EPTWow, nice observation. I dont know if hes just someone with a question or what, but I dont want to make hasty decisions and accidentally lynch someone that we shouldnt lynch.
TL Mafia XL - Page 9
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Jimbooo
203 Posts
Wow, nice observation. I dont know if hes just someone with a question or what, but I dont want to make hasty decisions and accidentally lynch someone that we shouldnt lynch. | ||
|
Treadmill
Canada2833 Posts
Jimbooo, we do have to lynch somebody. Being "hasty" isn't really a concern. And somebody with next to no evidence against them is a better lynch than everyone else with no evidence against them at all. Still, 48 hours yet. | ||
|
cherubael
United States12 Posts
On June 05 2011 13:35 aprudds wrote: Hmm, a bit suspicious no? Right when the PM are getting sent out too. Scum slip? A bit of a bold accusation, I would say. However, I do have to agree, the first question does look a bit suspicious. After all, a townie would have *no* reason to ask such a question, as they can't PM anyway. | ||
|
cherubael
United States12 Posts
| ||
|
AnxiousHippo
Australia1451 Posts
Cherubael's right, I'm not liking freeloader625 at the moment... | ||
|
freeloader625
United States180 Posts
On June 05 2011 13:49 cherubael wrote: A bit of a bold accusation, I would say. However, I do have to agree, the first question does look a bit suspicious. After all, a townie would have *no* reason to ask such a question, as they can't PM anyway. Oh but a townie does have reasons to ask such a question. Don't take my SC2 Mafia as lack of experience, I was able to deduce roles within the 50seconds given. :D | ||
|
Jimbooo
203 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:02 freeloader625 wrote: Oh but a townie does have reasons to ask such a question. Don't take my SC2 Mafia as lack of experience, I was able to deduce roles within the 50seconds given. :D What reason does a townie have to ask such a question? | ||
|
Aril
United States11 Posts
On June 05 2011 13:47 Treadmill wrote: It is a good spot, aprudds. We should keep an eye on freeloader625. Jimbooo, we do have to lynch somebody. Being "hasty" isn't really a concern. And somebody with next to no evidence against them is a better lynch than everyone else with no evidence against them at all. Still, 48 hours yet. If someone was asking a question that might be incriminating, and they weren't mafia, wouldn't the mafia be quick to accuse that person, to keep someone "actually" in the mafia from getting lynched? I think going after a person because of a question is a little low.. | ||
|
freeloader625
United States180 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:03 Jimbooo wrote: What reason does a townie have to ask such a question? All I can say is, all too often the first one to speak is "put on trial." Sleep on it. | ||
|
Jimbooo
203 Posts
| ||
|
Lafali
United States110 Posts
| ||
|
cherubael
United States12 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:06 freeloader625 wrote: All I can say is, all too often the first one to speak is "put on trial." Sleep on it. So...you asked a question so you could be lynched day one...alright...that makes sense. (note the sarcasm) Either you give a legitimate, straight reason to ask this sort of question as townie, or you clearly are just trying to save your butt after having messed and shown your role as mafia. Also, Aril, you seem to be very quick in defending him, while not wanting to accuse anyone. Are you afraid your role will be too obvious if you accuse someone? Also, what reason do you have to defend him? What has he done for you? The only reason would be because you are both mafia, and you are trying to look out for him. | ||
|
DeMorcerf
United States56 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:03 Jimbooo wrote: What reason does a townie have to ask such a question? A townie would ask the question in order to understand the game clearly. To defeat thine enemy, thou must know thine enemy. He needed to be sure whether the mafia had the power to coordinate or was as in the dark as townies are. And from having played SC2'sMafia, it seems to me like a question I'd be tempted to ask regardless of my role considering many of us are new to TL-Mafia (this is a game for "new players"). We shouldn't be rash. Haste makes waste. We still have many hours of this day left. I agree he is quite suspicious, but he could just be trying to confirm how the game operates. Perhaps SC2Mafia has made me adverse to random lynching. Unlike Jimbooo and cherubael, I'm not going to vote this soon. Now seeing his updated response, of "All I can say", freeloader does feel more suspicious to me. Especially because I feel like the reverse is true in SC2Mafia, where people blindly trust the first people to speak not lynch them. I'm going to sleep now, but still not convinced beyond a doubt there's enough to bother 'sleeping on.' | ||
|
Jimbooo
203 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:50 DeMorcerf wrote: + Show Spoiler + On June 05 2011 14:03 Jimbooo wrote: What reason does a townie have to ask such a question? A townie would ask the question in order to understand the game clearly. To defeat thine enemy, thou must know thine enemy. He needed to be sure whether the mafia had the power to coordinate or was as in the dark as townies are. And from having played SC2'sMafia, it seems to me like a question I'd be tempted to ask regardless of my role considering many of us are new to TL-Mafia (this is a game for "new players"). We shouldn't be rash. Haste makes waste. We still have many hours of this day left. I agree he is quite suspicious, but he could just be trying to confirm how the game operates. Perhaps SC2Mafia has made me adverse to random lynching. Unlike Jimbooo and cherubael, I'm not going to vote this soon. Now seeing his updated response, of "All I can say", freeloader does feel more suspicious to me. Especially because I feel like the reverse is true in SC2Mafia, where people blindly trust the first people to speak not lynch them. I'm going to sleep now, but still not convinced beyond a doubt there's enough to bother 'sleeping on.' Thinking about this , I am sort of happy I can unvote. But that doesnt change freeloaders suspiciousness. With his last post , I do think he is alot more shady , but I dont want to point fingers. Like I said in one of my posts , I dont want to be hasty and lynch a townie , but there is 48 hours left. | ||
|
heist
United States720 Posts
| ||
|
omgCRAZY
Canada551 Posts
What I find interesting is how aprudds was so quick to get everyones attention focused on someone else and how the game has barely started and yet cherubael and Jimboo are already throwing out votes. | ||
|
omgCRAZY
Canada551 Posts
On June 05 2011 15:03 heist wrote: Freeloader's last two responses were really vague and general. I'm not really suspicious of the people defending his first post, but the his last two posts do seem fairly fishy. Though I do agree the Freeloaders defensive posts were quite vague and are much more suspicious than his question. | ||
|
Jimbooo
203 Posts
| ||
|
Treadmill
Canada2833 Posts
A few thoughts: There are 8 mafia but do we know how much killing power they have? If 6 normally get 3 kills/night would it be sensible to extrapolate that 8 get 4? | ||
|
Aril
United States11 Posts
On June 05 2011 14:39 cherubael wrote: Also, Aril, you seem to be very quick in defending him, while not wanting to accuse anyone. Are you afraid your role will be too obvious if you accuse someone? Also, what reason do you have to defend him? What has he done for you? The only reason would be because you are both mafia, and you are trying to look out for him. Defending people in this situation isn't wrong. There is a suspicious atmosphere floating around everyone and half of us are townies so you know what I mean, we want to get some conversation out here so we can actual get a good look at what a everyone's saying, and it only hurts the town if they're afraid everything they say is going to get them falsely accused. We shouldn't all gang up on people right away and if we do then I'll be on the defending side until they make their case and I can make my own reasonable judgement. | ||
| ||
