|
On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good.
A lot of historians could confirm that between 1920 and 1930 after seeing the ravage of World War 1 people were thinking war in europe was over and that we would never live this again. Guess those people were wrong. Maybe we are too by not taking the rising of Nationalism in Europe seriously enough.
Again I will repeat myself I don't think we risk full scale war but conflicts like euromaidan crisis will be common things leading to a 'cold war' state between nearby countries all around europe leading to economical/social conflicts that will hurt us very much. Violence and riot could be common thing as military reppression.
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all.
|
On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:02 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? People are hugely underestimating how fragile peace is. I too am inclined too think "oh we're living in the internet age, war is so ridiculous, that's impossible to happen again!" After the fall of the Berlin wall people have often claimed that history has ended, but as we can see right now regarding the Ukraine conflict that's certainly not the case. I think the Ukraine conflict shows perfectly well just how peaceful we have become, and how civilized international relations are these days. Where in past times shots would have been fired long ago, these days we impose sanctions, conduct military exercises or other show of forces, and, most importantly, talk. Even when faced with an opponent who doesn't play by the rules at all, like Russia, military action is still next to unthinkable. If something like Ukraine can't bring us to go to war how in the world is it conceivable we as Europeans would start inner European wars? My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are.
But don't you think, that Russia wouldn't have been far more aggressive, if the EU-countries weren't as united as they where in this case? I think besides all economic reason this is the most good of the EU, the EU-countries are first forced to compromise with each other while otherwise there would probably some countries thinking it's more profitable for them to side with Russia.
I don't think the end of the EU would lead automatically to conflict and war but it would make the hole relations between it's countries far more fragile.
|
On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all.
If anything it's the EU (together with the US) who keeps starting conflicts in countries we should have nothing to do with...
|
On May 26 2014 21:33 iFU.pauline wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:28 klup wrote:On May 26 2014 21:24 iFU.pauline wrote: in 2005 people were already all aware of the bad effect the EU had on our country. It is no wonder they voted against it. And they will do so in the future if you give them the opportunity. In France, most of people don't want the EU, get over it. They don't want THIS EU not the EU in general. You are msitaken the institution and the people that are ACTUALLY leading. It's like saying that most people have problem with French republic whereas they have problem with UMP or PS rulling it. The EU institution as you stated has been created by bankers for bankers. Now if you decided that the EU and the bankers are 2 different things fair enough. But for me it is the same thing.
If you are saying we have to reform the institution to get rid of all the neoliberalism bullshit in it feeding bankers and rich people, I couldn't agree more. But saying we don't need a european parliament where all representative of european people can decide together of European policies , that I'm against it. European parliament is a great idea to me because if we can manage to live together and make decisions together as european brothers we would have overcome one of the greatest challenge of all time for peace and fraternity. I want my little boy to live in a place where people respect each other for their differences and that is the Europe I want to believe in. Destroying european institution right now to go back to 27 nation in a geographic zone called europe would be such a fail for humanity in general. It will show to the world even Europeans that are so close to each other can't bear to live together.
|
On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all.
You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East?In the last 30 years the West took part in more wars around this globe than you have fingers on your hands. Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point.
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd.
We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become.
|
On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. The thing that keeps the peace in Europe is not the EU, it's NATO and the nuclear weapons. No one is dumb enough to attack NATO country or a country that has nuclear weapons. The funny thing is that NATO is the reason why we have bad relations with our biggest economical partner - Russia and maybe China in the future.
|
On May 26 2014 21:43 klup wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:33 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 21:28 klup wrote:On May 26 2014 21:24 iFU.pauline wrote: in 2005 people were already all aware of the bad effect the EU had on our country. It is no wonder they voted against it. And they will do so in the future if you give them the opportunity. In France, most of people don't want the EU, get over it. They don't want THIS EU not the EU in general. You are msitaken the institution and the people that are ACTUALLY leading. It's like saying that most people have problem with French republic whereas they have problem with UMP or PS rulling it. The EU institution as you stated has been created by bankers for bankers. Now if you decided that the EU and the bankers are 2 different things fair enough. But for me it is the same thing. If you are saying we have to reform the institution to get rid of all the neoliberalism bullshit in it feeding bankers and rich people, I couldn't agree more. But saying we don't need a european parliament where all representative of european people can decide together of European policies , that I'm against it. European parliament is a great idea to me because if we can manage to live together and make decisions together as european brothers we would have overcome one of the greatest challenge of all time for peace and fraternity. I want my little boy to live in a place where people respect each other for their differences and that is the Europe I want to believe in. Destroying european institution right now to go back to 27 nation in a geographic zone called europe would be such a fail for humanity in general. It will show to the world even Europeans that are so close to each other can't bear to live together.
I couldn't agree more with your vision, but that is not why the EU has been created, actually the EU is exactly the opposite of those values. You can't reform it, it is being dictated by bankers they have control over it. They would not allow it. Therefore the best solution is to leave the circle.
|
On May 26 2014 21:56 iFU.pauline wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:43 klup wrote:On May 26 2014 21:33 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 21:28 klup wrote:On May 26 2014 21:24 iFU.pauline wrote: in 2005 people were already all aware of the bad effect the EU had on our country. It is no wonder they voted against it. And they will do so in the future if you give them the opportunity. In France, most of people don't want the EU, get over it. They don't want THIS EU not the EU in general. You are msitaken the institution and the people that are ACTUALLY leading. It's like saying that most people have problem with French republic whereas they have problem with UMP or PS rulling it. The EU institution as you stated has been created by bankers for bankers. Now if you decided that the EU and the bankers are 2 different things fair enough. But for me it is the same thing. If you are saying we have to reform the institution to get rid of all the neoliberalism bullshit in it feeding bankers and rich people, I couldn't agree more. But saying we don't need a european parliament where all representative of european people can decide together of European policies , that I'm against it. European parliament is a great idea to me because if we can manage to live together and make decisions together as european brothers we would have overcome one of the greatest challenge of all time for peace and fraternity. I want my little boy to live in a place where people respect each other for their differences and that is the Europe I want to believe in. Destroying european institution right now to go back to 27 nation in a geographic zone called europe would be such a fail for humanity in general. It will show to the world even Europeans that are so close to each other can't bear to live together. I couldn't agree more with your vision, but that is not why the EU has been created, actually the EU is exactly the opposite of those values. You can't reform it, it is being dictated by bankers they have control over it. They would not allow it. Therefore the best solution is to leave the circle.
You can reform it. That's how democracy works, right? Too bad only 44% of the people bother to vote. Apparently the other 56% don't see these issues that you mention, or don't give a crap.
|
On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become.
Like Yugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan in the last 15 years? Yes, that truly shows how peaceful we have become.
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 22:01 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:53 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:46 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. You think we are not going to war with countries outside of Europe? Have you ever heard of Africa or the Middle East? Also Norway is strongly connected with the EU and a Schengen member, and if you think that my argument is that every country that's not part of the EU is physically forced to declare war on each other I think you missed my point. I wasn't specifically replying to you specifically, but to someone who said war is "inevitable" as soon as the EU isn't anymore - something I find completely absurd. We are not going to war anymore with the rest of the world, no. Some minor exceptions, but really, compared to our history those are outright laughable. A few hundred men here, a patrol boat there. Ridiculously small instances compared to the mayhem we used to bring to our neighbors. Again that only shows how peaceful we have become. Like Yugoslavia, Iraq and Afghanistan in the last 15 years? Yes, that truly shows how peaceful we have become. Yugoslavia in the past 15 years? Anyway, it does, yes. I very much doubt you will find a period of similar tranquility in our past. And that is beside the fact that both Afghanstan and Iraq were not initiated by Euros and would not have happened without our American friends.
|
On May 26 2014 21:28 Velr wrote: The Problem is that you are a monetary union whiteout transfer-paiements.
Switzerland for itself has these, Germany for itself has these... Basically every Country/Currency-Area has this. I don't know how anyone could think it would be a good idea that make a giant currency like the Euro whiteout assuring that rich countries/areas have to support the weaker ones or some other mechanisms that would/should stop eu members from outcompeting each other... That is the problem with EU: Its structuring is made by emotional federalistic idealising politicians with a bigger emphasis on extending the cooperation as much as possible instead of rationally and gradually improving what already exists. The EURO is very close to the constitution idea.
The thought at the time (according to several of the actual politicians) was that the EURO would make europeans love eachother so much that it could be used to spearhead the inevitable changes needed for it to work in the longer terms. The constitution could be a way to make it easier to accelerate the integration. (Changing a constitution is easier than needing unanimous decissions in the council and having to suffer through referendums/reviews since some idiot countries had constitutional/ground law requirements to tend to!)
It is easier to introduce an idea and then force the consequences on reluctant populations than it is to go the slow way around and use years on introducing all the right mechanisms for something like that to work and at the end of it see the pressure from people who don't share the federal vision removing the possibility of introducing it!
|
On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all.
Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time.
Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2?
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 22:35 Asymmetric wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time. Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2? Not precisely, but certainly massively less that pre-WW2, in quantity but most of all in quality. Even our two most belligerent neighbors, France and England, are a peaceful shadow of what they were pre-war.
|
On May 26 2014 22:40 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 22:35 Asymmetric wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time. Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2? Not precisely, but certainly massively less that pre-WW2, in quantity but most of all in quality. Even our two most belligerent neighbors, France and England, are a peaceful shadow of what they were pre-war. The situation is actually pretty close to the situation post WW2 in terms of war. We, french, have been in war two times in the last two years, but we're fighting such small countries that people don't realise this.
|
On May 26 2014 22:45 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 22:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 22:35 Asymmetric wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time. Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2? Not precisely, but certainly massively less that pre-WW2, in quantity but most of all in quality. Even our two most belligerent neighbors, France and England, are a peaceful shadow of what they were pre-war. The situation is actually pretty close to the situation post WW2 in terms of war. We, french, have been in war two times in the last two years, but we're fighting such small countries that people don't realise this. Sorry but I don't call sending a bunch of aircraft to fly over Libya a war. The last actual war the EU was involved in was Afghanistan. And to a less extend Iraq but the people wanted little to do with that one.
|
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
War waged by small, professional armies in foreign lands is different to war on European soil where the civilian populace inevitably get involved.
I don't particular like the foreign policies of the likes of the UK, but I do think it's worth drawing that distinction when you're talking about the peace element of the European project.
|
On May 26 2014 22:48 Gorsameth wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 22:45 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 22:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 22:35 Asymmetric wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time. Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2? Not precisely, but certainly massively less that pre-WW2, in quantity but most of all in quality. Even our two most belligerent neighbors, France and England, are a peaceful shadow of what they were pre-war. The situation is actually pretty close to the situation post WW2 in terms of war. We, french, have been in war two times in the last two years, but we're fighting such small countries that people don't realise this. Sorry but I don't call sending a bunch of aircraft to fly over Libya a war. The last actual war the EU was involved in was Afghanistan. And to a less extend Iraq but the people wanted little to do with that one. What ? We're at war in Centreafrique and we were at war in Mali like one year ago..
On May 26 2014 22:49 Wombat_NI wrote: War waged by small, professional armies in foreign lands is different to war on European soil where the civilian populace inevitably get involved.
I don't particular like the foreign policies of the likes of the UK, but I do think it's worth drawing that distinction when you're talking about the peace element of the European project. Prior to WW I, most war were outside of western europe, in colonies and the like. People thought they had find eternal peace thanks to finance and economic partnership.
|
On May 26 2014 22:40 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 22:35 Asymmetric wrote:On May 26 2014 21:38 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 21:30 Nyxisto wrote:On May 26 2014 21:20 zatic wrote: My counterpoint is that because of European history, people hugely underestimate how peaceful we are. So because we permanently went to war for hundreds of years that truly shows how peaceful we are? We're not living in a magical time of unicorns and rainbows. If the European nations allow themselves to drift too far apart from each other again bad things will happen. We won't go to war in 5 years, or in 10 years, but what would happen in 50 or a hundred years if the European Union would dissolve is probably nothing that is going to be very good. Again you come back to that weird natural urge to kill each other we Europeans supposedly have. If the EU is what's keeping us from each other, why don't we constantly wage war on non-Europeans (like we used to)? What's keeping Norway in check? They have one of the most violent histories on the continent, and are not part of the EU - yet for some reason are maybe the most peaceful country of them all. Many of us do wage war on non-EU states all the time. Are you aware of how many military involvements Britain has been in post-WW2? Not precisely, but certainly massively less that pre-WW2, in quantity but most of all in quality. Even our two most belligerent neighbors, France and England, are a peaceful shadow of what they were pre-war.
The World has been relatively peaceful post World War 2. Despite this however the UK has been involved in post-WW2:
Indonesian National Revolution, Greek Civil War, Vietnam (Operation Masterdom), Malayan Emergency, Korean War, Suez Canal Zone Emergency, Mau Mau Uprising, Cyprus emergency, Suez Crisis, Border Campaign (Northern Ireland)), Indonesia–Malaysia confrontation, Dhofar Rebellion, Aden Emergency, The Troubles (Northern Ireland), Falklands War, Multinational Force in Lebanon, Gulf War, Bosnian War, Operation Desert Fox, Kosovo War, Sierra Leone Civil War, War in Afghanistan, Iraq War, Libyan intervention.
I would not dare suggest war remotely likely between any European state following the immediate dissolution of the EU, but it does make the nations of Europe competitors and rivals once again. Far more worryingly it divides and weakens Europe on a broad range of issues resulting in greater external influence in Europe in individual nations from the likes of Russia/USA/China.
National sovereignty in the traditional sense doesn't exist for any nations in the 21st century outside of hegemonic superpowers, like the USA or pariah states, like North Korea. Brussels gives you a vote in your future. Moscow, Washington or Beijing won't.
|
|
|
|
|
|