EPTGonna be coming up with my own theories after some post analysis, i hope i get called red for that as well. Lowest level tactic in the ol' mindset
Team Melee Mini Mafia - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
Gonna be coming up with my own theories after some post analysis, i hope i get called red for that as well. Lowest level tactic in the ol' mindset | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On June 25 2010 14:20 DarthThienAn wrote: And to lynch players because they are 'good' players and might be mafia is just silly, and encourages bad play. i think the line of reasoning is more like, yes they are 'good' players. They certainly have shown more depth and perception than anyone thus far, and are obviously known and experienced at this game. So why would the mafia not choose one of them to be lynched? It might not be a, lets lynch them! kind of thing, but what good reason can you come up with to answer that question. I mean i may lack enough experience playing with you guys but if i was red i certainly would have gotten one of those two teams. | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
1. BM said several things that didn't make any sense, pointed out by YI. I will hold off on voting just yet. But that combined with him trying to get YI lynched means that im right now leaning towards him. wtf is this? I'm leaning towards him, why leaning, why not cast the first vote? Might it look bad? Is bm really that confusing? Are there any original ideas in this post? Nope, just agreeing with someone and leaning towards someone we now know is town 100%. 2. What's the purpose of the mafia roleblocker in Setup 2 that flamewheel posted? It seems like he wont be able to block anything. he already explained this but i still think it's something to keep in the back of your mind, why wouldnt he just pm flamewheel. I dont actually know the answer to this question myself but why wouldnt he? 3. This would be bad for mafia in my eyes. In the first day they can easily start voting early since they only need a few weak arguments at that stage to start off the voting and they will probably get a lot of townies along with them. Doing what I did would be terrible if I was mafia. If I later would want to change my vote to the best/most active townie, I would have to explain myself based on all the posting that has been done today. Instead of just the early few pages. I'm casting my vote on BM's team right now. He's arguments and plans still feel off to me. scum radar alert! Why would townies have to go with weak arguments? Townies could be just as retarded and go with anything when there's so little info, we have good enough players that can make good enough arguments as it is. Blah blah mind games saying im not red could be red etc loop his arguments and plans still feel 'off', i already addressed this before, that has to be the worst logic ive ever seen for casting a vote, and as we all know now, we know this team is green even if they acted stupid so surely a red would go 'oh i could vote for the crazy town team and it wont look bad' HE CASTED HIS VOTE AFTER GOING AGAINST WHAT HE JUST SAID HE WOULD HAVE TO DO IF HE WERE TO VOTE AN ACTIVE PLAYER. 4. The only other mafia game I played in did not have roleblockers(it was in the role descriptions, but no one got it/used it afaik). So yes, I wasn't entirely sure what purpose they served without blues. I don't think this makes me more likely to be mafia. If I was I would've asked my mafia mates about it. 5. Several players posted about BM's early posting with flawed logic and at that time I posted I was leaning towards him. I now responded to one of his latest post(partly directed at me), and explained why it was wrong. Do you want me to quote it all in one post? It seems unnecessary. doesnt really give any reason other than, oh im siding with people that obviously some of them have to be town so it makes me look more pro town but i really have no reasons of my own note: STILL NO REASON FOR VOTE, just he 'felt' off 6. Ok, I'll stop using that word and be more specific. The last sentence was just a badly worded summary. still no come back from my attacks at his reasoning, just empty defenses 7.One is a simple clarification + me actually disagreeing with YI because I did not understand the voting rules (teams are lynched instead of players). The other would not be anything to go on if we would flip red. YI posted a whole lot, he pointed something out that seemed reasonable and that I would therefore base my voting on. I don't see how you can call this kissing up. openly admitting just band wagoning on a vote, though i guess this isnt the worst thing in the world for the first vote, but still these are pretty shallow and weak reasons for a vote. 8. Imo there is about 50/50 that either bum or BM's team is mafia. As it stands I'm keeping my vote on BM for obvious reasons. ok fuck you. This is the second post where you're like 'this team is very likely to be mafia' and now you're adding well another team might be, IMO, WHAT THE FUCK IS YOUR OPINION? You didnt state any reason for saying why bums team might be mafia. You're just trying to throw in little jabs. Voting staying on bm for obvious reasons, if they are so obvious can you please point them out? Sigh this is looking so weak to me. Plus my read on bums team is quite green at this point so it makes me think you KNOW both of those teams are green and you'd be fine killing either of them .Yeah Korynne, since more and more are switching frmo my team I will probably switch my vore later on. switching your vote cause others are, not for logical reasons, not for something you truly see as supsicious. POST some content man 10.Reading through this it does sound convincing. L would be an easy target for mafia to go after though. Only one person that needs to be implicated, and L has been posting quite a lot. Some of his mistakes are ones I would make myself. BUT, since none of Ace's posts seem like mafia and Ace has been bashing L since the start, that seems highly unlikely. first post with any reasoning behind anything. But this stuff isnt backed up by a vote, it's just well this person could be mafia and someone who doesnt seem like mafia is going after non mafia stuff seems unlikely confusing emptyness. Well until anything else comes up for me im voting team 7. Could people tell me what they think, is my first level reasoning too weak here? Are these adequate scum reads? Both him and his team mate have been among the more inactive people, and both of them have voted for the only two teams i really think are green, one of which is now dead. | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On June 26 2010 16:08 Nikon wrote: Yeah, I only defend myself, because all you people do is harp on me - my sister's wedding is coming up this Sunday and things are getting quite hectic around here to be honest. It's interesting to note however, that Laxercannon still hasn't posted jack shit, yet me and Zyrre are getting all the flak for being inactive. In fact, the only thing that Laxercannon posted after his "going to take a shower - state an obivous fact" combo was a poorly constructed attack on myself in response to my post - this I find very scummy. hurrah for the worst posted reasoning to vote for someone as of day 2! | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
o well was a fun game as town! | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
Durak, Zyrre, stormtemplar, johnnyspazz, 6 players died today groovy | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
3. LaXerCannon and bumatlarge 4. Ace and DarthThienAn 5.YellowInk 6.L 7.Nikon 8.BrownBear | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On June 27 2010 13:25 BrownBear wrote: Wat. Where were you??? Vote quickly, flame might have intentionally not showed up to extend voting period to get more active people in! that'd be entirely unfair to the people who thought 'ah too late ah well glhf' | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
gl, though im a big believer in sticking to rules, especially really easy to follow ones like this | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On June 28 2010 14:26 DarthThienAn wrote: BB, I think the newbie bearie should only be able to go to first timers =P. Unfortunately, none of them were too good. Divinek/Durak/stormtemplar were our noobies? I guess Divinek wins by default since he didn't get modkilled. Leave it un-given imo =p. http://excoboard.com/somethingveryverysecret gg all ^^ yeah this game was rofl bad i spent the whole game just trying not to die, let alone actually figure anything else out | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On June 28 2010 15:28 DCLXVI wrote: What great teamwork we had. I thought the strategy was to get us lynched. well it was clearly a great success | ||
| ||
