Team Mini Mafia III BCE

On January 05 2011 01:43 Ace wrote:
You should just vote for whoever you think will not help you win the game.

On January 04 2011 17:29 orgolove wrote:
...
I'm not going to post any votes until there's something more concrete to go on.

On January 04 2011 17:29 orgolove wrote:
I apologize for being busy.


So we're having a day 1 lynch without any starting information huh. An open setup with unknown roleblockers gives a disadvantage to the town, but as the saying goes, "a challenge means god's afraid of your progress"


All right, lets see.
...

Looking at the past two pages, there's nothing to analyze. There's only been two votes, and the only discussion has been whether to lynch inactives.


no. Bad idea. In a game such as this, planning to lynch an inactive just allows the reds to guide the discussion to whichever inactive green they know isn't a part of them and leads to the town's disadvantage.

I'm not going to post any votes until there's something more concrete to go on.

On January 05 2011 02:31 Ace wrote:
Yes it's still killing a townie but it gets you closer to your win condition. Doing it later in the game has major consequences but it's Day 1 and I don't see people trying to really do much.

Alas I can't vote. Oh well.

On January 05 2011 11:55 Beneather wrote:
There is really nothing I could do about being lynched. Since the people that already voted hasn't been here to change their decision.

There's really no information on who to vote for since there hasn't been much activity in this game.
Also aidnai is supporting different people then all of a sudden against them very confusing.




These post show that he agrees with what Ace is saying and just spamming away 1 line post etc.



Here he is protecting Ace from LSB's attack on Ace saying that he's too pro-town that he sucks at being a mafia. So basically he's saying that LSB is scum. But don't kill him because that would make less activity. This doesn't make sense because aren't we looking to lynch mafia. If we get a mafia then we're one step closer to win the game. If we get a mafia on day 1 we'll get more activity and so on. I'm not saying LSB is a mafia I'm just saying what aidnai is saying completely is going left to right.



Alright this post confuses me as lynching a bad town really confuses a town if he's a scum or if he's just a bad town. That's what we have to choose between to find scum. But aidnai is just saying that it is 1 less town that the mafia kills but that gets the closer to their own objective of out numbering the town. I believe the more town we have from not lynching them in Days is better for it will take longer for the Mafia to kill the town. It will also give the town more time to find these mafias. Yes lynching an inactive is good for the beginning but wouldn't it be better to lynch someone that is acting scummy. Near the end the DT's should have role checked the inactives to see if their scum. I think that's a better way of doing it because there is not other way of finding if their scum or towny since they're inactive.