|
To take a human life, to inflict pain upon others, is always wrong, regardless of the circumstances. Yes, this is an idealistic way of thinking. But as long as we think in terms of "an eye for an eye" and that this is necessary, violence and death will exist. Surely crime will not go away because we stop punishing it with equally brutal methods, but I believe that we, by employing that kind of brutallity, increases our tolerance to violence. If we say it is justice in this case, it might be justice in other cases, were do we draw the line?
On May 18 2011 20:30 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 20:22 Olinim wrote:On May 18 2011 20:16 MasterFischer wrote: And don't give me that shit about rehabilitation and what not in prison. Doesn't fucking work.
What works is FEAR, in order to deal with criminals on their terms, you have to use their tactics and their line of thought, fear. They don't give a fuck about the system or jail-time probaly, they laugh at the system.
They might think otherwise if they have fucking acid poured into their face... like..
ohoh... maybe I shouldn't totally go and do this crime just now ..eh??? Might get fucking acid in my fucking stupid criminal face... oh well... I'll just leave it.. aint worth it. Too scared. I don't wanna die.. bla bla... see?
You get the criminal to think about consequences and how THEY would like it, if somebody did it to THEM?
It's fair. So your genius plan to stop criminals and prove their actions are wrong... is to do exactly what they do. Hmm. We as a society are reactionary. We act upon others actions. This is the way it is. Why is punishment by death or otherwise wrong? Do you think criminals have a patent on killing another human? They don't. They just choose to do it. We act upon their choosing. Has nothing to do with the act itself or the punishment. but if you think you control other peoples lives by taking it away from them, then you deserve to pay with your own. always. Nobody has the right to take another life without permission, and if they do, they must and should be willing to trade in their life aswell.. Those are the terms. Fairly simply, pretty fair and just. What does sending them to jail do? Nothing. It costs society money, it costs time and ressources on lowlifes. We are so many people in the world, we got no fucking time to deal with each little fucking miserable scrub that thinks he or she is the king of the world by taking lives. Millions die everyday from big issues like hunger, poverty, accidents, natural diseasters and what not.. and you're telling me I should fucking care about 1 criminal scrub who deserves what he got? No. I don't. Don't fuck me with me, and I won't fuck with you. It's so simple and logical, that if you're too fucking dumb as a person to figure out the basics of human morality and life, you deserve to be put to rest. The end.
Your last sentence strikes me as an excellent example. "If you are stupid and (therefore) disagree with me, you should be killed." While I'm sure this is not a serious threat and not something you actually would do, this kind of thinking is problematic. I mean, if we are already killing murderers, cutting the penis of rapist and chopping the hands of thieves, and we understand that is an acceptable method in society. Maybe you believe someone should really die? Yeah, if I think he deserves it, he should. On the other hand, if you keep a no-tolerance mindset, that thought would never be possible.
What does having this mindset effect crime rates? Not much, probably. But if no one put's one's foot down, and says; "I will not take a human life" who will?
The answer is, no one.
|
If severe punishments worked then countries with the death penalty should have 0 murders, surely? That isn't shown in statistics at all, and further this system also adds:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/may/13/iran-blind-criminal-acid wrote:
...the man would be blinded only in one eye because "each man is worth two women" under Iranian law.
showing the unerlying disgusting nature of that legal system.
|
While I hate violence in general, somehow I find myself going for utilitarism on this one. I find a lot of consolation on the fact this actually might save some other woman from suffering the same fate.
World definitely isn't always a nice place. As nasty it is, sometimes some extra violence can make it bit nicer place for the future generations.
|
On May 18 2011 21:15 Bacillus wrote: While I hate violence in general, somehow I find myself going for utilitarism on this one. I find a lot of consolation on the fact this actually might save some other woman from suffering the same fate.
World definitely isn't always a nice place. As nasty it is, sometimes some extra violence can make it bit nicer place for the future generations. I'm not sure that's the case though. I don't know anything about Iranian law but I assume this has been in place and has been enforced for a while? The woman still became a victim of, in this case, acid despite the man knowing the repercussions.
|
I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.)
|
On May 14 2011 09:27 Cenecia wrote: Two wrongs don't make a right. More suffering never leads to less suffering. No pain can undo past pain. The punishment of a crime has very little to do with how many people do the crime. Increasing the severity of a punishment does not lead to less crime. Studies show this over and over again. This would make an interesting contribution to the conversation. Can you point to any of these studies?
By the way, here's a relevant link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retributive_justice.
|
On May 18 2011 20:40 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 20:35 Zorkmid wrote:On May 18 2011 20:31 MasterFischer wrote: Besides... Killing humans in war is perfectly natural and considered fine...
How do you feel about that?
So, killing each other over some stupid idea is alot better than killing a person who ACTUALLY deserves to be killed for concrete wrongdoings of INNOCENT.. I repeat, INNOCENT people?
As long as nations are killing each-other it's fine, but as soon as the justice system kills a single human for doing wrong, it's TOTALLY unethical.
What a load of bullshit. So because war is horrible, it's cool for the state to kill people for other reasons? WHUT? Killing afghans in Iraq is a little more distorted of justice, than killing a man, 100 % guilty of murdering another human being in cold blood, a person who was INNOCENT.
No such thing as 100% dude. One of the main reasons that states should not kill people is that it is almost NEVER 100%.
|
On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
Ok, I'll do my best to explain.
Justice refers to being fair and, well, just. It requires an objective system of penalisation to appropriately respond to a transgression. Revenge is when you harm someone for harming you, and is both subjective and reactionary.
The first aspect of this case that makes it incompatible with justice is to ask the victim for the punishment, which immediately deprives the system of any objective stance. The reason this is important is two fold, first that it means different punishment for different people comitting the exact same offense, and second that it becomes a system that can easily be influenced by external forces. Is it right to force that decision on all victims?
The second problem is the measure of the response. Is it ever right to torture or maim (etc) a person? If not, how can it be a just response to then do that? The simple fact is, it can't be, it's only right if you accept revenge as justice, something I outright reject.
The 'Golden Rule' you refer to has no basis being involved in the punishment side of a legal system. While it can help define what the rules should be, using it also as a punishment system becomes petty vengence. It's true the guy is barely worthy of pity, but to call it justice is to devalue justice itself, and any legal system that uses vengence over justice is nothing short of barbaric.
|
On May 18 2011 21:55 Iyerbeth wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others? Ok, I'll do my best to explain. Justice refers to being fair and, well, just. It requires an objective system of penalisation to appropriately respond to a transgression. Revenge is when you harm someone for harming you, and is both subjective and reactionary. The first aspect of this case that makes it incompatible with justice is to ask the victim for the punishment, which immediately deprives the system of any objective stance. The reason this is important is two fold, first that it means different punishment for different people comitting the exact same offense, and second that it becomes a system that can easily be influenced by external forces. Is it right to force that decision on all victims? OK, thanks for trying to explain.
Let's skip the part about giving the victim a choice, since I think that even if she wasn't given a choice to waive the punishment, we would still have the same fundamental disagreement about whether this punishment is just. For argument's sake, let's talk about the hypothetical case if the victim were not involved in choosing this punishment. In that case, you sayThe second problem is the measure of the response. Is it ever right to torture or maim (etc) a person? If not, how can it be a just response to then do that? The simple fact is, it can't be, it's only right if you accept revenge as justice, something I outright reject. Your argument would invalidate practically any form of punishment. Is it ever right to jail an innocent person? If not, then how can it be just to jail a guilty one? The difference, of course, is that innocence and guilt are factors in our notions of right or wrong. In my opinion, it is never right to torture or maim an innocent person, but it can be just to torture or maim a person who is guilty of torture or maiming.
The 'Golden Rule' you refer to has no basis being involved in the punishment side of a legal system. While it can help define what the rules should be, using it also as a punishment system becomes petty vengence. It's true the guy is barely worthy of pity, but to call it justice is to devalue justice itself, and any legal system that uses vengence over justice is nothing short of barbaric. It seems likely that we won't be able to convince each other of our respective notions of justice, but I'm interested in understanding yours. I imagine that you believe in restorative justice, correct? So, if somehow by blinding the attacker, sight could be restored to the victim, in that case you might see the procedure as just--it's when hurting the attacker does nothing for the victim that you consider it unjust. Is that a fair assessment of your view?
|
Justice is supposed to embody what is right. We agree that doing harm is wrong. How can doing harm then be justice?
If this man was raised from birth in a Western / European country, his views towards women would have been vastly different - and he would not have done this.
The vast majority of people in prison would not have been there under circumstances where they were treated with compassion, support, and kindness by everyone in their life (and felt that returning this love was equally important).
Cutting off the flower on a dandelion will never remove the weed. The problem needs to be healed at the source - hurtful enviroments. Killing a murderer is like cutting off one of the flowers, but feeding the roots.
|
Wow, kinda barbaric justice system; I assume it is more effective but there's no "whoops sorry" for the wrongfully accused. I wonder how it all stacks, say I am responsible for two people losing an arm; if they both choose to take an arm, leaving me armless. The price for my last arm is much more ,than the price for anyone's first.
What if the lady was near blind and guy had perfect sight, she was already adapted to a life with lesser vision; while the guy was as perfect therefore depending more on his eyes. I never really understood "eye for an eye" since everyone is different.
|
On May 18 2011 22:11 qrs wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:55 Iyerbeth wrote:On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others? Ok, I'll do my best to explain. Justice refers to being fair and, well, just. It requires an objective system of penalisation to appropriately respond to a transgression. Revenge is when you harm someone for harming you, and is both subjective and reactionary. The first aspect of this case that makes it incompatible with justice is to ask the victim for the punishment, which immediately deprives the system of any objective stance. The reason this is important is two fold, first that it means different punishment for different people comitting the exact same offense, and second that it becomes a system that can easily be influenced by external forces. Is it right to force that decision on all victims? OK, thanks for trying to explain. Let's skip the part about giving the victim a choice, since I think that even if she wasn't given a choice to waive the punishment, we would still have the same fundamental disagreement about whether this punishment is just. For argument's sake, let's talk about the hypothetical case if the victim were not involved in choosing this punishment. In that case, you say Show nested quote +The second problem is the measure of the response. Is it ever right to torture or maim (etc) a person? If not, how can it be a just response to then do that? The simple fact is, it can't be, it's only right if you accept revenge as justice, something I outright reject. Your argument would invalidate practically any form of punishment. Is it ever right to jail an innocent person? If not, then how can it be just to jail a guilty one? The difference, of course, is that innocence and guilt are factors in our notions of right or wrong. In my opinion, it is never right to torture or maim an innocent person, but it can be just to torture or maim a person who is guilty of torture or maiming.
There's actually an important distinction, in that it can be right to detain someone someone, and therefore it's use in a justice system is (in my opinion) permissible. I don't believe it is ever right to torture or main someone, and whilst I find myself unfortunately lacking the articulation to explain why at the moment, it's because those things are fundamentally always wrong. If something is always wrong, it can't be right to use it in some form of justice, and that's primarily where my disagreement with the punishment comes from.
On May 18 2011 22:11 qrs wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:55 Iyerbeth wrote: The 'Golden Rule' you refer to has no basis being involved in the punishment side of a legal system. While it can help define what the rules should be, using it also as a punishment system becomes petty vengence. It's true the guy is barely worthy of pity, but to call it justice is to devalue justice itself, and any legal system that uses vengence over justice is nothing short of barbaric. It seems likely that we won't be able to convince each other of our respective notions of justice, but I'm interested in understanding yours. I imagine that you believe in restorative justice, correct? So, if somehow by blinding the attacker, sight could be restored to the victim, in that case you might see the procedure as just--it's when hurting the attacker does nothing for the victim that you consider it unjust. Is that a fair assessment of your view?
I've read the page on restorative justice you linked and I feel it goes to far in the other direction, though it could probably have positive application in minor offences I imagine. I would place my concept of justice somewhere between that and a more traditional legal view. Towards the top of the article it has the quote:
Traditional criminal justice seeks answers to three questions: what laws have been broken? who did it? and what do the offender(s) deserve? Restorative justice instead asks: who has been harmed? what are their needs? whose obligations are these?
If I were to word, in a similar fashion, how I think an ideal system should be it would be something like: "Who has been harmed? What are their needs and whose obligations are these? What do the offender(s) deserve?". Within that guideline though I would say yes, if blinding the attacker (who was of fit mental state at the time of the attack) would restore sight to the victim, then I would say it was a reasonable course of action. The difference between blinding someone for vengeance and this is that this method has a purpose other than vengeance, and further redresses the balance of the situation.
|
On May 18 2011 22:18 FaZe wrote: Justice is supposed to embody what is right. We agree that doing harm is wrong. How can doing harm then be justice?
If this man was raised from birth in a Western / European country, his views towards women would have been vastly different - and he would not have done this.
The vast majority of people in prison would not have been there under circumstances where they were treated with compassion, support, and kindness by everyone in their life (and felt that returning this love was equally important).
Cutting off the flower on a dandelion will never remove the weed. The problem needs to be healed at the source - hurtful enviroments. Killing a murderer is like cutting off one of the flowers, but feeding the roots.
We do not agree that "doing harm is wrong".. or at least we don't agree punishing the guilty constitutes "harm".
The argument for retributive justice is Harming the guilty is Right. (and it makes sense, since ANY punishment constitutes "harm".. including jail or a fine, or even a stern warning)
Of course a punishment might also be considered rehabilitative... in that case punishing the guilty is not harming them, it is teaching them a lesson. (This does not apply to the death penalty, unless there is assumed to be an afterlife, in which case it may be beneficial to the guilty to even execute them)
It might not be the most rehabilitative, but given the nature of the crime (man exerting power over woman to destroy her) perhaps he will learn what that helplessness feels like as she exerts power over him.
Justice I think needs to be Retributive for the offender AND Restorative for the victim (if possible, it isn't really in this case) [this is why the US has Criminal+Civil courts.. one for punishment, the other for restoration]. Transformative Justice should be an additional work taken legislatively to make society better.
I agree that te 'victim's choice' does introduce elements of revenge, which is unfortunate. However, it is probably important for the retributive value of this punishment that it be carried out by a woman.
|
On May 18 2011 21:00 Belphegor13 wrote:To take a human life, to inflict pain upon others, is always wrong, regardless of the circumstances. Yes, this is an idealistic way of thinking. But as long as we think in terms of "an eye for an eye" and that this is necessary, violence and death will exist. Surely crime will not go away because we stop punishing it with equally brutal methods, but I believe that we, by employing that kind of brutallity, increases our tolerance to violence. If we say it is justice in this case, it might be justice in other cases, were do we draw the line? Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 20:30 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 20:22 Olinim wrote:On May 18 2011 20:16 MasterFischer wrote: And don't give me that shit about rehabilitation and what not in prison. Doesn't fucking work.
What works is FEAR, in order to deal with criminals on their terms, you have to use their tactics and their line of thought, fear. They don't give a fuck about the system or jail-time probaly, they laugh at the system.
They might think otherwise if they have fucking acid poured into their face... like..
ohoh... maybe I shouldn't totally go and do this crime just now ..eh??? Might get fucking acid in my fucking stupid criminal face... oh well... I'll just leave it.. aint worth it. Too scared. I don't wanna die.. bla bla... see?
You get the criminal to think about consequences and how THEY would like it, if somebody did it to THEM?
It's fair. So your genius plan to stop criminals and prove their actions are wrong... is to do exactly what they do. Hmm. We as a society are reactionary. We act upon others actions. This is the way it is. Why is punishment by death or otherwise wrong? Do you think criminals have a patent on killing another human? They don't. They just choose to do it. We act upon their choosing. Has nothing to do with the act itself or the punishment. but if you think you control other peoples lives by taking it away from them, then you deserve to pay with your own. always. Nobody has the right to take another life without permission, and if they do, they must and should be willing to trade in their life aswell.. Those are the terms. Fairly simply, pretty fair and just. What does sending them to jail do? Nothing. It costs society money, it costs time and ressources on lowlifes. We are so many people in the world, we got no fucking time to deal with each little fucking miserable scrub that thinks he or she is the king of the world by taking lives. Millions die everyday from big issues like hunger, poverty, accidents, natural diseasters and what not.. and you're telling me I should fucking care about 1 criminal scrub who deserves what he got? No. I don't. Don't fuck me with me, and I won't fuck with you. It's so simple and logical, that if you're too fucking dumb as a person to figure out the basics of human morality and life, you deserve to be put to rest. The end. Your last sentence strikes me as an excellent example. "If you are stupid and (therefore) disagree with me, you should be killed." While I'm sure this is not a serious threat and not something you actually would do, this kind of thinking is problematic. I mean, if we are already killing murderers, cutting the penis of rapist and chopping the hands of thieves, and we understand that is an acceptable method in society. Maybe you believe someone should really die? Yeah, if I think he deserves it, he should. On the other hand, if you keep a no-tolerance mindset, that thought would never be possible. What does having this mindset effect crime rates? Not much, probably. But if no one put's one's foot down, and says; "I will not take a human life" who will? The answer is, no one.
Do you really think criminals give a shit, that you put your foot down and say.. oh oh.. the world is made of roseberries and rainbows.. let's not kill anybody shall we ?? pleaseeee??
Murder, rape, torture, poverty all these things.. they go on and on.. and they will NEVER.. EVER fucking go away... ever.. understand?
So why not start punishing the crimes in a fair manner, instead of giving lee-way to murders. You know kind of message you are sending to criminals if you don't want them to suffer?
I'll tell ya, "Oh please, do more crime, we don't wanna punish you, it's wrong you know?"...
Criminals will be okay... fine, so while I rape your sister and kill your father with a knife, think REAL hard about not punishing me okay?... cool story bro..
THIS.DOES.NOT.WORK...
It's not ACCEPTABLE in society, it's acceptable as a punishment for doing wrong, as a punishment by the government and legal justice system. Not by common men. There is a huge fucking difference, and most MOST normal people understand this. we grant the government and the police, authority, to use force that is otherwise illegal to us citizens e.g. deadly force, the death penalty. We live in a democracy.
|
On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.)
Exactly my man.
by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment.
|
On May 18 2011 21:46 Zorkmid wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 20:40 MasterFischer wrote:On May 18 2011 20:35 Zorkmid wrote:On May 18 2011 20:31 MasterFischer wrote: Besides... Killing humans in war is perfectly natural and considered fine...
How do you feel about that?
So, killing each other over some stupid idea is alot better than killing a person who ACTUALLY deserves to be killed for concrete wrongdoings of INNOCENT.. I repeat, INNOCENT people?
As long as nations are killing each-other it's fine, but as soon as the justice system kills a single human for doing wrong, it's TOTALLY unethical.
What a load of bullshit. So because war is horrible, it's cool for the state to kill people for other reasons? WHUT? Killing afghans in Iraq is a little more distorted of justice, than killing a man, 100 % guilty of murdering another human being in cold blood, a person who was INNOCENT. No such thing as 100% dude. One of the main reasons that states should not kill people is that it is almost NEVER 100%.
Is sending a man away for life in prison to rot any better than death then?
Since you can never be sure at anything according to you, should we then just never give out severe punishments in fear of punishing innocents? no... that's a bullshit argument. The law system works pretty efficiently in most countries. THe police in MOST countries, are pretty darn educated and professional.
|
On May 18 2011 22:18 FaZe wrote: Justice is supposed to embody what is right. We agree that doing harm is wrong. How can doing harm then be justice?
If this man was raised from birth in a Western / European country, his views towards women would have been vastly different - and he would not have done this.
The vast majority of people in prison would not have been there under circumstances where they were treated with compassion, support, and kindness by everyone in their life (and felt that returning this love was equally important).
Cutting off the flower on a dandelion will never remove the weed. The problem needs to be healed at the source - hurtful enviroments. Killing a murderer is like cutting off one of the flowers, but feeding the roots.
Because it's invalid to compare a criminals way of harming innocent people by HIS own choosing, and the harm inflicted upon the criminal who choose to commit wrong on his own accord, thereby making him guilty, and sealing his own fate. He well understood the consequences of his actions, so now he shall suffer the result of murder or disfigurement.
As I said before, killing is perfectly okay in our modern society, as long as it is legal and as long as it is justified.
Is killing an innocent man justified? No.
Is killing a convicted murderer justified? Yes. It is. Since the criminal has acted wrongly on the account of society, and has thus received his punishment BY the society because we react upon what he has done.
Starting at the bottom is harder than it appears. Until we fix root problems, we might alleviate some of the problems by instating stricter laws, so it might scare more people into not committing crime. Most criminals have normal brain function and every human in the world cares about his own existence. So you don't have to tell me, than if criminals knew that there was a pretty fucking good chance they would end up in the electric chair for their crime,, I think they would think twice about doing it if they got caught.
|
Good to know that we have a ton of sadists lurking Team Liquid.
|
On May 18 2011 22:34 Ipp wrote: Wow, kinda barbaric justice system; I assume it is more effective but there's no "whoops sorry" for the wrongfully accused. I wonder how it all stacks, say I am responsible for two people losing an arm; if they both choose to take an arm, leaving me armless. The price for my last arm is much more ,than the price for anyone's first.
What if the lady was near blind and guy had perfect sight, she was already adapted to a life with lesser vision; while the guy was as perfect therefore depending more on his eyes. I never really understood "eye for an eye" since everyone is different.
What if the guy never attacked the lady in the first place? He might not even be in this shit. Ever think of that?
He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues
|
On May 19 2011 04:10 MasterFischer wrote:Show nested quote +On May 18 2011 21:33 qrs wrote: I don't understand why people don't think that this is justice. As I see it, this is justice in its purest form.
What makes it barbaric to drip acid in a man's eyes? Why is that something that the legal system shouldn't do? (Hold your gut reaction for a sec--figure out the reasoning behind it, if you can.) As I see it, the Golden Rule (do unto others as you would have done unto you) is the foundation of justice. Think of it as a social contract, if you like. This guy has voided his contract by throwing acid into another human's face. He has no basis to claim a right that he does not accord to others. That's how I see it.
If you see it differently, please explain. What is the source of the fundamental right to be treated better than you treat others?
(It should also be noted that this is a huge deterrent. The OP says, "According to the judges, the sole judgement has already awed a statistically significant amount of possible perpetrators, that there has been a noticeable decline in this crimesector." I mention that to show that this is not simply revenge with no other purpose than revenge. Still, this is a side point.) Exactly my man. by NOT punishing criminals the way the fucking should be, we actually view criminals above the innocent citizens, as nobody has the right to take lives without giving in their own in a trade. It is very much a contract. You decide your own fate. We decide your punishment.
Exactly, we decide your "punishment". And we're not like you, so we handle this in a humane fashion. This is not putting criminals above ordinary citizens, this is putting the state, and ordinary citizens, above criminals.
Furthermore, the concept of punishment in a legal system in intrinsically flawed in my opinion. Sure free will and all are fun concepts, but we're figuring out more and more that crimes mostly aren't so much a choice, but genetically or socially determined. If you pour acid over a woman who doesn't love you, you've got serious problems AND you're a danger for society. This should be prevented in future. The punishment aspect is purely retribution and stimulates the illusion that his suffering will reduce yours.
The whole deterrent story has proven to be bullshit, many times over. Just like the punishment theory, for that matter. Neither reduces crime or makes life better for anyone.
This whole eye for an eye thinking is just silly. If someone rapes your daughter, you will rape his? If I steal 10% of Bill Gates fortune, he can steal 10% of mine?
The Golden Rule isn't "do unto others as they did unto you" as you make it seem, it's "do unto others as you would have done unto you" as you state. However neither is up-to-date; it's simply "don't do this crap to others". Let's all stick to that.
On May 19 2011 04:23 MasterFischer wrote:He made a mistake, now it's time to pay up the dues 
I wonder why I even tried. That smiley is so out of place.
|
|
|
|
|
|