TL Mafia XLIV

On August 20 2011 00:30 Curu wrote:
Naw

Thanks for drawing Sevyrn out though.

So Sevyrn, because Palmar was a Townie in a completely different game, you decide to trust him and sheep his vote blindly?

On August 20 2011 02:46 DropBear wrote:
OK wtf Palmar? I actually don't understand. What is your problem with me exactly? Nearly all of your posts are one liners that are some variation of "Kill DropBear".


The "not safe" post you link included a joke about Harry Potter, a complete throwaway vote on kitaman27 and a joke about sandroba's plans. My first post in this thread advocated forcing people to change their vote, how is that so incredibly safe compared PTP2?

I don't actually understand your case, I will talk to you more if you actually come up with something.

---

My posts are 2 pages after the game started. 2 pages. Half the players hadn't even posted yet and most of the ones who did posted nothing other than "/confirm".

How do you expect me to have reads on people before they have even posted, through divination? Time travel?

What's with the random defence of your actions at the end? It's like you know it's a stupid idea, but you're doing it anyway.

On August 20 2011 03:15 Erandorr wrote:


I might have missed something but what exactly makes you believe everything Palmar says in this new game?

On August 20 2011 03:37 BrownBear wrote:


Pressure vote means acting like you're going to actually lynch someone to see how they react, not say "IM PRESSURE VOTING X OLOLOLOL"

On August 20 2011 01:40 RayzorFlash wrote:


Your post seemed like obvious scum to me, the scummiest post so far, and I will most likely be away for the rest of the day so I put in a vote against you... I'll check back later and see if I have to change it, but I doubt if I will :p

On August 21 2011 04:55 RayzorFlash wrote:
Town right now loses NOTHING by lynching Sev. If he flips red, we immediately know who to go after next, i.e. the people defending him, or the people trying to get someone else lynched first. If he flips green, we can target the ones who have most aggressively tried to get him lynched. Its a win-win situation.

On August 21 2011 06:02 RayzorFlash wrote:


My stealth vote for you was what an actual pressure vote looks like. All of a sudden, the pressure on you made you get all defensive and even pull your vote off DropBear. I'd say it was quite successful in exposing scummy behavior.



We lose a townie who has, for the entire first day contributed absolutely nothing towards discussion except a really scummy first accusation, and since then has just focused on defending himself? I don't think that's losing too much.
(OOC: What does WIFOM mean??)




Sure, I'll gladly take the fall if Sev proves to be green, but I don't think there was anything scummy at all about my post. I think it would be good leads to go after anyone aggressively pushing for Sev if he's green, and I know i'm included in that list :S.

On August 21 2011 06:52 wherebugsgo wrote:


Why don't you actually contribute something, then? Your posts and your activity makes sense from a mafia standpoint; for more than 24 hours you did absolutely nothing. Why didn't you contribute? If you had already defended yourself, why didn't you read posts and provide your opinion?

Why were you lurking? Trust me, there's time; if you can provide some reasonable defense for yourself and actually suggest things that will help town without appearing scummy (like you have appeared for the entirety of the day) then clearly it's in our best interest to lynch someone else. So far you haven't done a very good job of that, which paints you as red to me.

My vote stays on you as long as I believe you're mafia.

On August 21 2011 07:46 xtfftc wrote:
Would you pick a non-lynch instead of lynching Sevryn?

On August 21 2011 08:02 xtfftc wrote:

It was directed at Palmar's post but it is a question everyone has to think about, even if we don't discuss it openly.

Is there a possibility to lynch anyone but Sevryn tonight? It doesn't matter who would you like to lynch tonight if it's impossible.

If the answer is negative, it all comes down to lynching Sevryn or lynching no one.

On August 21 2011 09:07 wherebugsgo wrote:
Damn it Sevryn, if you're actually town you're.... The reason I don't feel bad about keeping my vote on you is because I sincerely think you're scum, but the problem is half the town right now doesn't seem to have a clear target. We have a bunch of other players who are semiscummy too. We can get them in the next couple of days, I suppose.

So, you're going to ignore my request (and a couple others' after mine) to actually put forth a decent argument, are you? I suppose that means you're dead...

On August 21 2011 09:15 supersoft wrote:


100% agree. We have jackal voting for Rayzor so far? I suspected nard before, but rayzor basically posts the same things.

@GM, sorry for the douche commentary, I just wanted to wake him up somehow...

On August 21 2011 09:31 chaos13 wrote:


I'm voting for the person I think is scum. I fail to see how that is scummy.

On August 21 2011 09:35 Curu wrote:
I'd be down for Rayzor instead. Why didn't you make any serious effort to defend yourself earlier Sevyrn? You were much more aggressive as Town in Kurumi's game.

We only have two hours though, how many people are here?

On August 21 2011 09:52 Navillus wrote:
Dammit I've been busy, but Palmar's right Sev is not scum there was way too little kickback on this vote like 1 person defended him, I'll take a no-lynch over lynching a townie. Bleh I went to sleep at the wrong time ><