|
On August 23 2011 19:13 Mig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 18:16 Palmar wrote:
@Mig
How did you not see the fact that sevryn was going to flip town on day 1? That's very unusual for you. Meh it didn't seem so obvious to me. All of his actions from early on and the middle of the day were scummy and they were different than his play in the last 2 games I had played with him where he was generally much more passive early on as town. His defense late seemed more townie but even that I thought could still have been plausible scum play trying to last ditch save himself. What do you think about my case against Dropbear?
I think it's very good, seeing as dropbear is reasonably active and almost always content with speaking his mind when he's town, to the point of trolling the thread. But this time it's almost as he's disappeared until the heat is off him.
It's actually the one saving grace in your play from my point of view. I'll call you bad names on skype if you flip town this game.
I'd like your thoughts on the following players: BrownBear, VisceraEyes, Curu
|
malicious or accidental mis-reading Erandorr?
Barundar clearly says he's okay with a vote-off between those two contenders, and he also makes it clear which one he'll be supporting.
|
also, I misread too! yay!
|
This requires re-reading.
|
Supersoft the only one who got his name from a known TL mafia player?
I need to write a long post.
|
he claimed JimboSilvers...
|
Also, each role has custom fluff, to deter any silly ideas like name claiming, the mafia may at any point request a safe-claim from me and I will provide it, safe claims can be for any role, from Liquidian to Inquisitor
Still... I don't have a name from TL Mafia, although my role description does mention Ver.
|
quit whining, 55 pages by late day 3 isn't all that much.
|
|
|
Millers do not know they are millers.
|
On August 23 2011 22:15 Curu wrote:How do you know this? Are Millers/Nosy Neighbors told they are such?
Because that's how millers always work.
|
DropBear claims DT and points at supersoft as scum:
There are quite a few things missing and I'm still trying to make sure how to interpret them. Maybe DropBear will be so kind as to provide answers or explanations where applicable.
a) DropBear never once even mentioned Supersoft's name before he claimed the check. Normal play for DT would suggest you immediately start planting it in your posts that your red check is scum after receiving the results, this is done in case you get killed.
b) I have no idea why DB decided to claim the role to out a relatively new scum player. His weight could easily have pushed the vote towards Mig, someone DB apparently considers a fair lynch too. It just seems like DB is playing DT very sub-optimally.
c) The timing of the claim is weird, why not just post it right at the start of the day if he was going to do it anyway. Votes were happily piling on Mig, just breadcrumb your results and check another day.
d) Why on earth would he check Supersoft? I think the obvious DT checks would be the more experienced and outspoken players, or the lurkers. Supersoft has been very enthusiastic in the thread so far, and definitely not afraid to speak his mind. I was getting a pretty townie feel from him overall.
e) Why do you feel the need to push your DT check with an analysis? Like... You know he's red, and you just told everyone else. Isn't that enough?
f) why the hell would you not immediately demand town lynches Supersoft when you claim?
But to be completely fair there are several points that also need considering, and those work in DB's favour.
a) This whole thing seems too elaborate to be manufactured. If DB wanted to simply frame someone red in a trade, he'd probably pick someone perceived as more dangerous to the scum team, or he'd just fake a dt check on some heavy candidate.
b) Supersoft does have some questionable content in his posts.
|
yeah DB needs to post his flavour immediately
|
DB did not even mention the possibility of him being insane/paranoid. This is weird.
|
Well to better understand it, what happens if Supersoft flips green?
Do we lynch DropBear?
|
Don't forget DropBear talked about me back on day one as if I was townie.
|
Da-Muffinman just stealthvoted, he's gonna be slided to red on my chart.
|
On August 24 2011 00:04 Mig wrote:Show nested quote +On August 24 2011 00:02 Palmar wrote:
Da-Muffinman just stealthvoted, he's gonna be slided to red on my chart. Huh is that guy even in this game?
lol, he isn't listed no.
Doesn't seem to be stopping him voting on Supersoft like the baller he is.
|
lol, dropbear, you're my hero.
|
On August 24 2011 00:20 DropBear wrote:
I'm the medic who protected Foolishness. That's how I know he is confirmed town. I voted Mig entirely because Foolishness did. I am having real troubles working out who is who other than that.
As long as this goes uncontested, I'm more than fine with believing it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
