|
On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things.
I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future.
|
On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly the connection? Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. That's an oversimplification really. Like WWII didn't make that possible ? Like I said, prior to WWI, Europe had a hundred year of peace. So yes we are in a period of peace, yes the europe is linked to it, but is not "responsible" of that peace, and that peace, or more exactly our unwillingness to take stands, could be responsible for wars in the years to come, because while economic ties can give peace, it can also give war.
On May 27 2014 00:19 mahrgell wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future. Yeah and what it is not true ? The europe didn't economically destroy portugal, greece ? Having foreigners paid at a third of the minimum wage is not a problem ? That's the core of the problem, if an institutions cannot help to fix those problems, it is normal that people are going to step back in their own country and fix them by themselves.
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly be the connection? Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. Like I said:
On May 26 2014 20:59 zatic wrote: Now you can argue that the EU as an institution helped to get us into the peaceful mind we are today, and I would agree. But 1) that doesn't mean we wouldn't have made it without the EU, and more importantly 2) doesn't mean we start waging wars the moment someone exits the EU.
|
On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now.
Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right?
The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategy
In Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me
|
On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
Theories of human nature and all that is quite irrelevant. The empirical data point one way, the fact that this goes contrary to some people's theories is a problem for those theories not the data.
|
On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. Germany was the only country that imposed austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way german media depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejecting the union ? And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. If you can't make a difference between economic problems and cultural / political ties between nations, then I guess there is a real problem.
|
On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly be the connection? Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. Why are war casualties and war count in general decreasing globally then ? EU might help, but it is just a small piece of the puzzle. Exact details are I think unclear as it is extremely complicated manner that is problematic to study (direct experiments are off the table). It also might be that creation of EU is more result than cause. It is quite possible that there is feedback loop.
The suspect causes are plenty : a) being interconnected through trade b) wealth - more to lose and less to gain in war c) cultural changes - the same forces that decreases violent crime and increase tolerance might decrease our warlikeness d) education e) expanding circle of sympathy ( possibly linked to c ) f) institutions g) ...
|
On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence?
That kind of comment shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe
So now Germany is 'dangerous' to Europe? That's exactly the kind of crap that starts nationalism and what he has been talking about, blaming other people, you do notice that?
For gods sake stop whining all day and fix your goddamn economy instead of pointing the finger in all directions instead of your own.
Why are war casualties and war count in general decreasing globally then I'm not convinced this is true. It's just that wars have changed a little and the definition of war became more complicated.
|
On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence? Show nested quote + That kind of comment shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe
So now Germany is 'dangerous' to Europe? That's exactly the kind of crap that starts nationalism and what he has been talking about, blaming other people, you do notice that? For gods sake stop whining all day and fix your goddamn economy instead of pointing the finger in all directions instead of your own. Do you use your brain ? Did you read what he just wrote ? "Germany is pretty peaceful but" what does it mean. I'm not pointing fingers tho, you are - first it was the lazy greeks, then it's the french who can't fix their goddam economy, etc. I'm giving fact on the economic situation, and pointing at artifacts, not people (the euro, the way the BCE act, etc.). If you're too blind to face those, then I guess it's your problem.
User was warned for this post
|
25% Front National. What the hell, France?
I'm also shocked about the one seat for the far right party NPD in Germany because of no electoral threshold for the first time.
|
On May 27 2014 00:23 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly the connection? On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. That's an oversimplification really. Like WWII didn't make that possible ? Like I said, prior to WWI, Europe had a hundred year of peace. So yes we are in a period of peace, yes the europe is linked to it, but is not "responsible" of that peace, and that peace, or more exactly our unwillingness to take stands, could be responsible for wars in the years to come, because while economic ties can give peace, it can also give war. Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:19 mahrgell wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote: [quote] So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen.
We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good.
Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future. Yeah and what it is not true ? The europe didn't economically destroy portugal, greece ? Having foreigners paid at a third of the minimum wage is not a problem ? That's the core of the problem, if an institutions cannot help to fix those problems, it is normal that people are going to step back in their own country and fix them by themselves. There was no 100 years of peace in Europe prior to WW1. The Franco - Prussian and Austro - Prussian wars are two examples.
|
On May 27 2014 00:47 RvB wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly the connection? On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. That's an oversimplification really. Like WWII didn't make that possible ? Like I said, prior to WWI, Europe had a hundred year of peace. So yes we are in a period of peace, yes the europe is linked to it, but is not "responsible" of that peace, and that peace, or more exactly our unwillingness to take stands, could be responsible for wars in the years to come, because while economic ties can give peace, it can also give war. On May 27 2014 00:19 mahrgell wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote: [quote] Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future. Yeah and what it is not true ? The europe didn't economically destroy portugal, greece ? Having foreigners paid at a third of the minimum wage is not a problem ? That's the core of the problem, if an institutions cannot help to fix those problems, it is normal that people are going to step back in their own country and fix them by themselves. There was no 100 years of peace in Europe prior to WW1. The Franco - Prussian and Austro - Prussian wars are two examples.
The nineteenth century produced a phenomenon unheard of in the annals of Western civilization, namely, a hundred years' peace - 1815-1914. Apart from the Crimean War - a more or less colonial event - England, France, Prussia, Austria, Italy, and Russia were engaged in war among each other for altogether only eighteen months. A computation of comparable figures for the two preceding centuries gives an average of sixty to seventy years of major wars in each. But even the fiercest of nineteenth century conflagrations, the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, ended after less than a year's duration with the defeated nation being able to pay over an unprecedented sum as an indemnity without any disturbance of the currencies concerned.
|
On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence? You are exaggerating small statistical anomalies and projecting election results into cultural changes. Are there any numbers that actually show that things are getting worse (I mean on a scale that is not statistical noise), because everything real I see points the other way. Nationalist parties gained few more votes mostly through protest votes not any actual cultural shift. Economic adversity has that effect. And if prolonged might cause some problematic societal changes, but currently all that doom and gloom seems like an overreaction.
I think the more telling sign is how those nationalist and even fascist parties hide their racism and homophobia in official proclamations, because they want to get the protest votes of people fed up with current political bs.
|
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
The EU also has the potential clout to enact financial reform. Obviously it's not happening at present, but potentially it's the only body that could do it. The problem is how the EU is an enabler and pusher of the worst excesses of big finance.
If the UK is out, to take my home nation as an example, will the 'City' EVER be touched? Will national politicians go against the money and regulate an industry that confers the UK a competitive advantage? Will they fuck.
You've seen this to a degree with environmental bills, left to their own devices I don't see the constituent states making as many steps forward (though there's a while to go!)
|
On May 27 2014 00:48 mcc wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence? You are exaggerating small statistical anomalies and projecting election results into cultural changes. Are there any numbers that actually show that things are getting worse (I mean on a scale that is not statistical noise), because everything real I see points the other way. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Europe#In_the_21st_century
|
On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote: [quote] So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen.
We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good.
Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe.
Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly.
Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries.
I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems.
I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean.
|
On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:I'm not convinced this is true. It's just that wars have changed a little and the definition of war became more complicated. Then just use the same definition for all periods. That is what people trying to estimate the numbers do. They do not call something a war just because it has "war" after it in history books. They count conflicts grouped by number of casualties and participants. Starting with wars of scale 0 (murder) to world wars. Of course you can question the numbers, but the general trend seems to be correct. When I get home I will consult the book I have the info from for sources if you want.
|
On May 27 2014 00:50 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:48 mcc wrote:On May 27 2014 00:37 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:28 mcc wrote: Actually in a sense we are. I am not saying that we inherently are better, but the cultural norms that we internalize are better. Just notice what happened in last 50 years. 50 years ago nobody would even be surprised by mass slaughter of animals. Today one reasonably put down giraffe causes global incident. 50 years ago even severe corporal punishments of children were thought as acceptable to a degree. Today even the thought is basically a taboo for most people. Same goes for women's rights, LGBT rights,.... . Violent crime is not so clear cut, but also that is decreasing after 1990s.
antisemitism is already on the rise again. Crimes with racist background, too. Also the parties that advocate more nationalism in Europe are also the among the groups that are again reinforcing homophobic stereotypes. You don't here a lot of gay hate coming out of pro European green parties. Coincidence? You are exaggerating small statistical anomalies and projecting election results into cultural changes. Are there any numbers that actually show that things are getting worse (I mean on a scale that is not statistical noise), because everything real I see points the other way. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism_in_Europe#In_the_21st_century
Antisemitism coming from MUSLIMS mostly...
|
On May 27 2014 00:48 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:47 RvB wrote:On May 27 2014 00:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly the connection? On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. That's an oversimplification really. Like WWII didn't make that possible ? Like I said, prior to WWI, Europe had a hundred year of peace. So yes we are in a period of peace, yes the europe is linked to it, but is not "responsible" of that peace, and that peace, or more exactly our unwillingness to take stands, could be responsible for wars in the years to come, because while economic ties can give peace, it can also give war. On May 27 2014 00:19 mahrgell wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote: [quote]
You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future. Yeah and what it is not true ? The europe didn't economically destroy portugal, greece ? Having foreigners paid at a third of the minimum wage is not a problem ? That's the core of the problem, if an institutions cannot help to fix those problems, it is normal that people are going to step back in their own country and fix them by themselves. There was no 100 years of peace in Europe prior to WW1. The Franco - Prussian and Austro - Prussian wars are two examples. Show nested quote +The nineteenth century produced a phenomenon unheard of in the annals of Western civilization, namely, a hundred years' peace - 1815-1914. Apart from the Crimean War - a more or less colonial event - England, France, Prussia, Austria, Italy, and Russia were engaged in war among each other for altogether only eighteen months. A computation of comparable figures for the two preceding centuries gives an average of sixty to seventy years of major wars in each. But even the fiercest of nineteenth century conflagrations, the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, ended after less than a year's duration with the defeated nation being able to pay over an unprecedented sum as an indemnity without any disturbance of the currencies concerned. True, but that's more because the Prussians beat both France and Austria soundly.
|
On May 27 2014 00:53 SpikeStarcraft wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:32 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:25 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote: [quote] Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. What has changed? Some people might want to sent troops to Ukraine, but we don't. In the past, shots would have been fired long ago, while today we conduct joined military exercises instead. I find it very clear that we are indeed so much better now. Its a bit similar to leaving your car doors unlocked. Opportunity makes thieves. And i assume you lock your doors right? The weird higher force you dont know about might be geopolitics. I dont make that shit up, you can read about it here http://www.stratfor.com/weekly/state-world-germanys-strategyIn Germany its pretty peaceful but 25% in France for a extreme right wing party is a red flag for me That kind of comment, if it is the dominant point of view in germany, shows how dangerous germany has become to europe tho. You were the only country that impose austerity on the entire europe, your media treated some european country like shit (like the way you all depicted greek as lazy workers who profited of the system) and now you're shocked that people are rejected the union. And the paper you link consider France (and Russia) as "hostile powers"... way to go europe. Man i had to explain that in Spain too when i went there, you can not take "Bild" seriously. They are trash and make such stupid headlines. You cant generalize and say everybody thinks like that. Thats just the media trying to sell their paper. German flags burned, Merkel with Hitler beard, you cant take stuff like that personal. both sides can find reasons to be upset. but it does not represent the majority of people and you have to be able to see through that bullshit and focus on the real problems. The paper is historically speaking about hostile powers. And most of our history it was that way undoubtedly. Like what else was Germany supposed to do? we cannot finance eurobonds without having any say where the money goes. I also disagree with the course of action for Greece. I think they should have left the euro and devalorize their currency by getting the drachme back and hope it doesnt spread to other european countries. I dont think there was an adequate way to deal with the euro crisis that would have been democratically legitimated.. because the european union in its current form is not able to deal with those problems. I mean you can financially save Greece because its a small country, but we could never finance eurobonds for italy or spain or france. And i agree that it absolutely had no democratic legiticamy how things went down with Greece and Italy. Thats why the european union has to change. The european parliament should seize more power so they can make those decisions in unison with the voters in europe and not the european comission or the european council. The politicians like Merkel pushes or drops agendas in the european council, she wouldnt dare to do on national level. But then it appears like Brussel decided about this and her hands are clean. You don't need to finance anything, it's not German's role to take France, Spain and Greece burden's, but it is not German's role to force on stupid policies on France, Spain and Greece either...
On May 27 2014 00:59 RvB wrote:Show nested quote +On May 27 2014 00:48 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:47 RvB wrote:On May 27 2014 00:23 WhiteDog wrote:On May 27 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On May 27 2014 00:15 mahrgell wrote: Today I learned, that we are all just better humans nowadays. We simply don't go to war anymore, just because 'we don't like to do it anymore'. TL life lessons rock!
I also don't get it. War is probably the strongest constant in human history. It has always been there. Magically since we have created supra-national institutions and governments on this continent they don't happen anymore. What could possibly the connection? On May 27 2014 00:17 mcc wrote:On May 26 2014 23:05 Nyxisto wrote: We're involved at wars all over the place. We have just moved the location farther away. If you're thinking we're living in peaceful times I don't know what you're smoking zatic.
Nothing has changed about humanity in the last 500 years. The fact that everyone has an Iphone now doesn't mean we've suddenly become peace loving hippies. People that think the EU is not necessary for peace on this continent seriously need to re-evaluate their perception on what times we're living in and how fast things can go bad. There's a reason the older guys in our society are way more afraid of war than we are, they've seen the shit repeating over and over again. If you look at relative casualties, we are living in most peaceful period in history. And that is worldwide, not just in Europe, so your point about wars just being moved away is plainly wrong. People did not become peaceful hippies, but world is not just black and white. Just because wars did not disappear does not mean nothing changed. If such state will last, I have no idea, but last few centuries the trend seems to be clear, and last 70 years it is not just a general trend, but clear reality. You're obviously right, it has gotten better. But my point is that the precise reason for that is that we have created institutions like the EU that make war impossible on this continent. We haven't turned into peace loving fairies that simply don't like war anymore. That's an oversimplification really. Like WWII didn't make that possible ? Like I said, prior to WWI, Europe had a hundred year of peace. So yes we are in a period of peace, yes the europe is linked to it, but is not "responsible" of that peace, and that peace, or more exactly our unwillingness to take stands, could be responsible for wars in the years to come, because while economic ties can give peace, it can also give war. On May 27 2014 00:19 mahrgell wrote:On May 27 2014 00:14 zatic wrote:On May 27 2014 00:08 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 27 2014 00:00 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 23:48 SpikeStarcraft wrote:On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote: [quote] I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd.
We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. You can say all say this is bullshit and this cant possibly ever happen again because we live in different times now. Other people say history repeats itself. Its not that bad yet, the front national isnt in the government yet, but you can prevent it. People can say lots of nonsense, doesn't make it right. We live in different times, that is why history will play out differently. That you can't learn from history is probably the only sensible thing history teaches us. We used to wage war all the time, when we were less peaceful. Now we are more peaceful, and don't anymore. It's not the EU that forces us to leave the tanks in the barracks. We have simple no desire for war. That is the main peacekeeping factor, not some institution. Afganistan, Iraq, Lybia, Balkan Why exactly are we so much better now? We dont want war, still German soldiers fight and die in Afganistan. A couple of years ago a war against Iran was a real possibility. Whats happening in Ukraine? People want to send nato troops there. I dont think blind faith in humanity is a wise thing to do. I am not blind, and I don't have any faith. I find it extremely simple to look at black and white numbers and conclude that we live in unprecedented peaceful times though. Until there is present evidence to the contrary I am not concerned of any European war happening any time soon. It's the appeal to some weird higher force driving us to arms I find more akin to faith. When I look at Europe today I see peoples not desiring of war - yet people here warn of some weird higher powers that are supposed to bring us to fight again. And even weirder, can only be tamed by the EU of all things. I see tons of people blaming their neighboring countries for their national problems. Blaming Romania, blaming Germany,, blaming the US, blaming whoever... And I see even more people voting for such people. And it is this selfvictimization that lead to the most destructive wars in this world... Because it is only the OTHERS fault, and WE have to stand up against it, because THEY are ruining our future. Yeah and what it is not true ? The europe didn't economically destroy portugal, greece ? Having foreigners paid at a third of the minimum wage is not a problem ? That's the core of the problem, if an institutions cannot help to fix those problems, it is normal that people are going to step back in their own country and fix them by themselves. There was no 100 years of peace in Europe prior to WW1. The Franco - Prussian and Austro - Prussian wars are two examples. The nineteenth century produced a phenomenon unheard of in the annals of Western civilization, namely, a hundred years' peace - 1815-1914. Apart from the Crimean War - a more or less colonial event - England, France, Prussia, Austria, Italy, and Russia were engaged in war among each other for altogether only eighteen months. A computation of comparable figures for the two preceding centuries gives an average of sixty to seventy years of major wars in each. But even the fiercest of nineteenth century conflagrations, the Franco-Prussian War of 1870-71, ended after less than a year's duration with the defeated nation being able to pay over an unprecedented sum as an indemnity without any disturbance of the currencies concerned. True, but that's more because the Prussians beat both France and Austria soundly. No it's because England and Russia were there watching.
|
|
|
|
|
|