What I'm trying to say is that etching this man is almost certainly not going to make the victim feel any better, but what is it going to do is reduce the number of similar future incidents.
Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 52
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
AcrossFiveJulys
United States3612 Posts
What I'm trying to say is that etching this man is almost certainly not going to make the victim feel any better, but what is it going to do is reduce the number of similar future incidents. | ||
|
Ravencruiser
Canada519 Posts
| ||
|
MozzarellaL
United States822 Posts
On May 21 2011 10:01 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: I'm in the camp of feeling that when a crime is proven without a shred of doubt to have been committed intentionally, that an "eye for an eye" type of punishment or worse is just. If deterrents to committing violent crimes and enforcement were efficient enough, I guarantee almost no violent crimes would ever be committed. What I'm trying to say is that etching this man is almost certainly not going to make the victim feel any better, but what is it going to do is reduce the number of similar future incidents. deterrents don't work, period. people have been devising new and innovative ways to punish people for crimes (stockades, the medieval 'pear', chopping off hands, public execution) -- if they worked why does crime still exist? It's laughable how people still cling to this misguided notion that deterrence actually does anything | ||
|
LetoAtreides82
United States1188 Posts
On May 21 2011 10:04 Ravencruiser wrote: So op hasn't been updated yet, any new developments on this? They postponed it indefinitely. | ||
|
Tor
Canada231 Posts
On May 21 2011 10:01 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: I'm in the camp of feeling that when a crime is proven without a shred of doubt to have been committed intentionally, that an "eye for an eye" type of punishment or worse is just. If deterrents to committing violent crimes and enforcement were efficient enough, I guarantee almost no violent crimes would ever be committed. What I'm trying to say is that etching this man is almost certainly not going to make the victim feel any better, but what is it going to do is reduce the number of similar future incidents. This is your opinion. General consensus on the death penalty is that it is not an effective deterrent. I couldn't find anything on the effectiveness of eye for an eye punishment I assume because its not actually used often (it would appear even Iranian judges view it barbaric). The main understanding I got from limited research is that the best deterrent is simply a society where it is hard to get away with crimes. Essentially the best deterrent would be more law enforcement and more effective law enforcement. To everyone saying retributive justice is an effective deterrent, you are all probably wrong, at the very least it is no more effective than jail time, and it could only be effective if enforced vigorously. The reality is, those arguing that putting acid in a mans face as punishment aren't actually arguing for eye for an eye justice, they generally appear to be arguing for harsh punishments in general. They seem to view jail time as lenient for some strange reason. Everyone can say stealing 50$, getting caught, and receiving a 50$ fine in return is an eye for an eye, but is it really effective at punishing the person? Maybe if they are guaranteed to get caught, but all they have to do is get away with stealing another 50$ and they break even, in which case they would have to be treated harsher. An effective deterrent would have to be put in place. An eye for an eye then wouldn't be enough. Please do the smallest amount of research. Violent crimes that occur in western societies are generally caused by people not considering the consequences of their actions, they have already decided to ignore powerful deterrents. Believe it or not 25 years to life in prison is a pretty damn big deterrent. Now let's get hypothetical, for arguments sake we'll say we've argued that blinding someone is as good a deterrent as jail time. (could be, but it has nothing to do with eye for an eye) Is it better to promote a culture of vengeance, retaliation and violence, or is it better to promote one of deterrence, rehabilitation and prevention? Is it alright to give the state the right to kill or torture or maim? Should we suggest the criminal will never reform, never learn from their mistake without a physical reminder? How much leeway do you give judges and juries? Is it okay to support capital punishment for murderers even if a small fraction of those put to death are innocent? Is torture ever ethical (torture beingin: using acid as a punishment). Does torture bring solace to the victim? Does torture replace jail time or go WITH jail time? Does torture prevent re-offending or does it encouraged re-offending and who gets to be the judge of that? And is it alright to tell our children that if someone hits you, you should hit them back instead of addressing why they hit you, can you trust your children to make that judgment call? Can you trust your government? I could go on and on, torture and capital punishment ask a lot out of a government, a judge and a jury. It also says a lot about a culture which finds it okay to devalue a persons life if the people in power deem it so. Especially about a culture that when given alternatives that work just as well, it decides that cruelty and violence are preferable to compassion and rehabilitation. edited for clarity | ||
|
redux46
Canada92 Posts
On May 21 2011 10:45 Tor wrote: Now let's get hypothetical, for arguments sake we'll say we've argued that blinding someone is as good a deterrent as jail time. (could be, but it as nothing to do with eye for an eye) Is it better to promote a culture of vengeance, retaliation and violence, or is it better to promote one of deterrence, rehabilitation and prevention? Is it alright to give the state the right to kill or torture or maim? Should we suggest the criminal will never reform, never learn from their mistake without a physical reminder? How much leeway do you give judges and juries? Is it okay to support capital punishment for murderers even if a small fraction of those put to death are innocent? Is torture ever ethical (in the case of using acid as a punishment). Does torture bring solace to the victim? Does torture replace jail time or go WITH jail time? Does torture prevent re-offending or does it encouraged re-offending and who is the judge? And is it alright to tell our children that if someone hits you, you should hit them back instead of addressing why they hit you, can you trust your children to make that judgment call? Can you trust your government? I would argue it's not an either or. Using methods of punishment outside of jail time such as whipping does not preclude rehabilitation. I would agree with you that deterrence is best achieved when the criminal feels there is a high probability of being caught. However, achieving this has its own set of problems. Employing far more cops on the streets and video surveillance in a time of budget cuts may not be politically viable and it creates its own privacy issue. Moving on, the issue of rehabilitation though noble in theory has shown to be very difficult to achieve. The recidivism rate is remarkably high (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism#Studies ) and research has shown the personality traits are more or less set after reaching adulthood. | ||
|
Tor
Canada231 Posts
I would agree with you that deterrence is best achieved when the criminal feels there is a high probability of being caught. However, achieving this has its own set of problems. Employing far more cops on the streets and video surveillance in a time of budget cuts may not be politically viable and it creates its own privacy issue. Everything has problems, the point is to aim for incremental improvements or serious reform in the search of improvements. We happen to live in a time where we have the luxury to aim for noble solutions. I don't need to argue for the best solution, I only need to argue that eye for an eye punishment is bad, and that we have better solutions already available. I personally believe the American prison system has a great deal of flaws. But I still believe it is better than a system based on vengeance (which is what many people seem to be abdicating despite it not really existing even in Iran) The Wikipedia article also suggests most causes of recidivism are based on a culture of intolerance towards criminals. Suggesting a culture emphasizing vengeance or retaliation is antithetical to rehabilitation. Causes It has been suggested that for many decades, correctional observers did not give priority to the reality that offenders who reenter society face a varied assortment of daunting challenges that predictably lead to high recidivism rates. Various researchers also noted that prisoners are stripped of civil rights and are reluctantly absorbed into communities which leads to their further alienation and isolation. A final factor when looking at the causes of recidivism is the difficulty of a released offender when faced with finding a job, renting an apartment or getting an education. Owners of business will often refuse to hire a convicted felon, and are at best hesitant, especially in any position that entails even minor responsibility or the handling of money (note that this includes most work), especially to those convicted of thievery, such as larceny, or drug addicts.[16] Many leasing corporations (those organisations and/or people who own and rent apartments) now routinely perform criminal background checks and disqualify ex-convicts (although many apartments, especially in the inner city or in areas with high crime rates, even if having such an official policy, do not follow it, or it leads to a situation where apartments are held in the name of a someone other than the occupant without a felony record). People with criminal records report difficulty or the inability to find educational opportunities, and are often denied financial aid based on their records. In America, those found guilty of even a minor misdemeanor (in some states, a citation offense, such as a traffic ticket) or misdemeanour drug offence (for example, simple possession of marijuana or heroin, respectively) are disqualified from receiving all government-funded educational loans and financial aid | ||
|
redux46
Canada92 Posts
On May 21 2011 11:50 Tor wrote: Everything has problems, the point is to aim for incremental improvements or serious reform in the search of improvements. We happen to live in a time where we have the luxury to aim for noble solutions. I don't need to argue for the best solution, I only need to argue that eye for an eye punishment is bad, and that we have better solutions already available. I personally believe the American prison system has a great deal of flaws. But I still believe it is better than a system based on vengeance (which is what many people seem to be abdicating despite it not really existing even in Iran) The Wikipedia article also suggests most causes of recidivism are based on a culture of intolerance towards criminals. Suggesting a culture emphasizing vengeance or retaliation is antithetical to rehabilitation. "Eye for an eye" is a broad statement. At its core, it's an argument for proportionality, which any notion of justice must incorporate. Western civilization has evolved to the point where sensibilities dictate it is more "civilized" to imprison a criminal than to apply physical pain. I would argue that it's not at all clear which is a harsher form of sentencing, a society where a robber receives 10 years in jail plus 100 whippings (Iran) or one where he spend 20 years. If its disturbing that so many people in this thread profess sympathy for the blinding sentencing its that the rehabilitation method you are arguing for effectively means that tax payers would effectively be paying large costs in order to organize group therapy meetings to teach the person responsible for disfiguring this women why it is that throwing acid on someone's face is morally wrong. | ||
|
David451
United States491 Posts
Let me explain with some logic. ![]() Let's assume that if your expected value of a crime E is greater than the cost C, you'll commit the crime. Let the cost consist of P=punishment, L=likelihood of getting caught, G is the guilt you would feel for committing the crime, D=difficulty of pulling off the crime, and A=how aware you are of these variables. Then if E > ( P * L + G ) * D * A, the crime will be committed. If I can assume that the likelihood of getting caught (L) was lower, then the punishment (P) would have to be higher to compensate. If smoking marijuana was punishable by death and not a slap on the wrist, do you really think it would be as common as it is? Likewise, I download TV and music because the likelihood of getting caught is lower than being struck by lightning. If people left and right were actually being fined and jailed for copyright infringement, you better believe than the amount of it would go down, or people would take further precautionary measures to not get caught. Addendum: why is prison not considered punishment, or revenge? It absolutely is. If I evade taxes, does putting me in jail really accomplish anything other than deterring other people from evading taxes? Finally, is going to jail for 10 years less of a punishment than 100 lashings with a whip? Just because jail is the punishment of Western society doesn't make it morally superior to whipping or whatever other misery you can come up with. EDIT: It's P * L, not P / L | ||
|
MozzarellaL
United States822 Posts
On May 21 2011 15:56 David451 wrote: I really don't buy all these arguments that torture in the middle ages didn't deter crimes. In the middle ages, it was probably somewhat easier to get away with serious crimes--fewer police, no FBI, no cameras, etc. Who is talking about the middle ages? What about the classical era? During the Roman Empire, during the Roman Republic? Or the contemporaneous Islamic Caliphate The level of sophistication of public institutions back then rivaled that of the modern age. And they did things like cut off people's hands for stealing, and publically crucifying other criminals. Let me explain with some logic. ![]() Let's assume that if your expected value of a crime E is greater than the cost C, you'll commit the crime. Let the cost consist of P=punishment, L=likelihood of getting caught, G is the guilt you would feel for committing the crime, D=difficulty of pulling off the crime, and A=how aware you are of these variables. Then if E > ( P / L + G ) * D * A, the crime will be committed. Your logic is garbage, what is the expected value of killing someone? Of raping someone while drunk? Of conspiring to rob a bank? Giving crime your economic risk-benefit analysis is a joke. If smoking marijuana was punishable by death and not a slap on the wrist, do you really think it would be as common as it is? Yes. Because the police generally don't care if you smoke pot. Likewise, I download TV and music because the likelihood of getting caught is lower than being struck by lightning. If people left and right were actually being fined and jailed for copyright infringement, you better believe than the amount of it would go down, or people would take further precautionary measures to not get caught. Downloading music and movies isn't a fineable or jailable offense to begin with, it isn't even criminal, your point is not taken. Addendum: why is prison not considered punishment, or revenge? It absolutely is. If I evade taxes, does putting me in jail really accomplish anything other than deterring other people from evading taxes? It is considered punishment. It is punitive by law. It is not revenge, because in modern legal systems, the person victimized by the crime has no say in how the punishment is carried out, or what the punishment is. Learn English. Finally, is going to jail for 10 years less of a punishment than 100 lashings with a whip? Just because jail is the punishment of Western society doesn't make it morally superior to whipping or whatever other misery you can come up with. Whipping people for a crime is not a uniform punishment. What if the whipper woke up one day with arthritis but gave out whippings anyway, what if one day the whipper woke up pissed because his wife used her teeth that morning? In any case, punishment which forces the criminal to receive medical care as a result, and can cause serious injury may be considered cruel or unusual punishment. Moral superiority has nothing to do with something that is barred by the US Constitution and modern law (in other countries). | ||
|
Trang
Australia324 Posts
On May 21 2011 15:56 David451 wrote: I really don't buy all these arguments that torture in the middle ages didn't deter crimes. In the middle ages, it was probably somewhat easier to get away with serious crimes--fewer police, no FBI, no cameras, etc. Let me explain with some logic. ![]() Let's assume that if your expected value of a crime E is greater than the cost C, you'll commit the crime. Let the cost consist of P=punishment, L=likelihood of getting caught, G is the guilt you would feel for committing the crime, D=difficulty of pulling off the crime, and A=how aware you are of these variables. Then if E > ( P / L + G ) * D * A, the crime will be committed. If I can assume that the likelihood of getting caught (L) was lower, then the punishment (P) would have to be higher to compensate. If smoking marijuana was punishable by death and not a slap on the wrist, do you really think it would be as common as it is? Likewise, I download TV and music because the likelihood of getting caught is lower than being struck by lightning. If people left and right were actually being fined and jailed for copyright infringement, you better believe than the amount of it would go down, or people would take further precautionary measures to not get caught. Addendum: why is prison not considered punishment, or revenge? It absolutely is. If I evade taxes, does putting me in jail really accomplish anything other than deterring other people from evading taxes? Finally, is going to jail for 10 years less of a punishment than 100 lashings with a whip? Just because jail is the punishment of Western society doesn't make it morally superior to whipping or whatever other misery you can come up with. The big flaw in your argument is that you're assuming we can look at all crimes the same. Violent crimes, especially crimes of passion (eg violence, rape, as a result of intense emotional impulses) are done for completely different motivations than crimes like theft. While in the latter case, or the examples you cited (possession of drugs, or piracy), perpetrators will tend to think more of the consequences of getting caught, people tend not to think about those things before committing the former. You really can't make class all crimes together as one. Deterrence in criminal justice is a vastly complex and controversial topic, which academics from many fields of expertise cannot find consensus on. It baffles me that people on this thread think they can make blanket statements as some clearly self-evident matter of fact ... | ||
|
laurine90
Serbia33 Posts
though an improvment you should do not the exact same thing as he did it 1st so like she didnt pick to get acidified she should have the right to just go and kill some of his relativ aswell | ||
|
David451
United States491 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:19 Trang wrote: The big flaw in your argument is that you're assuming we can look at all crimes the same. Violent crimes, especially crimes of passion (eg violence, rape, as a result of intense emotional impulses) are done for completely different motivations than crimes like theft. While in the latter case, or the examples you cited (possession of drugs, or piracy), perpetrators will tend to think more of the consequences of getting caught, people tend not to think about those things before committing the former. You really can't make class all crimes together as one. Deterrence in criminal justice is a vastly complex and controversial topic, which academics from many fields of expertise cannot find consensus on. It baffles me that people on this thread think they can make blanket statements as some clearly self-evident matter of fact ... While attempting to use logic in a thread like this is akin to using logic to change someone's mind about abortion, I feel it's fair to point out that I took into account the state of the perpetrator's mind with variable A="how aware you are of these variables." In crimes of passion this will be low--possibly so low that no amount of P could make up for it. | ||
|
Blasterion
China10272 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:31 David451 wrote: While attempting to use logic in a thread like this is akin to using logic to change someone's mind about abortion, I feel it's fair to point out that I took into account the state of the perpetrator's mind with variable A="how aware you are of these variables." In crimes of passion this will be low--possibly so low that no amount of P could make up for it. beh Jails aren't great solutions, make the criminals work their asses of for us law abidding citizens, after they have done their share of labor and contributed to society then release. Having them sit in jail is no good. | ||
|
MozzarellaL
United States822 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:31 David451 wrote: While attempting to use logic in a thread like this is akin to using logic to change someone's mind about abortion, I feel it's fair to point out that I took into account the state of the perpetrator's mind with variable A="how aware you are of these variables." In crimes of passion this will be low--possibly so low that no amount of P could make up for it. As many people who commit crimes of passion are lawyers, police officers, as well as other highly educated individuals I'm sure their A is very high, if not 100%. | ||
|
Vul
United States685 Posts
Let's assume that if your expected value of a crime E is greater than the cost C, you'll commit the crime. Let the cost consist of P=punishment, L=likelihood of getting caught, G is the guilt you would feel for committing the crime, D=difficulty of pulling off the crime, and A=how aware you are of these variables. You need to justify why we would accept this paradigm. It looks like a rationalistic, homo economicus model. Don't you think it's been reasonably well established that people don't always make decisions based on a strict cost benefit analysis? And to people saying that deterrence doesn't work--that's crazy. Obviously to some extent deterrence does work. No one can realistically say that punishments for breaking the law don't deter people from breaking the law. The question is whether increasing the penalty for certain crimes actually has an effect. | ||
|
David451
United States491 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:17 MozzarellaL wrote: Who is talking about the middle ages? What about the classical era? During the Roman Empire, during the Roman Republic? Or the contemporaneous Islamic Caliphate The level of sophistication of public institutions back then rivaled that of the modern age. And they did things like cut off people's hands for stealing, and publically crucifying other criminals. Your logic is garbage, what is the expected value of killing someone? Of raping someone while drunk? Of conspiring to rob a bank? Giving crime your economic risk-benefit analysis is a joke. Satisfaction, money, lust, revenge, who knows. It's subjective to the perpetrator, and therefore not particularly helpful to try to quantify it outside of that. Notice that all the other variables are also subjective to the perpetrator so the logic holds. You're claiming that L is low enough that P doesn't matter. That backs my logic. Downloading music and movies isn't a fineable or jailable offense to begin with, it isn't even criminal, your point is not taken. Nevermind that downloading music and movies is a fineable offense, the nature of the punishment is immaterial to the logic. It is considered punishment. It is punitive by law. It is not revenge, because in modern legal systems, the person victimized by the crime has no say in how the punishment is carried out, or what the punishment is. Learn English. Thanks to you, I decided to look up the definition of revenge. One of them was "to inflict hurt or harm on someone for an injury or wrong done to oneself or another." (source: Google Dictionary). Seems my English is fine, but hopefully we will not continue to debate my command of English. Whipping people for a crime is not a uniform punishment. What if the whipper woke up one day with arthritis but gave out whippings anyway, what if one day the whipper woke up pissed because his wife used her teeth that morning? In any case, punishment which forces the criminal to receive medical care as a result, and can cause serious injury may be considered cruel or unusual punishment. Moral superiority has nothing to do with something that is barred by the US Constitution and modern law (in other countries). Are you trying to argue for the moral superiority of prison because it does not cause physical harm? I'd take 100 lashings over 10 years of prison anyday. Perhaps you are arguing that prison is morally superior because it's more uniform. This is a poor argument, because some prisoners are treated very well, some very poor. | ||
|
David451
United States491 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:41 MozzarellaL wrote: As many people who commit crimes of passion are lawyers, police officers, as well as other highly educated individuals I'm sure their A is very high, if not 100%. I do appreciate that you are engaging the logic on its merits, without a knee-jerk reaction. A crime of passion is necessarily something that is not premeditated. Therefore, their accuracy A with calculating the consequences in-the-heat-of-the-moment might be low (the punishment might not even cross their mind during their flash of anger)--alternatively, one could argue that the satisfaction E they receive from consummating their passion is extraordinarily high. Like scratching the biggest itch you've ever had. | ||
|
David451
United States491 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:52 Vul wrote: You need to justify why we would accept this paradigm. It looks like a rationalistic, homo economicus model. It's just a model. You either intuitively agree with it, or you don't. It's an axiom, a statement of belief. I will make no attempt to convince you of its correctness. Don't you think it's been reasonably well established that people don't always make decisions based on a strict cost benefit analysis? The equation is subjective to the individuaI. I did not assume rationality. The lower their rationality, the more skewed their perception of the variables are. A criminally insane person might have vastly distorted variables when compared to a "sane" person. I am not attempting to state what the values of the variables are, or that we can even possibly attempt to. I do find it quite fascinating that crimes of acid splashing decreased remarkably after this verdict was handed out. | ||
|
MozzarellaL
United States822 Posts
On May 21 2011 16:52 David451 wrote: Satisfaction, money, lust, revenge, who knows. It's subjective to the perpetrator, and therefore not particularly helpful to try to quantify it outside of that. Notice that all the other variables are also subjective to the perpetrator so the logic holds. It cannot be quantified, so your equation cannot be proved. It has no use beyond 'theorycrafting' the mind of a criminal. It also assumes the criminal is a rational creature, which is ridiculous because humans do not act rationally. No it doesn't. Likelihood of enforcement is not the same as likelihood of being caught. The mere fact that you left out a 'likelihood of enforcement or conviction' variable shows the weakness of your 'logic' which isn't even logic, but an attempt to mathematically represent how people act. Nevermind that downloading music and movies is a fineable offense, the nature of the punishment is immaterial to the logic. It is not a fineable offense. Cite the laws which allow the government to fine someone for downloading music in violation of copyright law. It is considered punishment. It is punitive by law. It is not revenge, because in modern legal systems, the person victimized by the crime has no say in how the punishment is carried out, or what the punishment is. Learn English. Thanks to you, I decided to look up the definition of revenge. One of them was "to inflict hurt or harm on someone for an injury or wrong done to oneself or another." (source: Google Dictionary). Seems my English is fine, but hopefully we will not continue to debate my command of English. My point still stands. The state has no interest in 'inflicting hurt or harm' on another for injury or wrong done to one of its citizens or residents. Prosecutors represent the government, not the victim. Furthermore, legislators would not have moved the criminal penal system from one that administered corporal punishment to one that incarcerated criminals if they wanted vengeance as opposed to punishment. Are you trying to argue for the moral superiority of prison because it does not cause physical harm? I'd take 100 lashings over 10 years of prison anyday. Perhaps you are arguing that prison is morally superior because it's more uniform. This is a poor argument, because some prisoners are treated very well, some very poor. How do you interpret "Moral superiority has nothing to do..." to mean "prisons are morally superior to corporal punishment". I even suggested that a country's own laws prevent it from administering corporal punishment, yet you bring morality into this? What on earth do they have to do with each other? Learn English, seriously. wtf | ||
| ||
