Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 31
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Lavalamp799
United States554 Posts
| ||
|
Nothingtosay
United States875 Posts
| ||
|
DizzyDrone
Netherlands629 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote: What about her rights? As far as I know, revenge is not one of the rights and freedoms to which all humans are entitled. Here's one of those rights and freedoms; "No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment." Yes, he's a sick person for what he did - but if you condone him being punished like this you're no better then him. | ||
|
DatBoiRijad
100 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:52 clusen wrote: Sad and funny at the same time :p This is wrong, doing the same to him is not going to make anything better. I don't know if I could be strong in her situation and resist to take revenge, that's why laws should prevent that. @ Reaper I don't know if such crazy bullshit happens more often in Iran than this one incident, but if it does and the offenders do not get punished the legal system is just bad, eye for an eye is not the solution. No, it's not wrong. The lady has the full right to pour acid in his eyes. On May 15 2011 04:50 DizzyDrone wrote: As far as I know, revenge is not one of the rights and freedoms to which all humans are entitled. Here's one of those rights and freedoms; "No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment." Yes, he's a sick person for what he did - but if you condone him being punished like this you're no better then him. There is no such thing as "rights." And yes, you're a better person if you condone him getting punished. He shouldn't of done it in the first place, he knew all the pain he was putting the lady through. He should have thought twice, since he didn't, he's getting everything he deserves. | ||
|
DragonDefonce
United States790 Posts
| ||
|
RoosterSamurai
Japan2108 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:50 DizzyDrone wrote: As far as I know, revenge is not one of the rights and freedoms to which all humans are entitled. Here's one of those rights and freedoms; "No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment." Yes, he's a sick person for what he did - but if you condone him being punished like this you're no better then him. You're wrong; people who condone him being punished like this ARE, in fact, better than him. We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason. He also gets to be sedated, whereas the woman didn't get that comfort. | ||
|
Gigaudas
Sweden1213 Posts
She is no better than he is. | ||
|
DatBoiRijad
100 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:53 Gigaudas wrote: "An eye for an eye" - imagine the damage this sentence has done to humanity. She is no better than he is. Please explain how an eye for an eye is wrong? So we should just let people do what ever they want, but treat them fairly if they get caught? | ||
|
Kojak21
Canada1104 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:53 Gigaudas wrote: "An eye for an eye" - imagine the damage this sentence has done to humanity. She is no better than he is. there would probably be less murderers if we followed it | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
carloselcoco
United States2302 Posts
Ohh wait.... + Show Spoiler + Even though I don't agree completely with the legal system, or the punishment, I am sympathetic to the woman's choice of punishment as there is nothing in our current world that will give her back all she lost to this guy. The code of Hammurabi applies here really well. | ||
|
dakalro
Romania525 Posts
On May 15 2011 01:38 zeru wrote: If there is proof that it failed, link some. I would argue the exact opposite. In scandinavia the punishment for crimes is very mild and theres a big focus on rehabilitation and they have among the lowest homicide rates in the world. I don't see any reason having barbaric punishments in a legal system is good in any way. I would really like to know what failed systems you are talking about, because the average homicide rates in muslim countries is higher than in western europe. Also taking the moral high ground is good. [1][2] I think you should check the maps better before you link ... Places with highest % of Muslim population seems to have more grey than the rest of the world overall. Not sure where you learned to read them maps. Plus, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/index.cfm?ty=tp&tid=17 http://www.rikosseuraamus.fi/25234.htm (for Finland, check pdf tables at the end, the rates are above 60% if you go by max time from release) http://releasedandrestored.org/statistics.html - Shows Sweden and Japan doing nicely at ~35% but no time frame shown Kind of random choices because I lack time. And there don't seem to be too many world statistics, mostly US. But I think that was the point I made. You need to really work and invest into rehabilitation and actually care about people most would rather just forget about. http://www.defendingjustice.org/pdfs/factsheets/9-Fact Sheet - US vs World.pdf - check page 2, part about Cuba. How many people would agree to a system like that, how many countries actually give enough of a shit about rehabilitation compared to just punish & forget. And it's a lot of those countries that also take the moral high ground in cases like these when they're no different. Sure there's no state sponsored acid burning but throwing someone in jail knowing they'll get beaten, raped, abused and get little to no rehabilitation and no help to turn their lives around seems worse to me. | ||
|
Jakkerr
Netherlands2549 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:55 DatBoiRijad wrote: Please explain how an eye for an eye is wrong? So we should just let people do what ever they want, but treat them fairly if they get caught? How it's wrong? because we don't live in the medieval anymore -.- Victims should never have ANY saying in a legal system since it's supposed to be objective, I'm happy all Western countries came to senses a few hundred years ago ![]() | ||
|
Djzapz
Canada10681 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:00 Kojak21 wrote: there would probably be less murderers if we followed it Not really. We'd be worse off IMO. | ||
|
HolyArrow
United States7116 Posts
| ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
BlackJack
United States10574 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:04 zeru wrote: Because lex talionis and code of hammurabi something we in the modern world have somewhat abandoned, and invented new and better ways as far as i know. The only countries still using those laws are muslim countries which still use sharia. That doesn't answer his question at all, it just says "our way is better "That seems to be the bulk of arguments that oppose this. Just a whole lot of "that's just wrong!" "retribution is just wrong" "An eye for an eye is just wrong" etc. I find this discussion to be very similar to abortion debates where both sides are convinced that their way is the "right way" when there's really no way to prove your sense of morality is superior to another person's. They are just opinions.. | ||
|
Nightfall.589
Canada766 Posts
On May 14 2011 16:35 Cifer wrote: That's factually incorrect, if its just a form of containment that we should see more life sentences, why would you let a dangerous person back out? and why should the time scale with the crime? It's because they have done their "punishment" regardless of you truly think they have rehabilitated or not. That's because the possibility that people will change is weighed against the damage that they have done. Shoplifter? If we let him out after some time in jail, and he goes back to it, it won't be that much harm to society. First degree murderer? Yeah, he's going to be put away for at least 25 years. Yes, deterrence is a factor at play, here. However, if deterrence worked, then the United States would be the least criminal country in the Western World. Most criminals don't operate under the assumption that they will get caught. That's actually what parole is all about. I would also, point out, that I'd be willing to support extending a jail term for someone who would obviously go back to doing what got him in prison in the first place. In fact, although I don't have the figures off the top of my head, I could dig up a bunch of papers done by criminologists showing that prison does not reform or rehabilitate criminals. Incidentally, recidivism goes down when prisons shift their focus to rehabilitation, instead of incarceration. It just so happens that politicians can't really get up on a podium and call themselves tough on crime, when that happens. Life in prison? Well that costs money to feed and cloth the person. Make them earn their keep in prison? I guess that's the best option, but no one wants to use the term "slave" nowadays. Forced labour creates a conflict of interest for the state, and an incentive to put innocent people away. It's not at all about slavery. | ||
|
DizzyDrone
Netherlands629 Posts
On May 15 2011 04:51 DatBoiRijad wrote: he's getting everything he deserves. Nobody deserves this type of punishment. Preventing people from being punished this way is the entire reason for having a declaration of human rights in the first place. On May 15 2011 04:52 RoosterSamurai wrote: We aren't throwing acid on his face for no apparent reason. The reason doesn't matter, you're still allowing someone to "throw acid on his face". The fact is, you're saying: "That's a TERRIBLE thing to do to a human being!" while at the same time allowing her to do that to another human being. If you can't understand the problem with that I don't know what to tell you. | ||
|
Phenny
Australia1435 Posts
On May 15 2011 05:11 BlackJack wrote: That doesn't answer his question at all, it just says "our way is better "That seems to be the bulk of arguments that oppose this. Just a whole lot of "that's just wrong!" "retribution is just wrong" "An eye for an eye is just wrong" etc. I find this discussion to be very similar to abortion debates where both sides are convinced that their way is the "right way" when there's really no way to prove your sense of morality is superior to another person's. They are just opinions.. This. Personally I think there are plenty of situations where an eye for an eye is perfectly valid. However I acknowledge this is merely my opinion and others may have different views, just because it makes sense and feels logical to me doesn't mean others will agree. | ||
| ||

"