|
On May 02 2014 05:06 Incognoto wrote: What point is there caring about the work conditions of a European if his work can be taken by a Chinese slave? God forbid that a European has to work 40 hours a week but if it's a chinese person then yeah it's totally fine that he gets paid 1/3 the money for 60 hours a week. Numbers I pulled out of my ass but you get the point.
Basically ethics has a price. No one cares about shitty chinese work conditions: not the politicians who are in power because they want to please the masses who have the "power" to elect them. not the masses eithers because who the fuck cares about what's going on beyond the television set? not the chinese slave masters, who are selling their cheap product to a world who has no morals.
yet everyone in europe is screaming about morals and solidarity. work conditions! poverty is bad! health care, education!. double standards much? they're all fucking clowns, that's what they are. disgusts me to even think about it. it's even more disgusting that the masses follow such clowns
the point you said about the government having the advantage of being able to borrow indefinitely and whatnot is very interesting to me though.
let me ask another completely naïve economic question: what causes recessions? off the top of my head, isn't it things like the subprime crisis? oil crisis in the 70s? in the 30s was it banking or something that caused it (wallstreet crash? was that a symptom or a cause?) ? It seems that the common denominator is institutions fucking up with some arbitary monetary cursor. something of the sort, no? I'm going to say that, but take it with a grain of salt : a very common idea among mainstream economists is that what the eastern country are living is a transition based on capital accumulation, and that they more or less require that (because we don't know better) to get to our living wages. The question of ethics is in my opinion too often abandonned by economists, and the brilliant idea to export the bulk of our "proletariat" to China included the advantage of breaking the solidarity between workers. Some people have a huge problem with that though, I have at least...
As for the question of what causes recessions in general, I don't think anyone really have a definitive answer. Lack of money, too much debt, not enough investment, overproduction, underproduction overconsumption underconsumption, lack of confidence, inflation, deflation, wars, I've read it all and often about the same event to boot. Banking problems being a symptom, a declenching factor, a cause or something else...
|
On May 02 2014 05:09 Incognoto wrote: what would happen if the entire world had the same currency? theoretically?
it's like all the problems you guys are describing stem from the fact that money's value can change
I'm not really sure of the pan-global currency thing.
Just spit-balling here, but I think it would have the effect of lengthening the duration of upward and downward economic trends.
We can look at an isolated version (doesn't really have the same model constraints but it's fine) in large countries with disparate regions. In Canada, Alberta's oil industry and the Atlantic provinces have very different economic structures.
When the oil economy in the west is out-performing the industries in the east, the currency in the west doesn't increase as quickly as it would otherwise, ie it's lower than it should be; this increases the ability to export cheaper goods and increase foreign investment, while the currency in the east doesn't decrease as fast as it would otherwise (it's higher than it should be), limiting it's ability to recover by exporting what would be cheaper goods in isolation.
|
On May 02 2014 05:42 Prog455 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 02 2014 05:06 Incognoto wrote: Basically ethics has a price. No one cares about shitty chinese work conditions: not the politicians who are in power because they want to please the masses who have the "power" to elect them. not the masses eithers because who the fuck cares about what's going on beyond the television set? not the chinese slave masters, who are selling their cheap product to a world who has no morals.
yet everyone in europe is screaming about morals and solidarity. work conditions! poverty is bad! health care, education!. double standards much? they're all fucking clowns, that's what they are. disgusts me to even think about it. it's even more disgusting that the masses follow such clowns There is no doubt that the hypocrisy is strong in the US and EU when it comes to the work conditions that we demand for our own, and the work conditions we accept in China, but it is not entirely black and white. Even though i believe this is a very poor argument, you have to keep in mind that what China is going through right now in terms of work conditions, is something that workers in USA and EU experiences at some point aswell, just as the Chinese is going to pass on the torch in a couple of years. But China and the west is different in other aspects aswell. I know this is true in Denmark, and i assume it is for most other European countries aswell, that China is portrayed as being the land of milk and honey. Much as USA used to be. And while this may be true for some parts of China, it is certainly not true for China as a whole. There are regions in China the size of Germany (in terms of population and area), but with an economy that is little less than 1/8th of the German counterpart. A such region is for instance Sichuan, which is one of the places where Foxconn has factories. Foxconn being company that manufactors everything that you hold dear, including but not limited to Apple and Sony products. And even though their minimum wage is indeed merely about 50 euros a month, you have to keep in mind that everything is much cheaper in China, meaning that as bad as it sounds, it is not comparable to European wages. Their minimum wage is not €50 and their minimum wage is rising with double digits. THey're using the minimum wage as a tool to transform their export driven economy into a consumption driven economy. It's not really hypocritical at all, the only way to drag countries out of poverty is economic development. After that you can start caring about more worker rights, cleaner environment etc.
|
On May 02 2014 04:34 Incognoto wrote: You see this is why I tend to keep away from these discussions on teamliquid, there are interesting discussions to be had but people are so damn snarky when discussing these things (I just know better than you do) that I find it best to just leave things at that and do something else with my free time.
Kind of like French politics, which comes down to chest-thumping, ego and being politically popular instead of sitting down to discuss things to find a real solution a problem.
Of course I could take the the trouble to go through hours of reading up on economic theory, but I don't have masses of free time and there are other interesting things to do. Furthermore it's often easier to understand something if you have a discussion with someone who answers your questions directly instead of reading up on said topic. Discussions always lead to the growth of ideas and the evolution of our perception. Discussion is an exchange. Reading up is a fine way to learn but it's one-dimensional.
If you don't have the time or inclination to have a discussion with me then don't bother quoting my post. You don't have to waste your own time telling me that I'm not eligible to have a discussion with you. Just ignore my post and move on, lol, it's not that complicated. You're quite the rude person.
China has been manufacturing goods and exporting them to the west for decades and that has helped it grow into an economic power. Why shouldn't Europe attempt to do the same? Why shouldn't we bring back production into the Europe instead of having our goods manufactured by slave children in China? That's the kind of stuff I want to know: why can't we do it whereas China can? I responded to you about the role of the state. In theory it should be the opposite : the state should invest during hard time to help recovery, and do as little as possible during growth, to pay back its debt and let the economy and the market make most of the decisions in terms of invesment.
On May 02 2014 05:09 Incognoto wrote: what would happen if the entire world had the same currency? theoretically?
it's like all the problems you guys are describing stem from the fact that money's value can change It virtually happened in the past, when all money were related to real goods (gold). It created crisis to no end : to some people the 1930 crisis was created by the french massing up gold/
|
On May 02 2014 05:06 Incognoto wrote: the point you said about the government having the advantage of being able to borrow indefinitely and whatnot is very interesting to me though.
Well this is only kind of true if you are living in a country that is self-sustained. For example agriculture, tourism, fishing and producing stuff with the natural resources that are in the country.
As soon as you need to pay for oil, minerals or other natural resources outside of your country you are in big trouble if you either don't pay your debt or want to pay with your own paper money that loses in value because you continuously print more. You have to accept the prices of the countries exporting the natural resources.
The people living in such self-sustaining countries also pay a price because they usually can't afford to pay for goods that are not produced in the country itself.
|
On May 02 2014 04:34 Incognoto wrote: Kind of like French politics, which comes down to chest-thumping, ego and being politically popular instead of sitting down to discuss things to find a real solution a problem.
Not French politics but politics in general. I've tried to follow politics more closely but it's the same shit in Finland. It's all about calumniating other parties without giving any answers or solutions yourself. They're like little children in the sand box, truly disgusting and pitiful.
|
France specificity is we always want the head of the chief.
|
|
|
As always, it is quite a poor showing coming from politicians (especially this unknown french lady). I'm more and more for an out of the euro if that's the kind of people that govern us.
|
Those seem like the prototypical politicians, particularly Juncker and Verhofstadt. Maybe these are even in the higher quality-spheres when it comes to EU.
The "stay out of euro" parties we have are one EFD-party becoming the largest party (they are not going to get any influence since they cannot find a common policy except for maybe the value-policies they are loosing voters on supporting!), same will likely happen for FN and Wilders in their ultra-nationalistic group. We have a cross-political group affiliated with the far left group and they stand to get in too, but sitting in that group won't give them much influence either, even though they have a niche in transparency and anti-corruption they are pretty good at. A lot of the rest don't understand what EU is and/or are very pro-european. Since most of the previous election debates on EU falls into unanimous songs against the travelling circus etc., a transparency/personal costs issue where almost all of them ignore or evade the questions and a discussion of to what degree Luxembourgh has powerful black robed politicians, it is not gonna make you much the wiser.
The EURO has little to do with the parliament even though it is also a classic discussion at these debates. It is a bit of a waste to consider the president of the commission as the number 1 issue when voting, but that may be the most true EURO-connection for the parliament. It is far more relevant to vote in the fora controlling the treaties regarding the EURO and/or EU in general and that is almost 100 % in the council (national governments ie. you need to vote for the right chancellor.). A lot of the rest of the political EURO-power is at the economic commissioners (chosen among friends of national governments... You see the pattern?) and bodies further out of citizens reach. If you are against the EURO, the way to go is by far national government elections, not european parliament elections. Voting for the populistic "no to EU"-parties in these elections is a wash. It is the eternal populist dilemma of making bad legislation to undermine the institution you are working in, doing absolutely nothing legislatively or making good legislation and thereby, to some extend, breaking your election promises. Sceptics are much better than pro- or contra-politicians since it shows a level of understanding the others don't need to show to the same degree.
|
I mean, If you're living in Greece and you vote for these kind of parties I get it. It's pretty bad over there. But I can't wrap my head around people here in Germany,France or Denmark voting for these kinds of people. I'd rather have the EU run by established parties that may be a little not so in touch with the people than by total nut jobs. It's not like we're living in Somalia here. If the youth is so concerned about their politicians then they should join a reasonable political party and become involved or call their MP or whatever. But people voting for populist parties just because they're to lazy to actually get involved is just really really bad.
|
José Bové is a great man, but his English is so weak nothing interesting came out of his mouth, it's sad.
Nyxisto you're just in denial, you need to look at facts and get out of your own life. Look at poverty rate in europe, social security, purchasing power, unemployment, everything is going down in the last 10 years in all countries, germany included for a big part. How can you resent people for trying something else ? This term "populist" used every now and then to point out every politicians that refuse austerity and stupid policies is astonishing. Just face problems and stop hiding yourself... In this debate, aside from Bové, everybody defended the way they faced the crisis, like really ? Everything worked ?
|
Voting for Lega Nord. Out of the Euro! Out of this horrible bureaucratic monster called EU!
|
Germany has been in a glassbubble when it comes to the populations in other european countries. EU can be changed to be better, stronger, faster but it was only a question of when Germany decided to improve it by passing the next set of HRE reforms. It was just a given that more EU integration is the only future. The federal court decissions about the Lisbon Treaty and later have finally started waking Germany up to the idea, that EU might be better off in a looser cooperation or at least with a slower reform tempo, since the courts can smack EU down if the integration continues. AfD is a positive sign for Germany, even though some of their policies are rather questionable. Finally a party representing a slightly sceptical opinion on EU in Germany. They seem to fit nicely in the non-libertarian wing of ECR!
Surprising to many, Lega Nord is part of the same group as Die Grüne from Germany and it is therefore in a group with both EU federalists and complete EU-abandoners. It is not exactly the same policies as Berlusconi preaches in this political leftish group, but ironically it seems like a good balance between fighting for more regional independency and actually getting something done politically. They are one of the exceptions to the rule that populist parties are irrelevant.  Speaking of populism, how does the "MoVimento Cinque Stello" do in italian polls and do you know if they have decided on their friends in the parliament? Could be funny to see M5S and Lega Nord in the same group.
|
On May 10 2014 08:24 radiatoren wrote: Those seem like the prototypical politicians, particularly Juncker and Verhofstadt. Maybe these are even in the higher quality-spheres when it comes to EU.
The "stay out of euro" parties we have are one EFD-party becoming the largest party (they are not going to get any influence since they cannot find a common policy except for maybe the value-policies they are loosing voters on supporting!), same will likely happen for FN and Wilders in their ultra-nationalistic group. We have a cross-political group affiliated with the far left group and they stand to get in too, but sitting in that group won't give them much influence either, even though they have a niche in transparency and anti-corruption they are pretty good at. A lot of the rest don't understand what EU is and/or are very pro-european. Since most of the previous election debates on EU falls into unanimous songs against the travelling circus etc., a transparency/personal costs issue where almost all of them ignore or evade the questions and a discussion of to what degree Luxembourgh has powerful black robed politicians, it is not gonna make you much the wiser.
The EURO has little to do with the parliament even though it is also a classic discussion at these debates. It is a bit of a waste to consider the president of the commission as the number 1 issue when voting, but that may be the most true EURO-connection for the parliament. It is far more relevant to vote in the fora controlling the treaties regarding the EURO and/or EU in general and that is almost 100 % in the council (national governments ie. you need to vote for the right chancellor.). A lot of the rest of the political EURO-power is at the economic commissioners (chosen among friends of national governments... You see the pattern?) and bodies further out of citizens reach. If you are against the EURO, the way to go is by far national government elections, not european parliament elections. Voting for the populistic "no to EU"-parties in these elections is a wash. It is the eternal populist dilemma of making bad legislation to undermine the institution you are working in, doing absolutely nothing legislatively or making good legislation and thereby, to some extend, breaking your election promises. Sceptics are much better than pro- or contra-politicians since it shows a level of understanding the others don't need to show to the same degree. Wilders will probably be as big as D66 our most pro Europe party. They'll both have around 22 out of 150 seats that's 15% of the votes. Really for all he attention the anti Europe parties get they don't really get that many votes.
|
If I am going to vote, I think I vote Peter Sunde Kolmisoppi, one of the founders of piratebay. Or Perusuomalaiset's Even tho quite many say that EU government has way more power than finnish government idk who to vote to stop those fucking stupid directives that EU is doing all the time.
|
On May 10 2014 20:02 TheBloodyDwarf wrote: If I am going to vote, I think I vote Peter Sunde Kolmisoppi, one of the founders of piratebay. Or Perusuomalaiset's Even tho quite many say that EU government has way more power than finnish government idk who to vote to stop those fucking stupid directives that EU is doing all the time.
If you vote for Komisoppi, you propably are going to vaste your vote. He will not win one seat. The way better choice, in my opinion, is Perusuomalaiset.
|
Greece's Supreme Court has allowed the far-right Golden Dawn party to take part in upcoming European parliament elections, a party lawyer has said.
The move came despite the imprisonment of six of its MPs, including its leader, over claims of involvement in political violence.
Nearly all of the party's 18 politicians are under investigation over serious crimes allegedly committed by the once-fringe party over the past two years, during its rise to prominence.
Under Greek law, candidates are only prevented from standing in an election if they are convicted of a crime, not if they are under investigation.
"We expected this decision. We have faith in Greek justice," lawyer Pavlos Sarakis told the AFP news agency.
A date for the criminal trials has yet to be set.
The party's European election list includes none of its parliamentary deputies. Among its candidates are two retired senior army officers.
Source
|
|
|
i just hope that the right wing parties wont get that huge amount of votes which is currently predicted. really cant stand their bullshit
|
|
|
|
|
|