|
On May 21 2011 17:21 MozzarellaL wrote:Show nested quote +On May 21 2011 16:52 David451 wrote: Satisfaction, money, lust, revenge, who knows. It's subjective to the perpetrator, and therefore not particularly helpful to try to quantify it outside of that. Notice that all the other variables are also subjective to the perpetrator so the logic holds. It cannot be quantified, so your equation cannot be proved. It has no use beyond 'theorycrafting' the mind of a criminal.
It is an axiom, I do not attempt to prove it. It is merely a statement of belief. The fact you disagree with it makes it clear you do not accept the belief. I'm fine with that. I just wanted my belief to be clear. 
It also assumes the criminal is a rational creature, which is ridiculous because humans do not act rationally.
It makes no such assumption. It only assumes that humans respond to incentives. It makes no statement as to their ability to ascertain what these are, or even that they are aware of them. I make no claim as to rationality, merely that people do things that please them.
|
On May 21 2011 17:30 David451 wrote:It is an axiom, I do not attempt to prove it. It is merely a statement of belief. The fact you disagree with it makes it clear you do not accept the belief. I'm fine with that. I just wanted my belief to be clear.  Then don't call it logical. You don't know what logic is. You start off with assumptions, and reach a conclusion from those assumptions. Saying 'you don't need to prove it' implies you did not use any logic to arrive at that conclusion.
It makes no such assumption. It only assumes that humans respond to incentives. It makes no statement as to their ability to ascertain what these are, or even that they are aware of them. I make no claim as to rationality, merely that people do things that please them. Wrong. Your equation is no different that the rationality argument economists put forth (X will do A if A benefits him more than B, and X will do B if B benefits him more than A, X will not do anything if he does not know between A and B, and X will be indifferent if A is the same as B.) This rationality assumption has been proven false empirically.
|
So if it is a women choice its 'Okay' if it was the man choice it would have been 'Cruel' lol... Although i do understant the women thoughts, she just wants revenge. I do think that the law is stupid.
|
On May 14 2011 08:52 Jerubaal wrote: There's a big difference between justice and retribution.
Death penalty is exactly as stupid as this whole story.
|
|
|
Even though this seems morally wrong,the punishment should go through to set an example,so that others think twice before doing nonsense such as this. It's not a matter of vengeance but he ruined the woman's life completely on a wimp,therefore something must be done to avoid it happening again as much as possible.
It's fine and dandy to sit back as third persons and say it's wrong and what not,but put yourself in the woman's place.If you could, wouldn't you have done the same thing or something to protect others from the same fate as yours?
|
did she do it, i want to know
|
I just want to say that the eye for an eye system is to discourage people from doing evil heinous acts. For example the killing of a murderer is one thing I strongly support. Imagine if we killed all the prisoners serving 2/3 life sentences because they committed so many murders, we would have a lot emptier jails and more money to spend on important things like education and infrastructure.
|
On June 02 2011 02:41 phANT1m wrote: I just want to say that the eye for an eye system is to discourage people from doing evil heinous acts. For example the killing of a murderer is one thing I strongly support. Imagine if we killed all the prisoners serving 2/3 life sentences because they committed so many murders, we would have a lot emptier jails and more money to spend on important things like education and infrastructure. I whole heartedly agree. I don't think that killing someone for committing one murder is justified or acceptable. We need to give "wiggle-room" for mistakes in the justice system, along with false accusations that went through. However, someone who has murdered many people and there is little or no doubt about that, should be killed. A one time murderer should face a long prison sentence or life sentence.
An eye for an eye is the most equal system. You kill, you die. You steal, you should have something you treasure taken from you, to instigate empathy. This husband is learning the hard way that pouring acid on someones eye's actually does hurt and permanently mutilate you. If he had any sense he wouldn't have done it in the first place. I say to let the fucker feel it. Alternatively, they could put him under the anesthetics and let him suffer through the constant fear of knowing that when he wakes up he might be mutilated and blind, and there is nothing he could do about it. Suffering through that fear is quite possibly worse.
|
On June 02 2011 02:51 Kinetik_Inferno wrote: An eye for an eye is the most equal system. You kill, you die. You steal, you should have something you treasure taken from you, to instigate empathy. This husband is learning the hard way that pouring acid on someones eye's actually does hurt and permanently mutilate you. If he had any sense he wouldn't have done it in the first place. I say to let the fucker feel it. Alternatively, they could put him under the anesthetics and let him suffer through the constant fear of knowing that when he wakes up he might be mutilated and blind, and there is nothing he could do about it. Suffering through that fear is quite possibly worse. Is it? Let's say A has a family who is dependent on him.
A murders B, who lives alone and has no dependents.
Eye for an eye necessitates A's death, which leaves his family out on the street.
Equality rules.
|
On June 02 2011 04:48 MozzarellaL wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2011 02:51 Kinetik_Inferno wrote: An eye for an eye is the most equal system. You kill, you die. You steal, you should have something you treasure taken from you, to instigate empathy. This husband is learning the hard way that pouring acid on someones eye's actually does hurt and permanently mutilate you. If he had any sense he wouldn't have done it in the first place. I say to let the fucker feel it. Alternatively, they could put him under the anesthetics and let him suffer through the constant fear of knowing that when he wakes up he might be mutilated and blind, and there is nothing he could do about it. Suffering through that fear is quite possibly worse. Is it? Let's say A has a family who is dependent on him. A murders B, who lives alone and has no dependents. Eye for an eye necessitates A's death, which leaves his family out on the street. Equality rules.
I don't know exactly how the prison system works, but my understanding is that if A was put in prison, or if he was executed, punished by serving sentence isolated from the public, forced into solitary confinement, or unable to work and provide a steady income for his family, they would be living on the streets regardless no? If you're in prison, you can't work, nor can you produce anything but a deficit in the legal system and whatever social security system provides for your family. I was bringing up the point of how you determine exactly how long someone stays in prison for, assuming that he killed one person? The value of the other person? How much income did the other person have? An eye for an eye is the closest to equal system we could have.
Mathematically, the input of "I murdered some" can produce outputs that range wildly from life sentence to 20 years, to 10 years, to 5 years. I'm not saying that if someone killed, they should die, as many murders are by confused and estranged people who made a mistake, but if someone killed multiple times without doubt, is it really a mistake?
|
bump
Looks like the women did end up forgiving him
Source
|
"Last week, a young woman died after a man poured acid on her face for rejecting his marriage proposal. Her attacker remains at large." - THIS MAKES ME SOOOO MADDDDDDDDDDD
Taken from the article where it says she forgave him...
And where are these guys getting all this fking acid? Can you buy it at the supermarket over there?
I feel so sorry for all the women that are born in to that world. Oh my god.
|
I dont see how you can forgive someone for that. Gosh im glad I live in canada.
|
Really don't understand how you could "forgive" someone for something like this, hell it didn't even happen to me and I still couldn't forgive this worthless piece of shit.
|
On May 14 2011 08:49 Malgrif wrote:i'd say that was QUITE the observation. it's the woman's fault though. she shouldn't have made him fall in love with her. User was temp banned for this post.
That is unbelievable that someone would even say that...
|
On August 01 2011 00:52 mesohawny wrote: "Last week, a young woman died after a man poured acid on her face for rejecting his marriage proposal. Her attacker remains at large." - THIS MAKES ME SOOOO MADDDDDDDDDDD
Taken from the article where it says she forgave him...
And where are these guys getting all this fking acid? Can you buy it at the supermarket over there?
I feel so sorry for all the women that are born in to that world. Oh my god.
It's very easy to make acid, if you have a basic knowledge of chemistry.
|
And where are these guys getting all this fking acid? Can you buy it at the supermarket over there?
Probably getting from car batteries which is sulfuric acid.
|
Her face has been disfigured and her eyesight has been significantly reduced to next-to blindness.
the woman is allowed to exact her revenge onto the man by dripping acid into the eyes of him as well ( while he is sedated and in a controlled amount and enviro[n]ment )
hardly an 'eye for an eye'. It seems to be the woman should be entitled to dumping a vat of acid onto his face. I do not see why you would call this retribution=> The woman cannot see and virtually cannot love at the cause of one envious man just like you or me,albeit an extremist. Leave it at sweet justice and let the acid carve tears into his face. The bright side is the direct effect this incident had on possible offenders..
|
On August 01 2011 01:10 FLu wrote:Show nested quote +On August 01 2011 00:52 mesohawny wrote: "Last week, a young woman died after a man poured acid on her face for rejecting his marriage proposal. Her attacker remains at large." - THIS MAKES ME SOOOO MADDDDDDDDDDD
Taken from the article where it says she forgave him...
And where are these guys getting all this fking acid? Can you buy it at the supermarket over there?
I feel so sorry for all the women that are born in to that world. Oh my god.
It's very easy to make acid, if you have a basic knowledge of chemistry.
...It's definitely not 'easy' to make acid, no matter how good you are at Chemistry. And I agree with her decision. An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
|
|
|
|
|
|