Harry Potter Mafia!

On December 11 2010 16:58 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
Well you guys keep asking why we should kill him, but I ask why shouldn't we kill him?

On December 11 2010 23:39 GGQ wrote:


Why is that a scum tell, though?

On December 12 2010 06:01 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
but that is effort I don't want to put into stuff! Its actually not even a hunch, I just want to kill LSB for not hitting incognito/infundiblium in TMM2.

On December 12 2010 11:47 Airbag wrote:
I really feel now that if the mayor is elected honestly he should lynch LSB

im thinking about what his goal and intention is:
1. to control/direct town the way HE wants it
2. to make a private vote (if he is mafia easily he can pretend they voted differently than they did)
3. fished on me to see if I might be blue
4. more interested in defending himself and making HIMSELF look good and pro-town than he is to actually find and kill mafia/contribute something useful

that sort of arrogant attitude sounds like a mafia trying to force our trust and make us follow him

who is better to lynch at this point?

On December 13 2010 10:35 Amber[LighT] wrote:


To his defense he's the most vocal when he's scum, so this isn't much of a surprise. (Check Salem mafia)

On December 14 2010 09:05 Kenpachi wrote:

no.

On December 14 2010 09:27 Kenpachi wrote:
DONT LYNCH LSB

DONT LYNCH LSB

On December 14 2010 11:43 orgolove wrote:


Which detective did they use to confirm LSB's town?

On December 14 2010 14:21 LSB wrote:
FFFFFFFFFFFFFUUUUUUUUUUU

On December 14 2010 15:31 LunarDestiny wrote:
I DO NOT THINK THAT LYNCHING ORGOLOVE A IS GOOD CHOICE.

Look, LSB claims that both orgolove and LSB both contribute to mafia's KP
LSB, under huge danger of being lynched, role claimed and also SHITS happened.
Orgolove is being lynch because LSB claims he is mafia.

If we lynch LSB: Mafia's KP will be reduce and we will find out if he is telling the truth.
-If LSB is telling the truth, we lynch Orgolove tomorrow (result:2 mafia lynched)
-If LSB is lying (result: 1 mafia lynched, tomorrow's lynch unused)

If we lynch Orgolove: Mafia's KP might or might not be reduce depending on if LSB is lying or not.
-If LSB is telling the truth, we SHOULD lynch LSB tomorrow unless we find another mafia tomorrow.
-If LSB is lying (result: 1 townie lynched, tomorrow's lynch unused).

If we want to reduce mafia's KP, we should Lynch LSB today and base tomorrow's lynch based on if LSB is lying or not.

On December 15 2010 06:14 deconduo wrote:


Its so obvious he's legit, town just sheeped mafia.

On December 15 2010 15:53 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

And I'm still waiting for kenpachi to give us an explanation as to why he thinks LSB was not scummy.

On December 17 2010 04:56 jcarlsoniv wrote:
I don't have an alternate win condition in Gryffindor, not sure about the other two.

Why is NOT in my alliance group. I'm not sure why he is saying he is in Gryffindor.

On December 17 2010 05:26 Pandain wrote:


personal reasons :/

On December 17 2010 09:55 Pandain wrote:


O.O

On December 18 2010 04:57 LunarDestiny wrote:
From jcarlsoniv:
I can confirm that Dr.H PMd me at the start of the game (as Airbag) posing as a noob. He was asking some questions, saying he wanted to team up with a veteran to stay alive. I am by no means a veteran, and he was trying to sweet talk me to get my trust. After watching him post, I had determined that he was most certainly a smurf. When I called him out on it, he eventually told me that he was DocH. He also made a claim early that he was able to protect people, so I figured he was Poppy. When talking to Kitaman, he said that he had a DT who had found the real Poppy, and it was not Airbag/Dr.H.

We really need Kitaman's dt to claim now. If the dt claims, we will be certain that either the dt or Dr.H is lying.
If the dt is telling the truth, we kill a mafia in exchange for a dt to be out in the open which I think it a good trade.
If the dt is lying, we lynch a medic in exchange for a mafia lynch tomorrow. This is not as good but at least we get a compensation.

I don't think we shouldn't lynch someone because they claim a certain role.

There is an alternative plan to prove Dr.H is town:
Kenpachi can name check Dr.H.
And Dr.H can protect Kenpachi.

This plan will ensure Kenpachi's safety and we can confirm Dr.H's alignment.
If Kenpachi dies, then we lynch Dr.H tomorrow. The risk is the mafia can roleblock or bus either of them to make it not work.

On December 18 2010 06:35 LunarDestiny wrote:
Something don't make sense here. The reasons that we are lynching Dr.H is because:

1. He defends Pandain. We can't use this to determine if he is town or mafia.

2. jcarlsoniv's post

This post shows us that Dr.H claimed to jcarlsoniv to be Poppy. jcarlsoniv was told by Kitaman who was told by a dt that another Poppy was found.

There's too many loopholes here.
If either Kitaman or the dt is mafia, then lynching Dr.H would be stupid.

On December 18 2010 06:50 LunarDestiny wrote:
If exposing a dt can confirm we lynching a mafia and reduce mafia's KP by 1, I can fine with it.

Yes, the post is a defense to Dr.H.

On December 18 2010 07:02 LunarDestiny wrote:
Kitaman, have your dt personally claim to me and I will prove that I am town to him also.

If my prove is flawed in that it is not enough to prove I am 100% town, then either one of you can tell town. If I am mafia, town also knows Mr.Zergling is mafia.

On December 18 2010 07:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

if you're right that's a pretty lucky guess

lucky enough to be a mafia slip. i don't know why we aren't all lynching you since it's painfully obvious you're mafia.

On December 18 2010 07:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

if you're right that's a pretty lucky guess

lucky enough to be a mafia slip. i don't know why we aren't all lynching you since it's painfully obvious you're mafia.

On December 20 2010 08:51 Barundar wrote:
I think Kitaman is lying about extra DT and whatnot. Based on his dedication, Jcarl "confirmed" him. Obvious he is Voldemort or real Poppy, and at the moment it's down to a flip between him and DrH.

Kitaman said DrH and Pandain was scum. DrH said Pandain was not scum. Kitaman could have been lying about both. DrH could have been right about Pandain beceause he was scum.

Town would be safer to find scum elsewhere.

vote Coagulation

On December 21 2010 13:51 kitaman27 wrote:


sorta like you did yesterday? :/

On December 22 2010 05:45 Barundar wrote:
Well seems like noone cared about my post on Kitaman, it wasn't very reasoned either.

Long story short in last vote we had 6 votes for DrH:
Myself
LunarDestiny
Jcarlson
why
Node
Kitaman

Out of those I'm obviously not Kitaman's DT or medic. LunarDestiny Jcarlson and why are students at hogwarts. That leaves Node who can be Kitaman's DT + Medic. Since Node most likely isn't both, Kitaman was lying when he said that he had a DT confirm him and a medic.

This is a moot point now though, most likely since I dropped the argument. DrH will be lynched tonight, even if we had a better shot at hitting mafia % wise through a list with 7 mafia on it, than a choice between Kitaman and DrH.

My reasons for picking Coagulation was he seemed scummy to me, no way I had time to put together a list though.

On December 23 2010 07:33 Incognito wrote:
Wait...So town manages to get 2 out of 8 mafia while losing 3/5 of their members in the process and STILL win? Something isnt right here...