TL Mafia Ban List - Page 152

On December 21 2012 12:01 GreYMisT wrote:
Kush was not banned for poor play. I have made that clear.

On December 21 2012 11:29 kitaman27 wrote:


I think we've been fortunate enough to not have a major incident in quite a while and people have gotten better at sitting out their ban before trying to join another game. I do still like having an up to date list though when hosting. I'm a lot more comfortable not allowing a player play because they broke rule X, rather than deciding who can play based on personal preference. Perhaps we can change the thread owner to a shared account such as the TL Library user if flamewheel could use some help?

On December 21 2012 15:30 DarthPunk wrote:


Yeah. Regular updates to the ban list would be more appropriate than adhering to something that clearly isn't functioning in it's present state.

For example. Kush's ban. He was made to sit out some games but not others. Some people allow him in their games, some don't. There was no formal punishment in this thread and he was not added to the ban list. Some people agreed with his ban some didn't and there has not been any real resolution on kush's status as far as I can see.

On December 21 2012 15:58 GreYMisT wrote:


Thats because, for the most part, I prefer to handle things on my own. If a player bothers me he will be handled by me. I will state in this thread what occurred so hosts can make their own informed decisions. I have no need to beg the ban list when I have power over my own games.

On November 23 2012 07:05 GreYMisT wrote:
Its not that you were lying that was the problem. Its that instead of notifying me that you didn't feel up to the game so I could put in 1 of my replacements who would LOVE to play, you decided to just say "screw it". Its a disrespect to me, the host and creator of your role, a disrespect to the spot that will never be played or filled by a replacement, and a disrespect to the other players in the game who have had their experience worsened due to your actions.

On December 21 2012 22:41 DarthPunk wrote:
Well, if the intended function of this list is to inform others then I don't understand why the explanation wasn't simply copied across as you have done. rather than every potential reader of this thread in the future having to look up that particular post in a game as large as chrono.

It was my understanding that he misread his role and thought he was a suicide vig and that going in with that assumption he decided to trade one for one.

If that is the case and he simply misread his role PM and has been fine in countless other games then he shouldn't be banned IMO.

If he suicides for the sole purpose of leaving the game in full knowledge of the failure of his role he should be banned.

It is the intent behind the action rather than the consequence that is important. After all, isn't this about reforming/weeding out toxic players rather than a means of vengeance by the aggrieved party?

Anyway, that is all I have to say about the matter.

On December 22 2012 01:33 kushm4sta wrote:
For 4 days around thanksgiving I had this thing where I was super sick and felt terrible at night then in the morning I felt way better, only to become really sick again at night. That's why I signed up for a game in the morning (even though that would have been a shit idea because I felt like shit soon after, but that was the first night of it so I didn't know that at the time)

I knew there was a chance of me dying but I did not intentionally suicide. I thought if I had more hp than marv and if he was scum, then I would do it and everyone would be like ooo kush what an ownzor. If he had more hp than me I wouldn't have to deal with this game anymore. If we was town and he died then that was ok too because he said something in the thread that pissed me off. Therefore it seemed kind of like a win-win scenario. I did have a fever and I was not thinking that clearly.