|
On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote: Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. It is precisely this reason why the death penalty is abominable. First of all, not only is a person necessarily committing the murder that is execution regardless of how awful the person being executed may or may not be, but there is also the ever present possibility that you are executing an innocent person. I think we can all agree that executing an innocent person is unconscionable and so long as that possibility exists, draconian punishments are something with which I can never agree.
|
On May 19 2011 06:12 Keren wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote: Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. It is precisely this reason why the death penalty is abominable. First of all, not only is a person necessarily committing the murder that is execution regardless of how awful the person being executed may or may not be, but there is also the ever present possibility that you are executing an innocent person. I think we can all agree that executing an innocent person is unconscionable and so long as that possibility exists, draconian punishments are something with which I can never agree.
I will agree that the death penalty is good when the accused criminal can be made 100 % sure of the crime they committed.
But how much does this actually happen? If we look at severe cases, isn't the material usually pretty strong, and the evidence quite supportive? it depends on how professional the police investigating the crime scene are.
But I mean... was it wrong that ted bundy was executed? A serial killer... a mass murderer...
Sure.. we can never be REALLY sure it was him.. according to your argument, although we got very strong evidence it was... so was it wrong? Should we instead have jailed him for life, and kept spending money on that?
or?
Spending life in jail doesn't get much better than being dead in my opinion. And at strong murder cases, it's either death, or life in prison without parole. What would u rather have? Sure death is unrevokable once it's done, I dunno man... Haven't heard about alot of mistrials of high profile murders.. have you?
|
that's really sad that happened to the woman. I hope she's doing ok right now :\
|
On May 19 2011 06:09 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 05:28 HellRoxYa wrote:On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote:On May 19 2011 05:09 HellRoxYa wrote:A murderer isn't necessairly someone who just said "Fuck the rules, who needs them". And even when they do it might very well have been only partly in their control, etc, etc. Just because one life is ruined doesn't mean you need to ruin another. You said yourself it does no good. + Show Spoiler +Basically it's not as black and white as you make it out to be. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. No, but in those instances were it is pretty clear than murder was intentional from the criminals viewpoint, i think justice needs to be served. There are varying degrees of murder. involuntary manslaughter and what not.. those are all circumstances were life in prison or maybe half a life in prison might be suitable. Depending on how committed the murderer is to the act, and how well the case is being reviewed. Still doesn't change the fact that the death penalty is good for occasions were it is needed. Where are you gonna draw the line, if not at death? Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. In my world there are two kinds of people: a) Crazies, who do anything regardless of outcome b) normal functioning people, who knows the wrongdoings of killing, but do it anyway... REGARDLESS of how their social status and genetics are. This is still excluding "accidents" such as involuntary manslaughter. Do you fail to see that your argument relies on the fact that society (the judicial system is still society) needs exercise the very same disregard for human life to follow through with an execution? Yes, the person put himself in that position, sure, but that doesn't mean society gains the right to err in the same way. But for me personally, I'm against the death penalty mostly because you can never be sure enough. Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it?
Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you.
On May 19 2011 06:18 MasterFischer wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 19 2011 06:12 Keren wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote: Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. It is precisely this reason why the death penalty is abominable. First of all, not only is a person necessarily committing the murder that is execution regardless of how awful the person being executed may or may not be, but there is also the ever present possibility that you are executing an innocent person. I think we can all agree that executing an innocent person is unconscionable and so long as that possibility exists, draconian punishments are something with which I can never agree. I will agree that the death penalty is good when the accused criminal can be made 100 % sure of the crime they committed. But how much does this actually happen? If we look at severe cases, isn't the material usually pretty strong, and the evidence quite supportive? it depends on how professional the police investigating the crime scene are. But I mean... was it wrong that ted bundy was executed? A serial killer... a mass murderer... Sure.. we can never be REALLY sure it was him.. according to your argument, although we got very strong evidence it was... so was it wrong? Should we instead have jailed him for life, and kept spending money on that? or? Spending life in jail doesn't get much better than being dead in my opinion. And at strong murder cases, it's either death, or life in prison without parole. What would u rather have? Sure death is unrevokable once it's done, I dunno man... Haven't heard about alot of mistrials of high profile murders.. have you?
This is both hilarious and sad. I'm going to assume you're not aware of the myriad of cases where people have been declared innocent (or at least not guilty) in retrospect although already having been executed? Having it had happen even once should be more than enough...
|
On May 19 2011 06:18 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 06:12 Keren wrote:On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote: Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. It is precisely this reason why the death penalty is abominable. First of all, not only is a person necessarily committing the murder that is execution regardless of how awful the person being executed may or may not be, but there is also the ever present possibility that you are executing an innocent person. I think we can all agree that executing an innocent person is unconscionable and so long as that possibility exists, draconian punishments are something with which I can never agree. I will agree that the death penalty is good when the accused criminal can be made 100 % sure of the crime they committed. But how much does this actually happen? If we look at severe cases, isn't the material usually pretty strong, and the evidence quite supportive? it depends on how professional the police investigating the crime scene are. But I mean... was it wrong that ted bundy was executed? A serial killer... a mass murderer... Sure.. we can never be REALLY sure it was him.. according to your argument, although we got very strong evidence it was... so was it wrong? Should we instead have jailed him for life, and kept spending money on that? or? Spending life in jail doesn't get much better than being dead in my opinion. And at strong murder cases, it's either death, or life in prison without parole. What would u rather have? Sure death is unrevokable once it's done, I dunno man... Haven't heard about alot of mistrials of high profile murders.. have you?
Seeking the death penalty in the US can often outweigh the monetary costs of life in prison for a criminal offender.
|
On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote: Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. A rather simplistic and naive view on the morality of killing. No modern society categorizes all killing as "murder," or at least not from a moral standpoint. In other words, some killings are more moral than others. Some killings are less moral than others. I think there's a practical reason for this, and at the very heart of it, it comes down to this: sometimes a person needs to be killed to prevent an even greater harm.
|
On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 06:09 MasterFischer wrote: Show nested quote +
Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it? Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral. What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. This is both hilarious and sad. I'm going to assume you're not aware of the myriad of cases where people have been declared innocent (or at least not guilty) in retrospect although already having been executed? Having it had happen even once should be more than enough...
Just to play devil's advocate here... I think that our death penalty supporter is making the claim that killing a murderer is different (in a morally significant way) from killing an innocent person.
He implies that you are saying that killing a murder and killing an innocent person are morally equivalent, and objects to this.
To clarify: Do you think there is a morally significant difference between killing a murderer and an innocent? If so, why is it not ok to kill the murderer despite the act of killing him being "not as bad"?
I agree with you that it is pretty much never ok to kill anyone, however am hesitant to take a categorical stance against killing people. I am sure that there exist circumstances in which killing someone is the right (morally speaking) thing to do.
Maybe you can outline for MasterFischer what circumstances need to exist for killing a person to be permissible, and explain how those requirements are not met in the case of killing a detained murderer.
|
On May 19 2011 07:09 domovoi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote: Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. A rather simplistic and naive view on the morality of killing. No modern society categorizes all killing as "murder," or at least not from a moral standpoint. In other words, some killings are more moral than others. Some killings are less moral than others. I think there's a practical reason for this, and at the very heart of it, it comes down to this: sometimes a person needs to be killed to prevent an even greater harm.
The greater harm being life imprisonment? Or what are you talking about?
It seems interesting to add this:
On May 19 2011 07:13 Reason.SC2 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote:On May 19 2011 06:09 MasterFischer wrote: Show nested quote +
Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it? Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral. What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. This is both hilarious and sad. I'm going to assume you're not aware of the myriad of cases where people have been declared innocent (or at least not guilty) in retrospect although already having been executed? Having it had happen even once should be more than enough... Just to play devil's advocate here... I think that our death penalty supporter is making the claim that killing a murderer is different (in a morally significant way) from killing an innocent person. He implies that you are saying that killing a murder and killing an innocent person are morally equivalent, and objects to this. To clarify: Do you think there is a morally significant difference between killing a murderer and an innocent? If so, why is it not ok to kill the murderer despite the act of killing him being "not as bad"? I agree with you that it is pretty much never ok to kill anyone, however am hesitant to take a categorical stance against killing people. I am sure that there exist circumstances in which killing someone is the right (morally speaking) thing to do. Maybe you can outline for MasterFischer what circumstances need to exist for killing a person to be permissible, and explain how those requirements are not met in the case of killing a detained murderer.
As domovoi states, killing someone who's holding a knife to your family's throat can be considered different and is more morally accepted.
Killing someone after this person has comitted the crime isn't, in my eyes. If it were, where do you draw the line? At best, it becomes more understandable.
|
On May 19 2011 07:09 domovoi wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote: Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. A rather simplistic and naive view on the morality of killing. No modern society categorizes all killing as "murder," or at least not from a moral standpoint. In other words, some killings are more moral than others. Some killings are less moral than others. I think there's a practical reason for this, and at the very heart of it, it comes down to this: sometimes a person needs to be killed to prevent an even greater harm.
I only made it that simplistic because he wasn't getting my point. There's nothing naive about my view on the world or the morals therein, thank you.
|
As domovoi states, killing someone who's holding a knife to your family's throat can be considered different and is more morally accepted.
Killing someone after this person has comitted the crime isn't, in my eyes. If it were, where do you draw the line? At best, it becomes more understandable. Is jailing a convicted felon more morally acceptable than jailing an innocent person? I think we'd all say yes. It's not a huge leap to go from the revocation of the fundamental right of liberty to the revocation of the right to life. I think you are in the minority if you say killing a convicted murderer is as immoral as killing an innocent person.
|
|
|
On May 19 2011 07:59 Barrin wrote: So let me get this straight.
If I'm some kind of murderer holding a knife to your family's throat(s), then all I have to do is kill your family to prevent you from killing me? Yea, if you can get by him. He is, of course, justified in using deadly force to try to stop you. But after you kill his family, were he then to kill you (after you drop the knife, say), he will be guilty of at least manslaughter. That's how this country's laws work.
|
On May 19 2011 07:59 Barrin wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 07:15 Passion wrote:On May 19 2011 07:09 domovoi wrote:On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote: Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. A rather simplistic and naive view on the morality of killing. No modern society categorizes all killing as "murder," or at least not from a moral standpoint. In other words, some killings are more moral than others. Some killings are less moral than others. I think there's a practical reason for this, and at the very heart of it, it comes down to this: sometimes a person needs to be killed to prevent an even greater harm. The greater harm being life imprisonment? Or what are you talking about? It seems interesting to add this: On May 19 2011 07:13 Reason.SC2 wrote:On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote:On May 19 2011 06:09 MasterFischer wrote: Show nested quote +
Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it? Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral. What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. This is both hilarious and sad. I'm going to assume you're not aware of the myriad of cases where people have been declared innocent (or at least not guilty) in retrospect although already having been executed? Having it had happen even once should be more than enough... Just to play devil's advocate here... I think that our death penalty supporter is making the claim that killing a murderer is different (in a morally significant way) from killing an innocent person. He implies that you are saying that killing a murder and killing an innocent person are morally equivalent, and objects to this. To clarify: Do you think there is a morally significant difference between killing a murderer and an innocent? If so, why is it not ok to kill the murderer despite the act of killing him being "not as bad"? I agree with you that it is pretty much never ok to kill anyone, however am hesitant to take a categorical stance against killing people. I am sure that there exist circumstances in which killing someone is the right (morally speaking) thing to do. Maybe you can outline for MasterFischer what circumstances need to exist for killing a person to be permissible, and explain how those requirements are not met in the case of killing a detained murderer. As domovoi states, killing someone who's holding a knife to your family's throat can be considered different and is more morally accepted. Killing someone after this person has comitted the crime isn't, in my eyes. If it were, where do you draw the line? At best, it becomes more understandable. So let me get this straight. If I'm some kind of murderer holding a knife to your family's throat(s), then all I have to do is kill your family to prevent you from killing me?
They're different scenarios. One is while it is happening, the other is after the fact. In one you can kill because you would stop another killing from happening, the same exception (which in the first case makes it morally acceptable to kill) is not present in the latter case.
|
On May 19 2011 08:04 HellRoxYa wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 07:59 Barrin wrote:On May 19 2011 07:15 Passion wrote:On May 19 2011 07:09 domovoi wrote:On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote: Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral.
What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. A rather simplistic and naive view on the morality of killing. No modern society categorizes all killing as "murder," or at least not from a moral standpoint. In other words, some killings are more moral than others. Some killings are less moral than others. I think there's a practical reason for this, and at the very heart of it, it comes down to this: sometimes a person needs to be killed to prevent an even greater harm. The greater harm being life imprisonment? Or what are you talking about? It seems interesting to add this: On May 19 2011 07:13 Reason.SC2 wrote:On May 19 2011 07:01 HellRoxYa wrote:On May 19 2011 06:09 MasterFischer wrote: Show nested quote +
Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it? Actually, you don't seem to understand what I'm saying. I'm talking about ethics and what is right and wrong, morally. Yes, democracies can pass immoral laws in parliment in general, that doesn't suddenly make them moral. What I'm trying to make you realize is that murdering a murderer is still murder. That's the simplest way I can put it. If you still don't understand then I'm frankly very sorry for you. This is both hilarious and sad. I'm going to assume you're not aware of the myriad of cases where people have been declared innocent (or at least not guilty) in retrospect although already having been executed? Having it had happen even once should be more than enough... Just to play devil's advocate here... I think that our death penalty supporter is making the claim that killing a murderer is different (in a morally significant way) from killing an innocent person. He implies that you are saying that killing a murder and killing an innocent person are morally equivalent, and objects to this. To clarify: Do you think there is a morally significant difference between killing a murderer and an innocent? If so, why is it not ok to kill the murderer despite the act of killing him being "not as bad"? I agree with you that it is pretty much never ok to kill anyone, however am hesitant to take a categorical stance against killing people. I am sure that there exist circumstances in which killing someone is the right (morally speaking) thing to do. Maybe you can outline for MasterFischer what circumstances need to exist for killing a person to be permissible, and explain how those requirements are not met in the case of killing a detained murderer. As domovoi states, killing someone who's holding a knife to your family's throat can be considered different and is more morally accepted. Killing someone after this person has comitted the crime isn't, in my eyes. If it were, where do you draw the line? At best, it becomes more understandable. So let me get this straight. If I'm some kind of murderer holding a knife to your family's throat(s), then all I have to do is kill your family to prevent you from killing me? They're different scenarios. One is while it is happening, the other is after the fact. In one you can kill because you would stop another killing from happening, the same exception (which in the first case makes it morally acceptable to kill) is not present in the latter case. It works like this:
I've got a knife to your sister's throat.
I hear you coming. I know you have a gun. You will batter down the door in under ten seconds.
If I don't kill your sister, you will blow me away to protect her.
Therefore, I should immediately decapitate her for my own safety.
That way, when you show up, she's already dead, and you have no reason to kill me.
|
You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do 
How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really.
And HellRoxya.
I DO understand that you are trying to say, I just don't agree at all. You're sense of moral and equality hereof I don't agree with at all. So.
Who are you to say what's moral and what's not? What are you basing that on? Christianity? Instinct?
Killing somebody because they committed a horrible crime of murdering another person in cold blood, will never EVER be the same. In any universe. It just really won't.
If somebody ever killed my family or loved ones, I would make it my mission in life, to destroy them and see that their life will come to end and at some point in a near future. I would battle the justice, the press, everything, relentlessly, because taking a life, deserves fair justice. It's not about whether or not you get revenge, it's about making an example of how we deal with murderers as a society. Totally unacceptable and punishable by death.
|
On May 19 2011 08:11 MasterFischer wrote:You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do  How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really. No, it's not.
You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite.
It makes perfect logical sense.
|
On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:11 MasterFischer wrote:You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do  How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really. No, it's not. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. It makes perfect logical sense.
You kill them because they committed a crime. It's called a punishment. And thus, perhaps preventing further killings by this criminal in the future.
|
On May 19 2011 08:14 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote:On May 19 2011 08:11 MasterFischer wrote:You guys have a warped sense of realism, you really do  How in the hell is killing a criminal with a knife okay, and not killing a criminal that HAS actually already killed your family with the same knife? That's fucking retarded in terms of argument. Really. No, it's not. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. It makes perfect logical sense. You kill them because they committed a crime. It's called a punishment. And thus, perhaps preventing further killings by this criminal in the future. I understand your argument. I am not even against the death penalty.
What I am against is your "fucking retarded argument" that the following set of statements constitute a "fucking retarded argument."
1. You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening. 2. You shouldn't kill people out of spite or retribution.
|
On May 19 2011 08:12 EmeraldSparks wrote: You can kill people to prevent bad things from happening, but you can't kill them out of spite. What about from a standpoint of general application? Is it moral to have the death penalty to deter would-be murderers from murdering?
From a pragmatic standpoint, your system of morality would encourage would-be murderers to actually murder. Doesn't sound like a very ideal system.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|