Kaller Game - Page 5

On March 03 2012 04:23 Mattchew wrote:

cause hes town

On March 03 2012 04:56 vaderseven wrote:

Did your analysis happen to include his in post (firat post of his filter) ehere he clearly states this is his first game?

I dont find him scummy grey. I think he would be more coached if he was. As was said (ach hate to agree but) its a coindlip lynch at best.

On March 04 2012 08:54 Jayjay54 wrote:
Because scum wouldn't have an unkillable player. that insta-breaks the game. Town can only win when scums are dead.

if they have an unkillable role, they can't lose whatsoever. Town can still lose even with this role, because they have to be outnumbered. Third only makes sense if additional wincon is in there, but neither sheth nor nisani nor v7 claimed that.

Therefore ocean = town.

If I shoot him, there's still the chance of a scum medic. Yes. I am aware of that. But it is a really good chance that he's town if he survives this night.

On March 05 2012 03:13 Jayjay54 wrote:


it's not wasted. it'll confirm a townie at worst. Best scenario is I prevented everyone from believing a guy who is scum and killing him.

Not everybody believes his claim, for those, the shot makes perfect sense.

If I just randomly shoot into lurkers I have a good chance of killing town.

On March 05 2012 03:27 Jayjay54 wrote:


I agree it's not 100% confirming, they could have a medic or something as well. But where do you want to go from here? Ignore him until the rest of the game? I don't know how many vigs we have. I can only shoot tonight and not tomorrow. If he is unlynchable AND a vig, a shot still makes sense. You can't ignore him for the rest of the game.

Again, I think he's lying. And I don't believe kurumi would implement two "boring" roles like this with (assumable) so little scum around.

On March 05 2012 07:31 GreYMisT wrote:
Alright so it looks like GGQ was probably the one who burned me. I did not get burned last night weirdly enough which means he probally used one of his other abilities. Can anyone confirm if they recieved a nuke or vodka?

On March 06 2012 06:41 vaderseven wrote:
On Liquid`Sheth-
You are either playing an amazingly bad game as town or going for a hilarious wifom gambit as scum. The longer the game goes on the more I think the latter which is not how it usually goes in cases like this. I feel like your lies are just too much to take at this point. Leaning towards scum

On Bill Murray-
Lurker. Thinking maybe scum or 3rd party. Leaning towards 3rd party.

On Jayjay54-
He says he shot me last night. I didn't get a message about being shot. I think Nisani201 said he did get a message about being shot once with a bodygaurd message in there. If Nisani201 hasn't received any info on being shot since he became an ocean we cant conclude anything about Jay based on his claimed shot. If I ever get shot again and receive a message then I will look closer. His case on me seems legit pre my claim. Prolly town.

On Nisani201-
A flip on sheth would make me feel 100% either way about Nisani. You have pretty much played a very cautious game and thats not what you should be doing with the role you have at this point in time.

On EchelonTee-
Fairly sure he is town based on out of thread (oot) items.


These guys I dont raelly know yet. If anyone can add to my understanding via oot talking pls do so especially if your evidence helps to understand these people:

Kenpachi
evantrees
blubbdavid
Bluelightz
Ciryandor
Forumite
GreYmist

I am up for a Bill Murray or Sheth lynch as of right now.

Deadline is 20 minutes or so away or 1 day and 20 so minutes away? The latter right?

On March 06 2012 15:37 syllogism wrote:
Greymist are you mafia or stupid?

On March 06 2012 17:17 evantrees wrote:
Unsure still debating but I want to try and go to sleep soon. So give me a reason to vote for someone else.
would you rather I voted for Ciryandor for no reason?


For Poland?

On March 06 2012 17:19 syllogism wrote:

So you are still around but unwilling to vote for Forumite? There are 13 players alive, out of those there's 5-6 mafia and bluelightz suddenly gets 7 votes for no reason at all; do you really think he is mafia? Even vaderseven is voting for him

Original Message From Forumite:
........Unless Sheth actually got a helpfull role now then he´s a VT, can´t do anything, can´t even take another night to compensate for the failed check last night. There´s a town thief out there, who once each day can switch the roles of two players......

On March 07 2012 01:40 vaderseven wrote:


Someone make an intelligent statement saying why people are mass trusting someone that could very well win with any of the main factions in this game?

On March 07 2012 01:56 Forumite wrote:
What´s so surprising about me being right about the thief being a townie? The thief didn´t steal powers and keep them hidden, instead he took and saved pro-town powers from players who just claimed, and give them to other town players, so the power would not get lost to a nightkill. Chaos13 had an inventor role, he claimed and was a target, then later that role shows up on when syllo flipped. If the thief was scum, then syllo wouldn´t have been the one with the inventor role.