|
On February 20 2012 07:13 Jayjay54 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2012 07:12 hiro protagonist wrote:Over a century ago, murderer Cyrus Gold sought to escape justice by hiding in the Slaughter Swamp, where he met a fate worse than death. Mysterious forces doomed the now immortal Grundy to and endless cycle of death and rebirth. Robbed of his memories he has adopted the name of a nursery rhyme.
“Solomon Grundy, Born on a Monday, Christened on Tuesday, Married on Wednesday, Took ill on Thursday, Grew worse on Friday, Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday. This is the end of Solomon Grundy”
You are the bodyguard of penguin and protect him should he be hit from an attack. You are also extremely strong. You have the option of two powers. Bulletproof for a night or revenge killer(you kill the first person who attacks you in a night). Once your power has been expended (you have been hit on any given night after choosing which power to use) you are powerless and can die to a regular hit on any subsequent nights. Much like the rhyme your name comes from, if you survive a full seven days after your first hit, your powers refresh. Could I get confirmation that if option 2 was chosen, then He would only have 1 life? even IF that's the case, how would scum know?
They did not know, but that does not me its not a possibility right?
|
EBWOP: does not mean its not a possibility
|
On February 20 2012 07:18 hiro protagonist wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2012 07:13 Jayjay54 wrote:On February 20 2012 07:12 hiro protagonist wrote:Over a century ago, murderer Cyrus Gold sought to escape justice by hiding in the Slaughter Swamp, where he met a fate worse than death. Mysterious forces doomed the now immortal Grundy to and endless cycle of death and rebirth. Robbed of his memories he has adopted the name of a nursery rhyme.
“Solomon Grundy, Born on a Monday, Christened on Tuesday, Married on Wednesday, Took ill on Thursday, Grew worse on Friday, Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday. This is the end of Solomon Grundy”
You are the bodyguard of penguin and protect him should he be hit from an attack. You are also extremely strong. You have the option of two powers. Bulletproof for a night or revenge killer(you kill the first person who attacks you in a night). Once your power has been expended (you have been hit on any given night after choosing which power to use) you are powerless and can die to a regular hit on any subsequent nights. Much like the rhyme your name comes from, if you survive a full seven days after your first hit, your powers refresh. Could I get confirmation that if option 2 was chosen, then He would only have 1 life? even IF that's the case, how would scum know? They did not know, but that does not me its not a possibility right?
if they want to kill a vet and don't know about that, they'd doublestack. If they doublestack, no KP is unaccounted.
The ONLY way he tells the truth is that Palmar shot him instead of VE, I find that rather unlikely...
|
On February 20 2012 07:19 Jayjay54 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2012 07:18 hiro protagonist wrote:On February 20 2012 07:13 Jayjay54 wrote:On February 20 2012 07:12 hiro protagonist wrote:Over a century ago, murderer Cyrus Gold sought to escape justice by hiding in the Slaughter Swamp, where he met a fate worse than death. Mysterious forces doomed the now immortal Grundy to and endless cycle of death and rebirth. Robbed of his memories he has adopted the name of a nursery rhyme.
“Solomon Grundy, Born on a Monday, Christened on Tuesday, Married on Wednesday, Took ill on Thursday, Grew worse on Friday, Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday. This is the end of Solomon Grundy”
You are the bodyguard of penguin and protect him should he be hit from an attack. You are also extremely strong. You have the option of two powers. Bulletproof for a night or revenge killer(you kill the first person who attacks you in a night). Once your power has been expended (you have been hit on any given night after choosing which power to use) you are powerless and can die to a regular hit on any subsequent nights. Much like the rhyme your name comes from, if you survive a full seven days after your first hit, your powers refresh. Could I get confirmation that if option 2 was chosen, then He would only have 1 life? even IF that's the case, how would scum know? They did not know, but that does not me its not a possibility right? if they want to kill a vet and don't know about that, they'd doublestack. If they doublestack, no KP is unaccounted. The ONLY way he tells the truth is that Palmar shot him instead of VE, I find that rather unlikely...
OK, second question then:
Would the Mafia's Detective be given full role information about someone they investigated?
|
Im not trying to save JB right now btw, Im just trying to figure out all possible solutions, with all the info, we lynch the scummer person k?
|
The only possible way JB checks out is if Palmar shot at him.
Palmar only mentions JB twice in his entire 17 page filter. Once on Day 1 to commend me on my amazing RSV, and once on day 3, when he posted his list on the entire game, where he highlighted him has town.
Still think he shot him?
I don't. I think he shot VE. I think JB is lying. I think you'll flip Deadshot tonight when you get vigged, I think you should surrender because we have 2 lynches up our sleeve to find your last teammate.
|
On February 20 2012 07:23 hiro protagonist wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2012 07:19 Jayjay54 wrote:On February 20 2012 07:18 hiro protagonist wrote:On February 20 2012 07:13 Jayjay54 wrote:On February 20 2012 07:12 hiro protagonist wrote:Over a century ago, murderer Cyrus Gold sought to escape justice by hiding in the Slaughter Swamp, where he met a fate worse than death. Mysterious forces doomed the now immortal Grundy to and endless cycle of death and rebirth. Robbed of his memories he has adopted the name of a nursery rhyme.
“Solomon Grundy, Born on a Monday, Christened on Tuesday, Married on Wednesday, Took ill on Thursday, Grew worse on Friday, Died on Saturday, Buried on Sunday. This is the end of Solomon Grundy”
You are the bodyguard of penguin and protect him should he be hit from an attack. You are also extremely strong. You have the option of two powers. Bulletproof for a night or revenge killer(you kill the first person who attacks you in a night). Once your power has been expended (you have been hit on any given night after choosing which power to use) you are powerless and can die to a regular hit on any subsequent nights. Much like the rhyme your name comes from, if you survive a full seven days after your first hit, your powers refresh. Could I get confirmation that if option 2 was chosen, then He would only have 1 life? even IF that's the case, how would scum know? They did not know, but that does not me its not a possibility right? if they want to kill a vet and don't know about that, they'd doublestack. If they doublestack, no KP is unaccounted. The ONLY way he tells the truth is that Palmar shot him instead of VE, I find that rather unlikely... OK, second question then: Would the Mafia's Detective be given full role information about someone they investigated?
man, occam's razor?
you say that
a) he was DTed by bugs
b) Not killed immediately
c) when he claimed scum speculated that he had chosen option 2 and therefore
d) only used one shot, knowing that they gonna loose a member by killing him?
Just to make a KP free for JBs story?
Gather around children, hiro tells tales.
|
And yes, Im willing to side on occums razor, in that it would be extremely unlikely that the DT check him, and the killed him with deadshot protected with the intention of setting up this whole situation. but I want to know if its a possibility k?
|
lol wow, what a ninja that was, both saying Occums razor ^__^
|
I was so hoping you'd say that Hiro!
In this star- studded lineup of mafia players, you think Bugs chose N1 to investigate TUNKEG?
They wouldn't have got his night 2 check since he died that night.
You are grasping at straws.
|
|
|
So you're argueing that they DT'd him on N1, got his role, knew it would only take a single shot to kill him, then waited thee in game days, the day he claims, then they shot him with a single shot?
OK.
|
Yes, what you're putting forward is possible
but it is so outlandishly improbable, that i'm just going to go with the simpler explanation
you're defending your scum friend
|
good, glad your on board Adam, now we can move on to talking about which person we should lynch today based on all this info.
the Problem : both could be telling the truth.
the answer: lets lynch the one that is scum.
Could we have a discussion about motives and postings around both of them, seeing how this is a game of analysis? Im gonna read both there filter very carefully, then come back with some findings
would you mind doing the same? ^__^
|
... both could be telling the truth?
I dont think BC made the oversight of putting 2 Banes in the game.
|
lol, your right, what I meant to say is that both storys are plausible 
|
On February 20 2012 07:50 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
Evantrees - 2
Katina
Jaybrundage
Hiro protagonist - 3 (first)
rayzorflash
forumite
-_-quails
jaybrundage - 3
jayjay54
adam4167
evantrees
Not voting
hiro protagonist and rgtheschworz
followed up by this cute stealth vote:
On February 20 2012 07:54 rgTheSchworz wrote:
##vote hiro protagonist
team effort to save scum buddy?
get in here rg, why didn't you vote for JB? or at least evan?
|
Putting what might well be the hammer.
I dont think Pal shot anyone other than VE.
Jaybrundage is bullshitting and hiro is defending him.
Adam-still null.
I seriously think scum are pushing too hard for evantrees lynch, which would lose us the game
Crossing my fingers and
##vote hiro protagonist
|
Stealth my ass, JayJay, that was 5 mins ago.
|
On February 20 2012 07:59 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Putting what might well be the hammer.
I dont think Pal shot anyone other than VE.
Jaybrundage is bullshitting and hiro is defending him.
Adam-still null.
I seriously think scum are pushing too hard for evantrees lynch, which would lose us the game
Crossing my fingers and
##vote hiro protagonist
why vote for hiro and not JB, if you think he lying?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
