|
On May 19 2011 08:16 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:14 MasterFischer wrote:On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 19 2011 08:11 MasterFischer wrote:You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do  How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really. No, it's not. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. It makes perfect logical sense. You kill them because they committed a crime. It's called a punishment. And thus, perhaps preventing further killings by this criminal in the future. I understand your argument. I am not even against the death penalty. What I am against is your "fucking retarded argument" that the following set of statements constitute a "fucking retarded argument." 1. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening. 2. You shouldn't kill people out of spite or retribution.
Why shouldn't you kill people out of a justifiable punishment decided by the democracy?
It's not wrong to kill people who are atrocious human beings and contribute nothing to society other than kill its innocent inhabitants. In theory, nobody is able to pay enough debt in life, for murdering another human life, other than to pay with his or her own as an exchange.
Why should a person be allowed to breathe freely? While the person choose to end a life that was not his choice to make? The person violated the most sacred of human rights, and gets a slap on the wrist? Is that justice to you?
|
I wonder if this woman will actually feel better after maiming that man? she seems to think she will...
I don't really see how you can try and morally justify her dishing out some retribution though. When someone wrongs you... wrong them back? That does not seem like a place I'd prefer to live in
But I hope she ends up happy... that's wretched what happened to her
|
On May 19 2011 04:08 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:00 Belphegor13 wrote:To take a human life, to inflict pain upon others, is always wrong, regardless of the circumstances. Yes, this is an idealistic way of thinking. But as long as we think in terms of "an eye for an eye" and that this is necessary, violence and death will exist. Surely crime will not go away because we stop punishing it with equally brutal methods, but I believe that we, by employing that kind of brutallity, increases our tolerance to violence. If we say it is justice in this case, it might be justice in other cases, were do we draw the line? On May 18 2011 20:30 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 20:22 Olinim wrote:On May 18 2011 20:16 MasterFischer wrote: And don't give me that shit about rehabilitation and what not in prison. Doesn't fucking work.
What works is FEAR, in order to deal with criminals on their terms, you have to use their tactics and their line of thought, fear. They don't give a fuck about the system or jail-time probaly, they laugh at the system.
They might think otherwise if they have fucking acid poured into their face... like..
ohoh... maybe I shouldn't totally go and do this crime just now ..eh??? Might get fucking acid in my fucking stupid criminal face... oh well... I'll just leave it.. aint worth it. Too scared. I don't wanna die.. bla bla... see?
You get the criminal to think about consequences and how THEY would like it, if somebody did it to THEM?
It's fair. So your genius plan to stop criminals and prove their actions are wrong... is to do exactly what they do. Hmm. We as a society are reactionary. We act upon others actions. This is the way it is. Why is punishment by death or otherwise wrong? Do you think criminals have a patent on killing another human? They don't. They just choose to do it. We act upon their choosing. Has nothing to do with the act itself or the punishment. but if you think you control other peoples lives by taking it away from them, then you deserve to pay with your own. always. Nobody has the right to take another life without permission, and if they do, they must and should be willing to trade in their life aswell.. Those are the terms. Fairly simply, pretty fair and just. What does sending them to jail do? Nothing. It costs society money, it costs time and ressources on lowlifes. We are so many people in the world, we got no fucking time to deal with each little fucking miserable scrub that thinks he or she is the king of the world by taking lives. Millions die everyday from big issues like hunger, poverty, accidents, natural diseasters and what not.. and you're telling me I should fucking care about 1 criminal scrub who deserves what he got? No. I don't. Don't fuck me with me, and I won't fuck with you. It's so simple and logical, that if you're too fucking dumb as a person to figure out the basics of human morality and life, you deserve to be put to rest. The end. Your last sentence strikes me as an excellent example. "If you are stupid and (therefore) disagree with me, you should be killed." While I'm sure this is not a serious threat and not something you actually would do, this kind of thinking is problematic. I mean, if we are already killing murderers, cutting the penis of rapist and chopping the hands of thieves, and we understand that is an acceptable method in society. Maybe you believe someone should really die? Yeah, if I think he deserves it, he should. On the other hand, if you keep a no-tolerance mindset, that thought would never be possible. What does having this mindset effect crime rates? Not much, probably. But if no one put's one's foot down, and says; "I will not take a human life" who will? The answer is, no one. Do you really think criminals give a shit, that you put your foot down and say.. oh oh.. the world is made of roseberries and rainbows.. let's not kill anybody shall we ?? pleaseeee?? Murder, rape, torture, poverty all these things.. they go on and on.. and they will NEVER.. EVER fucking go away... ever.. understand? So why not start punishing the crimes in a fair manner, instead of giving lee-way to murders. You know kind of message you are sending to criminals if you don't want them to suffer? I'll tell ya, "Oh please, do more crime, we don't wanna punish you, it's wrong you know?"... Criminals will be okay... fine, so while I rape your sister and kill your father with a knife, think REAL hard about not punishing me okay?... cool story bro.. THIS.DOES.NOT.WORK... It's not ACCEPTABLE in society, it's acceptable as a punishment for doing wrong, as a punishment by the government and legal justice system. Not by common men. There is a huge fucking difference, and most MOST normal people understand this. we grant the government and the police, authority, to use force that is otherwise illegal to us citizens e.g. deadly force, the death penalty. We live in a democracy.
Neither does your method "work". In places that enforce the death penalty, and other savage punishments, crime is still rampant, sometimes even more so. Cops only get to use deadly force in SELF defense. Your comparison is completely nonsensical because they aren't permitted to use deadly force to exact revenge or "justice".
|
On May 19 2011 08:23 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:16 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 19 2011 08:14 MasterFischer wrote:On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 19 2011 08:11 MasterFischer wrote:You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do  How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really. No, it's not. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. It makes perfect logical sense. You kill them because they committed a crime. It's called a punishment. And thus, perhaps preventing further killings by this criminal in the future. I understand your argument. I am not even against the death penalty. What I am against is your "fucking retarded argument" that the following set of statements constitute a "fucking retarded argument." 1. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening. 2. You shouldn't kill people out of spite or retribution. Why shouldn't you kill people out of a justifiable punishment decided by the democracy? It's not wrong to kill people who are atrocious human beings and contribute nothing to society other than kill its innocent inhabitants. In theory, nobody is able to pay enough debt in life, for murdering another human life, other than to pay with his or her own as an exchange. Why should a person be allowed to breathe freely? While the person choose to end a life that was not his choice to make? The person violated the most sacred of human rights, and gets a slap on the wrist? Is that justice to you? I do not fucking care about the death penalty argument. What I was after was your retarded logical fallacy, and your assertion that everybody who opposes the death penalty is fucking retarded. I am pro-death penalty, get that into your head and learn to read.
For FUCK's sake.
On May 19 2011 08:19 domovoi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote: You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. What about from a standpoint of general application? Is it moral to have the death penalty to deter would-be murderers from murdering? From a pragmatic standpoint, your system of morality would encourage would-be murderers to actually murder. Doesn't sound like a very ideal system. I'm going to set you on fire out of spite.
|
On May 19 2011 08:11 EmeraldSparks wrote: It works like this:
I've got a knife to your sister's throat.
I hear you coming. I know you have a gun. You will batter down the door in under ten seconds.
If I don't kill your sister, you will blow me away to protect her.
Therefore, I should immediately decapitate her for my own safety.
That way, when you show up, she's already dead, and you have no reason to kill me. That's not how it works at all. If I were to come into a room and see you holding a bloody knife because you just killed my sister, I would reasonably fear for my own life and be well within justification to shoot you to protect myself. To shoot to kill you, maybe not, because I am holding a gun and you have a knife, and you are presumably a couple feet away. But I could claim I was aiming for your legs and the 'accidentally' hit your head.
Oops.
|
On May 19 2011 09:08 MozzarellaL wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:11 EmeraldSparks wrote: It works like this:
I've got a knife to your sister's throat.
I hear you coming. I know you have a gun. You will batter down the door in under ten seconds.
If I don't kill your sister, you will blow me away to protect her.
Therefore, I should immediately decapitate her for my own safety.
That way, when you show up, she's already dead, and you have no reason to kill me. That's not how it works at all. If I were to come into a room and see you holding a bloody knife because you just killed my sister, I would reasonably fear for my own life and be well within justification to shoot you to protect myself. To shoot to kill you, maybe not, because I am holding a gun and you have a knife, and you are presumably a couple feet away. But I could claim I was aiming for your legs and the 'accidentally' hit your head. Oops. I was talking to somebody who claimed that they wouldn't "accidentally" kill somebody out of spite because he or she thought that it was morally wrong to do so; they misinterpreted the argument (which I found to be astoundingly contrived and would never happen) and I was clarifying it.
|
On May 19 2011 09:14 EmeraldSparks wrote: I was talking to somebody who claimed that they wouldn't "accidentally" kill somebody out of spite because he or she thought that it was morally wrong to do so; they misinterpreted the argument (which I found to be astoundingly contrived and would never happen) and I was clarifying it. The fact remains that if I just walked into a room where some guy just killed my family, I would be reasonable in fearing for my own life, and therefore, justified in killing the murderer. Retribution doesn't factor into this argument. Hell, it doesn't even have to be my family. It could be my neighbor, or my friends, or my colleagues.
|
|
|
On May 19 2011 09:20 Barrin wrote: Unless, of course, you did know what's happening. I don't know about other states, but there is a law in my state (florida) that allows this thing called a "citizen's arrest". You may perform a citizen's arrest only if you or your friend/family/etc is in danger. I'm not sure, but I think you can only kill someone in "self-defense", not "friend-defense". (i think o.O) Yes, you can use deadly force to protect the life of another. Self-defense hinges on whether a reasonable person in the same situation would have thought the use of deadly force necessary, you would apply the same principle (maybe more strict) for the defense of another if that other is a family, or a friend, and use an even stricter standard for a stranger (or even none at all, so random citizens don't accidentally shoot plain-clothed police officers for apprehending criminals)
Anyways... it sounds as if you would be blocking the only exit to the room. Therefore you are literally trapping/cornering the murderer and you have no way to claim self-defense. Even if there is a window IMO. So? If the killer is in my home, I have the right to kill him anyway (most states allow the use of deadly force against trespassers if the homeowner reasonably believes the trespasser is there to commit a violent crime--If I found a random guy in my home holding a bloody knife I would be entirely justified in killing him). And if not, I am well within my rights to attempt to detain a suspected criminal until the police arrive. False imprisonment may be a crime, but one would most certainly be justified in detaining a suspected murderer.
But if there was a window (or another exit), then the murderer could just try to run away. If you shoot someone in the back, it is never self-defense (in my state at least). Like I was saying, "He moved, I shot at his leg because I was scared for my life and didn't know what he was going to do." Case closed.
|
I'm very disappointed that it has been postponed indefinitely. The human rights groups got their victory, they protected a worthless man and encouraged more acid attacks.
|
I don't really see an issue with retribution justice, I would imagine it lowers petty crime rates by an insane amount and quite frankly there's no good argument for why the offender doesn't deserve the same in return.
|
What a disgrace. Justice vs. vengeance. Which is the nobler of the two?
|
Even though the man should face severe punisment, nobody deserves that kind of suffering, I can understand the woman's desicion but the less suffering in the world there is the better.
|
On May 21 2011 06:16 Drolla wrote: Even though the man should face severe punisment, nobody deserves that kind of suffering, I can understand the woman's desicion but the less suffering in the world there is the better.
Why doesn't he deserve that suffering?
|
On May 21 2011 07:12 LetoAtreides82 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 21 2011 06:16 Drolla wrote: Even though the man should face severe punisment, nobody deserves that kind of suffering, I can understand the woman's desicion but the less suffering in the world there is the better. Why doesn't he deserve that suffering? You're right. Having someone else suffer is definitely righting a wrong. Idiot.
|
On May 21 2011 07:27 Klaus1986 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 21 2011 07:12 LetoAtreides82 wrote:On May 21 2011 06:16 Drolla wrote: Even though the man should face severe punisment, nobody deserves that kind of suffering, I can understand the woman's desicion but the less suffering in the world there is the better. Why doesn't he deserve that suffering? You're right. Having someone else suffer is definitely righting a wrong. Idiot.
It sends people a message that if you burn someone with acid than you will be burned with acid also as a consequence. Always got groups of people are so quick to protect some assholes "human rights" when he didn't respect someone elses. That attitude just breeds more perpetrators cause they know in the end they can get away with it with little to no punishment.
|
|
|
On May 21 2011 07:35 Baarn wrote:Show nested quote +On May 21 2011 07:27 Klaus1986 wrote:On May 21 2011 07:12 LetoAtreides82 wrote:On May 21 2011 06:16 Drolla wrote: Even though the man should face severe punisment, nobody deserves that kind of suffering, I can understand the woman's desicion but the less suffering in the world there is the better. Why doesn't he deserve that suffering? You're right. Having someone else suffer is definitely righting a wrong. Idiot. It sends people a message that if you burn someone with acid than you will be burned with acid also as a consequence. Always got groups of people are so quick to protect some assholes "human rights" when he didn't respect someone elses. That attitude just breeds more perpetrators cause they know in the end they can get away with it with little to no punishment.
I disagree. Send this asshole to jail. I don't think a lot of people think of the punishment they'll receive for their crimes when they act them out. In a fit of rage you don't think rationally, no matter how harsh the punishment you won't be able to deter too many from acid throwing. Besides the government allowing this sort of thing as retribution makes it look like an acceptable form of punishment.
In 2002 Bangladesh introduced very tough laws to try to stop acid throwing, including the death penalty in the most serious cases.
And there are regulations on the sale, use, storage, import and export of acid.
The number of people attacked has fallen from a high of nearly 500 in that year, but still, in 2005, according to the Acid Survivors' Foundation, 267 people had acid thrown on them.
It does reduce it, but I think they should deal with it the same way as school shootings. Give it as little media attention as possible to avoid others copying it, and change the law allowing people to use this as retribution.
|
On May 21 2011 07:54 Paperplane wrote: I disagree. Send this asshole to jail. I don't think a lot of people think of the punishment they'll receive for their crimes when they act them out. In a fit of rage you don't think rationally, no matter how harsh the punishment you won't be able to deter too many from acid throwing. Besides the government allowing this sort of thing as retribution makes it look like an acceptable form of punishment.
That argument doesn't seem to hold up as well for this situation, unless you carry around acid all the time just in case you happen to go into a fit of rage.
|
for every action there is an equal opposing reaction. vengeance is ok as long as its not over done.
you kill my sister = i kill you you kill my sister =/= i kill your family
but not everyone thinks the same and for most people, anger will out weigh.
|
|
|
|
|
|