|
On November 06 2010 10:24 DCLXVI wrote:
Wow so DocH says:
"I.S. is my #1 suspect"
--why?
"Wait, let me read through his posts to find out"
He faked his role by offering up another mafia teammate, sure. The way someone becomes #1 suspect is to find mafia.
What is this shit?
simple bus and I thought his posting was scummy earlier. he was my #1 scumsuspect until he outed coagulation, that unconfirmable and inconsistent roleclaim doesn't change shit
i'll analyse him, i never back down on my word
|
On November 06 2010 10:24 infinitestory wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2010 10:23 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On November 06 2010 10:21 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
because i think you faked your role and your posts still seem scummy to me
let me read through your posts first geez i thought either you or pandain were mafia on day 2 when my poke didn't come through I'm more inclined to believe that you were mafia based on the posting but when you claimed DT and got coagulation killed I rejected the notion until I realized it is an easy bus and you did absolutely nothing to confirm your role and there are things about your roleclaim that make me think its more likely a lie than the truth like the rng check and the 1/4th chance versus 10%, it's inconsistent with the other known ADD role in the game not to mention it's awfully convenient that the results returned were the roles and alignments of a player any mafia would know whether or not he had DT powers, you had no information that every mafia didn't already have just information town didn't necessarily have the only reason it was 1/4 is because it randomly selects a member from the game at the time (beginning of night 2), there were 7 reds and 21 blues hence, probability of finding a red is 7/28 = 1/4
you said it had a 1/4th chance of failure if i am remembering correctly
do you not remember the way the role you faked works?
|
You're right, I remembered incorrectly
"I get a RNG'd target to check every night. My chances of finding a red every night so far have been about 1 in 4, so I figured if I caught a scum I would consider claiming the very next day.
Night 1 I got annul (and ended up playing on his tire swing all night >____> while getting 0 information). Night 2 I got Coagulation. Excellllent~
Coagulation is a mafia, and his role is Mafia Retard (I giggled when I read it too). I have no idea what the role does, since DT checks don't give the full role PM."
it seems oddly inconsistent with the mechanics of ADD Medic which had some sort of nonexistent failure mechanics
the point is no one should say you are "confirmed town" right now.
|
On November 06 2010 10:28 LunarDestiny wrote:
So infinitestory fake claim to kill coag? Damn, that is some high level mafia play...
Shouldn't we keep it real, and play with logic.
no, buses happen all the time
i've done them as mafia before. it isn't high level, mafia talk about starting on the first day. what circumstances should they bus, who should they bus if they have to, etc.
in micro mafia i almost bus'd drag_ on the first day just so people would think I'm town
|
oh shit i forgot about infinitestories early fish
nevermind, not a bus
|
coagulation isn't good enough to play mind games
|
meh
depends on if the person will listen
i remember ghrur in the last mafia game would almost never post until he was instructed what to say by mafia
|
|
|
I think it is what it says, if he protects a mafia he dies. Why would he say the things he said if that wasn't the case? His role doesn't specify anything about flipping, you're going on a weird tangent.
I guess Pandain is still the best choice. I'm not sure if I'd rather see hyperbola or nemesis lynched though.
|
On November 06 2010 18:44 CubEdIn wrote:Show nested quote +On November 06 2010 10:24 DCLXVI wrote:
Wow so DocH says:
"I.S. is my #1 suspect"
--why?
"Wait, let me read through his posts to find out"
He faked his role by offering up another mafia teammate, sure. The way someone becomes #1 suspect is to find mafia.
What is this shit? I thought about this while I went to sleep last night. It's possible that IS is red, and he totally made up his role. There's nothing to prove otherwise, other than the fact that he gave us a mafia to lynch. However, Coag didn't have a very useful role. Not totally useless, but not very useful either. So think about the following investigations. He could just say that he randomly DTed X, Y, Z (on separate days ofc) and they are all townies (while in fact, they being mafia), and if we started believing him now, we'll be in deep trouble if he manages to protect his allies. That being said though, it's kind-of a long shot, and I wouldn't go as far as to vote for him to be lynched. Not even close. The main down-sides of his plan? It takes a bit long, and he can't cover the person who's being targeted by the town, because it would seem obvious. So, given that there are 6 mafia left, assuming that he's one of them, he would still need at least 5 nights to cover all of them. If we use double-lynch again, that means we'll have killed 6 to 7 people. Again, maybe mafia did this because people were starting to zone in on the members and they needed a way out, the possibilities are endless, but let's just take it with a grain of salt and see what happens next before we go say that he's "the #1 suspect", and risk causing a bandwagon on him. I mean, what if he lucks out and gets another red tonight? Do we still lynch him? 
Until I remembered how he fished for his role way way early in the game. IS isn't mafia.
|
Good luck town.
Don't start playing dumb. Stay sharp and really think about things. Don't make insane assumptions, avenge my death!
|
|
|
i wrote two of the death posts :D
|
there is an epic quotes thread
|
On November 12 2010 10:10 LunarDestiny wrote:Show nested quote +On November 12 2010 10:00 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
there is an epic quotes thread I remember, you switched votes to spare pandain. But I am the one that warned LSB that we got an extra hour...
it was not smart of me. i think i honestly lost town this game.
|
On November 12 2010 11:49 Ace wrote:Show nested quote +On November 12 2010 11:39 Coagulation wrote:
also i will mention doch did a damn fine job putting up with the barrage of mafia attacks on him and holding his cool and keeping town together.
if anyone gets any kind of pressure under fire award this game DOCH wins hands down. Yea I felt bad for Dr.H. While he wasn't always on the right track the Town was so bad he never had a chance to cut through all the bullshit. By the time Infinitestory came around it was too late. I guess now Dr.H knows how it feels to appear so pro-town and have to deal with bad townies and Scum undermining you and how hard it is to find the difference.
Do you think I did alright for my first time as town?
Please stroke my broken ego 
|
I was honestly just really scared to go after you. Your name has a lot of clout and with no one to really back me up I felt too nervous to go with my gut which from day 2 told me you were scum.
I started feeling unsure about Pandain later. The funny thing is if I stuck with my original intentions and feelings I would have lynched Divinek on the first day and pushed for you and Pandain to be lynched on the second day.
The worst mistake I feel I made was over posting. I'm used to spamming a bit as mafia and only later did I realize I shouldn't respond to everything people post. Secondly I wasn't confident and I played a little bit too reactionary.
|
:< so many negative vibes
|
it's not mafia without nerdrage!
|
hey there are some good hollywood movies brodawg
not many though D:
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
