted on halfway through N3... ....we were both hilariously wrong >_> DYH, may you explain why you thought we were town? EDIT: Apart from that "You guys were blue!" thing. Ceph already explained that to me like 1000 times >_> Early on you said something that really bugged me "I have got my hands on Hyde, and after talking about our opinions, we agreed to disagree in some things" That post was very very frustrating I read it and realized it would be perfect scum play, like perfect, first off why would a scum hydra disagree with itself? It know everything, furthermore your disagreement statues opens things up for you both to state opposite opinions, this move would be a stroke of genius if you were scum, the more likely explanation(well to be fair the one I wanted to be true) though was that you were just a conflicting townie hydra, but with that one line I realized it would too difficult to tackle you if you were mafia because I would be fighting someone who could agree with me and disagree with me at the same, Personally I think you should've capitalized on it more, you should've offered more split opinions and used the fact that you couldn't agree with each other as an excuse for poor lynch options if you were pressured(though that never came up as you pointed out ) | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 08 2012 13:12 gonzaw wrote: Really? I thought it was standard hydra-scum play. For instance, Bromancipate (Prob+Jitsu hydra on Newbie 3) did it with zelblade (Jitsu thought he was town, and Prob thought he was scum, or the other way round), and some others I think. That didn't work that well for them though, so I didn't really think it was a "perfect scum play". But that would have required me to post in the thread >_> yeah >_> I guess your right, I saw that early on and was like dammit thats brilliant, but I guess stuff like this comes down to experience | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 09 2012 03:52 DoYouHas wrote: slOosh did a great job of controlling the thread without immediately being drawn out as scum. NightFury played the hapless noob extremely well. J&H confused the hell out of me (though I blame most of that on them being a hydra). Phagga tunneled Chocolate a little too hard, though I blame myself for not bringing him around. Alderan, I really should have just started pushing people who would have cleared you early. Right from the start I realized we were thinking pretty similarly. If I had taken action to get a town read on you I think we could have torn the thread up. Ghost, when you posted those 2 quick posts after slOosh's defense, I decided you either just made a very very bad play or you were scum. They did sound rushed, they were contradictory, and they showed you sided with slOosh at that point. Whether or not that was true, that is how they came across. I didn't have a full case against you. But for me, just those 2 posts were enough. I should have realized that slOosh wouldn't have taken the risk of bussing you with his day1 case. But with how easily those suspicions were dropped by slOosh and Alderan, I thought slOosh might have been just being extra sneaky. k2hd, the fact that you were not posting often and you were posting extremely safe put you on both my radar and Alderan's. It took a scum vouching for your innocence before we would believe you. The scum team had you pegged as the DT day4. You in all likelihood would have been hit that night even if we lynched correctly. If your schedule permits it you have to take a more active role if you want to avoid being hit for looking blue by scum. gumshoe, it saddened me a bit to watch you get frustrated with the game and just start posting things that were wrong or had no benefit to the town. You showed last game that you can look at the game from a different angle, which is extremely valuable. Instead of looking at the lack of activity as a bad thing, take that opportunity when you know that the town isn't going to be posting new things that you need to respond to to read filters and generate content. zelblade, you need to start siding with me over slOosh. This is the second game you have picked up his cause and then offered a weak case against me. I wanted to believe that you were town. But the way you pushed me felt so much like SNMM7 that I started getting suspicious, and it also reduced my suspicion of slOosh. You threw a monkey wrench in my understanding of the game. Janaan, sad you got hit. I gave you my case on Test ( : the real gem was how quickly he reacted to it, he posted his defence even before I posted the entire case. Bit sad he got passed over ) : Also Sloosh was just so frustrating, I knew he was scum, his play was so much more vindictive, so much less positive, and after mislynching he showed no remorse, town sloosh would've gotten alot more emotional if he had just been the cause of towns third mislynch in a row, but there was no way to beat him back, he was just so entrenched in the thread and he never slipped up ) : my mistake was phagga but that was just more because he insulted me, lesson being keep your cool regardless if your the aggressor or the defender, and I wont lie its unbelievably disheartening to just know that someone is scum(test who was clearly playing the noob card to extreme lengths) and not be able to do anything about it because you've spent the whole game over compensating for other players with pointless posts ) : and now your word is worth less than copper league. Kudos to sloosh for being such a hard nut to crack. Also really glad ghost was a townie ( : | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On March 09 2012 04:08 gonzaw wrote: To be honest, we weren't technically a "hydra". It was more like I was replaced by Jekyll. Until N2, I was the only one that posted After N2, Jekyll was the only one that posted. I don't think we ever interacted with each other or posted reads at the same time, except for that "We just disagree with some reads" comment that happened only twice. So, trying to analyse us would be the same as analysing zelblade/4face for instance. But it didnt seem that way on the surface ( : Point is when a townies like ok time to build a case, do they wanna tackle the guy whose accused them or the guy who says hes a super noob? Or do you tackle the guy who IS TWO GUYS. | ||
| ||
