|
On May 19 2011 04:08 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:00 Belphegor13 wrote:To take a human life, to inflict pain upon others, is always wrong, regardless of the circumstances. Yes, this is an idealistic way of thinking. But as long as we think in terms of "an eye for an eye" and that this is necessary, violence and death will exist. Surely crime will not go away because we stop punishing it with equally brutal methods, but I believe that we, by employing that kind of brutallity, increases our tolerance to violence. If we say it is justice in this case, it might be justice in other cases, were do we draw the line? On May 18 2011 20:30 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 20:22 Olinim wrote:On May 18 2011 20:16 MasterFischer wrote: And don't give me that shit about rehabilitation and what not in prison. Doesn't fucking work.
What works is FEAR, in order to deal with criminals on their terms, you have to use their tactics and their line of thought, fear. They don't give a fuck about the system or jail-time probaly, they laugh at the system.
They might think otherwise if they have fucking acid poured into their face... like..
ohoh... maybe I shouldn't totally go and do this crime just now ..eh??? Might get fucking acid in my fucking stupid criminal face... oh well... I'll just leave it.. aint worth it. Too scared. I don't wanna die.. bla bla... see?
You get the criminal to think about consequences and how THEY would like it, if somebody did it to THEM?
It's fair. So your genius plan to stop criminals and prove their actions are wrong... is to do exactly what they do. Hmm. We as a society are reactionary. We act upon others actions. This is the way it is. Why is punishment by death or otherwise wrong? Do you think criminals have a patent on killing another human? They don't. They just choose to do it. We act upon their choosing. Has nothing to do with the act itself or the punishment. but if you think you control other peoples lives by taking it away from them, then you deserve to pay with your own. always. Nobody has the right to take another life without permission, and if they do, they must and should be willing to trade in their life aswell.. Those are the terms. Fairly simply, pretty fair and just. What does sending them to jail do? Nothing. It costs society money, it costs time and ressources on lowlifes. We are so many people in the world, we got no fucking time to deal with each little fucking miserable scrub that thinks he or she is the king of the world by taking lives. Millions die everyday from big issues like hunger, poverty, accidents, natural diseasters and what not.. and you're telling me I should fucking care about 1 criminal scrub who deserves what he got? No. I don't. Don't fuck me with me, and I won't fuck with you. It's so simple and logical, that if you're too fucking dumb as a person to figure out the basics of human morality and life, you deserve to be put to rest. The end. Your last sentence strikes me as an excellent example. "If you are stupid and (therefore) disagree with me, you should be killed." While I'm sure this is not a serious threat and not something you actually would do, this kind of thinking is problematic. I mean, if we are already killing murderers, cutting the penis of rapist and chopping the hands of thieves, and we understand that is an acceptable method in society. Maybe you believe someone should really die? Yeah, if I think he deserves it, he should. On the other hand, if you keep a no-tolerance mindset, that thought would never be possible. What does having this mindset effect crime rates? Not much, probably. But if no one put's one's foot down, and says; "I will not take a human life" who will? The answer is, no one. Do you really think criminals give a shit, that you put your foot down and say.. oh oh.. the world is made of roseberries and rainbows.. let's not kill anybody shall we ?? pleaseeee?? Murder, rape, torture, poverty all these things.. they go on and on.. and they will NEVER.. EVER fucking go away... ever.. understand?
So why not start punishing the crimes in a fair manner, instead of giving lee-way to murders. You know kind of message you are sending to criminals if you don't want them to suffer? I'll tell ya, "Oh please, do more crime, we don't wanna punish you, it's wrong you know?"... Criminals will be okay... fine, so while I rape your sister and kill your father with a knife, think REAL hard about not punishing me okay?... cool story bro.. THIS.DOES.NOT.WORK... It's not ACCEPTABLE in society, it's acceptable as a punishment for doing wrong, as a punishment by the government and legal justice system. Not by common men. There is a huge fucking difference, and most MOST normal people understand this. we grant the government and the police, authority, to use force that is otherwise illegal to us citizens e.g. deadly force, the death penalty. We live in a democracy.
How about you put the two bolded parts together.
+ Show Spoiler +Bonus: Criminals don't count on being caught.
|
On May 19 2011 04:35 HellRoxYa wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:08 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 21:00 Belphegor13 wrote:To take a human life, to inflict pain upon others, is always wrong, regardless of the circumstances. Yes, this is an idealistic way of thinking. But as long as we think in terms of "an eye for an eye" and that this is necessary, violence and death will exist. Surely crime will not go away because we stop punishing it with equally brutal methods, but I believe that we, by employing that kind of brutallity, increases our tolerance to violence. If we say it is justice in this case, it might be justice in other cases, were do we draw the line? On May 18 2011 20:30 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 20:22 Olinim wrote:On May 18 2011 20:16 MasterFischer wrote: And don't give me that shit about rehabilitation and what not in prison. Doesn't fucking work.
What works is FEAR, in order to deal with criminals on their terms, you have to use their tactics and their line of thought, fear. They don't give a fuck about the system or jail-time probaly, they laugh at the system.
They might think otherwise if they have fucking acid poured into their face... like..
ohoh... maybe I shouldn't totally go and do this crime just now ..eh??? Might get fucking acid in my fucking stupid criminal face... oh well... I'll just leave it.. aint worth it. Too scared. I don't wanna die.. bla bla... see?
You get the criminal to think about consequences and how THEY would like it, if somebody did it to THEM?
It's fair. So your genius plan to stop criminals and prove their actions are wrong... is to do exactly what they do. Hmm. We as a society are reactionary. We act upon others actions. This is the way it is. Why is punishment by death or otherwise wrong? Do you think criminals have a patent on killing another human? They don't. They just choose to do it. We act upon their choosing. Has nothing to do with the act itself or the punishment. but if you think you control other peoples lives by taking it away from them, then you deserve to pay with your own. always. Nobody has the right to take another life without permission, and if they do, they must and should be willing to trade in their life aswell.. Those are the terms. Fairly simply, pretty fair and just. What does sending them to jail do? Nothing. It costs society money, it costs time and ressources on lowlifes. We are so many people in the world, we got no fucking time to deal with each little fucking miserable scrub that thinks he or she is the king of the world by taking lives. Millions die everyday from big issues like hunger, poverty, accidents, natural diseasters and what not.. and you're telling me I should fucking care about 1 criminal scrub who deserves what he got? No. I don't. Don't fuck me with me, and I won't fuck with you. It's so simple and logical, that if you're too fucking dumb as a person to figure out the basics of human morality and life, you deserve to be put to rest. The end. Your last sentence strikes me as an excellent example. "If you are stupid and (therefore) disagree with me, you should be killed." While I'm sure this is not a serious threat and not something you actually would do, this kind of thinking is problematic. I mean, if we are already killing murderers, cutting the penis of rapist and chopping the hands of thieves, and we understand that is an acceptable method in society. Maybe you believe someone should really die? Yeah, if I think he deserves it, he should. On the other hand, if you keep a no-tolerance mindset, that thought would never be possible. What does having this mindset effect crime rates? Not much, probably. But if no one put's one's foot down, and says; "I will not take a human life" who will? The answer is, no one. Do you really think criminals give a shit, that you put your foot down and say.. oh oh.. the world is made of roseberries and rainbows.. let's not kill anybody shall we ?? pleaseeee?? Murder, rape, torture, poverty all these things.. they go on and on.. and they will NEVER.. EVER fucking go away... ever.. understand?
So why not start punishing the crimes in a fair manner, instead of giving lee-way to murders. You know kind of message you are sending to criminals if you don't want them to suffer? I'll tell ya, "Oh please, do more crime, we don't wanna punish you, it's wrong you know?"... Criminals will be okay... fine, so while I rape your sister and kill your father with a knife, think REAL hard about not punishing me okay?... cool story bro.. THIS.DOES.NOT.WORK... It's not ACCEPTABLE in society, it's acceptable as a punishment for doing wrong, as a punishment by the government and legal justice system. Not by common men. There is a huge fucking difference, and most MOST normal people understand this. we grant the government and the police, authority, to use force that is otherwise illegal to us citizens e.g. deadly force, the death penalty. We live in a democracy. How about you put the two bolded parts together. + Show Spoiler +Bonus: Criminals don't count on being caught.
No, but I can assure you, they think about IF they do.
|
On May 19 2011 04:42 MasterFischer wrote: No, but I can assure you, they think about IF they do.
The legal system isn't 100% accurate in handing out convictions.
Your entire argument fails.
|
On May 19 2011 04:32 Passion wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:10 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.) Exactly my man. by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment. Exactly, we decide your "punishment". And we're not like you, so we handle this in a humane fashion. This is not putting criminals above ordinary citizens, this is putting the state, and ordinary citizens, above criminals. Furthermore, the concept of punishment in a legal system in intrinsically flawed in my opinion. Sure free will and all are fun concepts, but we're figuring out more and more that crimes mostly aren't so much a choice, but genetically or socially determined. If you pour acid over a woman who doesn't love you, you've got serious problems AND you're a danger for society. This should be prevented in future. The punishment aspect is purely retribution and stimulates the illusion that his suffering will reduce yours. The whole deterrent story has proven to be bullshit, many times over. Just like the punishment theory, for that matter. Neither reduces crime or makes life better for anyone. This whole eye for an eye thinking is just silly. If someone rapes your daughter, you will rape his? If I steal 10% of Bill Gates fortune, he can steal 10% of mine? The Golden Rule isn't "do unto others as they did unto you" as you make it seem, it's "do unto others as you would have done unto you" as you state. However neither is up-to-date; it's simply "don't do this crap to others". Let's all stick to that. Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:23 MasterFischer wrote:He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues  I wonder why I even tried. That smiley is so out of place.
That's all great man.. Gimme a call once you figured out a way to fix the way society has been for the past oh I don't know.... 5000 years? or more?
No, punishment does not stimulate any reduction in the suffering of loved one left behind, but it serves to indicate justice, fairness, nothing more. You have any concept about how much money it would take to fix each individual and their problems so they don't commit crime?
Prevention and punishment are two different things.
I'm talking about punishment after the crime has happened, you are talking about preventing the crime.
How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine?
|
On May 19 2011 04:50 MasterFischer wrote: How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine?
One would suppose the idea is to prevent it from happening again
|
On May 19 2011 04:53 VIB wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:50 MasterFischer wrote: How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine?
One would suppose the idea is to prevent it from happening again 
Yea, but how is that related to what we are talking about?
it's not. we're not talking about prevention. We're talking about punishment for at crime already committed.
I don't care how it has come about, but it has. And now we should deal with it.
Just because you fix societal problems and what not, doesn't mean murder will go away.
Murder and such will never go away.. even in a perfect society, it will always exist, because humans inhabit the system. Therefore laws and penalties must be enforced, how else are you gonna have consequences for your own actions?
Alleviating your own responsibility as a human being, is such a cop out, you can blame whatever you want for your wrong doings, still makes you a murderer by your own choice and admission.
|
On May 19 2011 04:50 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:32 Passion wrote:On May 19 2011 04:10 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.) Exactly my man. by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment. Exactly, we decide your "punishment". And we're not like you, so we handle this in a humane fashion. This is not putting criminals above ordinary citizens, this is putting the state, and ordinary citizens, above criminals. Furthermore, the concept of punishment in a legal system in intrinsically flawed in my opinion. Sure free will and all are fun concepts, but we're figuring out more and more that crimes mostly aren't so much a choice, but genetically or socially determined. If you pour acid over a woman who doesn't love you, you've got serious problems AND you're a danger for society. This should be prevented in future. The punishment aspect is purely retribution and stimulates the illusion that his suffering will reduce yours. The whole deterrent story has proven to be bullshit, many times over. Just like the punishment theory, for that matter. Neither reduces crime or makes life better for anyone. This whole eye for an eye thinking is just silly. If someone rapes your daughter, you will rape his? If I steal 10% of Bill Gates fortune, he can steal 10% of mine? The Golden Rule isn't "do unto others as they did unto you" as you make it seem, it's "do unto others as you would have done unto you" as you state. However neither is up-to-date; it's simply "don't do this crap to others". Let's all stick to that. On May 19 2011 04:23 MasterFischer wrote:He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues  I wonder why I even tried. That smiley is so out of place. That's all great man.. Gimme a call once you figured out a way to fix the way society has been for the past oh I don't know.... 5000 years? or more? No, punishment does not stimulate any reduction in the suffering of loved one left behind, but it serves to indicate justice, fairness, nothing more. You have any concept about how much money it would take to fix each individual and their problems so they don't commit crime? Prevention and punishment are two different things. I'm talking about punishment after the crime has happened, you are talking about preventing the crime. How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine?
So basically you're arguing that punishment is unnecessary? Because it's actually not doing anyone any good what so ever, it only serves to state a point. So I guess you're going to argue that a stronger point needs to be sent across? I don't agree if so (see my previous post).
And as far as criminals apparently not being worth the time then why not just kill everyone convicted of a crime? Seems simple enough to me. I mean I don't agree at all but if we're going by your logics and your "facts" then it makes sense.
|
Now that is HORRIBLE! No one should be allowed to do self-justice.
I know he deserves something bad but its not her decision. Its the decision of the judge.
|
On May 19 2011 05:01 HellRoxYa wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:50 MasterFischer wrote:On May 19 2011 04:32 Passion wrote:On May 19 2011 04:10 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.) Exactly my man. by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment. Exactly, we decide your "punishment". And we're not like you, so we handle this in a humane fashion. This is not putting criminals above ordinary citizens, this is putting the state, and ordinary citizens, above criminals. Furthermore, the concept of punishment in a legal system in intrinsically flawed in my opinion. Sure free will and all are fun concepts, but we're figuring out more and more that crimes mostly aren't so much a choice, but genetically or socially determined. If you pour acid over a woman who doesn't love you, you've got serious problems AND you're a danger for society. This should be prevented in future. The punishment aspect is purely retribution and stimulates the illusion that his suffering will reduce yours. The whole deterrent story has proven to be bullshit, many times over. Just like the punishment theory, for that matter. Neither reduces crime or makes life better for anyone. This whole eye for an eye thinking is just silly. If someone rapes your daughter, you will rape his? If I steal 10% of Bill Gates fortune, he can steal 10% of mine? The Golden Rule isn't "do unto others as they did unto you" as you make it seem, it's "do unto others as you would have done unto you" as you state. However neither is up-to-date; it's simply "don't do this crap to others". Let's all stick to that. On May 19 2011 04:23 MasterFischer wrote:He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues  I wonder why I even tried. That smiley is so out of place. That's all great man.. Gimme a call once you figured out a way to fix the way society has been for the past oh I don't know.... 5000 years? or more? No, punishment does not stimulate any reduction in the suffering of loved one left behind, but it serves to indicate justice, fairness, nothing more. You have any concept about how much money it would take to fix each individual and their problems so they don't commit crime? Prevention and punishment are two different things. I'm talking about punishment after the crime has happened, you are talking about preventing the crime. How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine? So basically you're arguing that punishment is unnecessary? Because it's actually not doing anyone any good what so ever, it only serves to state a point. So I guess you're going to argue that a stronger point needs to be sent across? I don't agree if so (see my previous post). And as far as criminals apparently not being worth the time then why not just kill everyone convicted of a crime? Seems simple enough to me. I mean I don't agree at all but if we're going by your logics and your "facts" then it makes sense.
Im talking exclusively about murder. Taking life. Not about other criminals. Punishment is necessary because our legal justice system and our morality in modern worlds are focused upon cause and effect and consequential relationships. If you do A, B happens. You know this. Those are facts, but it's up to you, if you want to live by these rules. If you don't, then you will be punished for it. Murder is not acceptable, and never will be. I don't find laws that allow murders to ever walk the streets again, to be "effective". Why should you be allowed to live, if you have willfully taken another life? Are you the commander of life? It is your decision who lives or dies in a general society? No.
Nobody but the system of democracy has the right to decide what is right or what is wrong. collectively.
Also: Criminals are worth the time, but severe criminals are not. Depends on the damages they have caused.
im all for prevention, but im still for the death penalty for those who fail to have respect for human life.
You will never avoid murder. Ever. You will never prevent it from happening. So how are you gonna deal with it ?
|
A murderer isn't necessairly someone who just said "Fuck the rules, who needs them". And even when they do it might very well have been only partly in their control, etc, etc. Just because one life is ruined doesn't mean you need to ruin another. You said yourself it does no good.
+ Show Spoiler +Basically it's not as black and white as you make it out to be. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't.
|
On May 19 2011 05:09 HellRoxYa wrote:A murderer isn't necessairly someone who just said "Fuck the rules, who needs them". And even when they do it might very well have been only partly in their control, etc, etc. Just because one life is ruined doesn't mean you need to ruin another. You said yourself it does no good. + Show Spoiler +Basically it's not as black and white as you make it out to be. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't.
No, but in those instances were it is pretty clear than murder was intentional from the criminals viewpoint, i think justice needs to be served.
There are varying degrees of murder. involuntary manslaughter and what not.. those are all circumstances were life in prison or maybe half a life in prison might be suitable.
Depending on how committed the murderer is to the act, and how well the case is being reviewed.
Still doesn't change the fact that the death penalty is good for occasions were it is needed. Where are you gonna draw the line, if not at death?
Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in.
In my world there are two kinds of people:
a) Crazies, who do anything regardless of outcome
b) normal functioning people, who knows the wrongdoings of killing, but do it anyway...
REGARDLESS of how their social status and genetics are.
This is still excluding "accidents" such as involuntary manslaughter.
|
On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 05:09 HellRoxYa wrote:A murderer isn't necessairly someone who just said "Fuck the rules, who needs them". And even when they do it might very well have been only partly in their control, etc, etc. Just because one life is ruined doesn't mean you need to ruin another. You said yourself it does no good. + Show Spoiler +Basically it's not as black and white as you make it out to be. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. No, but in those instances were it is pretty clear than murder was intentional from the criminals viewpoint, i think justice needs to be served. There are varying degrees of murder. involuntary manslaughter and what not.. those are all circumstances were life in prison or maybe half a life in prison might be suitable. Depending on how committed the murderer is to the act, and how well the case is being reviewed. Still doesn't change the fact that the death penalty is good for occasions were it is needed. Where are you gonna draw the line, if not at death? Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. In my world there are two kinds of people: a) Crazies, who do anything regardless of outcome b) normal functioning people, who knows the wrongdoings of killing, but do it anyway... REGARDLESS of how their social status and genetics are. This is still excluding "accidents" such as involuntary manslaughter.
Do you fail to see that your argument relies on the fact that society (the judicial system is still society) needs exercise the very same disregard for human life to follow through with an execution? Yes, the person put himself in that position, sure, but that doesn't mean society gains the right to err in the same way.
But for me personally, I'm against the death penalty mostly because you can never be sure enough.
|
On May 19 2011 04:50 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 04:32 Passion wrote:On May 19 2011 04:10 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.) Exactly my man. by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment. Exactly, we decide your "punishment". And we're not like you, so we handle this in a humane fashion. This is not putting criminals above ordinary citizens, this is putting the state, and ordinary citizens, above criminals. Furthermore, the concept of punishment in a legal system in intrinsically flawed in my opinion. Sure free will and all are fun concepts, but we're figuring out more and more that crimes mostly aren't so much a choice, but genetically or socially determined. If you pour acid over a woman who doesn't love you, you've got serious problems AND you're a danger for society. This should be prevented in future. The punishment aspect is purely retribution and stimulates the illusion that his suffering will reduce yours. The whole deterrent story has proven to be bullshit, many times over. Just like the punishment theory, for that matter. Neither reduces crime or makes life better for anyone. This whole eye for an eye thinking is just silly. If someone rapes your daughter, you will rape his? If I steal 10% of Bill Gates fortune, he can steal 10% of mine? The Golden Rule isn't "do unto others as they did unto you" as you make it seem, it's "do unto others as you would have done unto you" as you state. However neither is up-to-date; it's simply "don't do this crap to others". Let's all stick to that. On May 19 2011 04:23 MasterFischer wrote:He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues  I wonder why I even tried. That smiley is so out of place. That's all great man.. Gimme a call once you figured out a way to fix the way society has been for the past oh I don't know.... 5000 years? or more? No, punishment does not stimulate any reduction in the suffering of loved one left behind, but it serves to indicate justice, fairness, nothing more. You have any concept about how much money it would take to fix each individual and their problems so they don't commit crime? Prevention and punishment are two different things. I'm talking about punishment after the crime has happened, you are talking about preventing the crime. How are you gonna prevent a crime from happening if it has already happening? A time machine?
Read carefully and notice I mention nowhere preventing crimes that have aleady happened. I'm merely talking about the prevention of recidivism.
How you jump from punishment to justice and fairness to the cost of preventing crime all together is a mystery to me, though I'm also starting to wonder how you even manage to type.
This leaves me equally amazed discovering you actually state something that sounds true (leading to me doubting it): prevention and punishment are two different things.
Prevention makes sure a murderer never kills someone again. Punishment in this context is no more than an act of hatred.
Anyway, shall we rename this "The MasterFischer Thread" ?
|
Why do violent criminals such as dudes who throw acid on a woman's face deserve any rights whatsoever? They are the scum of society and deserve to be punished. If victims want to take revenge, they have every right to do so.
|
This is strange. It's obviously wrong and two wrongs don't make a right and all that crap. But at the same time, even though it's barbaric, I feel like this would send a message in some ways. Women are constantly abused over there and men never pay. And since they never pay, they just keep doing it. Sure revenge isn't right, but at the same time it could stop some other guy from throwing acid on a girl. Probably not the best way to send a message, but it might be effective. And if anyone deserves acid in their eye, it's horrible men like that. Regardless of whether it's right or wrong though, you can't judge her.
|
whoops double post :/ sorry
|
personally i would prefer the death penalty to being blinded by acid
|
eye for an eye.. Nah but this is pretty sick actually more so that the man did it in the first place of course.
|
There is no objective way to torture someone. Example: You punch a guy. He punches you back WAY harder. The perception of the victim can lead to completely unbalanced responses. Imagine her cackling with laughter as she takes his eyesight away. Surely that is much worse than 'just' having your eyesight taken away?
|
On May 19 2011 05:28 HellRoxYa wrote:Show nested quote +On May 19 2011 05:22 MasterFischer wrote:On May 19 2011 05:09 HellRoxYa wrote:A murderer isn't necessairly someone who just said "Fuck the rules, who needs them". And even when they do it might very well have been only partly in their control, etc, etc. Just because one life is ruined doesn't mean you need to ruin another. You said yourself it does no good. + Show Spoiler +Basically it's not as black and white as you make it out to be. Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't. No, but in those instances were it is pretty clear than murder was intentional from the criminals viewpoint, i think justice needs to be served. There are varying degrees of murder. involuntary manslaughter and what not.. those are all circumstances were life in prison or maybe half a life in prison might be suitable. Depending on how committed the murderer is to the act, and how well the case is being reviewed. Still doesn't change the fact that the death penalty is good for occasions were it is needed. Where are you gonna draw the line, if not at death? Taking another human life should be the ultimate sacrifice, if you really are willing and capable of murdering another person in cold blood, then I see no reason not to execute this person, because the value of human life failed to sink in. In my world there are two kinds of people: a) Crazies, who do anything regardless of outcome b) normal functioning people, who knows the wrongdoings of killing, but do it anyway... REGARDLESS of how their social status and genetics are. This is still excluding "accidents" such as involuntary manslaughter. Do you fail to see that your argument relies on the fact that society (the judicial system is still society) needs exercise the very same disregard for human life to follow through with an execution? Yes, the person put himself in that position, sure, but that doesn't mean society gains the right to err in the same way. But for me personally, I'm against the death penalty mostly because you can never be sure enough.
Actually society is granted the right to execute people if it is passed by law. We as a democracy decides this. You are against death penalty, I'm for it. We'll agree to disagree. You seem to think that killing a guilty man, is the same as killing an innocent man. Why don't you think it isn't considered to err, by executing a known murderer who has no disregard for life, it is just his punishment, the justice of it?
|
|
|
|
|
|