|
On June 27 2010 09:27 YellowInk wrote:
BM, I can't find the post where the ministry of magic banned the word mafia, but I see it has been edited into the OP. When was this put into place?
Also, what is a paranoid gun owner? It's not listed in the rules either. If it's what I think it is, how did he die alone?
that, and also, what is a "weak weasley bodyguard"?
|
so the weasleys know who each other are? lol
this game is an absolute clusterfuck!
|
On June 27 2010 09:40 YellowInk wrote:
I only questioned paranoid gun owner because PGO dying alone is exceptionally rare. It's usually a pretty good role in the hands of a skilled townie because you get to take down a mafioso with you when they use their KP.
I guess He Who Must Not Be Named personally killed this one. That or someone was giving a serial killer + vet in the same role, though I think the former much more likely.
If rules get changed, please post them in thread as well so we don't have to accidentally notice their addition in the OP.
that, or maybe he used his only kill on madame pomfrey night 2. i'm assuming that PGO is a night vigilante? or are you assuming PGO kills whoever visits them?
either way, unless a doctor says they successfully protected someone last night, we can safely assume mafia KP = 1 (stacking 2 KP on hesmyrr sounds odd).
|
On June 27 2010 11:21 Bill Murray wrote:
there is a reason the PGO did not kill the person who sent in the kill
it is not good to dwell on the past
move on.
oh wow... we might be able to get some real information here. doctor(s), did you get a PM that you saved anyone? because if you did, you saved a death eater and we know who they are!
|
To clarify due to YI's suspicion, only reveal yourself if you did indeed protect someone who was saved. I think a doctor's life is worth a death eater, don't you, YI?
|
actually YI I just realized you don't understand. let me explain it in more detail:
a death eater targeting Hesmyrr would die unless medic protected. Hesmyrr died. therefore, either DE did not kill anyone last night but a vig killed Hesmyrr instead and was medic protected, or DE killed Hesmyrr and was protected.
if hypothetically a DT investigated Hesmyrr and was medic protected, how did Hesmyrr die? If a DE targetted Hesmyrr at the same time he would have died, right?
|
when did I say a DT should name claim? yellowink, your bad logic right now is strange when you are usually logical and think things through.
|
On June 27 2010 11:44 YellowInk wrote:
Well I guess that depends on the definition of the PGO role which our mod is choosing not to provide to us. Also, even assuming the rest of it, medic could be protecting DT, DT investigates Hes, medic covers DT, HWMNBN hits PGO, assuming PGO has infi shots we still have medic outing DT and medic for no gain.
For one example.
what is HWMNBN? -_-
that's a rather contrived case, but even if it happened, why didn't the death eater who targeted hesmyrr die?
|
ohh shit i forgot about the horcruxes. alright, well I guess due to the unlikely event that exactly what YI described happened, it would be best not to reveal a doctor who potentially saved someone.
|
|
|
No chez.
But I propose this instead:
you read from the beginning, then give us your own, somewhat unbiased opinion of what's happened and your opinion on the alignment of some people in the town.
Go!
|
so... I'm assuming that's the role check the guy you replaced did on abenson.
harry potter did a stupify curse on neville in book 1 or 2, got beaten, and heard his mother screaming. so i guess you are saying that abenson is harry potter?
and yes, i will befriend you my little chezpie
|
also, you should have 2 role checks, one from each night, right?
|
Yep, as opz and radfield have just gone back and forth about, something extremely fishy has just happened. JeeJee claimed he was going to reveal information, then claimed he found nagini but didn't give a name. Then, opz said he "agreed with JeeJee that lakrismam should be lynched" before JeeJee said any such thing.
We better hear a good explanation for why this is happening. We are already losing, and lynching another town aligned and suffering another night would put us into an almost unwinnable position it seems. If JeeJee/Opz are mafia (it seems like a possibility since they must have communicated by PM), lakris seems like the perfect target since he's not here to defend himself. I'm not about to vote for lakris until I hear a truthful explanation from you two. If you ARE indeed detectives, death eaters will be going after you tonight anyway (and meds can cover you), so you might as well tell the town what happened.
|
Alright, lakris it is. At least we'll know whether or not to trust JeeJee based on how he flips. We are going to need some serious luck in the future if he does flip green, though.
|
On June 28 2010 03:39 YellowInk wrote:
@ JeeJee/LM/~OpZ~ shenanigans:
I think it would be a good idea to wait untill JeeJee himself confirms LM is Nagini. Who is to say that ~OpZ~ isn't just twisting this whole thing? Remember that lynches occur when majority is hit, not just at end of day. My vote isn't going for a LM into JeeJee lynch untill I hear the words from the horse's mouth.
I'm considering unvoting now. I didn't notice that JeeJee hasn't posted since he said he investigated nagini, but rather it's been ~opz~ doing all the talking... wtf?
|
I'd like to help, but we're not supposed to post at night ><
Use your best judgement, and GL.
|
On June 29 2010 03:23 ~OpZ~ wrote:Show nested quote +On June 29 2010 02:33 Amber[LighT] wrote:you should probably not be told who to hit so mafia can't protect, or if we suggest someone and they do try to protect them we know that we should consider that individual for a lynch. It can really work both ways, and I figured we were in night mode, but BM never said not to speak  Mafia can protect...?
Was thinking the same thing when I read amber's post, but it seems possible... Nagini had leglimancy, so maybe one of the death eaters has episky?
|
On June 29 2010 06:26 Thegilaboy wrote:
Do not kill either of those people Abenson, do not listen to Opz
On June 29 2010 06:32 Thegilaboy wrote:
If my checks were accurate, those two are town, do not kill them
Uh... role claiming detective at night to stop a vig from hitting someone? Doesn't add up to me.
|
who did you hit so that you are a somewhat confirmed townie?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
