|
On May 15 2011 03:46 teekesselchen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote:On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore.
What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. You really don't seem to understand what human rights mean. Human rights are rights that every human has, without conditions. Even a criminal still has them. By not accepting them as universal, things like protection from torture and physical punishment are not mandatory anymore, with potentialy devastating consequences. Of course she has rights, too, and of course it is bad that her rights have been violated, but that cannot be equaled out by violating the criminal's rights, too. And: Allowing personal vengeance? This is totally broken. I think you should read Freesia one day. Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote:On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justiced" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. So no, it is not "Kira-like" See above, Freesia is a really great manga actually capturing this exact situation. It plays in a dystopic future, where it is allowed to take personal vengeance for oneself or related victims of crimes in so called "enforcements". Really no children's story à la Naruto etc., this is dystopic, good literature. I'd like to hear you offer a reasonable alternative, please.
|
Thinkin more about this, and so you will wake up blind? -_-"
|
On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justice" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. IIRC, L was just as ruthless in seeking out the maximum punishment himself (except going through the justice system). So no, it is not "Kira-like"
i didn't call that man Kira. i said the notions of eye for an eye as a justice system is "Kira-like".
|
|
|
On May 15 2011 03:51 Terranist wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote:On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justice" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. IIRC, L was just as ruthless in seeking out the maximum punishment himself (except going through the justice system). So no, it is not "Kira-like" i didn't call that man Kira. i said the notions of eye for an eye as a justice system is "Kira-like". You didn't even say that. Here is what you said (Direct copy-paste) "what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread."
|
On May 15 2011 03:35 Baum wrote: It's incredibly stupid to think that eye for an eye will stop people from committing such things. It's education and prosperity that reduces violence.
What education would you give a man who things its within his rights to throw acid in someones face?
|
On May 15 2011 03:53 RoosterSamurai wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:51 Terranist wrote:On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote:On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justice" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. IIRC, L was just as ruthless in seeking out the maximum punishment himself (except going through the justice system). So no, it is not "Kira-like" i didn't call that man Kira. i said the notions of eye for an eye as a justice system is "Kira-like". You didn't even say that. Here is what you said (Direct copy-paste) "what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread."
yes, and?
|
On May 15 2011 03:36 mutantmagnet wrote: *shrugs* Some people would see this is cathartic but in reality it isn't the most effective way to heal yourself mentally.
Eye for an eye is a punishment system and in most cases a bad one because the punishment doesn't fit the crime.
Not only does the punishment here fit the crime, it wasn't the only option in their laws. I have to respect that type of flexibility. I don't know if it would help me feel better, never was in such a situation before and I never want to be in one :p I just wanted to add it to your statement, maybe it is important for some religious people.
I'm still not sure if flexibility is a good thing in this case, I had written a long post about it but deleted it because it wasn't good enough imo, have to rewrite it after Hasu vs Kas :p
|
On May 15 2011 03:46 teekesselchen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote:On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore.
What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. You really don't seem to understand what human rights mean. Human rights are rights that every human has, without conditions. Even a criminal still has them. By not accepting them as universal, things like protection from torture and physical punishment are not mandatory anymore, with potentialy devastating consequences. Of course she has rights, too, and of course it is bad that her rights have been violated, but that cannot be equaled out by violating the criminal's rights, too. And: Allowing personal vengeance? This is totally broken. I think you should read Freesia one day.
No you don't understand that the rights people have is enforced by laws and willpower. Without codifying our rights into laws we lose track of the implicit agreements we make that all people should share and how to deal with someone who violates those rights. Will power is important because if you are apathetic in exercising your rights and protecting the rights of others society will fall to ruin from carelessness.
The idea of universal rights doesn't work unless you can indoctrinate everyone and everyone has the ambition to make it viable. You can't wave your hand say everyone has universal rights and expect it to work without a proper societal infrastructure.
Our societies are fragmented and in this part of the world their idea of laws are being followed and it's hard to disagree with the precision of their justice system in this case.
On May 15 2011 04:06 clusen wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:36 mutantmagnet wrote: *shrugs* Some people would see this is cathartic but in reality it isn't the most effective way to heal yourself mentally.
Eye for an eye is a punishment system and in most cases a bad one because the punishment doesn't fit the crime.
Not only does the punishment here fit the crime, it wasn't the only option in their laws. I have to respect that type of flexibility. I don't know if it would help me feel better, never was in such a situation before and I never want to be in one :p I just wanted to add it to your statement, maybe it is important for some religious people. I'm still not sure if flexibility is a good thing in this case, I had written a long post about it but deleted it because it wasn't good enough imo, have to rewrite it after Hasu vs Kas :p
Looking forward to it. Send me a PM when you do.
|
On May 15 2011 03:54 Bosko wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:35 Baum wrote: It's incredibly stupid to think that eye for an eye will stop people from committing such things. It's education and prosperity that reduces violence. What education would you give a man who things its within his rights to throw acid in someones face? His point is that with proper education he would not think it's okay to do that, not that education will change criminals into ordinary citizens..
|
On May 15 2011 02:06 zeru wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On May 15 2011 02:03 BuddhiBadougi wrote: How can anyone feel not right about it and at best claim human rights for that man?
1) He threw acid into her face, so nobody ever wants to look at her again forever
2) What better way is there to learn, that you shouldn't do to others, what you wouldn't want to be done to you either? I don't get the critique on "an eye for eye" and Gandhi's "the world would be blind then". If people just wouldn't do things to others, they wouldn't want to be done to themselves, how would everybody be blinded exactly? So basically. What he did is completely inhumane and wrong, lets show him how wrong it was and show how to be a better human being by doing the same thing to him. I don't think i'll ever get that logic.
No man, show others how wrong that was and what happens to you, if you do it, so whoever may be contemplating something like this, just neglects the idea
|
The people who are saying its wrong for the victim to decide the punishment...she didn't actually decide the punishment, she was given a choice between 2 punishments and chose one of them. If it were up to her, maybe she'd kill him...who knows. The only difference she'll be the one physically doing it, rather than a government worker. The point is, this is not a valid argument. The same thing happens in western societies, the victim sometimes is given deals for weather they wanna push for example the highest degree of that crime effectively meaning capital punishment and or not and guarantee the assailant goes to jail and get a compensation. I understand the people saying its wrong, i feel the same way... but I think its hypocritical to not also recognize the faults of your own system, as its has the same flaws in principle.
|
if the guy can do it, there is no other equal punishment.
|
|
|
The woman i think has the right to do this. The man is sickening to do something like this. He deserves the same fate
|
I think half of the people of this thread should turn to Sharia if they support this retributionsystem... See how they like it.
|
I think this is a really bad idea.
|
On May 15 2011 04:33 DwmC_Foefen wrote: I think half of the people of this thread should turn to Sharia if they support this retributionsystem... See how they like it. We're all men, so I think we're all good, lol.
|
On May 15 2011 04:07 mutantmagnet wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:46 teekesselchen wrote:On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote:On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore.
What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. You really don't seem to understand what human rights mean. Human rights are rights that every human has, without conditions. Even a criminal still has them. By not accepting them as universal, things like protection from torture and physical punishment are not mandatory anymore, with potentialy devastating consequences. Of course she has rights, too, and of course it is bad that her rights have been violated, but that cannot be equaled out by violating the criminal's rights, too. And: Allowing personal vengeance? This is totally broken. I think you should read Freesia one day. No you don't understand that the rights people have is enforced by laws and willpower. Without codifying our rights into laws we lose track of the implicit agreements we make that all people should share and how to deal with someone who violates those rights. Will power is important because if you are apathetic in exercising your rights and protecting the rights of others society will fall to ruin from carelessness. The idea of universal rights doesn't work unless you can indoctrinate everyone and everyone has the ambition to make it viable. You can't wave your hand say everyone has universal rights and expect it to work without a proper societal infrastructure. Our societies are fragmented and in this part of the world their idea of laws are being followed and it's hard to disagree with the precision of their justice system in this case.
So, to conclude: You oppose human rights. You are saying that universal human rights are not feasable and that the whole human rights idea is optimistical or even totalitarian bogus. That is what you are saying, right? Any objections?
On May 15 2011 03:49 RoosterSamurai wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2011 03:46 teekesselchen wrote:On May 15 2011 03:17 mutantmagnet wrote:On May 15 2011 01:45 teekesselchen wrote: What's mainly been worrying me is the fact, that so many people on international and German boards agreed with the judgement, some partially, some absolutely. It seems that really a lot of people don't agree with fundamental human rights anymore.
What about her rights? The man didn't have acid thrown in his face by some gang. He was arrested and put through a judicial process. This process grants the accuser options and she exercised her options under law. Most cases like this is supposed to end with the guy getting away scott free since the system is stacked against women or pay out big time to the victim and go to jail for those who made it too easy to get convicted. The fact they don't rely on eye for an eye as their sole method of penalizing the accused makes this system acceptable. This doesn't mean I believe she doesn't need to forgive him at some point because forgiveness is the best way to move on from grudges that are psychologically eating you up. Yet there is no reason for him to be given a slap on the wrist. He needs to be penalized some how for his actions. You really don't seem to understand what human rights mean. Human rights are rights that every human has, without conditions. Even a criminal still has them. By not accepting them as universal, things like protection from torture and physical punishment are not mandatory anymore, with potentialy devastating consequences. Of course she has rights, too, and of course it is bad that her rights have been violated, but that cannot be equaled out by violating the criminal's rights, too. And: Allowing personal vengeance? This is totally broken. I think you should read Freesia one day. On May 15 2011 03:45 Neo7 wrote:On May 15 2011 03:20 Terranist wrote: what a bunch of little sheltered psuedo-kiras we have in this thread. this is not crime deterrence, this is an inhumane display of government sponsored torture. they are walking the razor's edge. In the anime/manga, Kira "exercised justiced" while completely bypassing the justice system. This man was arrested, put through trial, found guilty of the said crime, and sentenced at the mercy of the woman he violated. He knew the rules as set by Sharia Law and that it could lead to such a situation (or at the very least had access to such information since it is public). It's a fair judgement. So no, it is not "Kira-like" See above, Freesia is a really great manga actually capturing this exact situation. It plays in a dystopic future, where it is allowed to take personal vengeance for oneself or related victims of crimes in so called "enforcements". Really no children's story à la Naruto etc., this is dystopic, good literature. I'd like to hear you offer a reasonable alternative, please.
Scandinavian countries showed a great alternative. 1/3rd of Norways prisons are very liberal, open correction institutes, most are not even properly guarded and anyone who wanted could escape any time. These are made for rehabilitation, not punishment (only available for inmates who already served a part of their punishment though). They are not giving an atmosphere of "you are scum and our society doesn't want you!" like many prisons do. They are made to teach them a normal living, which is very crucial - many criminals arriving their can barely make it leading a normal, civil life there, but rather request to get back to normal prison! You see, the theory of criminals as often distorted persons is not that far off reality.
This is not just for pickpockets. There are murderers, rapist and whatelse of any caliber in there.
These countries have the lowest regression ratios of criminals worldwide, their system is the most efficient one in rehabilitating. It works. Additionally: More care and better education for those from a difficult social background, more assistance for parents who might need it. Such activities -like having an official nurse sent to all families and aiding the parents when they need it- worked incredibly well in a German city (they were able to have that kind of luxury there because they had a low birth ratio, but it significantly improved the education level of aided families' children. This way such a program is paying off tenfold).
|
On May 15 2011 04:33 DwmC_Foefen wrote: I think half of the people of this thread should turn to Sharia if they support this retributionsystem... See how they like it.
No, supporting this particular instance is very different from supporting the disgusting clusterfuck that is Sharia.
|
|
|
|
|
|