Some Mafia Game - Page 6

On September 19 2011 10:24 GGQ wrote:


When did you know I was sk? Was there any chance you were going to lynch sandroba?

On September 19 2011 10:35 Mig wrote:
We had decided you were most likely SK once Bum flipped PGO. Xt was possible but less likely since it seemed more likely for Ace to give SK to a more experienced player, and then jackal was nice enough to check him and announce it in thread lol. Jackal obviously wasn't SK. Then sandroba didn't make as much sense kill wise, I didn't think he would have shot WBG day2. Combined with his drunken ranting about SKs which was much more likely to be something he would do as a discouraged townie. And I thought it was a lot more likely for sandroba to shoot me last night if he were the SK, based on you suspecting jackal in the thread.

So there wasn't any real chance of me lynching sandroba.

On September 19 2011 14:44 Zona wrote:
Sheesh, it's frustrating to play so seriously and invest so much effort without support from your team. I probably won't play as seriously as I did in this one in any games on TL for some time.

Jackal, there's only a SINGLE thing I wish you had done differently in this game.

Right here. I gave you what I thought was 100% unbreakable, completely logical evidence that Palmar was scum, regardless of whether or not you thought I was scum, Bayonnet was scum, or anything else that happened in the game...(like your alignment checks), and you didn't switch. Since you didn't switch and spouted a line about "go[ing] with the info I have", I was convinced you were another mafia, like Bayonnet, trying to avoid lynching Palmar with some shitty reasoning. Sigh. And depending on how quickly Mig sent in his second vote, you switching over could have changed everything. Plus I would then have entertained the idea that both Mig/chaos were scum instead of thinking chaos was the 4th earlier, then switching to thinking Mig later on.