On May 17 2014 21:39 AngryMag wrote: Quick question: Can somebody tell me when the election actually takes place in Germany?
If somebody would be willing to do the work, it would be very nice and useful if the opening post had a little list of the dates on which the election takes place in each of the member states..
No clue about Germany but it's the 25th here.
Will vote for a right wing party that is for the union, that's all I know at the moment.
Not sure who to vote for and I'm going over now. We don't really have an orthodox left/right split of varying degrees to decide upon, the legacy of the Troubles sees to that. For the most part the left-leaning parties are Republican, the former I am and the latter I'm not, the right is affiliated with Unionism.
Then aside from that you have a lot of either ineffectual ones who try to play the middle road like the Alliance (who I don't mind) lunatic socialists and anti-immigrants and single-issue parties. The Greens are ok except all they seem to do is campaign about the environment, which for me isn't a priority in this country. They're adopting more and more social positions and fleshing them out, but far too much of their base consists of the worst kind of internet equality activist.
On May 17 2014 21:39 AngryMag wrote: Quick question: Can somebody tell me when the election actually takes place in Germany?
i'd assume it's on your usual voting day which iirc is a sunday
edit - voted ukip, would have voted pirate but getting out and/or telling cameron that he needs to get reforms right if he wants to stay in power is more important than IP reform
On May 22 2014 23:14 Wombat_NI wrote: Not sure who to vote for and I'm going over now. We don't really have an orthodox left/right split of varying degrees to decide upon, the legacy of the Troubles sees to that. For the most part the left-leaning parties are Republican, the former I am and the latter I'm not, the right is affiliated with Unionism.
Then aside from that you have a lot of either ineffectual ones who try to play the middle road like the Alliance (who I don't mind) lunatic socialists and anti-immigrants and single-issue parties. The Greens are ok except all they seem to do is campaign about the environment, which for me isn't a priority in this country. They're adopting more and more social positions and fleshing them out, but far too much of their base consists of the worst kind of internet equality activist.
Decisions decisions!
I don't necessarily mind single-issue parties. The problem I had with the national elections here in Germany is that for all the parties there was at least one petty thing on which the party's stance and I disagreed so strongly upon that I didn't want to vote for them. :-/
On all the websites with the quizzes, I rarely get close to 65% concord with one of the parties.
On May 17 2014 00:25 Banaora wrote: I agree with you WhiteDog, the debate was stale. There was so little interaction between the candidates and having only one minute to answer complex questions does not help either. Especially when the audience is so diverse and you have to keep that in mind when answering.
@WhiteDog: I never heard about this law you are talking about in Germany. Could you post a source? But maybe you are mixing things up, because we have tolls for all trucks on our highways - German trucks included (Toll Collect). And there is talk to introduce tolls for everyone for using the highways, but Germans would have to pay, too. (Like it is in France.) But it's not decided yet.
My source are french, but here is an article that talk about the subject in english.
[...] Brussels has given unexpected backing for a proposed road toll in Germany that would effectively only be charged on foreign drivers.Under the proposal by conservative politicians in the Bavaria region, all cars would face a charge to use motorways, including both German and foreign drivers.But a separate tax on German car owners would be reduced, by the same amount expected to be raised from them by the toll. This means, in effect, that all the new revenue raised by the motorway toll would come from foreign drivers - to be spent on infrastructure projects.
Could you elaborate on how a road toll for everybody independent of the country of origin goes against european ideals? Not saying that I am a fan of this CSU proposal, considering that a large part of the gains by it is likely to be immediately eaten up by the bureaucracy needed to a PS: this is not yet a law, it is still in discussion. Our governing coalition agreed upon the plans for it when they formed the coalition, with the SPD (the junior partner in the grand coalition) making EU conformity a pre-requisite for the toll.
It has nothing to do with ideals, it is just a protectionist measure. It has been more or less voteed to be put in place in 2016. By voting that law, most other EU countries will do the same, unless they re stupid. It open a lot of perspectives for foreigners targetted taxation, and it says a lot about the state of the Eu and rising nationalism.
Sorry, but this is just nonsense. A toll is already in effect in a lot of countries, for example in Austria and also in France. This toll will NOT single out foreigners, EU or otherwise. Also, let me repeat, this is not yet a law. Parliament has not passed it yet, not even discussed a specific proposal, although it is highly likely that it will come within the next three years, with the EU having green lighted it. If you want to discuss rising nationalism, then yeah, I totally see that as a problem as well, and am afraid at the perspective of Wilders, Front National etc gaining in the upcoming election.
Edit: Tolls in EU here you can see the tolls already in effect. As you can see, if the world hasn't ended yet, then the crossing off of the (12t) behind Germany won't either.
So what you are saying is that there is no difference between a toll that everyone pay and a toll specifically targeted at foreigner ? You don t see how this can be used like some kind of tool for economic warfare ? There is a difference between discourse and action you know. Front National is discourse.
But the toll does not specifically target foreigners.
That was my whole point. It is no different than any other toll, because it will target everybody. Anything else would violate EU law. The plan is to introduce the toll - which everybody has to pay - and use it to finance the highways. Like France does. Since the highways were already financed before the toll, at the same time a sperate measure will be introduced to lower taxes on cars, with the intent of making it a zero sum move for those paying taxes on cars. Neither of these measures discrimates foreigners. If you find that this is "action against foreigners" like you seem to imply, then by all means you should protest against your own government and demand that France stop collecting tolls on highways and instead be increasing your taxes. Because it is the same situation, only France and other countries have been doing this all the time and therefore don't catch any of the bad press for it, like the polemic rainbow press article you linked. It only sucks really for the countries that still don't collect tolls and have a lot of transit traffic, like the BeNeLux countries.
Interesting that you are defending Front National. You think that when somebody is agitating against foreigners and islam like they do, it won't lead to action in the long run? I like the Latin saying "Principiis obsta"
Did you read the article I gave ? Do you have any proof that it does not specifically target foreigners ? From everything I read, it is supposed to be higher for foreigners.
It's kinda lying, what you're doing. Let's check a bit closer.
Germans paid the "toll" for years and years now via taxes, whereas foreign vehicles did not (except lorreys, but there's no difference between local and foreign lorreys, in fact local lorreys pay twice - via toll and via tax). It actually says it right there in the rainbow-press-article you linked.
"Under the proposal by conservative politicians in the Bavaria region, all cars would face a charge to use motorways, including both German and foreign drivers."
Okay. We established, that german and foreign drivers would pay the same toll to use our beloved Autobahn. Which, again, is at the moment solely paid by: trucks (foreign and domestic) and german drivers via taxes. Now:
"But a separate tax on German car owners would be reduced, by the same amount expected to be raised from them by the toll."
We go from "we pay via taxes" to "we pay via tolls", basically our "road-maintenance-tax" will get shanked and transformed into "road toll".
How dailymail (quoting them as a reliable source btw is pretty courageous) comes to the conclusion that now "everything is paid by foreign drivers" is an interesting mystery, but it's just plain wrong. And somebody with a background in economics (i gathered that from the US Politics thread i think) should be alot smarter than what you're trying there.
What the law proposes is that everyone who's using the road, pays for it. For the moment, germans pay via taxes, but no road toll. With that law, we pay road tolls, but "no taxes" (well we'll still do, but the part explained with "road mainenance" etc falls out). This is basically exactly the same system as any other country that uses road taxes/vignettes. For some reason though, if the evul germans try it, hell breaks loose.
It's a toll on cars. Not on Nationality.
As a small sidenote: "from everything you read" is not a reliable source. He doesn't have to prove to you that tolls for everyone are the same - you have to prove your claim that it's higher for foreigners. Which, btw, i couldn't find any source for. People are arguing that german drivers get helped with the toll by reduced taxes, which is bs. The "implemented" toll in our taxes gets shanked, yes. I don't see a reason why german drivers would need to pay twice.
edit: as a french person, you actually know all this. There's a reason we pay a specific tax called "KFZ Steuer" (car tax) that doesn't even exist in france. Next (not instead) to the french system of taxing big on fuels.
On May 17 2014 00:25 Banaora wrote: I agree with you WhiteDog, the debate was stale. There was so little interaction between the candidates and having only one minute to answer complex questions does not help either. Especially when the audience is so diverse and you have to keep that in mind when answering.
@WhiteDog: I never heard about this law you are talking about in Germany. Could you post a source? But maybe you are mixing things up, because we have tolls for all trucks on our highways - German trucks included (Toll Collect). And there is talk to introduce tolls for everyone for using the highways, but Germans would have to pay, too. (Like it is in France.) But it's not decided yet.
My source are french, but here is an article that talk about the subject in english.
[...] Brussels has given unexpected backing for a proposed road toll in Germany that would effectively only be charged on foreign drivers.Under the proposal by conservative politicians in the Bavaria region, all cars would face a charge to use motorways, including both German and foreign drivers.But a separate tax on German car owners would be reduced, by the same amount expected to be raised from them by the toll. This means, in effect, that all the new revenue raised by the motorway toll would come from foreign drivers - to be spent on infrastructure projects.
Could you elaborate on how a road toll for everybody independent of the country of origin goes against european ideals? Not saying that I am a fan of this CSU proposal, considering that a large part of the gains by it is likely to be immediately eaten up by the bureaucracy needed to a PS: this is not yet a law, it is still in discussion. Our governing coalition agreed upon the plans for it when they formed the coalition, with the SPD (the junior partner in the grand coalition) making EU conformity a pre-requisite for the toll.
It has nothing to do with ideals, it is just a protectionist measure. It has been more or less voteed to be put in place in 2016. By voting that law, most other EU countries will do the same, unless they re stupid. It open a lot of perspectives for foreigners targetted taxation, and it says a lot about the state of the Eu and rising nationalism.
Sorry, but this is just nonsense. A toll is already in effect in a lot of countries, for example in Austria and also in France. This toll will NOT single out foreigners, EU or otherwise. Also, let me repeat, this is not yet a law. Parliament has not passed it yet, not even discussed a specific proposal, although it is highly likely that it will come within the next three years, with the EU having green lighted it. If you want to discuss rising nationalism, then yeah, I totally see that as a problem as well, and am afraid at the perspective of Wilders, Front National etc gaining in the upcoming election.
Edit: Tolls in EU here you can see the tolls already in effect. As you can see, if the world hasn't ended yet, then the crossing off of the (12t) behind Germany won't either.
So what you are saying is that there is no difference between a toll that everyone pay and a toll specifically targeted at foreigner ? You don t see how this can be used like some kind of tool for economic warfare ? There is a difference between discourse and action you know. Front National is discourse.
But the toll does not specifically target foreigners.
That was my whole point. It is no different than any other toll, because it will target everybody. Anything else would violate EU law. The plan is to introduce the toll - which everybody has to pay - and use it to finance the highways. Like France does. Since the highways were already financed before the toll, at the same time a sperate measure will be introduced to lower taxes on cars, with the intent of making it a zero sum move for those paying taxes on cars. Neither of these measures discrimates foreigners. If you find that this is "action against foreigners" like you seem to imply, then by all means you should protest against your own government and demand that France stop collecting tolls on highways and instead be increasing your taxes. Because it is the same situation, only France and other countries have been doing this all the time and therefore don't catch any of the bad press for it, like the polemic rainbow press article you linked. It only sucks really for the countries that still don't collect tolls and have a lot of transit traffic, like the BeNeLux countries.
Interesting that you are defending Front National. You think that when somebody is agitating against foreigners and islam like they do, it won't lead to action in the long run? I like the Latin saying "Principiis obsta"
Did you read the article I gave ? Do you have any proof that it does not specifically target foreigners ? From everything I read, it is supposed to be higher for foreigners.
It's kinda lying, what you're doing. Let's check a bit closer.
Germans paid the "toll" for years and years now via taxes, whereas foreign vehicles did not (except lorreys, but there's no difference between local and foreign lorreys, in fact local lorreys pay twice - via toll and via tax). It actually says it right there in the rainbow-press-article you linked.
"Under the proposal by conservative politicians in the Bavaria region, all cars would face a charge to use motorways, including both German and foreign drivers."
Okay. We established, that german and foreign drivers would pay the same toll to use our beloved Autobahn. Which, again, is at the moment solely paid by: trucks (foreign and domestic) and german drivers via taxes. Now:
"But a separate tax on German car owners would be reduced, by the same amount expected to be raised from them by the toll."
We go from "we pay via taxes" to "we pay via tolls", basically our "road-maintenance-tax" will get shanked and transformed into "road toll".
How dailymail (quoting them as a reliable source btw is pretty courageous) comes to the conclusion that now "everything is paid by foreign drivers" is an interesting mystery, but it's just plain wrong. And somebody with a background in economics (i gathered that from the US Politics thread i think) should be alot smarter than what you're trying there.
What the law proposes is that everyone who's using the road, pays for it. For the moment, germans pay via taxes, but no road toll. With that law, we pay road tolls, but "no taxes" (well we'll still do, but the part explained with "road mainenance" etc falls out). This is basically exactly the same system as any other country that uses road taxes/vignettes. For some reason though, if the evul germans try it, hell breaks loose.
It's a toll on cars. Not on Nationality.
As a small sidenote: "from everything you read" is not a reliable source. He doesn't have to prove to you that tolls for everyone are the same - you have to prove your claim that it's higher for foreigners. Which, btw, i couldn't find any source for. People are arguing that german drivers get helped with the toll by reduced taxes, which is bs. The "implemented" toll in our taxes gets shanked, yes. I don't see a reason why german drivers would need to pay twice.
edit: as a french person, you actually know all this. There's a reason we pay a specific tax called "KFZ Steuer" (car tax) that doesn't even exist in france. Next (not instead) to the french system of taxing big on fuels.
I don't understand why you have to make it so long : german were paying the toll before, and now your government wants to make foreigners pay a toll, but not the same one, a different one (not the same amount). So there is a difference in nationality. If you give me a proof or a source that says the opposite I would love it, but until then I don't feel like any of your explanations actually change a thing.
This whole road charge thing for foreigners is ridiculous. It's a bureaucratic nightmare and it undermines the idea of free mobility in Europe. (Like all road charges, if you want to fix your streets increase your stupid taxes >_>)
The good thing is it will probably never happen because no one besides a small minority of people want it and the two big parties that are now governing clearly spoke out against it.
It's one of these things that blurts out of Bavaria from time to time, at worst they're going to pass some meaningless law that doesn't actually do anything so our southern conservative friends are happy again.
On May 17 2014 21:39 AngryMag wrote: Quick question: Can somebody tell me when the election actually takes place in Germany?
i'd assume it's on your usual voting day which iirc is a sunday
edit - voted ukip, would have voted pirate but getting out and/or telling cameron that he needs to get reforms right if he wants to stay in power is more important than IP reform
Speaking of UKIP: my understanding is that UKIP pursues leaving the EU and has great success with that agenda. Is the UK exiting the EU realistic at all? And would it become more or less likely if Scotland were to become independent? Frankly, as a strong pro-European, UK leaving the EU would be great news. I can't help but feel the Brits have blocked the EU's progress and acted as a mole for the USA for many years. As much as I'd like a united Europe, if the UK doesn't want to be a part of it, we'd be better off without them.
Speaking of UKIP: my understanding is that UKIP pursues leaving the EU and has great success with that agenda. Is the UK exiting the EU realistic at all?
cameron has said if re-elected he would offer an in-out referendum on the matter, so in theory, it is. that said, given that both the main parties have previously reneged on similar promises, i won't be holding my breath.
On May 23 2014 00:25 Nyxisto wrote: This whole road charge thing for foreigners is ridiculous. It's a bureaucratic nightmare and it undermines the idea of free mobility in Europe. (Like all road charges, if you want to fix your streets increase your stupid taxes >_>)
The good thing is it will probably never happen because no one besides a small minority of people want it and the two big parties that are now governing clearly spoke out against it.
It's one of these things that blurts out of Bavaria from time to time, at worst they're going to pass some meaningless law that doesn't actually do anything so our southern conservative friends are happy again.
Ever been to Austria or Switzerland?
Pay for sticker. Attach sticker to car. Get fined if Cops see you whiteout it.
I'd rather have people driving around our fucking streets how long they want without getting hunted down by the sticker police, who actually could do useful stuff instead. This thing is supposed to bring us two billion a year and people don't even know if introducing the system is going to cost more than that.
The middle class car owner is probably the most squeezed person on this planet when it comes to paying their share of taxes. I don't see why I need to introduce stickers and road charges when we could just increase our income tax by 0.x% which actually costs zero time and zero people controlling it.
I voted the dutch equivalent of Liberal Democrats. Very pro Europe, I don't really like the idea of the nation state and would prefer a federal Europe to get rid of that shit.
On May 23 2014 00:25 Nyxisto wrote: This whole road charge thing for foreigners is ridiculous. It's a bureaucratic nightmare and it undermines the idea of free mobility in Europe. (Like all road charges, if you want to fix your streets increase your stupid taxes >_>)
The good thing is it will probably never happen because no one besides a small minority of people want it and the two big parties that are now governing clearly spoke out against it.
It's one of these things that blurts out of Bavaria from time to time, at worst they're going to pass some meaningless law that doesn't actually do anything so our southern conservative friends are happy again.
Ever been to Austria or Switzerland?
Pay for sticker. Attach sticker to car. Get fined if Cops see you whiteout it.
OH NOES, THE BUREAUCRATIC NIGHTMARE!
I've been to switzerland. If you don't have the sticker, you can pay a fee no ? If you're a tourist that is. I passed Switzerland from Italy to France with no pb at all.
On May 23 2014 04:19 RvB wrote: I voted the dutch equivalent of Liberal Democrats. Very pro Europe, I don't really like the idea of the nation state and would prefer a federal Europe to get rid of that shit.
I agree entirely but that kind of federal european government idea would be doable only if governments in all state push for serious common policies in education and culture. As of now, Europe has been built like a big market, and a flawed market at that, which makes it impossible for national countries to realistically pass to the next stage.
Iirc the fee is smaller for non swiss people (but i'm really not sure about that, iirc in austria there is seperate one for short stays/tourists and/or maybe the cops were just nice (unlikely in my experience )... If you paid CHF 40.00 thats actually the full fee for a year. Which is dirt cheap when compared to about everything else here ^^.
I like the system much better than frances which is just annoying, the sticker system is so simple and you just buy it sometime in january at a random gas station and your fine. There is also no "sticker" police. This year i drove "illegaly" on the Autobahn for about 3 Months because i just forgot to actually put the sticker on my car and never was stopped (about 30 minutes a day total... Its even on an "Autobahn" that leads to the german border). But they might check tourist cars more often.
After my 3 Month stay in france i could/had to buy one right at the border in Switzerland (and 5 minutes later got flashes for speeding... After 9 hours driving at ~140 in france going down to ~130 in Switzerland was hard ).
On May 23 2014 06:09 Velr wrote: Iirc the fee is smaller for non swiss people (but i'm really not sure about that, iirc in austria there is seperate one for short stays/tourists and/or maybe the cops were just nice (unlikely in my experience )... If you paid CHF 40.00 thats actually the full fee for a year. Which is dirt cheap when compared to about everything else here ^^.
I like the system much better than frances which is just annoying, the sticker system is so simple and you just buy it sometime in january at a random gas station and your fine. There is also no "sticker" police. This year i drove "illegaly" on the Autobahn for about 3 Months because i just forgot to actually put the sticker on my car and never was stopped (about 30 minutes a day total... Its even on an "Autobahn" that leads to the german border). But they might check tourist cars more often.
After my 3 Month stay in france i could/had to buy one right at the border in Switzerland (and 5 minutes later got flashes for speeding... After 9 hours driving at ~140 in france going down to ~130 in Switzerland was hard ).
That is one way to make a toll (though the income is fairly limited, Austria charges 75€ for a year basically, less for short amounts for tourists). Italy (and France and likely a number of countries i do not know) charge per kilometer driven, which does in fact include a massive system to track that. I have no firm numbers (and cannot find any within 5 minutes of searching) but when Austria implemented the "vignette" (our sticker) a study showed that nearly 60% of the Italian tolls are lost in the administration of the tolling system. That is why we decided for a flat amount, it might be more unfair and the total income might be much less, but it is far easier to implement.