Surprisingly Normal Mini Mafia II - Page 5

On May 16 2011 18:49 nard wrote:
hio everyone, obligatory 1st post here.

@current discussion:

Mataza seems to be more experienced than the average newcomers here so i don't suspect him just because he made the first posts with some actual content today.. i rather find it interesting that VisceraEyes is jumping to conclusions / trying to badmouth someone that quick. :p

im really curious how were gonna settle for our 1st lynch given that no special roles are in the game!

On May 17 2011 02:25 nard wrote:
dont forget we have an 48hour day cycle, so there is still plenty of time for everybody to post.
i can imagine there are still some people thinking about what they could include in their first post which is not completely trivial - took me a while as well :p

On May 17 2011 10:35 nard wrote:
nice to see a 2nd poster with a lot of content besides mataza - thanks prplhz

onto your note:


i realized when i made that post that it in itself is suspicious as well and thats kinda supporting the argument i posted - everything you post except a trivial "hello" might be endangering your life and i guess most if not all townies want not only the town to win, but also to survive until the end.

as requested here are my opinions on the 3 most active posters. this is no deep analysis just some gut feelings after having read the last 2 thread pages. i might post a reasoning with quotes and all that jazz in a few hours when i have a break.

Mataza - before prplhz posted his argument about him trying to set up a leadership he was pretty unsuspicious to me. currently undeciced, still tending to townie though.
Viscera - so far the most suspicious. locking in on only Mataza, a lot of posts with lacking content.
Giygas - less suspicious then Viscera. kind of in an odd place to make a decision as his posts are way less agressive / suspicious than viscera, but they keep appearing as a double tag team which makes it harder to form a seperate opinion on both.

hoping for the 2 inactives to show up soon :>

On May 18 2011 10:08 nard wrote:
oh my, waking up and checking mafia thread as the 1st thing was a good choice :D
by skimming the last 4 new pages quick i find hiro's lynch logic the most appelling.
as im lacking a big analysis right now, ill jump the bandwagon for the inactives - skrammen slightly more suspicious as after his 1st post there will still 8 hours to go and he didnt post again, even after being asked to.

##vote Skrammen

modkill avoided, suspicion raised - see you on day2 :3