Insane Mafia 2 - Page 10

On March 28 2011 12:27 Insanious wrote:
Just want to throw this out there...

Say Lemon is mafia. He knew what items both jackal and caog had.

Lemon steals from jackal (taking away town medic), then gets mafia to buss the target (tack) that coag had told him.

This would result in annul dying, town lynching tack, and mafia winning IG. Just a thought. Im off to bed now though.

On March 28 2011 12:17 Coagulation wrote:
Also i would like to urge all you scumfucks to come on out and defend your scum bud tackster.

On March 28 2011 12:35 Lanaia wrote:
Logically, we should be asking tackster what he did last niht, shouldn't we?

Logical Inconsistency:

If Tackster were Red, why would he both try to steal the item to prevent his death, AND Red would use their Bus on him? Surely one would have been sufficient to save him. This is primarily what is making me look more closely into what's happening rather than blindly accepting that Tack is scum.

What might have happened (and how it will continue):

Jackal is Mafia
Jackal says he has KP in thread, Tack steals (Don't know his motivations, but he thinks Jackal is red, so maybe he wanted to try to stop a red KP)
Coag really has the gun
Jackal convinces Coag to shoot Tack
Mafia know Coag is shooting Tack, bus it to Annul
Town is now convinced Tack is scum, lynches Green. Scum kills townies, wins IG

On March 28 2011 13:31 Eiii wrote:
Aww, I'm on a scumlist now? :/ I eagerly await your reasons then, kav.

Quick question: If the whole IG plan was to bait the scum player into stealing jackal's items, why did jackal just let it get stolen instead of protecting it? That's the one thing that I'm confused by in this whole affair.

3. My scum team bussing Annul is stupid
Apparently if I am scum and my team bus Coags shot onto Annul then that 100% confirms me as scum. If that is the case this is a TERRIBLE plan for mafia. Why do something so obvious?

Now to the conclusions:
1. The other three IG players have in no-way confirmed each other
Your in no way confirmed either Moot point. Not to mention I STILL have the ability to CONFIRM JACKAL after we lynch you. Another moot point because he will be confirmed when you flip red
2. The fact that they are so sure of themselves without confirmation throws their judgement into question - green or not.
Ok fantastic this doesnt help you at all.
3. Jackal can easily be scum. The plan is clever but also strong and something red could have come up with. They didn't even need to come up with it before jackal decided on his 'plan' because as he is such a tunneler they probably just decided to make the most of it
Ok but how does this prove your green in the slightest.. you have given 0 information for town to attempt to work with. you just repeat over and over jackal could be scum. thats fantastic why dont you try coming up with a plan like jackal did why dont you try dumping information that town wants to know in the thread like jackal did.
4. The IG is in great peril. All evidence has to be scrutinized, all votes have to be carefully considered
your mafia teams chance at getting the items are in peril
5. My stealing Jackals item in NO WAY makes me scummy. It was in fact the town thing to do.