|
On May 27 2014 01:00 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote: [quote]
You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either...
National states used to have the power to devalorize their currency when they were too much in debt, the value of their currency sank and therefore the value of their debt --> they were able to repay them. With the euro this is no longer possible because we're all stuck together. You cant shrink your debt, because we all pay in euro. So the options are either save Greece financially, kick Greece out of the Euro or let civil war ensue when the government cant cover their expenses anymore. The decision was made undemocratically by the european council which is dominated by Merkel. This decision should have been made by the european parliament and thus all people of the european union.
|
On May 27 2014 00:50 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:48 mcc wrote:On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence? You are exaggerating small statistical anomalies and projecting election results into cultural changes. Are there any numbers that actually show that things are getting worse (I mean on a scale that is not statistical noise), because everything real I see points the other way. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Europe#In_the_21st_century The article claims the increase in violence, although no hard numbers are actually presented. As for antisemitism in general the increase is not even claimed as sure. They even say that it was lower in 2004 than in 1991. As for the crimes, it is possibly true, so conceded as the economic trouble and muslims would explain it, but would still like to see some actual data.
Does not say anything about LGBT issues.
|
On May 27 2014 01:07 SpikeStarcraft wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 01:00 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote: [quote] I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd.
We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either... National states used to have the power to devalorize their currency when they were too much in debt, the value of their currency sank and therefore the value of their debt --> they were able to repay them. With the euro this is no longer possible because we're all stuck together. You cant shrink your debt, because we all pay in euro. So the options are either save Greece financially, kick Greece out of the Euro or let civil war ensue when the government cant cover their expenses anymore. The decision was made undemocratically by the european council which is dominated by Merkel. This decision should have been made by the european parliament and thus all people of the european union. There are trillion of solutions. You could change the BCE to let it borrow to state, you can make it buy american bounds to devaluate, you can make a general investment plan in the entire european union to invest in southern countries like Greece or Portugal, with policies to sustain demand in excedentary countries. Seriously the europe is a big whale, it can do a ton of things.
|
On May 27 2014 01:14 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 01:07 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 01:00 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote: [quote] You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either... National states used to have the power to devalorize their currency when they were too much in debt, the value of their currency sank and therefore the value of their debt --> they were able to repay them. With the euro this is no longer possible because we're all stuck together. You cant shrink your debt, because we all pay in euro. So the options are either save Greece financially, kick Greece out of the Euro or let civil war ensue when the government cant cover their expenses anymore. The decision was made undemocratically by the european council which is dominated by Merkel. This decision should have been made by the european parliament and thus all people of the european union. There are trillion of solutions. You could change the BCE to let it borrow to state, you can make it buy american bounds to devaluate, you can make a general investment plan in the entire european union to invest in southern countries like, with policies to sustain demand in excedentary countries. Seriously the europe is a big whale, it can do a ton of things.
Like who could do that and who would have the right to do it? And where do you want to get the money from? to buy american bounds? or to make a general investment plan?
There are no democratic european institutions that could decide for all of Europe.
|
Hey guys.
On the subject of war and peace in Europe, I believe that as long as we continue to teach the history of WW1 and WW2, we may be safe of an european war for centuries to come. However, memories can be forgotten, and history repeats itself when the new generation doesn't learn from the old one. Education and mobility plays a huge role in this matter, and this should be Europe first goal: Give the youth of Europe a true european identity.
I also believe that war and peace mostly depends on our conception of "the others". A group of people will designate those they don't consider to be part of their society, and go at war with them. Until they realise they have a lot more in common that they thought, so they unite and form a bigger society. This usually happens when the two aforementioned parties find a common rival.
This is how nations were born: From small duchies to kingdoms and then republics. These European nations fought between themselves, but realised they needed to unite against new rivals: Mainly US, Russia, and now China. I think war between humans will stop only when we found extra-terrestrial rivals. When that day arrives, we will have more in common with anyone on Earth and so we probably will have some sort of peace, also that is not likely to happen in our lifetime, so we better get our shit together and build the Europe we need.
I would say that democracy is failing really hard right now. It's not about people voting for the wrong people, it's about people not going to vote and letting the most furious of us voting for the wrong people.
The European project is a beautiful thing, but we made mistakes. We focused too much on the economy and not enough on the social. Europe is about people, not coins. We should create European infrastructure, European Army, European Labour, European Healthcare, European Law before anything else. Of course, this raise the question of the diverging national interest of each members. We expanded our membership too fast. We should have begun with the original members and push the federalism system from there. Then expand membership to countries that are less rich than western Europe, but still are in our culture group. It is a difficult thing though, even sister countries like France and Germany have different national and economic interests. At least we have a lot of political common ground. (Sadly, I can't say the same about the UK though )
The Euro is a beautiful idea. I believe currency should be the prerogative of the state. Many people do, and think that it means we should go back to national currencies. I disagree. It means that the real state should be Europe.
|
On May 27 2014 01:26 SpikeStarcraft wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 01:14 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 01:07 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 01:00 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote: [quote] People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us.
We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either... National states used to have the power to devalorize their currency when they were too much in debt, the value of their currency sank and therefore the value of their debt --> they were able to repay them. With the euro this is no longer possible because we're all stuck together. You cant shrink your debt, because we all pay in euro. So the options are either save Greece financially, kick Greece out of the Euro or let civil war ensue when the government cant cover their expenses anymore. The decision was made undemocratically by the european council which is dominated by Merkel. This decision should have been made by the european parliament and thus all people of the european union. There are trillion of solutions. You could change the BCE to let it borrow to state, you can make it buy american bounds to devaluate, you can make a general investment plan in the entire european union to invest in southern countries like, with policies to sustain demand in excedentary countries. Seriously the europe is a big whale, it can do a ton of things. Like who could do that and who would have the right to do it? And where do you want to get the money from? to buy american bounds? or to make a general investment plan? There are no democratic european institutions that could decide for all of Europe. Well the commission could maybe ? But most of the things I lister are forbidden in the constitution. That's the problem imo.
The money you would print it directly at the BCE, it's called monetizing the debt, and it's forbidden for some reasons.
|
Thought you guys might like this:
|
On May 27 2014 01:27 aXa wrote:Hey guys. On the subject of war and peace in Europe, I believe that as long as we continue to teach the history of WW1 and WW2, we may be safe of an european war for centuries to come. However, memories can be forgotten, and history repeats itself when the new generation doesn't learn from the old one. Education and mobility plays a huge role in this matter, and this should be Europe first goal: Give the youth of Europe a true european identity. I also believe that war and peace mostly depends on our conception of "the others". A group of people will designate those they don't consider to be part of their society, and go at war with them. Until they realise they have a lot more in common that they thought, so they unite and form a bigger society. This usually happens when the two aforementioned parties find a common rival. This is how nations were born: From small duchies to kingdoms and then republics. These European nations fought between themselves, but realised they needed to unite against new rivals: Mainly US, Russia, and now China. I think war between humans will stop only when we found extra-terrestrial rivals. When that day arrives, we will have more in common with anyone on Earth and so we probably will have some sort of peace, also that is not likely to happen in our lifetime, so we better get our shit together and build the Europe we need. I would say that democracy is failing really hard right now. It's not about people voting for the wrong people, it's about people not going to vote and letting the most furious of us voting for the wrong people. The European project is a beautiful thing, but we made mistakes. We focused too much on the economy and not enough on the social. Europe is about people, not coins. We should create European infrastructure, European Army, European Labour, European Healthcare, European Law before anything else. Of course, this raise the question of the diverging national interest of each members. We expanded our membership too fast. We should have begun with the original members and push the federalism system from there. Then expand membership to countries that are less rich than western Europe, but still are in our culture group. It is a difficult thing though, even sister countries like France and Germany have different national and economic interests. At least we have a lot of political common ground. (Sadly, I can't say the same about the UK though  ) The Euro is a beautiful idea. I believe currency should be the prerogative of the state. Many people do, and think that it means we should go back to national currencies. I disagree. It means that the real state should be Europe. That's a beautiful piece. I hope the European peoples still have the strength and will left to continue the integration and eliminate the flaws in the EU's design (like too much influence of international corporations and banks, lack of central power for common economic decisions and so on)! Some of the results of this election make me scared, and I hope it is just a temporary setback and some of the flaws will be fixed in this legislature period to alleviate the concerns of the sceptics.
|
On May 27 2014 01:07 SpikeStarcraft wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 01:00 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote: [quote] I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd.
We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either... National states used to have the power to devalorize their currency when they were too much in debt, the value of their currency sank and therefore the value of their debt --> they were able to repay them. With the euro this is no longer possible because we're all stuck together. You cant shrink your debt, because we all pay in euro. So the options are either save Greece financially, kick Greece out of the Euro or let civil war ensue when the government cant cover their expenses anymore. The decision was made undemocratically by the european council which is dominated by Merkel. This decision should have been made by the european parliament and thus all people of the european union.
There are no decisions considered final if they wont get an approval by the governments and if i remember correct the european parliament acknowledged and welcomed the formation of the first, unelected, puppet government a member of which was a far right party. Also the major party of the current puppet government is a right party, member and fully supported by the EPP (the major political group of the european parliament) have clear connections with the far right party i mentioned above but also with the fascist Golden Dawn, that's a fact nowdays in Greece.
What im trying to say here is that as most have guessed there are no black and white situations, that the gains of fascist groups didnt came out of nowhere but largely supported by the old parties as a defence against the left and because of the prevalence of the same old political groups at the european parliament i sadly doubt there would be any differentiation to the undemocratic tactics of the council.
|
On May 27 2014 01:27 aXa wrote:Hey guys. On the subject of war and peace in Europe, I believe that as long as we continue to teach the history of WW1 and WW2, we may be safe of an european war for centuries to come. However, memories can be forgotten, and history repeats itself when the new generation doesn't learn from the old one. Education and mobility plays a huge role in this matter, and this should be Europe first goal: Give the youth of Europe a true european identity. I also believe that war and peace mostly depends on our conception of "the others". A group of people will designate those they don't consider to be part of their society, and go at war with them. Until they realise they have a lot more in common that they thought, so they unite and form a bigger society. This usually happens when the two aforementioned parties find a common rival. This is how nations were born: From small duchies to kingdoms and then republics. These European nations fought between themselves, but realised they needed to unite against new rivals: Mainly US, Russia, and now China. I think war between humans will stop only when we found extra-terrestrial rivals. When that day arrives, we will have more in common with anyone on Earth and so we probably will have some sort of peace, also that is not likely to happen in our lifetime, so we better get our shit together and build the Europe we need. I would say that democracy is failing really hard right now. It's not about people voting for the wrong people, it's about people not going to vote and letting the most furious of us voting for the wrong people. The European project is a beautiful thing, but we made mistakes. We focused too much on the economy and not enough on the social. Europe is about people, not coins. We should create European infrastructure, European Army, European Labour, European Healthcare, European Law before anything else. Of course, this raise the question of the diverging national interest of each members. We expanded our membership too fast. We should have begun with the original members and push the federalism system from there. Then expand membership to countries that are less rich than western Europe, but still are in our culture group. It is a difficult thing though, even sister countries like France and Germany have different national and economic interests. At least we have a lot of political common ground. (Sadly, I can't say the same about the UK though  ) The Euro is a beautiful idea. I believe currency should be the prerogative of the state. Many people do, and think that it means we should go back to national currencies. I disagree. It means that the real state should be Europe. If we have learned anything from history it is that we don't learn anything from history. I agree though. Europe should be more united, in everything. If the European project is going to be a success, it has to be through a political union, not a geographical one.
|
On May 27 2014 00:45 Ethi wrote: 25% Front National. What the hell, France?
I'm also shocked about the one seat for the far right party NPD in Germany because of no electoral threshold for the first time.
when do people will understand that it is not 25% of france that voted for the front national ?
you had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election
now if you take 100% of the voters, FN represents 15%-20% at his peak (source : Le monde, it is french sorry http://www.lemonde.fr/les-decodeurs/article/2014/05/26/peut-on-relativiser-le-score-du-fn_4426060_4355770.html)
FN will never lead France, it's a stillborn party , it was created by the previous socialist president to divide the right wing, and it worked extremely well (see : 2012 french presidential election)
don't worry, the European Union is safe so is Germany, you will be able to continue to do your business
|
relevant low quality polandball comic
you had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic.
|
The European Community of Defense was proposed by France and yet was not accepted by the parliament in 1954. Yeah that's sad because the EU was small at the time and we could have been more unified.
|
That seems to be pretty well investigated. Any party above DPP in that chart could end up being in the far right group, maybe with Attakas lack of direction, BNPs lack of MEPs and Golden Dawns violent methods as specific problems. But also with NDP and a few other ultra-nationalists not on the list in reserve.
DPP has been praised by Hannan and implicitly ECR (last election they discarded DPP for the front candidates racism conviction, but they claim to have found out that he no longer holds objectionable opinions.). Also the front candidate for DPP has said that he is sorry to see the strong increase among the far right in Europe (Whitewashing? Genuine? Purely tactical to signal their lack of interest in the FN-group, just like UKIP has done?). Putting the foot down in that way indicates that they are poised to join a british lead group, whether that be with UKIP, Tories or both. Since his partner in crime from last period left DPP and joined the ECR-group and he has mentioned the wish to join ECR several times in the election campaign, it seems the way the wind blows! Their only real alternative now seems to be UKIP and whatever they can collect of NIs.
|
On May 27 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote:relevant low quality polandball comicShow nested quote +you had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic. You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30.
|
Exciting times The election result can rightfully be called an earthquake. In countries like Great Britain, France and Denmark the political map has been completely redrawn. The results in many countries witness of a nationalistic, value conservative and Euro-skeptic hurricane. Albeit scaremongering, warnings of a brown wave and returning pictures of marching supporters of obscure and distasteful organizations like Golden Dawn and Jobbik, it's not the extreme but the more moderate nationalists that forcefully have strengthened their positions.
|
On May 27 2014 03:52 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote:relevant low quality polandball comicyou had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic. You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30.
It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties.
|
On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 03:52 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote:relevant low quality polandball comicyou had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic. You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30. It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties.
Most nonvoters are either totally ignorant people or people who are fed up with the current politics
|
On May 27 2014 05:13 BeaSteR wrote:Exciting times  The election result can rightfully be called an earthquake. In countries like Great Britain, France and Denmark the political map has been completely redrawn. The results in many countries witness of a nationalistic, value conservative and Euro-skeptic hurricane. Albeit scaremongering, warnings of a brown wave and returning pictures of marching supporters of obscure and distasteful organizations like Golden Dawn and Jobbik, it's not the extreme but the more moderate nationalists that forcefully have strengthened their positions.
Well I think completely redrawn is a bit of an overstatement. This is the EU elections after all. Until DPP attain the same result at the national election (which will happen at the latest next year) I'll remain hopeful.
|
On May 27 2014 05:16 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 03:52 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote:relevant low quality polandball comicyou had 57% of non voters, it means that on the 43% left you had that 25%, and that's for the european election but in the end only the votes count. I don't undestand people who don't vote. There's practically a party crazy enough for everyone. We seriously need to get the voting numbers up in Europe because right-wingers will always be able to mobilize their demographic. You'e ignorant about the subject really. The people voting for the FN are the ones that vote the least : workers at minimum wage and young people from 18 to 30. It's no wonder that the target group of the FN are young working class people, unlike the Ukip they're a national-socialist party after all. Targeting young male workers is what theses parties do. And what's wrong about my post? The FN successfully mobilized the people they wanted to vote for them, that's all I said. That's why all the other people need to get off their couch next time and vote for pro-European parties. What's wrong is that young people and workers at minimum wages are the people that vote the least.
Krugman's take on the subject :
European Green Lanterns Sitting in a room listening to EU officials reacting to the European Parliament elections — and it seems to me that they’re deep in denial. Barroso just declared that the euro had nothing to do with the crisis, that it was all failed policies at the national level; a few minutes ago he said that Europe’s real problem is a lack of political will.
This is quite amazing, in a really bad way.
Sorry, but depression-level slumps didn’t happen in Europe before the coming of the euro. And we know very well what happened: first the creation of the euro encouraged massive capital flows to southern Europe, then the money dried up — and the absence of national currencies meant that the debtor countries had to go through an extremely painful process of deflation. How anyone could deny any role for the currency …
And if there’s one thing Europe has, it’s political will. All across the southern tier, governments have dutifully imposed incredibly harsh austerity in the name of being good Europeans. What should they have done that they haven’t?
I guess the notion is that if the Greeks, or the Portuguese, or the Spaniards really, truly committed their all-powerful wills to reform and adjustment, their economies would boom despite deflation and austerity. The possibility that things are so bad — and radicals have been empowered — because the policies are fundamentally misguided just doesn’t seem to be considered. http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/05/26/european-green-lanterns/?module=BlogPost-Title&version=Blog Main&contentCollection=Opinion&action=Click&pgtype=Blogs®ion=Body
|
|
|
|
|
|