BC's Arkham Asylum - Page 101

On July 26 2011 20:54 Liquid`Nazgul wrote:
I agree with bum that there is a chance Palmar is a 3rd party. The way he has been running this game is impressive and we need to be aware of the fact that he may not be town. That said Palmar is not making it to the end of this game and as long as he is doing useful things for town there is absolutely no reason to lynch him right now while we look for mafia a bit more.

Specifically before checking the thread today I was going to say I don't trust bumatlarge/Pyo and think one of them is mafia but am not sure which one. I'd like to take both out before we start thinking about lynching Palmar.

My request for now would be Batman please pick some other possible joker targets for now. If Palmar is indeed a medic you could screw this game up by shooting him. We need to at least wait with such desperate measures until we hang bum and then Pyo next. If bum is indeed mafia then the post above makes perfect sense. Just in case Palmar is a medic he is asking Batman to shoot him.

On July 27 2011 00:49 Pyo wrote:


I'm a little curious about this since I seem to have missed where it originally came from, but what is my connection to bumatlarge? I seem to recall Palmar mentioning that I had some connection to him before, but I can't seem to find where this connection came from.

On July 27 2011 03:23 ghrur wrote:
Wait, it's still night. Batman/DTs, just check Palmar.

On July 27 2011 03:24 Shraft wrote:


How would that help? It is very unlikely that he is mafia, and if he is 3rd party the check will do no good.

On July 26 2011 23:57 Palmar wrote:
he's just an idiot for lying.

On July 27 2011 02:53 bumatlarge wrote:


don't read too much into it, the only thing people have on me is not posting as often as I usually do. I don't think anyone has done any analysis on me just lazy fleeting accusations because I'm a cool guy and they jelly. Not sure how that relates to you.

VE is doing us a favor by saying nothing, he's a claimed traitor. Anything he says will just distract us.

That makes 6 non-town individuals left. 2 are traitors with no powers, so I think we can make them non-factors, but thats theoretical. 2 are 3rd party, but only one is a true SK. The that leaves 2 mafia and 12 townies, with scattered mounts of blues around.

Palmar, the more I read of the OP, the less I believe you. Ok so BC put in a hidden role when he said he would not. Let's let that slide. You are the riddler, a 4th hidden medic. 2 medics are already dead and you are in contact with the remaining med? Ok then. If that is actually true, I want one more person to claim a hidden role, they don't have to say what it is, just that palmar is teling the truth. If so, I will buy it. They don't even have to be public about it, just PM someone you trust and have them say it for you.

I noticed 3 people said yes in RoL's poll, and even if palmar and his medic partner voted, thats an additional person. So it's possible. I just think it's highly improbable. I know BC is going to keep quiet on the matter, so let's try to figure this out. I think it's the last piece of the puzzle (or perhaps the puzzle is finished and palmar is trying to convince us that it isn't )

I suppose he could be batman? Not really too sure. Being active would get him a medic most likely, but batman goes through medic protection so as the joker that would be pointless. The only thing he would have to fear would be ra'as al ghul.

It's all I really got for him, the behavior analysis on him is that he is playing VERY differently than normal, on top of which he was secretly getting Kurumi to claim hatter whcih is REALLY stupid, because at the end of a day a hatter doesn't die, when Kurumi says "btw im not a hatter lol1" you have to lynch him for lying for so long for the dumbest reason.

So I manipulating Kurumi serves only to get him lynched and is overall bad for town. You could argue he thought it was a good idea to lie, and that it was justified. However the way he attacked my lie makes the above logic turning him into a hypocrite.

Conversely, if he thought I was third party and left me for the other third party it could of been him trying to guess my role. If he was batman I would have to be the joker or ra'as. Logically if he is sure I am third party I should get hit that night as long as the other third believes it. If I don't get hit then I am ra'as (assuming palmar is batman) because the joker has no incentive to actually hit me. If I am the joker and I get hit by ra'as I won't die, and palmar confirms that I am the joker, thus allowing him to win the game the next night cycle by hitting me.

That is assuming he is batman, it could be a good way to play. Extremely pro town to not allow ra'as to kill you, then out a third party using the above logic. Plus, if I just straight up died last night that would also help him by confirming I am not third party and allow him to move on.

The fact I didn't die means if Palmar is batman and still believes I am a third party I will get hit to kill the "joker", but then again all this assumes he knows if I got hit again which he would have to deduce from the daily KP count.

On July 27 2011 03:26 Shraft wrote:
And I'm almost positive we don't have any DTs, if you check the OP you can see that the DTs were the only blues that BC didn't bother to come up with any specific names for.

On July 27 2011 03:57 Nisani201 wrote:

Wrong, there is a role called Blackgate Sniper.

On July 27 2011 03:57 ghrur wrote:
Wait, was this PM after night 1 or 2?