If you dont care, then dont care for real.
The European Parliament election thread - Page 33
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Fjodorov
5007 Posts
If you dont care, then dont care for real. | ||
|
corumjhaelen
France6884 Posts
| ||
|
Ethi
Germany275 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:50 Danglars wrote: So y'all on the other side of the Atlantic crushing these At least Germany has some bad experience with waiting till a right wing party beat themself while beeing in power. I'd prefer other ways to deal with them. | ||
|
Boblion
France8043 Posts
On May 27 2014 20:42 Ethi wrote: At least Germany has some bad experience with waiting till a right wing party beat themself while beeing in power. I'd prefer other ways to deal with them. And that's why you elected Merkel right ? ![]() | ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
On May 27 2014 19:44 Cynry wrote: I don't know how it is outside of France, but I think a fairly large part of non voters are just fed up with the apparent obvious lies that happens every single election. Some dude gets elected for a program, and then seems to forget about it once in power. No wonder trust in politics is low. Anyone got an explanation about that by the way ? I guess it has something to do with multiple parties working together or something, but I'd be really interested in a more educated insight. I don't know about manual workers, but you got to remember that 75% of under 35 years old didn't vote. I'm fairly sure FN wouldn't score 40/50% (I think that's what it is for these categories) if you were to "force" an opinion on 100% of them. At least I god damn hope this wouldn't be. The dude doesn't forget about it. He just needs to make so many deals to get any influence that he has to abandon most of the nonconformist ideals/suggestions if he wants any chance of actually changing something. First he has to negotiate to become part of a group, then he needs to negotiate his titles in the group and last but most important he has to specialize in one of at least 22 specific topics where he gets some actual influence outside of just being voting cattle (whether cattle for home-government, home-party, EP group or something unrelated). Who votes for what is a huge black market behind the scenes horse trading business. It is not for nothing EP have their own research into these matters to help the politicians find other politicians with some likelyhood of having the same opinions! A lot of votes are locked in twists where the treaty has to change and at least one country in the councils shoot out vetos if you dare mentioning the issue, some economic interest conflicts where both sides have strong lobbying and thus the legislation in either direction gets voted down, some conflicts between EP, council and commission or some multi-diverging opinions (Remember that all issues have at least 2 sides. Most have more, when you start to bundle them up!). | ||
|
Cynry
810 Posts
On May 27 2014 21:03 radiatoren wrote: The dude doesn't forget about it. He just needs to make so many deals to get any influence that he has to abandon most of the nonconformist ideals/suggestions if he wants any chance of actually changing something. First he has to negotiate to become part of a group, then he needs to negotiate his titles in the group and last but most important he has to specialize in one of at least 22 specific topics where he gets some actual influence outside of just being voting cattle (whether cattle for home-government, home-party, EP group or something unrelated). Who votes for what is a huge black market behind the scenes horse trading business. It is not for nothing EP have their own research into these matters to help the politicians find other politicians with some likelyhood of having the same opinions! A lot of votes are locked in twists where the treaty has to change and at least one country in the councils shoot out vetos if you dare mentioning the issue, some economic interest conflicts where both sides have strong lobbying and thus the legislation in either direction gets voted down, some conflicts between EP, council and commission or some multi-diverging opinions (Remember that all issues have at least 2 sides. Most have more, when you start to bundle them up!). That is for Europe, right ? Does that also works with national elections ? From the Europe point of view, it's rather obvious to me how the one we elect, let's say in France, won't have the weight needed to go through all of his agenda (and again, for France, thank fucking god). Too many parties, different opinions, etc. But how come it's the same for national elections ? When we elect a president, we kinda expect that person to at least be able to "rule" the way he wants. Why not then ? Same stuff you talked about on a smaller scale ? | ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
![]() | ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
On May 27 2014 21:13 Cynry wrote: That is for Europe, right ? Does that also works with national elections ? From the Europe point of view, it's rather obvious to me how the one we elect, let's say in France, won't have the weight needed to go through all of his agenda (and again, for France, thank fucking god). Too many parties, different opinions, etc. But how come it's the same for national elections ? When we elect a president, we kinda expect that person to at least be able to "rule" the way he wants. Why not then ? Same stuff you talked about on a smaller scale ? That is from an EU point of view. National elections are completely different. If you compare United Kingdom, Germany and France when it comes to national elections, you will find out that it is night, day and another time not on the watch! Since the equivalent to "groups" in EP are parties in national elections and they are formed pre-election, that is not a problem. Also, the politicians in national elections have a chance of advertising their specific area of interest before an election. The problems in national legislation are caused partly by "politicians in robes" from EU court striking down ideas (sometimes a good thing), advisors striking down more speculative ideas (almost universally a good thing!), think tanks giving ammunition against the ideas, lobbyists making attacks on ideas into completely one-sided speculative bullet points for politicians and other opinion-formers to ad verbatim repeat and international level commitments that suck the soul out of a lot of ideas before they reach from election campaign to actual policies. I think those are the same problems in most western democracies. The problems are just far more obvious and solvable in EP democracy! | ||
|
Acertos
France852 Posts
Sorry but the UK has always been the bitch that managed (with De Gaulle) to stop the federalization process when it was still realistic. Now because we are 27 it isn t possible anymore and most British parties along with extreme right European ones continue to bluff and make threats of leaving the EU. "I want my money back!" Me too, I want to see Europe succeed and its the condition of my country success and growth. | ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
| ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
The sceptics and anti-EU wants to revert the integration and that is to be expected. More importantly and less well-known, several of the pro-EU parties in the nordic countries are ranging from cautious to outright critique of the social union and the speed of reforms being too high in EU. Unfortunately it seems some german politicians wants to fight fire with fire. Schäuble has been out and called FN "fascist" and called for a "more decisive" EU integration in the face of the election result... | ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10991 Posts
| ||
|
SpikeStarcraft
Germany2095 Posts
They cant afford to dick around anymore. So they better push for reforms now as long as they still can or they're gonna lose so many votes not only in european election but in their home countries too. | ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
On May 28 2014 04:20 Velr wrote: Calling FN fascist is just the correct way to call them... Maybe, but in conjunction with a call for increased decisiveness from the pro-EU parties and a characterisation of the european electorate as "They simply don't understand what EU is about", it is as close to a call for ignoring the result of the election and move on as you get. | ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
| ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
On May 28 2014 04:51 SpikeStarcraft wrote: Its a warning to the established parties that if they wont compromise and push for reforms now, then next election euro critical and radical parties will have at least enough votes to block the parliament. If the European Union even lasts that long. They cant afford to dick around anymore. So they better push for reforms now as long as they still can or they're gonna lose so many votes not only in european election but in their home countries too. But they better be damn sure about the positive effects on economy and the lack of bad cases of EUfication in these reforms. If they push for "more EU" despite the result of the election and things get worse, it accelerates the popular discontent to a level where things might turn really ugly in one or another way by next election. | ||
|
mahrgell
Germany3943 Posts
On May 28 2014 06:09 radiatoren wrote: But they better be damn sure about the positive effects on economy and the lack of bad cases of EUfication in these reforms. If they push for "more EU" despite the result of the election and things get worse, it accelerates the popular discontent to a level where things might turn really ugly in one or another way by next election. How about pushing for more EU, but give some nations an easier way out... Hey, if our friends on this little island don't want to be part of it, let them leave. Then everyone can have a look if they do better or worse as before. I think it would be an helpful experience, no matter which way it goes. And obviously the brits want to volunteer for it. They can't even manage to make a single national soccer team, how would you expect them to understand the idea of a more federal europe. And if they would really find the golden road outside of the EU... Well... a lot of countries would follow and we would have all learned something. But those step would in any case save those willing and believing in the EU from a lot of annoyance. Like Cameron stating today, that he wants neither Schulz nor Junker, but chose someone entirely different (not from the candidates) And then he wonders, why the people don't take the EP and its elections serious, when even their leading clown is basically ignoring it? Awesome! | ||
|
Acertos
France852 Posts
On May 28 2014 06:32 mahrgell wrote: How about pushing for more EU, but give some nations an easier way out... Hey, if our friends on this little island don't want to be part of it, let them leave. Then everyone can have a look if they do better or worse as before. I think it would be an helpful experience, no matter which way it goes. And obviously the brits want to volunteer for it. They can't even manage to make a single national soccer team, how would you expect them to understand the idea of a more federal europe. And if they would really find the golden road outside of the EU... Well... a lot of countries would follow and we would have all learned something. But those step would in any case save those willing and believing in the EU from a lot of annoyance. Like Cameron stating today, that he wants neither Schulz nor Junker, but chose someone entirely different (not from the candidates) And then he wonders, why the people don't take the EP and its elections serious, when even their leading clown is basically ignoring it? Awesome! The treaties are a joke, so normally it shouldn't be possible to leave the EU and the condition would be the agreement of all the 27.. But it would be possible if there was a strong European leader that pushed for it but aside from Merkel who doesn't want to see the situation change, there are no strong, passionate and pro action leader in the EU right now (that's why people turn to the extremes too, their leaders are mad and they won't hesitate to take actions). And in France that is what we are lacking. De Gaulle and Mitterand had their (huge) flaws but they also had the balls to shake things up both in France and Europe. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
The EU passes a lot of very reasonable stuff. Net neutrality laws, consumer friendly laws when it comes to food, they're trying to ensure competition in Europe is fair.(for example reminding Germany that our exports are too high, and that we're subsiding our energy markets too much). Water quality is at an all time high, and biodiversity is actually recovering after the environment was hit pretty hard in the 60's to 80's. | ||
|
radiatoren
Denmark1907 Posts
The issues relate to the kind of states in Scandinavia and UK. The non-conform parts that have worked well so far are under pressure. "Social union"-issues are worse here since Ie. the EU-solutions of state-mandated minimum wages, doesn't fit at all in countries without a a structure suited for state-mandated minimum wage! The problem is that the current national systems have been very positive for the societies and EU forcing the abandoning through the "one size fits all"-reforms is problematic. Don't get me wrong, it is inevitable that the systems had to change. It is just not suitable to force the issue. | ||
| ||

