On January 20 2010 14:16 citi.zen wrote:
How about this: one of Qatol's quotes is: "guns make you stupid." We have a player called magicbullet - who could resent that and call him vile, dirty scum.

That's really really far-fetched.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:22 GMT

#121

For the first I'd guess it's abenson/ghote since the fridge/apple clues actually have a concrete connection to the user.

for mafia #2, I'm at a loss.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:26 GMT

#126

Keit doesn't fit every clue either. None of the suspected players really fit 100%

I think we shouldn't get too ahead of ourselves with these clues.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:37 GMT

#131

On January 20 2010 14:33 citi.zen wrote:
Hobbes maybe fits the "barbaric noises" and "raised fists" description. Also, he has the NyC before the name - the "big apple".

that's better than keit imo since it fits at least 2 clues

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:48 GMT

#135

I guess I might as well run for mayor/sheriff.

If I'm elected mayor, I will most likely lynch ghote, unless someone turns out to be more suspicious.

As far as the position of sheriff is concerned, the power of incarceration is pretty important. The problem is the possibility of incarcerating a blue like a medic/detective/vig

I wouldn't incarcerate indiscriminately to avoid something like that as much as possible.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:52 GMT

#138

It fits more clues than your profile, true.

I'd say then that Hobbes would be the most suspicious as of now, not that anyone is super super suspicious yet. But still, if we can get a mafia with the mayor's first lynch that's ideal.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 05:56 GMT

#142

All the suspects end up that way, fitting in one aspect and not in another.

Hobbes is the only one who can potentially fit the whole picture, even if it seems a bit far-fetched.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 06:07 GMT

#145

On January 20 2010 15:03 Ser Aspi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I agree!

These clues seem really hard. They'll probably be easier as the game continues

DoctorH you seem pretty active. Are you by chance going to run for office? You seem to be making the most sense so far.

Right now I think we should be discussing who is going to run for office and what plans they have. This Sherrif role seems kinda funky I don't really understand it. Would be great if someone could make some sense of that blasted contraption.

Also can clue checks find out the godfather? I'm really afraid of the godfather. How can we find them out without a rolecheck.

On January 20 2010 14:48 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I guess I might as well run for mayor/sheriff.

If I'm elected mayor, I will most likely lynch ghote, unless someone turns out to be more suspicious.

As far as the position of sheriff is concerned, the power of incarceration is pretty important. The problem is the possibility of incarcerating a blue like a medic/detective/vig

I wouldn't incarcerate indiscriminately to avoid something like that as much as possible.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 06:18 GMT

#148

anything below that area has no clues so analyzing it would be fruitless

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 16:37 GMT

#192

So as we see it now, whoever is elected mayor should be lynching Hobbes? That first lynch can't go to waste and he's definitely the most suspicious as of now.

There are also 5 other mafia not described in clues from this post, keep that in mind.

Also, who all is running?

t_co (platform is mafia experience)
myself (platform is going along with the town, being very active)
meeple (platform isn't really anything at all)
citi.zen (platform is going along with the town/being helpful)

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 16:47 GMT

#197

whoops, my bad.

forgot about that one.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 16:57 GMT

#203

The tricky thing about sheriff, is his power is really only effective if he knows who is blue and who isn't. He can avoid incarcerating blues and act as something of a medic to townies he suspect may be targeted by mafia.

Also if he incarcerates a "townie" and mafia killpower decreases that night, that's a good indicator they might be mafia.

However, revealing yourself as a blue to the sheriff would be disastrous for the town if the sheriff was mafia. Luckily if that was the case and we suddenly started seeing extreme amounts of blues being hit, we can suspect the sheriff and lynch him.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 17:01 GMT

#205

On January 21 2010 01:55 [NyC]HoBbes wrote:
Wow, I log back on and suddenly I'm top suspect... fun. Only thing I'll say in my defense is that out of Calvin and Hobbes in the cartoon, Hobbes comes off at least 90% of the time as the exact opposite of Calvin's Loud/barbaric. Even though he's the tiger, he's usually the laid-back, philosophical one.

That is true, except when Hobbes attacks Calvin every time he comes home from school. I'm not saying you're for sure mafia. I think we're all reluctant here to be too certain of any accusation with clues this vague.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 17:06 GMT

#207

Right. It's imperative that the mayor goes along with the wishes of the town on the first lynch.

DoctorHelvetica

United States15034 Posts

January 20 2010 17:21 GMT

#215

Right. We should pick a mayor/sheriff based on who is doing the most to help the town at the moment. As far as I see it, meeple and myself have been the most active looking for clues/trying to help the town.

t_co had a nice banner but he just kinda popped in to say "vote for me" and then left. I don't want to say it's extremely suspicious behavior but if the mafia were trying to nab an elected position that would be one way of doing it.