Pick Their Power Mafia 2 - Page 87

Amber[LighT]

United States5078 Posts

July 29 2011 17:56 GMT

#1721

On July 30 2011 02:49 bumatlarge wrote:

BWHAHAHAHAHAHAAHA this coming from kurumi. I'm doing what I can tell help us win. And that involves not claiming, so sue me.

Last time we took your word for it we let you slip out of 2 lynches.

That's not happening this time.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

July 29 2011 17:59 GMT

#1722

On July 30 2011 02:52 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't know if you're aware of this but Kurumi has just been proclaimed BOSS MASTER TROLL in BC's AA game, that's how pro he is.

Boss Master Troll is Chezinu. I am only Young Trolldawan

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 29 2011 18:01 GMT

#1723

Stop blaiming me for you guys not paying attention, it's all in the past 10 pages why we probably would get the short end of the stick lynching foolish. Honestly every game I've played with this more recent crowd has been jumping from one thing to another and then ignoring what someone else has given you. I may sound like a hypocrit, but has anyone been compiling claimed roles and who gave who what? It's favorable to town to discuss all of that. When I was joker in PTP, there was a nice little niche in that we all gave roles, so we started the game with a ridiculous amount of very useful information, where town has no role list to follow.

I'll start doing that now I suppose.

DropBear

Australia4442 Posts

July 29 2011 18:50 GMT

#1724

On July 29 2011 21:14 chaos13 wrote:
Sorry about all the posts, but I keep thinking of things that I didn't say in the last one.

I'm guessing there is probably 5 scum. I would say the remaining scum team is Palmar, Nisani, and Foolishness. One of the more active vocal players is probably third party. Sandroba or DropBear maybe. DB might even be faking his penalty here, it could be something completely different and he's just doing that to distract from the content in his posts.

My posts the last few days were not posting restrictions. It's the last week before I go back to uni so I've got to make it count

I don't think Foolishness is a good lynch today. I am a little concerned by him but I don't think he's a good lynch.

- The Foolishness is godfather theory isn't a good one. Deconduo has said that it was assigned randomly. Sure it's possible but nowhere near as likely as Curu has made out.
- Going on the Mafia quiz and the XXXVII analysis, he tends to be less active in the first few days and then ramps it up later on.
- If we just completely ignore him for now it benefits us in a few ways. If he's town, Mafia will take him out sooner rather than later. He's too much of a risk. The longer he lives, the more he can help us if he's town, if he's Mafia it will become increasingly obvious if he doesn't lift his game.

I would prefer that we lynch today based on the voting pattern from Day 1.
I may have been drunk when I wrote this but the point still stands. There is almost guaranteed that the vote list for BC just before supersoft's check has more than just the one Mafia on it.

I'd like to see the lynch between Nisani and kitaman. Vote staying on Nisani for now.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

July 29 2011 18:57 GMT

#1725

All this information has been in the thread. Revealing, semi-revealing or not revealing are not bad or good, it is completely role dependent. No one should be forcing anyone to fully claim if they haven't.

On July 28 2011 20:32 Palmar wrote:
You are the Red Hood. However you are not the first person to wear this name. At one point in time you were Jason Todd, otherwise known to a select few as Robin or the boy wonder. In a fight with the joker you were killed. With the help of the lazurus pit you were brought back to life and have returned to Gotham City to take up the mantle of the cities protector. Unlike your former partner, you prefer to be in control of the crime to stem its tide instead of fighting it ineffectually. The tools you have at your disposal only help with this. You are able to plant tracking devices on a player. This will then inform you when they move locations and what they do when they get to their destination. Anyone who visits them will also be revealed to you.

Pretty straightforward, a neat watcher/tracker, and he can easily be caught when lying. Someone who mafia would want to get rid of, but no wiggle room in public. I like it!

On July 28 2011 06:49 syllogism wrote:
By the way, I was visited last night. Anyone want to claim the visit?

He is a self-watcher? That's all I get, probably something else on top of it.

On July 26 2011 05:54 Kurumi wrote:
Please guys vote for me or I will die soon

I have no idea what kurumi is, but it sounds borderline VI, and he has sure been acting like it. But the next part seems to be a beneficial part to kurumi's thing, if it is that.

On July 28 2011 06:28 Curu wrote:
Also Kurumi, was this a softclaim that you can see who gets targeted by night actions?

Show nested quote +

I know for a fact two of the people on your list had night actions done to them.

Another watcher-ish role, but more then one target? Doesn't get any more info.

On July 29 2011 00:24 Amber[LighT] wrote:

Show nested quote +

No I'm essentially a dolled up JOAT

JOAT so good

On July 28 2011 07:23 Drazerk wrote:
You have activated your penalty!

You must always be voting for someone that's voting for you to be lynched, unless no one is voting for you.

Still reading through the thread but if anyone votes for me from now on this is in place and I can't help it.

He activated it but I'm not sure how, he did make some early joke claims and guessed at YM's role and was close. That's all I saw.

On July 29 2011 02:51 heist wrote:
NO ONE SHOOT FOOLISHNESS. I've got him covered. My role creator knows what I'm talking about.
If he's to be the lynch, he'll be taken care of.

Protective role, even through lynches? I thought he meant he was going to get rid of foolish, but he said "if he's to be lynched, he'll be taken care of" that doesn't sound like shooting him. If heist wants to expand on this, it's up to him.

DB claimed he made SS's role, and then he got that drunk poster penalty or hes just doing that. Haven't heard a roleclaim.

On July 26 2011 00:39 DropBear wrote:
Ok I may as well cop the penalty. Mafia now knows who shot youngminii and all his abilities so I have to come out and save him now. I made the Tim Roth role.

Supersoft is Tim Roth. He only gets one kill. His kill causes his alignment and role abilities to be PMd to everyone of the opposite alignment to him. I didn't get that PM so supersoft is now 100% confirmed to be town.

His other ability is an alignment check, which activates if you get into a 3 each quote convo with him i.e. you post, he quotes, you quote the quote until there is 3 each.

I would suggest forcing people to quote him. Not everyone at once though as it would shit up the thread something shocking.

I don't think SS countered it, and i didnt get any PM. Don't see how this can be faked unless they are both scum.

That's all I found. Alot of claims.

Foolishness - I've already said what I thought.

Palmar

Iceland22634 Posts

July 29 2011 19:06 GMT

#1726

syllogism is dead...

DropBear

Australia4442 Posts

July 29 2011 19:06 GMT

#1727

KITAMAN27

First 10 or so posts are vague questions.

This confused me.
The explanation confused me too. It just seemed unnecessary. His point about giving away the stick so quickly was a good one though.

This is a good defence. Not only that but he willingly submitted to supersoft's check.

Posts a couple of times saying he'll give his opinions later then delivers with this. All of these made sense.

The following is his reasoning for voting BC:

On July 27 2011 01:37 kitaman27 wrote:
Voting for BC because
1) I enjoy watching him die
2) He refuses to submit to an alignment check

Others should be forced to quote SS. There are a surprisingly few people who are willing to submit to it.

His vote made it 9-6 in BC's favour so it wasn't lynch changing. He doesn't however, like nisani, mention Jackal at all, which I think is slightly suss. Someone who was debated so much wasn't even mentioned.

Since here he's been quiet but it was his birthday so I'm willing to cut him some slack.

CONCLUSION

Unsure.

I feel better about him than Nisani and worse about him than Palmar.

Now that I've done the three of them, I would like to see Nisani dead first, failing that kita, failing that Palmar.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

July 29 2011 19:09 GMT

#1728

I am the Oracle. When I die a person of my choosing will have their role revealed to all. Thanks to penalty, it has 50% chance of working! I can confirm Amber being JOAT (he activated his penalty though, so powers like double lynch have gotten away T_T)

DropBear

Australia4442 Posts

July 29 2011 19:10 GMT

#1729

Bum I did claim supersoft's role, however decon changed it. Read supersoft's flip again. What I sent in was it got revealed to everyone, decon changed it to being revealed to the Mafia. If you are telling the truth about you not receiving a PM then you are not Mafia. Are you telling the truth though

And again, the drunk posting was me being drunk and isn't a penalty. I've already claimed my penalty.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 29 2011 19:24 GMT

#1730

Palmar is correct, Foolishness has become the Role Thief.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 29 2011 19:26 GMT

#1731

And bum, Foolishness will not survive a lynch unless someone has a Pardoner role.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

July 29 2011 19:29 GMT

#1732

On July 30 2011 04:24 Curu wrote:
Palmar is correct, Foolishness has become the Role Thief.

He must die here and now then.

Palmar

Iceland22634 Posts

July 29 2011 19:30 GMT

#1733

Kurumi, why do you want to die early?

Your role becomes so much stronger later in the game when most people have claimed their roles, and you can catch them lying.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

July 29 2011 19:32 GMT

#1734

This is the only part of it that doesn't make sense to me:

Nisani's voting patterns. Clearly he doesn't give a fuck who he votes for, jumping around from wagon to wagon any time an easy one forms.

However, he never touched Jackal's wagon. I am leaning very far towards him being scum, but he also voted Foolishness and I don't think Nisani would ever bus a teammate.

My original theory was that it was either chaos and Nisani (both look scummy as hell) or Foolishness. But Foolishness looks very Anti Town too, though if my Godfather theory is incorrect he may just be a 3rd Party.

That's why I want Nisani flipped ASAP.

Kurumi

Poland6130 Posts

July 29 2011 19:33 GMT

#1735

On July 30 2011 04:30 Palmar wrote:
Kurumi, why do you want to die early?

Your role becomes so much stronger later in the game when most people have claimed their roles, and you can catch them lying.

1)
To kick role-maker's ass.
2)
To punch role-maker in the face
3)
To date Lanaia
4)
It might not work now. Anyway, I am neither vet or good player. They wouldn't shoot me unless I had good role.