|
So, here's the thing I don't understand chaos13:
First off, after re-reading everything you've posted I find it hard to believe you are scum because of this little thing here, from the post where you originally voted for me:
On August 20 2011 10:14 chaos13 wrote:
The bolded is probably the scummiest thing about DB at the moment. You say that as if Palmar is confirmed town "I hope you didn't land vigi..."
Any explanation for this?
You see, I don't see why any mafia would ever point this out, because it basically is giving credit to someone who is controversial. Sure, you may not have followed through and voted on me anyway, but it's still something to consider. Some people might actually believe you and consider this a scumslip by DB, and by extension a confirmation of myself.
Thing is there are some things in your posting that make absolutely no sense though. Like are you seriously posting shit like this?
On August 22 2011 03:39 chaos13 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2011 03:35 Palmar wrote:
im just going to pretend ve doesnt exist, he's town anyway. I point out your scumminess and suddenly I'm scum, and apparently should be vigi hit. Viscera points out your scumminess and he's town. HMMMMMMM
and this (anyone who has ever played with VE, knows why this post is super-scummy)
On August 22 2011 03:36 chaos13 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2011 03:19 VisceraEyes wrote:
Hiro:
Palmar isn't raging. He's trying to manipulate town with an appeal to emotion. I'm surprised he's even trying, it's one of the most obvious scum-tells there is. Regarding Rayzor, if he was a good enough target to risk a no-lynch today with your ill-fated vote-switch, what has changed in your opinion that makes him not-so tomorrow?
Palmar:
You're better than this. Your play has NOT been good, you haven't provided ANYTHING aside from your weak case against DB, and admittedly I haven't read your case against BB yet (I'm working on it). The fact that you're using that as a reason to rage when everyone here knows you're better than that makes me very suspicious. Finally somebody smart gets in here. I can't believe people let Palmar away so easily.
Let's assume for a second you don't think I am scum, and in turn I'll think for a second you might be town aligned.
What would you think about lynching BrownBear. I will give my thoughts on your lynch target of choice after I've done re-reading his posts.
|
On August 22 2011 23:29 Erandorr wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2011 23:15 Palmar wrote:So, here's the thing I don't understand chaos13: First off, after re-reading everything you've posted I find it hard to believe you are scum because of this little thing here, from the post where you originally voted for me: On August 20 2011 10:14 chaos13 wrote:
The bolded is probably the scummiest thing about DB at the moment. You say that as if Palmar is confirmed town "I hope you didn't land vigi..."
Any explanation for this?
You see, I don't see why any mafia would ever point this out, because it basically is giving credit to someone who is controversial. Sure, you may not have followed through and voted on me anyway, but it's still something to consider. Some people might actually believe you and consider this a scumslip by DB, and by extension a confirmation of myself. Thing is there are some things in your posting that make absolutely no sense though. Like are you seriously posting shit like this? On August 22 2011 03:39 chaos13 wrote:On August 22 2011 03:35 Palmar wrote:
im just going to pretend ve doesnt exist, he's town anyway. I point out your scumminess and suddenly I'm scum, and apparently should be vigi hit. Viscera points out your scumminess and he's town. HMMMMMMM and this (anyone who has ever played with VE, knows why this post is super-scummy) On August 22 2011 03:36 chaos13 wrote:On August 22 2011 03:19 VisceraEyes wrote:
Hiro:
Palmar isn't raging. He's trying to manipulate town with an appeal to emotion. I'm surprised he's even trying, it's one of the most obvious scum-tells there is. Regarding Rayzor, if he was a good enough target to risk a no-lynch today with your ill-fated vote-switch, what has changed in your opinion that makes him not-so tomorrow?
Palmar:
You're better than this. Your play has NOT been good, you haven't provided ANYTHING aside from your weak case against DB, and admittedly I haven't read your case against BB yet (I'm working on it). The fact that you're using that as a reason to rage when everyone here knows you're better than that makes me very suspicious. Finally somebody smart gets in here. I can't believe people let Palmar away so easily. Let's assume for a second you don't think I am scum, and in turn I'll think for a second you might be town aligned. What would you think about lynching BrownBear. I will give my thoughts on your lynch target of choice after I've done re-reading his posts. Hey Palmar could you pretend for one second that I exist and answer my question ? :D
What question?
|
|
|
oh, I don't know I'm not exactly a Veteran player, it's only been 3 months since I signed up for my first mafia game ever.
But if you're interested in my opinion, then no, I only find it easier to analyse people I've played a lot with because I better understand their posting.
|
On August 22 2011 23:52 Erandorr wrote:Done with that , what now? Maybe you could tell me whom to vote for , you seem to be very good at that
BrownBear.
|
I don't usually try to form ideas on too many people at once, and currently I'm pretty satisfied with killing BrownBear. If that fails I'll support a Mig lynch.
|
Tunneling me is VE's towntell btw.
|
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
|
On August 23 2011 00:59 Curu wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
....why are you blue fishing the Medic? Foolishness is in no danger of being lynched at the moment, there are a million scummier people in this Town.
Are you being intentionally thick?
|
On August 23 2011 01:04 Curu wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:00 Palmar wrote:On August 23 2011 00:59 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
....why are you blue fishing the Medic? Foolishness is in no danger of being lynched at the moment, there are a million scummier people in this Town. Are you being intentionally thick? I see no reason to disbelieve Foolisness's claim, especially with the RBer add-on. If no one gets RBed the rest of the game, he comes under suspicion and Foolishness makes sense as a N1 hit. I see no reason for the Medic to out himself to "confirm" a guy who shouldn't need to be confirmed at this point anyways.
Hence "I don't know when and how".
The medic should absolutely claim if Foolishness was up for a lynch. Also, if the medic suspected he might be getting shot for some reason, leaving the information with us is good.
If I get RB'd tomorrow does that confirm Foolishness? Hell no... I don't even know what you're saying here. But yes, he's not about to be lynched today, thus it's stupid to claim until at first near daybreak tomorrow, maybe even wait another cycle or two.
People keep talking about Vain: I think shooting him tonight would be an excellent idea. He hasn't contributed squat to this game and doesn't deserve to live.
|
On August 23 2011 01:09 Curu wrote:
I can agree with that. Medic claiming now or at the end of this night is absurdly stupid when Foolishness it not in danger of being lynched.
So what do you think about lynching Mig?
|
On August 23 2011 01:10 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
You want Mig dead. What's hard about that?
Yes I think Mig is scum.
let's entertain the thought that he flips town, does that make me scum?
|
|
|
bleh, ignore me.
Jackal only stated that if Mig flipped scum he'd see me as more green, not the other way around. So I'm just being an idiot.
|
yah, I said, I misread your post.
|
purely out of respect for mig's normal awesome townplay I'm fine with lynching him.
|
I still think we should lynch brownbear.
|
|
|
@Mig
How did you not see the fact that sevryn was going to flip town on day 1? That's very unusual for you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
