|
On May 26 2014 20:45 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. And they aren't as productive because of the euro. Are you saying France was less productive before the euro ? Do you know France has a higher GDP growth than Germany for the last 15 years ? It's only since the euro that Germany is catching up.
And you think switching back to the French franc will improve your situation?
|
On May 26 2014 20:47 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:46 Boonbag wrote:On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. yeah i'm not sure what makes people think France stands a fucking chance alone and it's uber competitive were outdated and slow =( You say that because you have no knowledge on currency, macroeconomic policies, and reality. That's the boring thing about people who believe they know. Being competitive from the point of view of a firm is a question of labor cost and innovation (investment), but from the point of view of a country it is the social network (that increase costs) and the currency that are in question. French don't want to lose their social network (build throughout history) while they can get their competitivity back with a change in the exchange rate of their own currency. It's like people who think Germany is like the best model for the europe, while its model is based around a commercial deficit of the rest of the euro zone.
how charming of you
please teach me self me lord
edit : i just read your second paragraph and im sorry to inform you XIXth / early XXth century economics aren't the best grounds to try to understand modern world economics x___x
and it's actually fun you accuse of me what you then proceed to display in your own next paragraph !
|
On May 26 2014 20:43 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:41 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:26 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:22 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:18 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:13 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 20:08 Gorsameth wrote:On May 26 2014 19:59 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:44 Gorsameth wrote: [quote] So you wish France to have an economy like Russia? You know there economically dead right? Their gas exports is the only reason the country still exists. You think your life is bad? Have you any idea how bad people are living in Russia?
Seriously you have no fucking clue what your talking about. I am not complaining about my life, I perfectly am aware of the convenience of living in France compare to other countries like the Philippines and Indonesia where I used to live, that doesn't mean I can't stand up to whatever I consider shit. edit : and i don't wish we have an economy like Russia, I wish we would apply some of their rules when it comes to foreign worker, that would protect us a bit more. If you think you can run a super protective economy like Russia and not get punished for it like Russia then you once again show that you don't know what your talking about. Please...Don't over exaggerate, I never talked about a "super protective economy" or what ever. I talk about a system that would protect workers. Right now THERE IS NO SUCH S SYSTEM, I put it using big letter so you guys understand once and for all. We need laws that regulate this shit, and I don't care if Russia economy isn't a example to follow, if they have at least ONE good law that can make our life better, I'll copy it. Work protection leads to endogamy, endogamy leads to eventual poverty and in the end, the war, like it or not. We should all accept that workforce movement within Europe has enriched everyone in the EU, even if the Swiss seem to think not nowadays. And again, want to protect workforce, then with the time, you will protect products, because if you buy outside, the work goes there, then, you will have to produce yousrself and wont be able to benefit from specialization in your economy, going down the gutter compared to countries that obtain them. Both right wing nationalists and far left idealists need a good damn reality check. That's some serious argument you got there. You read them were ? On a cereal box ? I base them on my economics background, and my strong belief on the benefits of the centralization os europe as a big entity. With that answered I would kindly ask you to stop landing personal attacks, I understand that is a banable ofence in this forum. It's not a personal attack, but your reasoning don't stand your own "reality check". You live a world you don't quite comprehend. What's especially shoking is that you are from Spain, a country with over 20% unemployment. Sure, it is a success. Spanish unemployment is about 24% at the moment, I know that very well, and it might even let me understand this world we live in very well, I see people losing jobs and barely scrapping by every single day. I also see people having to go and search for a life outside our borders, many not going to France or Germany like many seem to believe, South America way farther away is where many Doctors and Teachers have to go if they want to make a living. If you want to pick on my background btw, I can tell you I have lived in Belgium, and Ireland where I have both worked and studied, besides getting to known the diferent mentalities of other fellow europeans, and live with them, and I can see myself working anywhere in Europe, as much as I accept people from other countries to live and work in Spain. I actually know what it is to live in different countries. And again, if you have no ways to refute my arguments, please at least dont attack me. First you doubted my background Second you attacked me on my nationality. And you think unemployment in Spain has nothing to do with the current europe policies ? Did you know Spain was considered to be the best pupil of the european union until the crisis ? And please stop playing like I attacked anything about you, I'm just giving my point of view, like you are.
That is a good example of what I mean, the economic problems in Spain had nothing to do with the Euro or EU, it was a gigantic housing bubble which was going on way to long and finally bursted which all the negative consequenses - downfall of the building sector which was way to big and the lose of alot of money from the financing of these projects.
|
On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The fact that we have common interest ? Come on, I know you don't agree with me on this one but there is danger in a complete destruction of the EU, one I'll never want to take especially at a time when nationalistic ideas have tremendous success.
As for your rebuttal in itself, the Balkans are in peace because the EU and NATO intervene (albeit very poorly). Macedonia versus Greece is also an issue. On the long term, population flux, cultural mixity are major concerns - which are better resolved on a bigger scale than solely nations.
What's preventing major armies to bully their neighbors like Russia is doing if there is no common interest ?
|
On May 26 2014 20:51 Boonbag wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:47 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:46 Boonbag wrote:On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. yeah i'm not sure what makes people think France stands a fucking chance alone and it's uber competitive were outdated and slow =( You say that because you have no knowledge on currency, macroeconomic policies, and reality. That's the boring thing about people who believe they know. Being competitive from the point of view of a firm is a question of labor cost and innovation (investment), but from the point of view of a country it is the social network (that increase costs) and the currency that are in question. French don't want to lose their social network (build throughout history) while they can get their competitivity back with a change in the exchange rate of their own currency. It's like people who think Germany is like the best model for the europe, while its model is based around a commercial deficit of the rest of the euro zone. how charming of you please teach me self me lord I just did, you need to get out of the easy state of mind that france need to seek a positive commercial balance. If we'd thought the euro zone intelligently, we'd know that the goal was a global equilibrium of the commercial balance within the said zone - fair trade between partners - and not the current situation with an economy at a record high excedent, and all the others in deficits, and fighting against those deficit through impoverishment (mathematically lowering importations).
On May 26 2014 20:52 Myt wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:43 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:41 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:26 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:22 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:18 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 20:13 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 20:08 Gorsameth wrote:On May 26 2014 19:59 iFU.pauline wrote: [quote]
I am not complaining about my life, I perfectly am aware of the convenience of living in France compare to other countries like the Philippines and Indonesia where I used to live, that doesn't mean I can't stand up to whatever I consider shit.
edit : and i don't wish we have an economy like Russia, I wish we would apply some of their rules when it comes to foreign worker, that would protect us a bit more. If you think you can run a super protective economy like Russia and not get punished for it like Russia then you once again show that you don't know what your talking about. Please...Don't over exaggerate, I never talked about a "super protective economy" or what ever. I talk about a system that would protect workers. Right now THERE IS NO SUCH S SYSTEM, I put it using big letter so you guys understand once and for all. We need laws that regulate this shit, and I don't care if Russia economy isn't a example to follow, if they have at least ONE good law that can make our life better, I'll copy it. Work protection leads to endogamy, endogamy leads to eventual poverty and in the end, the war, like it or not. We should all accept that workforce movement within Europe has enriched everyone in the EU, even if the Swiss seem to think not nowadays. And again, want to protect workforce, then with the time, you will protect products, because if you buy outside, the work goes there, then, you will have to produce yousrself and wont be able to benefit from specialization in your economy, going down the gutter compared to countries that obtain them. Both right wing nationalists and far left idealists need a good damn reality check. That's some serious argument you got there. You read them were ? On a cereal box ? I base them on my economics background, and my strong belief on the benefits of the centralization os europe as a big entity. With that answered I would kindly ask you to stop landing personal attacks, I understand that is a banable ofence in this forum. It's not a personal attack, but your reasoning don't stand your own "reality check". You live a world you don't quite comprehend. What's especially shoking is that you are from Spain, a country with over 20% unemployment. Sure, it is a success. Spanish unemployment is about 24% at the moment, I know that very well, and it might even let me understand this world we live in very well, I see people losing jobs and barely scrapping by every single day. I also see people having to go and search for a life outside our borders, many not going to France or Germany like many seem to believe, South America way farther away is where many Doctors and Teachers have to go if they want to make a living. If you want to pick on my background btw, I can tell you I have lived in Belgium, and Ireland where I have both worked and studied, besides getting to known the diferent mentalities of other fellow europeans, and live with them, and I can see myself working anywhere in Europe, as much as I accept people from other countries to live and work in Spain. I actually know what it is to live in different countries. And again, if you have no ways to refute my arguments, please at least dont attack me. First you doubted my background Second you attacked me on my nationality. And you think unemployment in Spain has nothing to do with the current europe policies ? Did you know Spain was considered to be the best pupil of the european union until the crisis ? And please stop playing like I attacked anything about you, I'm just giving my point of view, like you are. That is a good example of what I mean, the economic problems in Spain had nothing to do with the Euro or EU, it was a gigantic housing bubble which was going on way to long and finally bursted which all the negative consequenses - downfall of the building sector which was way to big and the lose of alot of money from the financing of these projects. And who invested in the bubble ? Excedentary countries with excess money who refuse to reinvest that money in increasing their own demand. That's the idea of a desequilibrium - it is not stable and create bubble. It was the same situation in the US, and China's excedent.
|
On May 26 2014 20:43 WhiteDog wrote:
And you think unemployment in Spain has nothing to do with the current europe policies ? Did you know Spain was considered to be the best pupil of the european union until the crisis ?
And please stop playing like I attacked anything about you, I'm just giving my point of view, like you are.
Spain's unemployment problem has it seed in past national growth policies and a needed change in the structure of the economy. Also the global economic crisis hit us harder because of it
Had Europe not interfered we would have dig ourselves a bigger grave, and YES, we could have solved it if we were out of europe by printing money, devaluating the Peseta so people can buy affordable spanish goods in the grocery store. Then also try to get French, German and Brits to our beaches, and start the ever brick building madness that started this all in the first place. As a result, for many years the country would get more and more poor compared to our neighbours, and the imports would increase in a great deal, making the influx of foreign technology, which we need because we are not big technology producers more expensive, leading to a reversion in technological advance for the whole country.
And on top of all that, if the far gith would get a stronger grip of society which we dont have at the moment I am sure eventually, we would be getting terrorism problems again, (which I would ask you not to joke about since I have been very close to that actual problem and dont want to get into that one).
And I stand my ground... what you did were 2 personal attacks, and if you dont want to see them as that, I think you might have a problem.
|
On May 26 2014 20:45 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. And they aren't as productive because of the euro. Are you saying France was less productive before the euro ? Do you know France has a higher GDP growth than Germany for the last 15 years ? It's only since the euro that Germany is catching up.
But Germany had in the last 10 year also deep reforms of their social system (Agenda 2010) and till the last 2-3 years very stagnant wage development, imo that's by far more reason for it's current succsess as the Euro.
|
Zurich15366 Posts
On May 26 2014 20:52 Otolia wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The fact that we have common interest ? Come on, I know you don't agree with me on this one but there is danger in a complete destruction of the EU, one I'll never want to take especially at a time when nationalistic ideas have tremendous success. As for your rebuttal in itself, the Balkans are in peace because the EU and NATO intervene (albeit very poorly). Macedonia versus Greece is also an issue. On the long term, population flux, cultural mixity are major concerns - which are better resolved on a bigger scale than solely nations. What's preventing major armies to bully their neighbors like Russia is doing if there is no common interest ? Certainly not the EU.
My point is that unlike what many of my co-Europeans seem to think, I believe that we have become a continent of astoundingly peaceful peoples. We simply don't want to go to war anymore. Yet the common theme seems to be that we are all war crazy and only kept at bay by some magical force that for some ludicrous reason comes from the EU.
Now you can argue that the EU as an institution helped to get us into the peaceful mind we are today, and I would agree. But 1) that doesn't mean we wouldn't have made it without the EU, and more importantly 2) doesn't mean we start waging wars the moment someone exits the EU.
We have become peaceful people and there is simply no evidence that that is going to change any time soon - completely independent of an institution like the EU existing or not.
|
On May 26 2014 20:57 Myt wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:45 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. And they aren't as productive because of the euro. Are you saying France was less productive before the euro ? Do you know France has a higher GDP growth than Germany for the last 15 years ? It's only since the euro that Germany is catching up. But Germany had in the last 10 year also deep reforms of their social system (Agenda 2010) and till the last 2-3 years very stagnant wage development, imo that's by far more reason for it's current succsess as the Euro. Their reform was made possible because of France and Spain's demand. At that time, Germany had an all time low inflation, while we were in inflationary moment, pushing to increase our demand and buying german goods. We helped you. Now do you know what would happen for Germany if they had their own currency right now ? They would buy a lot of US dollars just to prevent their money from adjusting higher and higher, like China is doing. The euro prevent that.
Here's some fact about current account in the euro zone :
![[image loading]](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-GwshwEiooT0/U4KJMbhUdZI/AAAAAAAAAHs/JFFDfAYlWcU/w426-h264/ssss.jpg) Now tell me the problem is France.
|
On May 26 2014 20:59 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:52 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The fact that we have common interest ? Come on, I know you don't agree with me on this one but there is danger in a complete destruction of the EU, one I'll never want to take especially at a time when nationalistic ideas have tremendous success. As for your rebuttal in itself, the Balkans are in peace because the EU and NATO intervene (albeit very poorly). Macedonia versus Greece is also an issue. On the long term, population flux, cultural mixity are major concerns - which are better resolved on a bigger scale than solely nations. What's preventing major armies to bully their neighbors like Russia is doing if there is no common interest ? Certainly not the EU. My point is that unlike what many of my co-Europeans seem to think, I believe that we have become a continent of astoundingly peaceful peoples. We simply don't want to go to war anymore. Yet the common theme seems to be that we are all war crazy and only kept at bay by some magical force that for some ludicrous reason comes from the EU. Now you can argue that the EU as an institution helped to get us into the peaceful mind we are today, and I would agree. But 1) that doesn't mean we wouldn't have made it without the EU, and more importantly 2) doesn't mean we start waging wars the moment someone exits the EU. We have become peaceful people and there is simply no evidence that that is going to change any time soon - completely independent of an institution like the EU existing or not.
so peaceful we harbor a nice rack of nuke warheads in our backyard right...
|
On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring?
The EU has deeply connected our economies which naturally means that war would result in a catastrophic economical situation. the more you're connected the harder it is to bash each others head in naturally. And actually yes, without exaggeration this continent has been mostly in a permanent state of war before 1950. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe)
People are hugely underestimating how fragile peace is. I too am inclined too think "oh we're living in the internet age, war is so ridiculous, that's impossible to happen again!" After the fall of the Berlin wall people have often claimed that history has ended, but as we can see right now regarding the Ukraine conflict that's certainly not the case.
|
On May 26 2014 20:56 Usagi wrote:
Spain's unemployment problem has it seed in past national growth policies and a needed change in the structure of the economy. Also the global economic crisis hit us harder because of it.
Had Europe not interfered we would have dig ourselves a bigger grave, and YES, we could have solved it if we were out of europe by printing money, devaluating the Peseta so people can buy affordable spanish goods in the grocery store. Then also try to get French, German and Brits to our beaches, and start the ever brick building madness that started this all in the first place. As a result, for many years the country would get more and more poor compared to our neighbours, and the imports would increase in a great deal, making the influx of foreign technology, which we need because we are not big technology producers more expensive, leading to a reversion in technological advance for the whole country.
And on top of all that, if the far gith would get a stronger grip of society which we dont have at the moment I am sure eventually, we would be getting terrorism problems again, (which I would ask you not to joke about since I have been very close to that actual problem and dont want to get into that one).
And I stand my ground... what you did were 2 personal attacks, and if you dont want to see them as that, I think you might have a problem.
I understand the house bubble market and it might not be related to the EU, but you know what I am not sure if overtime what the EU and IMF lend to your country will benefit you when you have to pay it back. Iceland understood that, and they said fuck off to the IMF. And if your country would have said the same, it would be a matter of time before things get better. Now at the first problem we have to kneel to get money from the European central bank, we can't control our money, we can't control our politics, Brussels decides for us. Because of that, we are not capable of sustaining ourselves and that is not normal, each country should be able to stand for themselves if shit goes wrong. Now if there is one down, everybody is down, I don't call that improvement. We are weaker than before.
|
On May 26 2014 20:59 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:52 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The fact that we have common interest ? Come on, I know you don't agree with me on this one but there is danger in a complete destruction of the EU, one I'll never want to take especially at a time when nationalistic ideas have tremendous success. As for your rebuttal in itself, the Balkans are in peace because the EU and NATO intervene (albeit very poorly). Macedonia versus Greece is also an issue. On the long term, population flux, cultural mixity are major concerns - which are better resolved on a bigger scale than solely nations. What's preventing major armies to bully their neighbors like Russia is doing if there is no common interest ? Certainly not the EU. My point is that unlike what many of my co-Europeans seem to think, I believe that we have become a continent of astoundingly peaceful peoples. We simply don't want to go to war anymore. Yet the common theme seems to be that we are all war crazy and only kept at bay by some magical force that for some ludicrous reason comes from the EU. Now you can argue that the EU as an institution helped to get us into the peaceful mind we are today, and I would agree. But 1) that doesn't mean we wouldn't have made it without the EU, and more importantly 2) doesn't mean we start waging wars the moment someone exits the EU. We have become peaceful people and there is simply no evidence that that is going to change any time soon - completely independent of an institution like the EU existing or not.
Have you even tried to read Whitedogs post? In every second line he is blaming Europe, Germany, Romania and whoever for their national problems. If more and more people adopt this rhetoric and thinking it will create tensions. And tensions lead to conflicts. No one is talking about putting tanks at your border right away. But still... those conflicts will arise, if more and more nationalistic ideas are voted to power, and longterm they will escalate.
|
On May 26 2014 21:02 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The EU has deeply connected our economies which naturally means that war would result in a catastrophic economical situation. the more you're connected the harder it is to bash each others head in naturally. And actually yes, without exaggeration this continent has been mostly in a permanent state of war before 1950. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_conflicts_in_Europe) People are hugely underestimating how fragile peace is. I'm too are inclined too think "oh we're living in the internet age, war is so ridiculous, that's impossible to happen again!" After the fall of the Berlin wall people have often claimed that history has ended, but as we can see right now regarding the Ukraine conflict that's certainly not the case. Prior to WWII, the first economic partner of France was Germany. We need to stop making that easy thinking like economic partnership prevent war. There is a brilliant book on the subject : The Great transformation by Polanyi.
On May 26 2014 21:05 mahrgell wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:59 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:52 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 20:40 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 20:28 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 19:14 zatic wrote:On May 26 2014 19:10 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 19:05 Otolia wrote:On May 26 2014 18:52 iFU.pauline wrote: It's not even about frustration, people are disappointed with Europe, FN are they only one talking about it. Who else am I gonna vote if I want to be out of this EU rip off? Le front republicain is a joke and those people aren't less racist or have more black friends than FN politicians. They are all the same on that lvl. Valls and his buddies.
I am pretty sure that if you do a referendum today about getting out of the EU, it will be a massive YES, and those faggots would never have the balls to do it because they know and their job is just to defend European central bank interest. So prepare for more FN, and at the end fuck it, that will bring more change than what we have atm.
I can't believe some people argue that our lives were better than 15 yr ago, that is not true, you can't buy shit anymore with 20 euro at the grocery. That is a massive inflation caused by the EU. And if that continues we will be 50 countries in the EU with banks loaning to countries billion and billion so they can adjust to our economy somehow, and we will live happy and ever all united in debt working our ass for central banks. Thanks EU. If we ever get out of EU, there will be war again. That's inevitable. But don't worry, on that day, I'll come to your house and deliver cheap groceries, so that you can enjoy watching everyone you love being destroyed by war. But but ... cheap groceries right ?! RIGHT !? Tell me why it will bring war in Europe please... Seriously that is one of the dumbest misconceptions out there: Exit from the EU = war. I really don't get how that can be plausible, never mind inevitable to anyone. Because we have been having wars for decades before the EU, nationalism is on the rise, independent activism is on the rise. Does that sound like a powder keg ? Good because that's one. EDIT: And I'm not saying it will happen immediately after, I'm saying it will happen eventually. NATO without the EU or a common enemy is vain. So either civil war, interstate wars, or North-South wars. So fascist Spain, militaristic Greece, England, and all the newer EU countries, not to mention Switzerland and Norway, were/are in a constant state of war? Why didn't we see this strange urge to kill each other in all the European countries that were / are not part of the EU? Again, what specifically does the EU do to keep us from warring? The fact that we have common interest ? Come on, I know you don't agree with me on this one but there is danger in a complete destruction of the EU, one I'll never want to take especially at a time when nationalistic ideas have tremendous success. As for your rebuttal in itself, the Balkans are in peace because the EU and NATO intervene (albeit very poorly). Macedonia versus Greece is also an issue. On the long term, population flux, cultural mixity are major concerns - which are better resolved on a bigger scale than solely nations. What's preventing major armies to bully their neighbors like Russia is doing if there is no common interest ? Certainly not the EU. My point is that unlike what many of my co-Europeans seem to think, I believe that we have become a continent of astoundingly peaceful peoples. We simply don't want to go to war anymore. Yet the common theme seems to be that we are all war crazy and only kept at bay by some magical force that for some ludicrous reason comes from the EU. Now you can argue that the EU as an institution helped to get us into the peaceful mind we are today, and I would agree. But 1) that doesn't mean we wouldn't have made it without the EU, and more importantly 2) doesn't mean we start waging wars the moment someone exits the EU. We have become peaceful people and there is simply no evidence that that is going to change any time soon - completely independent of an institution like the EU existing or not. Have you even tried to read Whitedogs post? In every second line he is blaming Europe, Germany, Romania and whoever for their national problems. If more and more people adopt this rhetoric and thinking it will create tensions. And tensions lead to conflicts. No one is talking about putting tanks at your border right away. But still... those conflicts will arise, if more and more nationalistic ideas are voted to power, and longterm they will escalate. I'm just pointing out facts. I'm not saying there are no problem at the french level, but they are not economic. In fact, no countries have economic problems, the problem is our interactions, and those are supposed to be regulated by the european commission, who don't do its job. Closing your eyes before Greece's current situation, before the sorry state of the union, is not the best way to help it get back on its feet.
|
On May 26 2014 21:04 iFU.pauline wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:56 Usagi wrote:
Spain's unemployment problem has it seed in past national growth policies and a needed change in the structure of the economy. Also the global economic crisis hit us harder because of it.
Had Europe not interfered we would have dig ourselves a bigger grave, and YES, we could have solved it if we were out of europe by printing money, devaluating the Peseta so people can buy affordable spanish goods in the grocery store. Then also try to get French, German and Brits to our beaches, and start the ever brick building madness that started this all in the first place. As a result, for many years the country would get more and more poor compared to our neighbours, and the imports would increase in a great deal, making the influx of foreign technology, which we need because we are not big technology producers more expensive, leading to a reversion in technological advance for the whole country.
And on top of all that, if the far gith would get a stronger grip of society which we dont have at the moment I am sure eventually, we would be getting terrorism problems again, (which I would ask you not to joke about since I have been very close to that actual problem and dont want to get into that one).
And I stand my ground... what you did were 2 personal attacks, and if you dont want to see them as that, I think you might have a problem. I understand the house bubble market and it might not be related to the EU, but you know what I am not sure if overtime what the EU and IMF lend to your country will benefit you when you have to pay it back. Iceland understood that, and they said fuck off to the IMF. And if your country would have said the same, it would be a matter of time before things get better. Now at the first problem we have to kneel to get money from the European central bank, we can't control our money, we can't control our politics, Brussels decides for us. Because of that, we are not capable of sustaining ourselves and that is not normal, each country should be able to stand for themselves if shit goes wrong. Now if there is one down, everybody is down, I don't call that improvement. We are weaker than before.
Do you know what is the difference? I dont think of Brussels as THEM, I think of Brussels as US, I consider myself part of it.
|
On May 26 2014 20:59 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:57 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:45 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. And they aren't as productive because of the euro. Are you saying France was less productive before the euro ? Do you know France has a higher GDP growth than Germany for the last 15 years ? It's only since the euro that Germany is catching up. But Germany had in the last 10 year also deep reforms of their social system (Agenda 2010) and till the last 2-3 years very stagnant wage development, imo that's by far more reason for it's current succsess as the Euro. Their reform was made possible because of France and Spain's demand. At that time, Germany had an all time low inflation, while we were in inflationary moment, pushing to increase our demand and buying german goods. We helped you. Now do you know what would happen for Germany if they had their own currency right now ? They would buy a lot of US dollars just to prevent their money from adjusting higher and higher, like China is doing. The euro prevent that. Here's some fact about current account in the euro zone : ![[image loading]](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-GwshwEiooT0/U4KJMbhUdZI/AAAAAAAAAHs/JFFDfAYlWcU/w426-h264/ssss.jpg) Now tell me the problem is France.
I don' say the problem is France or that Germany didn't profited from the EU, im just saying alot from the french problems comes from within France and not alone from EU/Euro, else France would have been able to profit in a similar way.
|
Basically all people here have problem with free market and uncontrolled liberalism. You can fight against that for sure, just don't vote for people using that argument among others that are deeply racist and xenophobe.
Mr Jean Marie Lepen saying Ebola virus is a good thing to get rid of black African people is just insane and should be a reminder of what these people trully are.
The problem with Europe is that it has been ruled by right wing liberal parties that have imposed free market everywhere even where it is not economically viable. Now we are reaping the seeds of that disastrous policy and the consequence of that is we now fear/hate the Romanian next door living in his shitty caravan whereas we should rise pitchfork and go to attack insanely rich people.
Europe will remain in a disastrous state because guess what, even if there was a lot of Nationalist , the big winners are the friends of banks and rich : PPE with their leader Jean Claude Juncker which is just the apostle of neo-liberalism. Even if I hate that very much I would never vote for people wishing black people dying from Ebola virus or want to oppress other people , that is just not me.
|
On May 26 2014 21:06 Usagi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:04 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 20:56 Usagi wrote:
Spain's unemployment problem has it seed in past national growth policies and a needed change in the structure of the economy. Also the global economic crisis hit us harder because of it.
Had Europe not interfered we would have dig ourselves a bigger grave, and YES, we could have solved it if we were out of europe by printing money, devaluating the Peseta so people can buy affordable spanish goods in the grocery store. Then also try to get French, German and Brits to our beaches, and start the ever brick building madness that started this all in the first place. As a result, for many years the country would get more and more poor compared to our neighbours, and the imports would increase in a great deal, making the influx of foreign technology, which we need because we are not big technology producers more expensive, leading to a reversion in technological advance for the whole country.
And on top of all that, if the far gith would get a stronger grip of society which we dont have at the moment I am sure eventually, we would be getting terrorism problems again, (which I would ask you not to joke about since I have been very close to that actual problem and dont want to get into that one).
And I stand my ground... what you did were 2 personal attacks, and if you dont want to see them as that, I think you might have a problem. I understand the house bubble market and it might not be related to the EU, but you know what I am not sure if overtime what the EU and IMF lend to your country will benefit you when you have to pay it back. Iceland understood that, and they said fuck off to the IMF. And if your country would have said the same, it would be a matter of time before things get better. Now at the first problem we have to kneel to get money from the European central bank, we can't control our money, we can't control our politics, Brussels decides for us. Because of that, we are not capable of sustaining ourselves and that is not normal, each country should be able to stand for themselves if shit goes wrong. Now if there is one down, everybody is down, I don't call that improvement. We are weaker than before. Do you know what is the difference? I dont think of Brussels as THEM, I think of Brussels as US, I consider myself part of it.
I am with them too, we French have been forced into, they made a referendum about getting in the EU and we said NO, but they don't care about democracy, they still did it. For the better good, according to them.
You know, a majority said no, and you still do it, that is not working for the people. It's working from somebody else interest. You are with them? They aren't with you.
|
On May 26 2014 21:07 Myt wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 20:59 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:57 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:45 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:44 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:35 WhiteDog wrote:On May 26 2014 20:34 Myt wrote:On May 26 2014 20:04 Spaylz wrote: Smart countries prioritize their citizens over immigrants when it comes to work (i.e. an employer has to justify the fact that this particular job can't be performed by a citizen before giving it to an immigrant). But in France, that idea is associated with racism by the masses. Idk, but in my opinion smart countries attack their deeper economic problem instead of blaming them on others. You may even be right that immigrants increase these problems but getting rid of them would still not be a solution. What bothers me the most on this hole discussion is that populists form left and right are always way to simplistic. There is no easy solution for such complex problems like the economic welfare of a hole continent or even a single country. In Germany we had late 90th/early 2000 a big discussion about retirement pensions as the German system wasn't sustainable anymore. A lot of people blamed it on German reunification and immigrants from Eastern Europe, completely disregarding the fact that the system couldn't work anyways anymore because of the demographic development (smaller workforce compared to more older people). I think this is a similar discussion, looking for someone to blame (EU, banks, immigrants or whatever) instead of attacking the deeper problems, the fact that many economic structures aren’t competitive anymore in a globalized market. And what's the french deeper economic problem please ? I'll tell you, the euro. No, the Euro makes the problems just more obvious and may even increase them a little but the deeper problem behind is that many of your industries aren't as productive as in other countries. Getting rid of the Euro wouldn't be a solution for that. And they aren't as productive because of the euro. Are you saying France was less productive before the euro ? Do you know France has a higher GDP growth than Germany for the last 15 years ? It's only since the euro that Germany is catching up. But Germany had in the last 10 year also deep reforms of their social system (Agenda 2010) and till the last 2-3 years very stagnant wage development, imo that's by far more reason for it's current succsess as the Euro. Their reform was made possible because of France and Spain's demand. At that time, Germany had an all time low inflation, while we were in inflationary moment, pushing to increase our demand and buying german goods. We helped you. Now do you know what would happen for Germany if they had their own currency right now ? They would buy a lot of US dollars just to prevent their money from adjusting higher and higher, like China is doing. The euro prevent that. Here's some fact about current account in the euro zone : ![[image loading]](https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-GwshwEiooT0/U4KJMbhUdZI/AAAAAAAAAHs/JFFDfAYlWcU/w426-h264/ssss.jpg) Now tell me the problem is France. I don' say the problem is France or that Germany didn't profited from the EU, im just saying alot from the french problems comes from within France and not alone from EU/Euro, else France would have been able to profit in a similar way. France have huge problems. Our problems are way deeper than simple economic problem, we have no democracy, two party with 95 % of the deputee seats and only 30 % (at best) of the entire electorate voting for them, no economic policies, a structural unemployment at 7 to 10 % since 40 years. But we can't get out of this mess without a change in policy, and those policies are at the european level.
Also we can't profit from the EU because we are not the same... Germany produce specific goods, with high out of price competitivity. We french are producing for more competitive market, where labor costs and innovations are core. The euro just don't benefit our economic structure. Even our economic system are really different, the role of banks, the place of middle weight firms, the way our election works, our mentality, etc.
|
On May 26 2014 21:08 iFU.pauline wrote:Show nested quote +On May 26 2014 21:06 Usagi wrote:On May 26 2014 21:04 iFU.pauline wrote:On May 26 2014 20:56 Usagi wrote:
Spain's unemployment problem has it seed in past national growth policies and a needed change in the structure of the economy. Also the global economic crisis hit us harder because of it.
Had Europe not interfered we would have dig ourselves a bigger grave, and YES, we could have solved it if we were out of europe by printing money, devaluating the Peseta so people can buy affordable spanish goods in the grocery store. Then also try to get French, German and Brits to our beaches, and start the ever brick building madness that started this all in the first place. As a result, for many years the country would get more and more poor compared to our neighbours, and the imports would increase in a great deal, making the influx of foreign technology, which we need because we are not big technology producers more expensive, leading to a reversion in technological advance for the whole country.
And on top of all that, if the far gith would get a stronger grip of society which we dont have at the moment I am sure eventually, we would be getting terrorism problems again, (which I would ask you not to joke about since I have been very close to that actual problem and dont want to get into that one).
And I stand my ground... what you did were 2 personal attacks, and if you dont want to see them as that, I think you might have a problem. I understand the house bubble market and it might not be related to the EU, but you know what I am not sure if overtime what the EU and IMF lend to your country will benefit you when you have to pay it back. Iceland understood that, and they said fuck off to the IMF. And if your country would have said the same, it would be a matter of time before things get better. Now at the first problem we have to kneel to get money from the European central bank, we can't control our money, we can't control our politics, Brussels decides for us. Because of that, we are not capable of sustaining ourselves and that is not normal, each country should be able to stand for themselves if shit goes wrong. Now if there is one down, everybody is down, I don't call that improvement. We are weaker than before. Do you know what is the difference? I dont think of Brussels as THEM, I think of Brussels as US, I consider myself part of it. I am with them too, we French have been forced into, they made a referendum about getting in the EU and we said NO, but they don't care about democracy, they still did it. For the better good, according to them. You know, a majority said no, and you still do it, that is not working for the people. It's working from somebody else interest. You are with them? They aren't with you.
Could you stop posting blatant lies? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Maastricht_Treaty_referendum,_1992 You may not like it, but 51% is a majority for YES...
|
|
|
|
|
|