|
On April 30 2014 23:40 WhiteDog wrote: Lol we work more than germans. Germans have 20% of their work force working part time. Greek work the most in europe, look where they are. But that's basically just because we have a lot of part time work which drags the average working hours down. Not that I necessarily think that part time work is a good thing, but arguing that the Greeks work the most in Europe with unemployment numbers beyond good and evil is just blatant misinterpretation of numbers. Also less labour market regulations wouldn't hurt most countries in Europe. Keep in mind that less regulation does not equal eroding the social net. Denmark's(although a small country for comparison) idea of 'flexicurity' is working very well for them.
People are blaming Germany because while the rest of Europe is suffering they are doing moderately well because a weaker euro allows them to export more goods.
Keep in mind that exporting less goods to those countries that technically can't afford them means nothing else than lowering the living standard in those countries. In a two currency system between the North and South for example, the southern countries couldn't keep up buying as much stuff from us as they are doing now.
|
On April 30 2014 23:42 RvB wrote: Does anyone know why it's only possible to vote for your national parties and not parties from a different country? They're European elections after all.
You can vote for anyone so long as they stand candidates in your region. There were a few pan-European parties in the last couple of elections, but no-one voted for them and it cost a fortune when they lost their deposits and party registration fees in every country. Now they don't stand candidates any more.
|
On May 01 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On April 30 2014 23:40 WhiteDog wrote: Lol we work more than germans. Germans have 20% of their work force working part time. Greek work the most in europe, look where they are. But that's basically just because we have a lot of part time work which drags the average working hours down. Not that I necessarily think that part time work is a good thing, but arguing that the Greeks work the most in Europe with unemployment numbers beyond good and evil is just blatant misinterpretation of numbers. Also less labour market regulations wouldn't hurt most countries in Europe. Keep in mind that less regulation does not equal eroding the social net. Denmark's(although a small country for comparison) idea of 'flexicurity' is working very well for them. That is exactly what I said. Greek were working more than everybody else prior to the crisis, that's just how it is. It is a fact. Saying "lolololol France 35 hour" is okay but stating the fact that the country who had its economy destroyed over the last 5 years work on average more than anyone else in europe is wrong ? Do you know that the place with the highest living expectancy in europe is an island (Ikaria Island) in Greece where they basically work day and night, but alone with no boss and for themselves ?
Less labor market regulations ? What are you talking about ? Flexisecurity ? We have flexibilize our market, in fact we have been since 10 years now, with no effect on employment. Market is so flexibilized right now that even boss say they don't need any more reform. That is the kind of argument the OECD had like ten or so years ago, trying to explain high unemployment in europe in comparaison to the US. Now they don't fucking understand what is going on anymore - because you know economist made them believe Phillips curve was wrong, despite it being the result of empirical data.
|
On May 01 2014 00:20 WhiteDog wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On April 30 2014 23:40 WhiteDog wrote: Lol we work more than germans. Germans have 20% of their work force working part time. Greek work the most in europe, look where they are. But that's basically just because we have a lot of part time work which drags the average working hours down. Not that I necessarily think that part time work is a good thing, but arguing that the Greeks work the most in Europe with unemployment numbers beyond good and evil is just blatant misinterpretation of numbers. Also less labour market regulations wouldn't hurt most countries in Europe. Keep in mind that less regulation does not equal eroding the social net. Denmark's(although a small country for comparison) idea of 'flexicurity' is working very well for them. That is exactly what I said. Greek were working more than everybody else prior to the crisis, that's just how it is. It is a fact. Saying "lolololol France 35 hour" is okay but stating the fact that the country who had its economy destroyed over the last 5 years work on average more than anyone else in europe is wrong ? Do you know that the place with the highest living expectancy in europe is an island (Ikaria Island) in Greece where they basically work day and night, but alone with no boss and for themselves ? Less labor market regulations ? What are you talking about ? Flexisecurity ? We have flexibilize our market, in fact we have been since 10 years now, with no effect on employment. Market is so flexibilized right now that even boss say they don't need any more reform. That is the kind of argument the OECD had like ten or so years ago, trying to explain high unemployment in europe in comparaison to the US. Now they don't fucking understand what is going on anymore - because you know economist made them believe Phillips curve was wrong, despite it being the result of empirical data.
Well especially for young people it seems hard to get a job in France which shows in the 25% unemployment rate among France's youth. France still has harsh regulations on part-time work (Luxembourg being the only country having stronger regulations in place if I'm not mistaken) coupled with very high minimum wages isn't exactly what i would call 'flexible'. Also France seems to have a strong tradition of employees and employers bashing each others head in, and the strong involvement of France's government in economic decisions, both from the right and left (for example the recent GE/Alstom/Siemens deal) seems a little 'out of time'.
Regarding the Phillips curve, that's the short-term relationship between inflation and unemployment right? But that's monetary policy, what does it have to do with the topic of labour markets?
|
On May 01 2014 00:09 Gorsameth wrote:Show nested quote +On April 30 2014 23:33 Velr wrote: This blame game on Germany is getting very old.
The main Problem is that the other big european nations are a joke atm. GB is playing princess on the Island and doesn't really want to be part of this whole thing anyway. Spain is basically grounded. Italy is basically grounded. France is struggling hard.
Even if you want to blame the Problems many EU countries have on german policies. As far as i know the EU was created by all your countries together, it wasn't Germany dictating everyone how the Euro and all this stuff should be implemented. The thing is… Germany was actually ready for it while many other EU-countries obviously weren't.
I mean… Simplified you can sum it up like this: Italy is just systematically corrupt and its whole mid/south-area is underdeveloped. GB basically outsourced all its "traditional" industry and now is basically a giant bank. France has the hilarious 35h workweek and constant strikes... Now your telling me no one predicted that Germany would outcompete you?
Sad fact is: Germany (+"the North") is leading atm because no one else is capable of doing so.
Btw: I fundamentally disagree with many policies Germany adapted in the 00's and I see how they accelerated the problems, but they were answers to the big problems germany faced during the 90ies (+the whole reunion) and kinda worked out. These weren’t exactly popular solutions, i wouldn’t even call them « good » solutions but they kinda worked... Now blaming Germany for (being forced too) fixing their shit in advance and not still being « crippled » by the reunion cost is just stupid.
People are blaming Germany because they are the ones pushing hard for austerity which hadn't worked and if anything has only further and further deepened and lengthen the economic crisis. People are blaming Germany because while the rest of Europe is suffering they are doing moderately well because a weaker euro allows them to export more goods. The Euro isn't weak enough is the issue. Germany and London have a great deal of savings piled up, which means they want inflation as low as possible. Germans can handle the low inflation/deflation quite well since their labor laws (up until now) didn't require a minimum wage, and further, their employment was essentially guaranteed by the German government. This allows for comparatively cheap products to come out of Germany, especially since the recession wiped out cheap industry in all competing market places.
If inflation took hold in Germany (which is what should happen to help the other economies), the German economy would likely "overheat" and we'd see wages rise, making the savings of the Germans not as strong. This inflation would help reduce the debt burden on the periphery, and drive demand for German goods high enough that a price difference could be noticeable between their products and products from Greece, Italy, Spain, etc. German people would need raises to purchase German products, or they would buy cheaper products from other EU countries. At some point, the inflation would be high enough to give breathing room to those periphery countries and they could finally grow and catch up, which would also help ease the inflation naturally without raising rates.
I should add that the Germans don't want to do this for 2 reasons: 1) Reminders of hyper-inflation long ago - Weimar in the 1930s is still a lesson the administration leans on heavily. 2) Rent-seeking - Germans are in a great position compared to their neighbors, they'd rather keep it and expand upon it rather than help out the neighbors at the risk of losing their strong #1 spot.
|
On May 01 2014 00:49 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 00:20 WhiteDog wrote:On May 01 2014 00:18 Nyxisto wrote:On April 30 2014 23:40 WhiteDog wrote: Lol we work more than germans. Germans have 20% of their work force working part time. Greek work the most in europe, look where they are. But that's basically just because we have a lot of part time work which drags the average working hours down. Not that I necessarily think that part time work is a good thing, but arguing that the Greeks work the most in Europe with unemployment numbers beyond good and evil is just blatant misinterpretation of numbers. Also less labour market regulations wouldn't hurt most countries in Europe. Keep in mind that less regulation does not equal eroding the social net. Denmark's(although a small country for comparison) idea of 'flexicurity' is working very well for them. That is exactly what I said. Greek were working more than everybody else prior to the crisis, that's just how it is. It is a fact. Saying "lolololol France 35 hour" is okay but stating the fact that the country who had its economy destroyed over the last 5 years work on average more than anyone else in europe is wrong ? Do you know that the place with the highest living expectancy in europe is an island (Ikaria Island) in Greece where they basically work day and night, but alone with no boss and for themselves ? Less labor market regulations ? What are you talking about ? Flexisecurity ? We have flexibilize our market, in fact we have been since 10 years now, with no effect on employment. Market is so flexibilized right now that even boss say they don't need any more reform. That is the kind of argument the OECD had like ten or so years ago, trying to explain high unemployment in europe in comparaison to the US. Now they don't fucking understand what is going on anymore - because you know economist made them believe Phillips curve was wrong, despite it being the result of empirical data. Well especially for young people it seems hard to get a job in France which shows in the 25% unemployment rate among France's youth. France still has harsh regulations on part-time work (Luxembourg being the only country having stronger regulations in place if I'm not mistaken) coupled with very high minimum wages isn't exactly what i would call 'flexible'. Also France seems to have a strong tradition of employees and employers bashing each others head in, and the strong involvement of France's government in economic decisions, both from the right and left (for example the recent GE/Alstom/Siemens deal) seems a little 'out of time'. Regarding the Phillips curve, that's the short-term relationship between inflation and unemployment right? But that's monetary policy, what does it have to do with the topic of labour markets? The current unemployment is, from my point of view, highly related to phillips curve, and the low inflation (and of course the desastrous european policy and money, the euromark). And it's not short term - it's the augmented phillips curve that is short term.
The difficulty to get jobs in France has nothing to do with flexibility. I'm talking about real jobs, not 400 € part time jobs like in Germany's 6% unemployment perfect land. And Greece, Portugal, Spain, all have higher unemployment and their job market is so flexible it change from a day to day perspective.
On May 01 2014 00:51 aksfjh wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 00:09 Gorsameth wrote:On April 30 2014 23:33 Velr wrote: This blame game on Germany is getting very old.
The main Problem is that the other big european nations are a joke atm. GB is playing princess on the Island and doesn't really want to be part of this whole thing anyway. Spain is basically grounded. Italy is basically grounded. France is struggling hard.
Even if you want to blame the Problems many EU countries have on german policies. As far as i know the EU was created by all your countries together, it wasn't Germany dictating everyone how the Euro and all this stuff should be implemented. The thing is… Germany was actually ready for it while many other EU-countries obviously weren't.
I mean… Simplified you can sum it up like this: Italy is just systematically corrupt and its whole mid/south-area is underdeveloped. GB basically outsourced all its "traditional" industry and now is basically a giant bank. France has the hilarious 35h workweek and constant strikes... Now your telling me no one predicted that Germany would outcompete you?
Sad fact is: Germany (+"the North") is leading atm because no one else is capable of doing so.
Btw: I fundamentally disagree with many policies Germany adapted in the 00's and I see how they accelerated the problems, but they were answers to the big problems germany faced during the 90ies (+the whole reunion) and kinda worked out. These weren’t exactly popular solutions, i wouldn’t even call them « good » solutions but they kinda worked... Now blaming Germany for (being forced too) fixing their shit in advance and not still being « crippled » by the reunion cost is just stupid.
People are blaming Germany because they are the ones pushing hard for austerity which hadn't worked and if anything has only further and further deepened and lengthen the economic crisis. People are blaming Germany because while the rest of Europe is suffering they are doing moderately well because a weaker euro allows them to export more goods. The Euro isn't weak enough is the issue. Germany and London have a great deal of savings piled up, which means they want inflation as low as possible. Germans can handle the low inflation/deflation quite well since their labor laws (up until now) didn't require a minimum wage, and further, their employment was essentially guaranteed by the German government. This allows for comparatively cheap products to come out of Germany, especially since the recession wiped out cheap industry in all competing market places. If inflation took hold in Germany (which is what should happen to help the other economies), the German economy would likely "overheat" and we'd see wages rise, making the savings of the Germans not as strong. This inflation would help reduce the debt burden on the periphery, and drive demand for German goods high enough that a price difference could be noticeable between their products and products from Greece, Italy, Spain, etc. German people would need raises to purchase German products, or they would buy cheaper products from other EU countries. At some point, the inflation would be high enough to give breathing room to those periphery countries and they could finally grow and catch up, which would also help ease the inflation naturally without raising rates. I should add that the Germans don't want to do this for 2 reasons: 1) Reminders of hyper-inflation long ago - Weimar in the 1930s is still a lesson the administration leans on heavily. 2) Rent-seeking - Germans are in a great position compared to their neighbors, they'd rather keep it and expand upon it rather than help out the neighbors at the risk of losing their strong #1 spot. It's weak for them, in fact if they were alone with their own currency, Germany would be buying US currency like China and putting all those dollars in a vault just to make it sure their currency would not go too high.
|
@aksfjh :
Besides QE there isn't much more the ECB can do to get the inflation up, as interest rates are basically at zero anyway. And given the fact that Europe's current state resembles Japans situation in the 90's I'd be doubtful that a more expansive monetary policy is going to do miracles in the long run.
The difficulty to get jobs in France has nothing to do with flexibility. I'm talking about real jobs, not 400 € part time jobs like in Germany's 6% unemployment perfect land.
I'll agree that part time jobs aren't great, but it's better to earn 400 bucks a month than nothing. Also it gives people the chance to participate again and may get them a real job.
|
On May 01 2014 01:11 Nyxisto wrote: @aksfjh :
Besides QE there isn't much more the ECB can do to get the inflation up, as interest rates are basically at zero anyway. And given the fact that Europe's current state resembles Japans situation in the 90's I'd be doubtful that a more expansive monetary policy is going to do miracles in the long run. Japan's problem is their reliance on imports from competing economies. Inflation in Japan is likely to take hold as unsustainable import costs (and we see that to a degree already). Since Japan creates mostly durable goods and not services or consumption goods, it's hard to get the Japanese to buy more Japanese stuff.
Germany, on the other hand, is closely tied to their neighbors. They have a cooperative economy within the Eurozone. The more stuff Germany buys from it's neighbors, the more their neighbors buy from Germany. Germany makes a lot of durable goods, but they vacation and import a lot of stuff from their neighbors. True, it can't all be done by the ECB at this point, but their tepid response to the crisis (on behalf of Germany) is what got us here. Germany needs to feel pressure from the EU member countries, like France, Spain, and Italy, to change its fiscal stance. Those countries won't do crap though as long as Germany effectively controls the ECB, which has it's foot on the throat of struggling debtor countries through austerity-backed loans (sponsored by Germany).
|
What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that.
|
On May 01 2014 02:06 Sermokala wrote: What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that.
I think the purpose of the EU is to work together and not try to 'put pressure' on each other. 'Their foot on the Debtor countries throat'?. Come on, we're not the fucking Sith empire. Sure we can talk about printing some more money all day long, and in the end the ECB will go for it anyway. But Southern Europe needs some serious structural reforms sooner or later.Neutrality of money holds true in the long run (and there's no empirical evidence suggesting otherwise). Flaws in a countries economy are not going to be solved by inflation.
|
On May 01 2014 02:20 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 02:06 Sermokala wrote: What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that. I think the purpose of the EU is to work together and not try to 'put pressure' on each other. 'Their foot on the Debtor countries throat'?. Come on, we're not the fucking Sith empire. Sure we can talk about printing some more money all day long, and in the end the ECB will go for it anyway. But Southern Europe needs some serious structural reforms sooner or later.Neutrality of money holds true in the long run (and there's no empirical evidence suggesting otherwise). Flaws in a countries economy are not going to be solved by inflation. In the long run, we're all dead...
I like how you start out saying that the EU needs to "work together and not put pressure on each other" when that's exactly what is going on now with debt relief being used to pressure other countries into structural reforms "sooner or later."
|
Recently I read an interesting article stating the city of Gothenburg in Sweden has reduced working hours per day to six: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/sweden/10754656/Swedish-city-embarks-on-6-hour-workday-experiment.html .
There was an article in "Der Spiegel" mentioning the same and that this has been done in Sweden also in a company where productivity increased so much after this change that it is paying off for the employer. I can't remember what kind of company it was. This probably wll not work everywhere.
The article above also mentions that Greece has the hardest working population of OECD countries but they are about 70% less productive on average than German workers. So in my opinion it's not about working 40 hours a week or more or something but to increase productivity in several European countries to help them become more competitive.
So some smart money spending combined with reduction of bureaucracy and regulations should help I think.
We all compete on a global scale and it does not help anyone in Europe if Germany becomes less competitive. The other countries need to close the gap. I think this is a huge problem of capitalism in general because it's all about competitiveness and not primarily about the people.
|
Toyota Center in Mölndal have had it since the end of 2002. A recent bit about it in Swedish here
|
On May 01 2014 02:59 AlternativeEgo wrote:Toyota Center in Mölndal have had it since the end of 2002. A recent bit about it in Swedish here
Summary: They had an 8 hour work day, had too much business. Implemented 6h two-shifts, increased profit, health of employees. When decreasing work hours they removed the bonus you usually get outside of normal work hours, still a net gain per hour worked for the employees since they kept a normal 8h wage.
---------------------
As for the topic. Voting PP again. Will see if they can keep their seats, not really following it closely since I decided who to vote for 2-3 years ago.
|
On May 01 2014 02:29 aksfjh wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 02:20 Nyxisto wrote:On May 01 2014 02:06 Sermokala wrote: What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that. I think the purpose of the EU is to work together and not try to 'put pressure' on each other. 'Their foot on the Debtor countries throat'?. Come on, we're not the fucking Sith empire. Sure we can talk about printing some more money all day long, and in the end the ECB will go for it anyway. But Southern Europe needs some serious structural reforms sooner or later.Neutrality of money holds true in the long run (and there's no empirical evidence suggesting otherwise). Flaws in a countries economy are not going to be solved by inflation. In the long run, we're all dead... I like how you start out saying that the EU needs to "work together and not put pressure on each other" when that's exactly what is going on now with debt relief being used to pressure other countries into structural reforms "sooner or later." The Greeks aren't forced to do reforms, they voted to stay within the EU. But if they realistically want to be part of that Union they need to get their act together. Greece wouldn't get a cent of money from the capital markets and has not for the last several years(besides the bonds they only handed out recently). What alternative do you propose? That the Northern European countries just hand out credits without any conditions?
The only pressure that lies on the countries is to fulfill the Maastricht criteria and create an economic framework that makes economic prosperity possible.Germany isn't forcing anyone to do anything. But to make a 17 trillion dollar economy with 28 member states work you need a certain amount of coordination. The amount of corruption and bad government that came and comes out of several European countries simply isn't sustainable.
|
On May 01 2014 02:48 Banaora wrote:Recently I read an interesting article stating the city of Gothenburg in Sweden has reduced working hours per day to six: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/sweden/10754656/Swedish-city-embarks-on-6-hour-workday-experiment.html . There was an article in "Der Spiegel" mentioning the same and that this has been done in Sweden also in a company where productivity increased so much after this change that it is paying off for the employer. I can't remember what kind of company it was. This probably wll not work everywhere. The article above also mentions that Greece has the hardest working population of OECD countries but they are about 70% less productive on average than German workers. So in my opinion it's not about working 40 hours a week or more or something but to increase productivity in several European countries to help them become more competitive. So some smart money spending combined with reduction of bureaucracy and regulations should help I think. We all compete on a global scale and it does not help anyone in Europe if Germany becomes less competitive. The other countries need to close the gap. I think this is a huge problem of capitalism in general because it's all about competitiveness and not primarily about the people. Exactly, it is not about working hard, it is about capital and innovations that enhance productivity. The problem is, Greece is poor and didn't have enough capital. The arrival of the euro came like a gift to resolve that lack of capital, so they endebted themselves, then the subprime crisis.
You are wrong about competitiveness: it is not the goal of capitalism, just a side product. It's Germany's behavior that is seeking competition, but it is just wrong economically. Sure firm needs to seek competitiveness, but when a country to search for competitiveness, not only will it had negative impact on internal demand, but it will only normally impact on currency. The problem is the euro permit Germany to sell more than it should, and push small country further and further into a deficit of their trading balance because with such a currency they can't come back (at least not without some form of protectionnism). It's some kind of neo mercantilism that has no real economic justification for Germany from a short run high profit for a selected few (in fact Germany in Europe is much like China pushing the entire economy in disarray prior to 2007 and the subprime crisis). From a pure rational standpoint, Germany's position and their "competitiveness" has nothing to do with their behavior, and more with the overall economical context of the EU in the last 10 years. They just profit from it.
On May 01 2014 02:06 Sermokala wrote: What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that. Germany has everything to lose actually. Whatever the solution, they will take a hard hit, and that is one of the biggest problem. Better make suffer all europe than to accept losing its position. It has come to a point where even Kai A. Konrad, chief finance advisor of Merkel, considered in 2013 that Germany should get out of the euro (I recommend the interview btw, it is in Die Welt, but in German with some french traductions).
On May 01 2014 03:20 Nyxisto wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 02:29 aksfjh wrote:On May 01 2014 02:20 Nyxisto wrote:On May 01 2014 02:06 Sermokala wrote: What kind of pressure could the euro countries put on Germany though? Their foot on the Debtor countries throat gives them all the leverage in the world in the Parliament to do whatever they want, and with the UK thinking of leaving the euro Germany can just hint an interest to leave the union to get all the leverage from the larger countries it wants.
IT appears that the EU is right where Germany wants it to be and it has no inventive to change that. I think the purpose of the EU is to work together and not try to 'put pressure' on each other. 'Their foot on the Debtor countries throat'?. Come on, we're not the fucking Sith empire. Sure we can talk about printing some more money all day long, and in the end the ECB will go for it anyway. But Southern Europe needs some serious structural reforms sooner or later.Neutrality of money holds true in the long run (and there's no empirical evidence suggesting otherwise). Flaws in a countries economy are not going to be solved by inflation. In the long run, we're all dead... I like how you start out saying that the EU needs to "work together and not put pressure on each other" when that's exactly what is going on now with debt relief being used to pressure other countries into structural reforms "sooner or later." The Greeks aren't forced to do reforms, they voted to stay within the EU. But if they realistically want to be part of that Union they need to get their act together. Greece wouldn't get a cent of money from the capital markets and has not for the last several years(besides the bonds they only handed out recently). What alternative do you propose? That the Northern European countries just hand out credits without any conditions? The only pressure that lies on the countries is to fulfill the Maastricht criteria and create an economic framework that makes economic prosperity possible.Germany isn't forcing anyone to do anything. But to make a 17 trillion dollar economy with 28 member states work you need a certain amount of coordination. The amount of corruption and bad government that came and comes out of several European countries simply isn't sustainable. Seriously ? Greek didn't have the choice. What the EU did to Greece - where the idea of europe came from... - is, in my mind, a crime. Their debt was nothing for Europe, it could have been wiped away in a second. But solidarity is nothing right, they should get their shit together... they deserved this 25 % unemployment and 5 year recession.
|
On May 01 2014 02:48 Banaora wrote:
We all compete on a global scale and it does not help anyone in Europe if Germany becomes less competitive. The other countries need to close the gap. I think this is a huge problem of capitalism in general because it's all about competitiveness and not primarily about the people. So much this. In these debates you usually read that Germany should lose competitiveness and thus it would buy more from the other EU states. This may be true to some extent, but it seems most of you just forget that the Eurozone is not a closed system. Germany is mostly competing against the low wages in emerging markets, where they not only produce T-Shirts anymore, but are already on a technological level that you cannot simply ignore. Then there are old competitors such as Japan and the US. The idea to chop down Germany's competitiveness to help countries like Greece, which - to quote a greek citizen - does not even produce bicycles, is just asinine. All that would happen is that the EU's overall zero trade balance would tip to the negative. Greece would not start to produce high-class machinery or cars when Germany's wages are raised by a substantial amount, the infrastructure for that is not there. However, the Chinese or US competitors would have a field day.
Edit: To the poster above me: You really think several hundred billion € are nothing?
|
On May 01 2014 03:41 WhiteDog wrote: Seriously ? Greek didn't have the choice. What the EU did to Greece - where the idea of europe came from... - is, in my mind, a crime. Their debt was nothing for Europe, it could have been wiped away in a second. But solidarity is nothing right, they should get their shit together... they deserved this 25 % unemployment and 5 year recession. This isn't about what Greece "deserves".I don't know what kind of anti-German resentments you have but I can assure you no one here enjoys seeing Greece in it's current state. If you let a country default on their debt/haircut all of the debt away, how are they supposed to gain access to capital again? No private investor is going to invest into such a country. No one is doing the people of Greece a favour if you just let their debt go without any incentive. As you said the most important thing for a country is a productive and well educated workforce, this is not going to happen if these countries keep getting buried under political corruption and bureaucracy.
|
On May 01 2014 04:16 Restrider wrote:Show nested quote +On May 01 2014 02:48 Banaora wrote:
We all compete on a global scale and it does not help anyone in Europe if Germany becomes less competitive. The other countries need to close the gap. I think this is a huge problem of capitalism in general because it's all about competitiveness and not primarily about the people. So much this. In these debates you usually read that Germany should lose competitiveness and thus it would buy more from the other EU states. This may be true to some extent, but it seems most of you just forget that the Eurozone is not a closed system. Germany is mostly competing against the low wages in emerging markets, where they not only produce T-Shirts anymore, but are already on a technological level that you cannot simply ignore. Then there are old competitors such as Japan and the US. The idea to chop down Germany's competitiveness to help countries like Greece, which - to quote a greek citizen - does not even produce bicycles, is just asinine. All that would happen is that the EU's overall zero trade balance would tip to the negative. Greece would not start to produce high-class machinery or cars when Germany's wages are raised by a substantial amount, the infrastructure for that is not there. However, the Chinese or US competitors would have a field day. Germany's current account and "competitiveness" is only possible because of what it did during 2004 (I should say what was "permitted" by an inflation in the entire europe aside from germany) and the euro today. With the account Germany has, in any other situation, German currency would rise a lot and prevent Germany to continue sell its goods abroad this cheap - or it would force Germany to basically invest a lot in other countries like China is doing right now, to prevent the currency from rising too much. Being with the euro and other economy with bad trade balance is what is permitting Germany to be this "competitive" and not its industry, by effectively lowering the currency exchange rate. So basically, it is not about "making Germany lose its competitiveness", but just acknowledging the fact that this situation and the euro is aggraving the discrepancies between europeans economy just to permit Germany to keep its place in the sun for some more years.
|
On May 01 2014 00:09 Gorsameth wrote:Show nested quote +On April 30 2014 23:33 Velr wrote: This blame game on Germany is getting very old.
The main Problem is that the other big european nations are a joke atm. GB is playing princess on the Island and doesn't really want to be part of this whole thing anyway. Spain is basically grounded. Italy is basically grounded. France is struggling hard.
Even if you want to blame the Problems many EU countries have on german policies. As far as i know the EU was created by all your countries together, it wasn't Germany dictating everyone how the Euro and all this stuff should be implemented. The thing is… Germany was actually ready for it while many other EU-countries obviously weren't.
I mean… Simplified you can sum it up like this: Italy is just systematically corrupt and its whole mid/south-area is underdeveloped. GB basically outsourced all its "traditional" industry and now is basically a giant bank. France has the hilarious 35h workweek and constant strikes... Now your telling me no one predicted that Germany would outcompete you?
Sad fact is: Germany (+"the North") is leading atm because no one else is capable of doing so.
Btw: I fundamentally disagree with many policies Germany adapted in the 00's and I see how they accelerated the problems, but they were answers to the big problems germany faced during the 90ies (+the whole reunion) and kinda worked out. These weren’t exactly popular solutions, i wouldn’t even call them « good » solutions but they kinda worked... Now blaming Germany for (being forced too) fixing their shit in advance and not still being « crippled » by the reunion cost is just stupid.
People are blaming Germany because they are the ones pushing hard for austerity which hadn't worked and if anything has only further and further deepened and lengthen the economic crisis. People are blaming Germany because while the rest of Europe is suffering they are doing moderately well because a weaker euro allows them to export more goods.
Maybe because it's math but I don't see how increasing spending helps in times of economic crisis? Disregarding Germany here, what's wrong with austerity?
|
|
|
|
|
|