There is absolutely no point for you to ever check Xt unless you thought there could be 2 mafia potentially who didn't vote palmar, which makes no sense considering everything that went down right before the lynch.

Seriously nothing about your claim adds up.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 16 2011 11:02 GMT

#942

If there is a cvig shoot jackal and we win.

If there is a sk do not listen to palmar you still need to shoot mafia to win. If you shoot a townie you will reveal yourself and it will be 1-1-1 random who wins. If you shoot jackal it will be 2-1 and you will have a shot to win 3 handed if you can pull off the mislynch.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 16 2011 20:27 GMT

#951

Night is so long

I voted bum for 3 reasons. 1) I had a strong scum read on sandroba so I thought it was more likely for both of them to be scum 2) bum's PGO claim I didn't believe because of balance 3) I didn't think it made sense for palmar to fake claim dt like that, but I guess he was just being dumb.

Btw I realized something else now that palmar has flipped goon. Mafia still has their double voter/vote stealer. Palmar's attempting to convince SK to shoot town makes sense now. If it was left 1-1-1 the game wouldn't be a draw mafia could still win by instantly voting twice.

So the only way for town or sk to win is if they shoot the last mafia tonight. Shoot jackal.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 17 2011 00:54 GMT

#953

I only had a town read on zona.

How was anyone supposed to have a real town read on you? I thought there was a good chance you could have been mafia considering how low your activity had been. And I was undecided towards GGQ.

My strongest scum read was sandroba and bum was also shady. But like I said that was only part of the reason I voted bum.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 00:00 GMT

#969

Sandroba you voted before the game was unpaused! Don't worry I will kill the ugly SK for us.

Double vote death for GGQ!

##Vote: GGQ

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 00:07 GMT

#972

You are hammered GGQ. I used my double vote on you.

If sandroba is SK I will be very sad

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 00:12 GMT

#975

Too late!

Death to GGQ

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 00:18 GMT

#976

Day 1 me/palmar attacking each other was definitely a massive mistake.

Palmar's fake claim was horrible and served no purpose for our team. He did it just for fun like a bastard. I raged so hard at him over it.

We ended up all piling onto bum on day3 because we thought there was a chance bum was the SK. If bum was the SK then town could only have 1 kp and it was game over. In retrospect it was almost certainly a mistake. Should have just let palmar die.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 00:20 GMT

#978

Here is the mafia QT

http://www.quicktopic.com/46/H/zrHSUQGwB8e

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 01:21 GMT

#991

My scum play is definitely still terrible. 100x worse than my normal town.

GGQ/Curu/Zona all played well

Thanks for hosting Ace. And big thanks for taking the time to write out your thoughts all game.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 01:35 GMT

#994

We had decided you were most likely SK once Bum flipped PGO. Xt was possible but less likely since it seemed more likely for Ace to give SK to a more experienced player, and then jackal was nice enough to check him and announce it in thread lol. Jackal obviously wasn't SK. Then sandroba didn't make as much sense kill wise, I didn't think he would have shot WBG day2. Combined with his drunken ranting about SKs which was much more likely to be something he would do as a discouraged townie. And I thought it was a lot more likely for sandroba to shoot me last night if he were the SK, based on you suspecting jackal in the thread.

So there wasn't any real chance of me lynching sandroba.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 04:59 GMT

#1007

Kav that is exactly what we thought about bum. After bum's first statement we considered that he could be a blue but eventually settled on him likely being a vet or VT trying to draw a shot. No medic/dt was ever going to make that statement at the start of the game. So we only briefly ever considered shooting him.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

September 19 2011 06:00 GMT

#1011

I attacked bum a little bit and put it out there that he would be my #2 candidate after sinani. So if it had picked up any steam I would have been set up to jump over.

A big part of why I didn't commit too much to it tho was the fact that so much of your case against bum was based on your breadcrumb. The breadcrumb was so well hidden that I don't think anyone would have ever seen it if you didn't point it out (nobody on the mafia team saw it). If there had been more of an emphasis on the rest of your analysis I think more townies would have been willing to listen and switch over to him.