Woman will legally etch a man's eyes - Page 28
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:12 HoldenR wrote: You know how, as a child, when your mother told you not to do something dangerous because it might hurt(like holding your finger in a flame), you were more tempted to try it anyway? Then you burned your finger, depending on your age you might have cried about it, and then you never did it again. Well some people never fucking learn until they get hurt. And it's a pretty safe bet that this guy will definitely learn. The point is will it serve any of the purposes the justice system has ? Deterrence - doubtful and if so then other punishments will have similar effect with the benefit of not having torture as part of your justice system, which is good as introducing torture into it is pretty slippery slope. Rehabilitation - highly probable if he keeps sight in one of his eyes he will be angry at everyone, do not expect him to become productive member of the society ever again Protection of the society from him - nope, jail works better He should get long sentence more than 15/20/25 years without parole. If after that panel of specialists decide that it is safe to let him free then let him free, otherwise life it is. If you really think that your country cannot afford keeping him in jail for so long, well execute him, his crime was bad enough. | ||
|
Krehlmar
Sweden1149 Posts
Do I think what she is doing is wrong? Yes. From a juridical perspective it's wrong. Would I stop her? Not sure, there's so much injustice in the world and frankly the execution of Osama Bin Ladin was a worse crime against international law than what she is doing... and knowing these countries, having lived in Saudiarabia for a year, I say this is sadly the best choice of path. | ||
|
Greatness
United States450 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:30 zeru wrote: I don't know what a good punishment would be, I'm not a judge. But I do know you seem to want a legal system which is close to the code of hammurabi, which was used 1700 b.c. Good avoid. Life in prison? Well that costs money to feed and cloth the person. Make them earn their keep in prison? I guess that's the best option, but no one wants to use the term "slave" nowadays. | ||
|
zeru
8156 Posts
| ||
|
mcc
Czech Republic4646 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:36 zeru wrote: I didn't avoid anything. I never understood people complaining about prisoners costing tax money... By that logic we shouldnt have any prisons, because everyone in prison is a bad person and just a waste of money. We should just have physical punishment instead, but we don't, because we are trying to be civlized. Actually there is even better reason for prisons. Unless you want to execute every dangerous criminal, having them physically punished and then released will just allow them to commit more crimes. The point of prisons is also protection of the society from criminals by separation. | ||
|
RoosterSamurai
Japan2108 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:25 zeru wrote: I don't see how straight up forced violent rape is less known to be wrong than throwing acid in someones face. There's no way anyone can think either one is right in any way. So what makes it right to throw acid in someones face who did that to someone, but not to rape a rapist as punishment? Just so you know, there are more types of rape than someone forcing sex on you in a back alley. | ||
|
AntiSleep
Canada91 Posts
| ||
|
Iron_Booger
Canada9 Posts
The issue of whether moral prescriptions are relative to a society, or whether they can be universal, is a separate one as well. Moral relativism, at least in the academic world (my major is philosophy/ethics), has been thoroughly invalidated. In pop American culture, the debate seems to surround this notion that the only alternative to relativism is divine universal law, and that dichotomy is terribly incomplete. If you are a relativist, on the basis that God's law seems silly and unjustified, then you are only half right, and the Christians have still duped you into thinking that those are the only two lines of thinking. Now on the issue of this woman and this "punishment" of her assaulter, the answer has got to be more clear than people are saying here. Would you honestly, truly, feel that your society was a fair and just one if people were literally sanctioned by law to burn each others eyes out? It may well be what /she/ wants, or what you would want if you were her, but that's the whole point of having a system that doesn't allow victims to exact whatever punishment satisfies them! Letting victims decide punishment is unjust in that the punishments themselves will become disproportional and arbitrary relative to each other. Committing crimes against pacifists would, I suppose, also be in a sense freely licensed. Isn't anyone concerned about the logical ends of this law? If Bob attacks Jim with a power drill, does Jim get to do the same? How about if Bob goes after Jim's legs with a chainsaw... does Jim get to do the same by court sanction? Does this sound just or modern in any way? Is this how a civil society handles violent crime, by arming the victims and having them double down on the brutality? | ||
|
clusen
Germany8702 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:12 HoldenR wrote: Well some people never fucking learn until they get hurt. And it's a pretty safe bet that this guy will definitely learn. And how do you know that he didn't learn his lesson already? The incident happened in 2004, he was sentenced in 2009 and most likely living in fear since then. And it makes no sense to teach him a lesson if you destroy his life anyways, the logic is retarded. @ greatness If you cripple him that he is unable to take care of himself the state has to pay for him anyway, or how do you think he is going to make money? If they do not pay him afterwards the whole thing was a farce and they should've shot him right away in 2009. | ||
|
Iron_Booger
Canada9 Posts
| ||
|
Omegalisk
United States337 Posts
For instance, if a serial killer who killed 20 people gets life sentence, is that just? No, but it is moral, as it does not go against the moral code of killing. If a person who runs over a pedestrian gets the death sentence, is that moral? No, but it is just, as he will get the same punishment as he inflicted. That is where Gandhi's phrase of "An eye for an eye just makes the whole world blind.". If one only follows the laws of justice, then the world loses it's sense of morality. The justice system isn't just to administer justice, it also has to conform to moral codes. | ||
|
cari-kira
Germany655 Posts
On May 14 2011 08:49 Malgrif wrote: it's the woman's fault though. she shouldn't have made him fall in love with her. I sometimes read idiotic statements like this. | ||
|
See.Blue
United States2673 Posts
| ||
|
Tor
Canada231 Posts
On May 15 2011 01:54 Sporadic44 wrote: no thats not what i am trying to say. what i mean is the moral high ground is subjective. people have different morals. its a matter of finding equality between all those places. not assuming you are more just than another individual. because in the end we're all animals looking to self preserve. we're designed that way. i'm not automatically better than you because i disagree with how you think. and i think accepting that ideal is pivotal in understanding eachother and growing as a global community. take the nazis for example, they saw themselves as morally superior. were they right in that assumption? or religion. the crusades were based on moral beliefs. and now islamic fundamentalists think they're morally superior to christians, and vica versa. who has the high ground? And people took the moral high ground when they decided the nazis should be stopped. | ||
|
Phenny
Australia1435 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:06 See.Blue wrote: The only thing more saddening then this whole situation is the idea that seems to grip so many people in this thread that this is ok. How people can justify supporting this while not condoning torture or any other sort of barbarism is hypocritical in the extreme. The idea that this acts as a deterrent doesn't stand up. This is horrible, and in all honesty I'm disgusted by all the people in this thread justifying and OK-ing it from the comfort of their couch. Because you thinking it is not okay is no more legitimate or ~right~ than someone else thinking it is okay. You can back up each point of view with pretty good arguments. | ||
|
Karok
Netherlands142 Posts
"beasts" like the dude that threw acid in her face should just be put down. | ||
|
wakefield
United Kingdom114 Posts
| ||
|
optical630
United Kingdom768 Posts
On May 15 2011 03:11 wakefield wrote: I don't see why people are saying she shouldn't do it, he made her face like that why can't she? tbh this is one of the things the middle east seems to be doing right this | ||
|
Deadlyfish
Denmark1980 Posts
On May 15 2011 02:55 Omegalisk wrote: People really need to separate justice and morality. A thing can be moral and not just, and another can be just and not moral. For instance, if a serial killer who killed 20 people gets life sentence, is that just? No, but it is moral, as it does not go against the moral code of killing. If a person who runs over a pedestrian gets the death sentence, is that moral? No, but it is just, as he will get the same punishment as he inflicted. That is where Gandhi's phrase of "An eye for an eye just makes the whole world blind.". If one only follows the laws of justice, then the world loses it's sense of morality. The justice system isn't just to administer justice, it also has to conform to moral codes. Sometimes they are the same though. In the case of your example of the serial murder, i would argue that killing him would be the moral choice and serve justice at the same time. The Gandhi quote has never made any sense to me. If makes as much sense as this: "Turning the other cheek doesnt work when someone is pouring acid on you, you'll just get acid on both cheeks then." | ||
| ||