Just saying there are a few people who have random votes that stayed off the votelist, so checking incog's should read 0 mafia if he is scum. Why wouldn't it unless the mafia played extremely risky.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 03:32 GMT

#1412

On May 22 2011 12:20 Chezinu wrote:

Show nested quote +

So true...

Have you played terraria yet chez? Give me your opinions on that.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 04:03 GMT

#1420

Sweet!

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 04:54 GMT

#1441

Incog wasn't scum? And chez was. uhhhh hmm.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 06:25 GMT

#1450

##Use Police Radio

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 07:51 GMT

#1452

It's posts all the results of investigative actions last night and the way it was worded means we know exactly who is the target without saying who the DT is.

So we get GM's list regardless

If he really is that DT. Pretty crazy.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 14:32 GMT

#1466

We can wait for the radio before jumping on to anything for certain. I still doubt that Ace is scum, even with incog popping town. Can we also analyzed exactly what happened yesterday and what mafia KP is at right now? I think we can reasonably assume it is at 1. 2kp were used yesterday to hit FW and scamp. 2kp were used today to hit node and barundar. Chez the scum CPR is dead, so that leaves only 1 kp for mafia to use, if we assume mafia didn't get very unlucky with stacked hits (also assuming ace used his KP on incog).

I think we are in a better spot then people are making us out to be. Lack of politician and CGF, evidence of alternate GF leave 2 open roles. Neither seem to have consistent KP like CPR, so we can probably dote on what they will be.

NRA Member
Hero
Janitor
Vengeful player
Zombie
Framer

These are what I find most likely at this point. NRA, janitor, hero and framer seem obvious, as the other two require getting lynched. They all involve causing confusion for town in order to extend the game and as such put it in their favor. I do not think they have more KP then town at this point, so we might have the upperhand if this is the case.

So I think we should for the moment heed what caller and radfield say, and take more then just DT actions into consideration when deciding lynches. It will benefit us until we see more information that say otherwise. I think the radio will help a good deal with this, as I find it unlikely scum picked dt roles. And also I will have to confess, I am not really the watcher

the radio will show that, but I can explain if you want me to. Otherwise, I'd rather keep my real role a secret.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 20:41 GMT

#1528

I lied about being watcher because I had the town cred to do so, and I could prevent mafia from making abnormal fakeclaims. Threatening with information would help scare mafia. But my actual role will be more helpful. I dont have anything everyone doesn't already know, but maybe after tonight I can provide a service in the form of KP to town. I have my targets in my scope, I just need to figure out how to pull the trigger...

GM and myself are pretty reasonably town. I'll let caller and fishball argue about how they got framed. We got a nice free lynch on tnkted, and we also know we have a lovely amount of DTs. Glad our town is smart. Mafia couldn't have known about the radio and tnkted had no reason to be covered while not on the last list iirc?

Easy peezy. Also infy's same thing is interesting. Hopeful that cop is getting good info.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 22 2011 20:46 GMT

#1530

On May 23 2011 04:47 infinitestory wrote:

Show nested quote +

Doesn't that also mean that out of Bumatlarge, Caller, GMarshal, Fishball there are 2 scum, based on who's alive + scum counts? That does NOT sound right to me, especially since GMarshal is as good as town right now. I suspect there's one mafia out of Bumatlarge, Caller, Fishball, (guess who I think it is) and the mole is hiding somewhere in those two votelists.

I misread this fish, I thought it was another votelist-check. For the guy that got the radio, I sure am confused about all the DT actions.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 00:50 GMT

#1554

Hmm well Im going to hold off on pushing chaoser, he appropriately responded how I think he should. He should have waited with the claim if he didn't find any reason for it, but I don't think he fully caught up with everything (barundar is dead, and I don't really think town has any need to confirm me of all people).

He's just another target on mafia's long list of people to get rid of with their whopping one KP. Hope you get back in the swing chowser.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 05:20 GMT

#1556

Slow day I guess, no suprise

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 19:52 GMT

#1576

On May 24 2011 04:23 tnkted wrote:
Also, how do we know that our alignment cop isn't insane?

That should have been the first thing you said. You didn't think scamp was inventor? Are you even reading the thread?

Adios Muchacho.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 20:03 GMT

#1578

Ah yes the rose glasses seem to make sense kurumi, as an additional list check. Leaves us with 4 different DTs.

Shame I didnt have watcher, I would have watched GM I think.

Also, I do agree with radfield about Ace. I do not think he is mafia, but a mole could be plausible. This should be an endgame prospect I believe, as ace did not pick traitor (KP), and Mafia does not have assasin to combo with capitalist, if N2 showed anything.

Masons should eventually try to contact radfield if they haven't already.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 20:14 GMT

#1579

On May 24 2011 04:59 tnkted wrote:
If alignment cop IS insane, it would mean that you're the scum here bum. I find it interesting that you pop out right as I happened to implicate you. Means that you've been reading the thread, but haven't bothered contributing. Happy with the way the wagon is rolling, eh scum?

No, I didn't think scamp was the inventor. Flamewheel claimed that he didn't grab it. If I was scamp, would I risk my NUMBER 2 PICK on flamewheel's word? No, I absolutely would not. The fact that scamp happened to trust it doesn't mean I did.

I have not the slightest clue about anything you are saying. If you want to make a nice death post calling me scum, thats fine by me. But by what you are saying, alignment cop being insane does not implicate me, because I do not believe I was ever checked by alignment cop. If alignment cop knew he was insane from a previous check, he would have claimed. Chaoser said he checked me if that is what you misconstrued.

Of course I've been reading the thread. If you could find one thing I havent gave my opinion on, I'd be surprised.

FW said he was picking rockstar or jack. Even as scum, those were viable picks, there was no reason to doubt him there. We told scamp that he should be picking inventor, and I don't think he ever mentioned picking something other then inventor. I'm baffled as to how a town medic would think like this. Oh wait, is it because you're actually red? Oh that makes sense then. You never stated who you actually protected night 1. Come now, there is no watcher and the tracker is dead, your lie is safe with us.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 23 2011 20:25 GMT

#1581

By the way Ace, thanks

I'll tell you what you did tomorrow.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 24 2011 01:15 GMT

#1605

Oh come on he couldnt have waited for day to end at least? meh

I think that shortens a list or two right?

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 24 2011 01:55 GMT

#1614

Well you have to factor in that chaoser is actually a role checker, or someone is telling him strategy. Before anyone lynches or kills him, please tell him, so he can verify himself.

Otherwise, ZOOT ZOOT RIOT!

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 24 2011 02:00 GMT

#1619

On May 23 2011 08:22 chaoser wrote:
Since everyone is apparently focused on me, I'm going to claim so that we can move on from the topic of me and onto hopefully better topics. You guys can lynch me to confirm my role. I'm a Modern Detective. I only got to check bum due to missing last night and wasn't able to check anyone and got back a good result. I won't reveal his role but I will say he has a power. That means if GM is telling the truth then on the voting for

INCOGNITO (5): Ace, infinitestory, Foolishness, Chaoser, Barundar

Ace, infinitestory, Foolishness, Barundar, one of them is mafia. I'm betting on it being Foolishness from previous posts. I haven't read anything since I last posted and probably won't have time till late tomorrow night due to previously stated personal reasons.

He checked me, and said it made sense. It does make sense. I'd expect scum to out me in some effort, but chaoser is keeping his mouth shut, when he would probably gain more cred just saying my role. He could be guessing? I dont really think so.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 24 2011 02:02 GMT

#1620

On May 24 2011 10:56 Ace wrote:
bumatlarge is scum and I have proof

Can you at least hint at the proof? You two did this with radfield and I did not follow at all. You better explain ace, it's in your best interest.

bumatlarge

United States4567 Posts

May 24 2011 02:09 GMT

#1622

I'll have to take insurance measures. Let's just say it would make things easier the way incog's death made things easier. If guessed my role just say it.