- blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like.
- non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options.
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
xM(Z
Romania5299 Posts
- blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. | ||
|
Danglars
United States12133 Posts
| ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10992 Posts
| ||
|
sharkie
Austria18777 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:49 xM(Z wrote: i think the general idea is: - blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. Exactly. Voting blank is a statement, not voting is just being lazy. I mean here in Austria we keep having record lows in participation and what do the media and politicians blame it upon? Oh the weather was too good/bad thats why so many didn't come. Not voting is not even being considered as a protest as it shouldn't be. | ||
|
endy
Switzerland8971 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:50 Danglars wrote: So y'all on the other side of the Atlantic crushing these Problem is that other parties are not doing well. UMP (right) was elected and failed, PS (left socialists) was elected and failed, communists have no credibility, and the greens are seen as a bunch of pot smokers. Hence FN looks (for many, mostly less educated people) the only alternative. Obviously it would be a disaster shall they be elected, but since they haven't thus far, a lot of people are willing to give them a chance. | ||
|
Usagi
Spain1647 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:05 mcc wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 16:29 Usagi wrote: On May 27 2014 16:22 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 09:26 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 08:38 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 07:01 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 06:51 Acertos wrote: On May 27 2014 05:21 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote: [quote] It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties. Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics I voted blank and some of my friends did too or didn't vote at all. It's just that people (like me) feel that they can't be represented by our current parties. I don't rly care if the European Parliament gets blocked all the fucking time by the right extremes perhaps they will be so annoying that it will force the EU functioning to change. Also in the next election I will most likely vote blank again and only vote against the FN if it goes to the second round. The majority of non voters / blank voters think like that, and believe me when we see how Europe is managed right now that stance isn't retarded at all. You'll vote for Sarkozy against the FN ? They already made us play that silly game. On May 27 2014 06:54 Liquid`Drone wrote: there's a big difference between non-voters and people who vote blank. In France right now, voting blank is the elegant way of not voting, and voting FN is unelegant way. that's the case in all countries where right wing parties are on the rise I just wish EVERY nonvoter would vote blank... Nonvoting gives the impression of "I dont care", voting blank (especially with majorities of 60%+) would give a huge, huge statement People have other stuff to do, why waste time voting blank, when you can just not vote. The result is the same. Very few people who do not vote, do not actually care at all. They just do not care enough to spend the time as the selection of choices is just too poor. Many people I know (university educated smart people) who voted the first few elections after fall of communism are now completely fed up and just stopped voting due to there not being anyone to vote for and they refuse to play the "lets pick lesser evil" games. And voting in this day and age doesn't even require 10 minutes lol... intelligence (coming from studying) != smart... Maybe in Austria, here it requires to at least go to the voting station or post office, both of which take much more than 10 minutes. Not even mentioning if you live on the other side of the country that you are officially registered in. But even if it was 10 minutes. 10 minutes are still not worth it, when there is no good option to pick. Anyone who puts equivalence between not voting and not being smart is neither smart nor intelligent. Not voting is degrading yourself to not take on one of the biggest and most fought over rights that people have died for. Not only it is not smart, it is disrespectful for the people who fought so you could do it. Take your damn time to go to the station, and then if there is none you like, vote blank. if that 80% instead of nonvoters, were blank votes, things would be very diferent. And if someone does not care about that right ? People fight for all sorts of useless stuff, so just because people fought over it means absolutely nothing. And can you be more sanctimonious ? I still did not see any reasonable argument why it is not smart, except for constant stating that it is so. Voting right is a social engineering tool, nothing more, nothing less, it is not some divine idea. No they would not, just more wasted time. There is no reason to go to the station since we get all the voting sheets at home and thus can determine that there is noone good to vote for. EDIT: Just to clarify, I actually consider electoral democracy pretty good idea and I vote whenever I have opportunity (except for senate, because it is stupid institution and local elections, since I do not live where I am registered and have no time to follow local politics anyway). But I also see as completely legitimate stance decision to not vote at all. If someone does not care about their right to vote towards electing their representatives they could aswell be living in a hut and paying their land owner with the crops they harvest. Not caring about elections certainly equals not caring about your daily life and the situation where you live. If you dont vote you are giving an "I dont care, do whatever you want to me and to where I live". Blank votes are counted and a high % blank voters would mean people are really worried, nonvoters can be seen as people who just dont care about their situation, which are more often than not the ignorant people, or as a fail to mobilize voters for other parties in which case they can asume, yeah, well, results wouldnt be very different. What baffles me is that people who have time to come and discuss to a forum, and are smart enough to turn on a computer and discuss in a language diferent to their own are actually in favor of nonvoting, and defending it. Sometimes I wish every country took the belgian route of making voting an obligation. In a a somewhat related way, the spanish movement of people who were in distrust of the political reality here, founding as a party 3 months ago obtained about 7% of the votes. They do not like the situation and are trying to change it, my deepest respect for them. | ||
|
Usagi
Spain1647 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:58 sharkie wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 17:49 xM(Z wrote: i think the general idea is: - blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. Exactly. Voting blank is a statement, not voting is just being lazy. I mean here in Austria we keep having record lows in participation and what do the media and politicians blame it upon? Oh the weather was too good/bad thats why so many didn't come. Not voting is not even being considered as a protest as it shouldn't be. It took me too long to write my own response, but basically this. | ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:49 xM(Z wrote: i think the general idea is: - blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. That does not seem to be true, why would it ? | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18777 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:08 mcc wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 17:49 xM(Z wrote: i think the general idea is: - blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. That does not seem to be true, why would it ? Because that's how everyone (general public) sees nonvoters. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
| ||
|
Crushinator
Netherlands2138 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:01 Usagi wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 17:05 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 16:29 Usagi wrote: On May 27 2014 16:22 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 09:26 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 08:38 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 07:01 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 06:51 Acertos wrote: On May 27 2014 05:21 sharkie wrote: [quote] Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics I voted blank and some of my friends did too or didn't vote at all. It's just that people (like me) feel that they can't be represented by our current parties. I don't rly care if the European Parliament gets blocked all the fucking time by the right extremes perhaps they will be so annoying that it will force the EU functioning to change. Also in the next election I will most likely vote blank again and only vote against the FN if it goes to the second round. The majority of non voters / blank voters think like that, and believe me when we see how Europe is managed right now that stance isn't retarded at all. You'll vote for Sarkozy against the FN ? They already made us play that silly game. On May 27 2014 06:54 Liquid`Drone wrote: there's a big difference between non-voters and people who vote blank. In France right now, voting blank is the elegant way of not voting, and voting FN is unelegant way. that's the case in all countries where right wing parties are on the rise I just wish EVERY nonvoter would vote blank... Nonvoting gives the impression of "I dont care", voting blank (especially with majorities of 60%+) would give a huge, huge statement People have other stuff to do, why waste time voting blank, when you can just not vote. The result is the same. Very few people who do not vote, do not actually care at all. They just do not care enough to spend the time as the selection of choices is just too poor. Many people I know (university educated smart people) who voted the first few elections after fall of communism are now completely fed up and just stopped voting due to there not being anyone to vote for and they refuse to play the "lets pick lesser evil" games. And voting in this day and age doesn't even require 10 minutes lol... intelligence (coming from studying) != smart... Maybe in Austria, here it requires to at least go to the voting station or post office, both of which take much more than 10 minutes. Not even mentioning if you live on the other side of the country that you are officially registered in. But even if it was 10 minutes. 10 minutes are still not worth it, when there is no good option to pick. Anyone who puts equivalence between not voting and not being smart is neither smart nor intelligent. Not voting is degrading yourself to not take on one of the biggest and most fought over rights that people have died for. Not only it is not smart, it is disrespectful for the people who fought so you could do it. Take your damn time to go to the station, and then if there is none you like, vote blank. if that 80% instead of nonvoters, were blank votes, things would be very diferent. And if someone does not care about that right ? People fight for all sorts of useless stuff, so just because people fought over it means absolutely nothing. And can you be more sanctimonious ? I still did not see any reasonable argument why it is not smart, except for constant stating that it is so. Voting right is a social engineering tool, nothing more, nothing less, it is not some divine idea. No they would not, just more wasted time. There is no reason to go to the station since we get all the voting sheets at home and thus can determine that there is noone good to vote for. EDIT: Just to clarify, I actually consider electoral democracy pretty good idea and I vote whenever I have opportunity (except for senate, because it is stupid institution and local elections, since I do not live where I am registered and have no time to follow local politics anyway). But I also see as completely legitimate stance decision to not vote at all. If someone does not care about their right to vote towards electing their representatives they could aswell be living in a hut and paying their land owner with the crops they harvest. Not caring about elections certainly equals not caring about your daily life and the situation where you live. If you dont vote you are giving an "I dont care, do whatever you want to me and to where I live". Blank votes are counted and a high % blank voters would mean people are really worried, nonvoters can be seen as people who just dont care about their situation, which are more often than not the ignorant people, or as a fail to mobilize voters for other parties in which case they can asume, yeah, well, results wouldnt be very different. What baffles me is that people who have time to come and discuss to a forum, and are smart enough to turn on a computer and discuss in a language diferent to their own are actually in favor of nonvoting, and defending it. Sometimes I wish every country took the belgian route of making voting an obligation. In a a somewhat related way, the spanish movement of people who were in distrust of the political reality here, founding as a party 3 months ago obtained about 7% of the votes. They do not like the situation and are trying to change it, my deepest respect for them. When you are voting you are in practice doing the same, since all the choices are bad and all new movements quite quickly become the same old shit full of nonsense. Electoral democracy is just an outlet for powermongers so they solve their needs through political infighting instead of actual fighting and military and violent coups and revolts. And thus normal people can live their lives in relative peace while the sociopaths are playing their game. It is not a stable solution and people are not as powerless as my statement makes them out to be, but that power does not really come directly from voting. | ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:09 sharkie wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 18:08 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 17:49 xM(Z wrote: i think the general idea is: - blank votes are guaranteed to turn into normal/regular votes if you give the blank voters an option they like. - non voters would never turn into voters regardless of their voting options. That does not seem to be true, why would it ? Because that's how everyone (general public) sees nonvoters. General public are nonvoters quite often, what then. | ||
|
ACrow
Germany6583 Posts
On May 27 2014 16:22 mcc wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 09:26 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 08:38 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 07:01 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 06:51 Acertos wrote: On May 27 2014 05:21 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote: On May 27 2014 03:52 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote: relevant low quality polandball comic [quote] but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic. You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30. It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties. Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics I voted blank and some of my friends did too or didn't vote at all. It's just that people (like me) feel that they can't be represented by our current parties. I don't rly care if the European Parliament gets blocked all the fucking time by the right extremes perhaps they will be so annoying that it will force the EU functioning to change. Also in the next election I will most likely vote blank again and only vote against the FN if it goes to the second round. The majority of non voters / blank voters think like that, and believe me when we see how Europe is managed right now that stance isn't retarded at all. You'll vote for Sarkozy against the FN ? They already made us play that silly game. On May 27 2014 06:54 Liquid`Drone wrote: there's a big difference between non-voters and people who vote blank. In France right now, voting blank is the elegant way of not voting, and voting FN is unelegant way. that's the case in all countries where right wing parties are on the rise I just wish EVERY nonvoter would vote blank... Nonvoting gives the impression of "I dont care", voting blank (especially with majorities of 60%+) would give a huge, huge statement People have other stuff to do, why waste time voting blank, when you can just not vote. The result is the same. Very few people who do not vote, do not actually care at all. They just do not care enough to spend the time as the selection of choices is just too poor. Many people I know (university educated smart people) who voted the first few elections after fall of communism are now completely fed up and just stopped voting due to there not being anyone to vote for and they refuse to play the "lets pick lesser evil" games. And voting in this day and age doesn't even require 10 minutes lol... intelligence (coming from studying) != smart... Maybe in Austria, here it requires to at least go to the voting station or post office, both of which take much more than 10 minutes. Not even mentioning if you live on the other side of the country that you are officially registered in. But even if it was 10 minutes. 10 minutes are still not worth it, when there is no good option to pick. Anyone who puts equivalence between not voting and not being smart is neither smart nor intelligent. Back then when I was in school, my history teacher would always tell us the story about the original meaning of the word "idiot" when someone in class said something along those lines. Declining to take part in public life, such as democratic government of the polis (city state), was considered dishonorable. "Idiots" were seen as having bad judgment in public and political matters. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot Even if it is a choice between lesser evils, there is still a choice that is closer to one's preferences. If the similarities are so few that it is unbearable, there is no way around participating and joining a party and trying to change it for the better, or founding one's own. You will never get around compromising your positions, as democracy is all about finding consensus and that means compromise in a large group. Democracy can only work if society actively partakes in it. | ||
|
SiroKO
France721 Posts
On May 27 2014 17:50 Danglars wrote: So y'all on the other side of the Atlantic crushing these FN scored the highest among youth and manual workers. In other words, the true revolutionary forces are on the FN side. If anybody is going to get ousted, it's the left/righ-wing liberals, notably their apathy and disconnection from harsh reality masqueraded as tolerance. | ||
|
Cynry
810 Posts
Anyone got an explanation about that by the way ? I guess it has something to do with multiple parties working together or something, but I'd be really interested in a more educated insight. FN scored the highest among youth and manual workers. I don't know about manual workers, but you got to remember that 75% of under 35 years old didn't vote. I'm fairly sure FN wouldn't score 40/50% (I think that's what it is for these categories) if you were to "force" an opinion on 100% of them. At least I god damn hope this wouldn't be. | ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 27 2014 18:58 ACrow wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 16:22 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 09:26 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 08:38 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 07:01 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 06:51 Acertos wrote: On May 27 2014 05:21 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote: On May 27 2014 03:52 WhiteDog wrote: [quote] You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30. It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties. Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics I voted blank and some of my friends did too or didn't vote at all. It's just that people (like me) feel that they can't be represented by our current parties. I don't rly care if the European Parliament gets blocked all the fucking time by the right extremes perhaps they will be so annoying that it will force the EU functioning to change. Also in the next election I will most likely vote blank again and only vote against the FN if it goes to the second round. The majority of non voters / blank voters think like that, and believe me when we see how Europe is managed right now that stance isn't retarded at all. You'll vote for Sarkozy against the FN ? They already made us play that silly game. On May 27 2014 06:54 Liquid`Drone wrote: there's a big difference between non-voters and people who vote blank. In France right now, voting blank is the elegant way of not voting, and voting FN is unelegant way. that's the case in all countries where right wing parties are on the rise I just wish EVERY nonvoter would vote blank... Nonvoting gives the impression of "I dont care", voting blank (especially with majorities of 60%+) would give a huge, huge statement People have other stuff to do, why waste time voting blank, when you can just not vote. The result is the same. Very few people who do not vote, do not actually care at all. They just do not care enough to spend the time as the selection of choices is just too poor. Many people I know (university educated smart people) who voted the first few elections after fall of communism are now completely fed up and just stopped voting due to there not being anyone to vote for and they refuse to play the "lets pick lesser evil" games. And voting in this day and age doesn't even require 10 minutes lol... intelligence (coming from studying) != smart... Maybe in Austria, here it requires to at least go to the voting station or post office, both of which take much more than 10 minutes. Not even mentioning if you live on the other side of the country that you are officially registered in. But even if it was 10 minutes. 10 minutes are still not worth it, when there is no good option to pick. Anyone who puts equivalence between not voting and not being smart is neither smart nor intelligent. Back then when I was in school, my history teacher would always tell us the story about the original meaning of the word "idiot" when someone in class said something along those lines. Show nested quote + Declining to take part in public life, such as democratic government of the polis (city state), was considered dishonorable. "Idiots" were seen as having bad judgment in public and political matters. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot Even if it is a choice between lesser evils, there is still a choice that is closer to one's preferences. If the similarities are so few that it is unbearable, there is no way around participating and joining a party and trying to change it for the better, or founding one's own. You will never get around compromising your positions, as democracy is all about finding consensus and that means compromise in a large group. Democracy can only work if society actively partakes in it. Your history teacher seems to on the other hand satisfy the modern definition of the word. See I can also do ad-hominem name-calling. Anyway, you are another person making claims about how stupid nonvoting is without any strong reasoning beyond : "Because I think it is good, mmmokaaay". Name-calling based on other people's free choices in situation where correct choice is as unclear as here seems very pretentious. There can be argument easily made that people who vote "are having bad judgment in public and political matters". Sociology will offer you no arguments here as it is not advanced enough science. Even if I took it seriously, polis is not a modern state, Athenian democracy has nearly nothing in common with the modern one and basing something on such comparison is useless. Sometimes there is no lesser evil and all choices are equally bad based on person's preferences. The political process is hijacked by powermongers and you have enough work that is more beneficial to society than anything that can be done in politics. Why would you bother spending the remaining time politicking instead enjoying your well earned free time ? The problem is that actually reasonable, well-meaning people avoid politics as it is unproductive wasteful and toxic environment and that is unavoidable as that is where those that do not actually want to do productive things congregate. Politics in democracy is peaceful outlet for sociopaths. The goal of the rest of society is through public pressure at least direct the politicians in the somewhat correct direction. This is done not through voting , but through a threat to the political status quo itself (civil disobedience, revolutions, press, shifts in cultural values, ...., voting is quite irrelevant in that). I strongly agree that actively participating society is important for improving the situation, but I have big doubts about voting being the avenue of such change. I would say that nearly all other ways of civic activism are much more important. | ||
|
ACrow
Germany6583 Posts
On May 27 2014 19:56 mcc wrote: Show nested quote + On May 27 2014 18:58 ACrow wrote: On May 27 2014 16:22 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 09:26 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 08:38 mcc wrote: On May 27 2014 07:01 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 06:56 WhiteDog wrote: On May 27 2014 06:51 Acertos wrote: On May 27 2014 05:21 sharkie wrote: On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote: [quote] It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties. Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics I voted blank and some of my friends did too or didn't vote at all. It's just that people (like me) feel that they can't be represented by our current parties. I don't rly care if the European Parliament gets blocked all the fucking time by the right extremes perhaps they will be so annoying that it will force the EU functioning to change. Also in the next election I will most likely vote blank again and only vote against the FN if it goes to the second round. The majority of non voters / blank voters think like that, and believe me when we see how Europe is managed right now that stance isn't retarded at all. You'll vote for Sarkozy against the FN ? They already made us play that silly game. On May 27 2014 06:54 Liquid`Drone wrote: there's a big difference between non-voters and people who vote blank. In France right now, voting blank is the elegant way of not voting, and voting FN is unelegant way. that's the case in all countries where right wing parties are on the rise I just wish EVERY nonvoter would vote blank... Nonvoting gives the impression of "I dont care", voting blank (especially with majorities of 60%+) would give a huge, huge statement People have other stuff to do, why waste time voting blank, when you can just not vote. The result is the same. Very few people who do not vote, do not actually care at all. They just do not care enough to spend the time as the selection of choices is just too poor. Many people I know (university educated smart people) who voted the first few elections after fall of communism are now completely fed up and just stopped voting due to there not being anyone to vote for and they refuse to play the "lets pick lesser evil" games. And voting in this day and age doesn't even require 10 minutes lol... intelligence (coming from studying) != smart... Maybe in Austria, here it requires to at least go to the voting station or post office, both of which take much more than 10 minutes. Not even mentioning if you live on the other side of the country that you are officially registered in. But even if it was 10 minutes. 10 minutes are still not worth it, when there is no good option to pick. Anyone who puts equivalence between not voting and not being smart is neither smart nor intelligent. Back then when I was in school, my history teacher would always tell us the story about the original meaning of the word "idiot" when someone in class said something along those lines. Declining to take part in public life, such as democratic government of the polis (city state), was considered dishonorable. "Idiots" were seen as having bad judgment in public and political matters. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot Even if it is a choice between lesser evils, there is still a choice that is closer to one's preferences. If the similarities are so few that it is unbearable, there is no way around participating and joining a party and trying to change it for the better, or founding one's own. You will never get around compromising your positions, as democracy is all about finding consensus and that means compromise in a large group. Democracy can only work if society actively partakes in it. Your history teacher seems to on the other hand satisfy the modern definition of the word. See I can also do ad-hominem name-calling. Anyway, you are another person making claims about how stupid nonvoting is without any strong reasoning beyond : "Because I think it is good, mmmokaaay". Name-calling based on other people's free choices in situation where correct choice is as unclear as here seems very pretentious. There can be argument easily made that people who vote "are having bad judgment in public and political matters". Sociology will offer you no arguments here as it is not advanced enough science. Even if I took it seriously, polis is not a modern state, Athenian democracy has nearly nothing in common with the modern one and basing something on such comparison is useless. Sometimes there is no lesser evil and all choices are equally bad based on person's preferences. The political process is hijacked by powermongers and you have enough work that is more beneficial to society than anything that can be done in politics. Why would you bother spending the remaining time politicking instead enjoying your well earned free time ? The problem is that actually reasonable, well-meaning people avoid politics as it is unproductive wasteful and toxic environment and that is unavoidable as that is where those that do not actually want to do productive things congregate. Politics in democracy is peaceful outlet for sociopaths. The goal of the rest of society is through public pressure at least direct the politicians in the somewhat correct direction. This is done not through voting , but through a threat to the political status quo itself (civil disobedience, revolutions, press, shifts in cultural values, ...., voting is quite irrelevant in that). I strongly agree that actively participating society is important for improving the situation, but I have big doubts about voting being the avenue of such change. I would say that nearly all other ways of civic activism are much more important. I really didn't intend this as an adhominem, sorry if it came across as such. It was merely intended as an historical anecdote that impressed me when I was younger. Of course the polis is a whole different beast than today's democracies, and in fact wouldn't even qualify as democracy by modern standards, but wouldn't you agree, that if more actually reasonable, well-meaning people would go into politics, it would be better for all? Our society's job is to make this a more attractive opportunity and include more people. If we yield the field to nationalistic morons who only propose the easy solutions, we'll all suffer from it, if we voted or not. In Germany this happened once, I hope it won't ever happen again. (this also goes for other civic activities of course!) | ||
|
SixStrings
Germany2046 Posts
| ||
|
Skilledblob
Germany3392 Posts
On May 27 2014 20:31 SixStrings wrote: So, is there a genuine threat of England getting out of the EU in 2015? lets hope they do. | ||
| ||
|
|
Replay Cast
Monday Night Weeklies
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
OSC
Replay Cast
GSL
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
OSC
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] KCM Race Survival
RSL Revival
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
WardiTV Weekly
|
|
|