Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again.
The European Parliament election thread - Page 28
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic. Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. What EU are you talking about ? It has been sacrificed on the altar of economic competitivity and price stability. Here how Polanyi introduce his Great Transformation (on the reasons that created WW II) : The nineteenth century produced a phenomenon unheard of in the annals of Western civilization, namely, a hundred years' peace - 1815-1914. Apart from the Crimean War - a more or less colonial event - England, France, Prussia, Austria, Italy, and Russia were engaged in war among each other for altogether only eighteen months. A computation of comparable figures for the two preceding centuries gives an average of sixty to seventy years of major wars in each. But even the fiercest of nineteenth century conflagrations, the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, ended after less than a year's duration with the defeated nation being able to pay over an unprecedented sum as an indemnity without any disturbance of the currencies concerned. This triumph of a pragmatic pacifism was certainly not the result of an absence of grave causes for conflict. Almost continuous shifts in the internal and external conditions of powerful nations and great empires accompanied this irenic pageant. During the first part of the century civil wars, revolutionary and anti-revolutionary interventions were the order of the day. In Spain a hundred thousand troops under the Duc d'Angoulème stormed Cadiz; in Hungary the Magyar revolution threatened to defeat the Emperor himself in pitched battle and was ultimately suppressed only by a Russian army fighting on Hungarian soil. Armed interventions in the Germanics, in Belgium, Poland, Switzerland, Denmark, and Venice marked the omnipresence of the Holy Alliance. During the second half of the century the dynamics of progress was released; the Ottoman, Egyptian, and the Sheriffian empires broke up or were dismembered; China was forced by invading armies to open her door to the foreigner and in one gigantic haul the continent of Africa was partitioned. Simultaneously, two powers rose to world importance: the United States and Russia. National unity was achieved by Germany and Italy; Belgium, Greece, Roumania, Bulgaria, Serbia, and Hungary assumed, or reassumed, their places as sovereign states on the map of Europe. An almost incessant series of open wars accompanied the march of industrial civilization into the domains of outworn cultures or primitive peoples. Russia's military conquests in Central Asia, England's numberless Indian and African wars, France's exploits in Egypt, Algiers, Tunis, Syria, Madagascar, Indo-China, and Siam raised issues between the Powers which, as a rule, only force can arbitrate. Yet every single one of these conflicts was localized, and numberless other occasions for violent change were either met by joint action or smothered into compromise by the Great Powers. Regardless of how the methods changed, the result was the same. While in the first part of the century constitutionalism was banned and the Holy Alliance suppressed freedom in the name of peace, during the other half - and again in the name of peace - constitutions were foisted upon turbulent despots by business-minded bankers. Thus under varying forms and ever-shifting ideologies - sometimes in the name of progress and liberty, sometimes by the authority of the throne and the altar, sometimes by grace of the stock exchange and the checkbook, sometimes by corruption and bribery, sometimes by moral argument and enlightened appeal, sometimes by the broadside and the bayonet - one and the same result was attained: peace was preserved. http://uncharted.org/frownland/books/Polanyi/POLANYI KARL - The Great Transformation - v.1.0.html | ||
|
zatic
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic. Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. We are living in unprecedented peaceful times, as a German especially this should be perfectly obvious. | ||
|
Velr
Switzerland10992 Posts
Germany (or the "area" you would call Germany today) becomes super powerfull --> Goes to war with France and/or itself and loses most of its advantage because it fought mainly on homesoil. Repeat. I mean.. 30 years war, 7 years war, Napoleon, WW1, WW2 and i don't know how many "smaller" wars before and between these... Wasn't Germany, during peace times after recovery, not allways the "real" powerhouse in Europe? | ||
|
SpikeStarcraft
Germany2095 Posts
On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote: I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. Franco-Prussian War 1870/1871 France loses Elsace-Lorraine WW1 1914-1918 Treaty of Versailles WW2 1939-1945 1945-1990 Germany is split into occupied zones, neither the BRD nor the DDR are sovereign nations that could start a war because they were militarily occupied. 1990 the German reunification was only granted by the Allies (especially France) upon condition that Germany will be bound economically to the European Union and that a joint currency will be formed. History shows that an independent France and an independent Germany wage war on each other 3 times in less than 100 years on average. 24 years ago France would not have accepted the Unity of Germany if it was not for more European integration. Is that so long ago? After 4 years of Great Depression following the Wall street crash from 1929 and the failure of the traditional political parties, the right-wing extremist NSDAP gets democratically elected with 43.9% of the votes. Today the right-wing extremist have 25% in France. Some people defend them, and say they actually make some good points etc. pp. but so did the NSDAP 1933. People didnt vote for the Holocaust, they voted right wing extremist for similar reasons as today. How fast did things escalate when you let right-wing extremist form your government? campaign poster 1933 ![]() You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. | ||
|
mdb
Bulgaria4059 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:37 Velr wrote: Wasn't the Story of europe kinda: Germany (or the "area" you would call Germany today) becomes super powerfull --> Goes to war with France and/or itself and loses most of its advantage because it fought mainly on homesoil. Repeat. I mean.. 30 years war, 7 years war, Napoleon, WW1, WW2 and i don't know how many "smaller" wars before and between these... Wasn't Germany, during peace times after recovery, not allways the "real" powerhouse in Europe? The story of western europe maybe. I read somewhere that in the past Germany has tried to conquer Europe by means of war, now they`ll conquer it only by economic means. ^^ | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:37 Velr wrote: Wasn't the Story of europe kinda: Germany (or the "area" you would call Germany today) becomes super powerfull --> Goes to war with France and/or itself and loses most of its advantage because it fought mainly on homesoil. Repeat. I mean.. 30 years war, 7 years war, Napoleon, WW1, WW2 and i don't know how many "smaller" wars before and between these... Wasn't Germany, during peace times after recovery, not allways the "real" powerhouse in Europe? That's the opposite. Germany was a dwarf during Napoleon's time (and prior to it), because it was not united (the prussian were kinda the powerhouse of germany). France and England were in constant fight, and Prussia was kinda grinding (like Russia, and the US), but didn't had any colony, so they built theirselves on their industry. During this time, If I remember correctly Germany closely related to Austria, and kinda dominated by it. Some kind of equilibrium appeared after Napoleon, between France Germany and England. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
What EU are you talking about ? It has been sacrificed on the altar of economic competitivity and price stability. What has been sacrificed? I can still drive over to France, the Netherlands or any neighbor states anytime I want. Not a single one of the advantages has gone away. Tons of kids are using Erasmus Programme to travel all over Europe and it's only getting bigger. People should remind themselves of the advantages the EU offers that they take for granted. | ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:53 Nyxisto wrote: Exactly that. History has proven that it repeats itself over and over again. Only since the European Union exists we seem to have found some kind of stability. What has been sacrificed? I can still drive over to France, the Netherlands or any neighbor states anytime I want. Not a single one of the advantages has gone away. Tons of kids are using Erasmus Programme to travel all over Europe and it's only getting bigger. People should remind themselves of the advantages the EU offers that they take for granted. lol the advantage of the EU : taking your car to visit a foreign country, travel during education, and 10% average unemployment with no democratic institutions. Dream picture. | ||
|
Laurens
Belgium4558 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:55 WhiteDog wrote: lol the advantage of the EU : taking your car to visit a foreign country, travel during education, and 10% average unemployment with no democratic institutions. Dream picture. Yeah those are all the advantages, good job. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
| ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
Then show those advantages to me. Plus I don't even understand why you have to rationalize. The Europe was build, first and foremost, for political reasons, to create link and friendship between the people of europe. That project was, in my opinion, a beautiful project and the kind of project that could have brought peace. Now it's only defended as a global market and its core principle are the freedom to travel and make money. On May 26 2014 23:58 Nyxisto wrote: Well maybe you need your country divided by a wall first to understand what borders mean, and seeing how France is voting maybe you'll get the opportunity to enjoy that sooner or later What's the relation ? I see none. I'm sorry but the idea that protecting your industry is leading to hitler is ridiculous. On the other side, refusing to help people in disarray might lead to that kind of extremism. | ||
|
zatic
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote: You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. | ||
|
SpikeStarcraft
Germany2095 Posts
On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote: People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:59 WhiteDog wrote: What's the relation ? I see none. I'm sorry but the idea that protecting your industry is leading to nazism is ridiculous. On the other side, refuse to help people in disarray might lead to that kind of extremism. The thing is that this thread is full of 20 year old's who keep whining about the EU, take every single of it's advantages for granted (and free mobility is a big,big one which not many people on this planet enjoy) and want to fall back to nationalistic solutions that didn't already work anymore 50 years ago. And protectionism may not directly lead to nazism, but it leads to isolation and nationalism, none of which is very advantageous for the European community as a whole. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. No, war is unimaginable nowadays because we're so strongly tied together that war isn't a realistic option for anybody. Humans didn't simply change over the last few decades because someone turned the 'war switch' off. | ||
|
zatic
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote: Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead, and impose sanctions. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. | ||
|
mahrgell
Germany3943 Posts
TL life lessons rock! | ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic. Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. | ||
|
Roman666
Poland1440 Posts
On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote: People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. The way I see it, we ain't more peaceful. It is just that no one wants to engage in expensive wars, which cost a shit load of money. I think it is just not in interest of our pockets to wage wars. Even Polish aid to intervention in Iraq was under the belief (at least this is what the idiots that were in charge in Poland thought back then), that when the conflict is over, we will make money on lucrative contracts over there. | ||
|
Nyxisto
Germany6287 Posts
On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock! I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly be the connection? On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote: If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. | ||
| ||
![[image loading]](http://pressechronik1933.dpmu.de/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/AKiP_NSDAP_nationale-Front_1933.jpg)